Securities Repurchase Damages Calculation Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe proceeding concerned several claims arising from a business transaction involving the sale and repurchase of securities, where the appellate court was asked to review the application of various statutory and contractual provisions regarding warranties, representations, and the determination of damages following a breach. The court reasoned that the plain language of the relevant statute dictated that the proper measure of damages was based on the difference between the contract price and the market value at the time of the breach, rather than the actual repurchase price paid by the aggrieved party, because the statute provided a specific, mandatory measure of recovery superseding common law or contract terms, and that certain exclusions cited by the opposing party did not apply under the facts presented.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Securities Repurchase Damages Calculation Dispute: The court reasoned that the plain language of the relevant statute dictated that the proper measure of damages was based on the difference between the contract price and the market value at the time of the breach, rather than the actual repurchase price paid by the aggrieved party, because the statute provided a specific, mandatory measure of recovery superseding common law or contract terms, and that certain exclusions cited by the opposing party did not apply under the facts presented.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for the allocation of court costs.
Testo completo
!! ""# $%& ""$
''
() '*+), , , ( )', *
-. ! / ""$
! ""#
#"
$$ $ $ $$$$$ # ! %"#"&'#()+,- .
20/32
, 0*
*4 " # !!! 5 !6" 0,,& 7"8 9 " !7! 7"## :" 9 # "9 9# ; $< 7"8 $$ $ $ $$$$$; 27"8 <# :=#"9"# 7" 7##4
04 " "" " *' (!9" " 0,,1 99 ! > 79 "#" "! # #!7":(( #:"2 9 #!; <"#!(#" 4
'4 0* (!9" " 0,,1 : ("! : #!"! ?: !# # : 7 6 #!" #(9"6>"?=#4
@4 """ "0@(!9" "0,,1( #7"#!" ?#"(## ? 9 #!#!77!#!9 ( ? "!(#" #"!4
&4 "A! #A00"0,,1 $$ $ $ $ $$$$ "(! ("# :8 " ( >994
BC! ? ## " 8" 79 # 7"!9 " : #!"=# 7" C7"## >#" "# #!": #"# !7D"79 #7"!#">:#" 7"## $ 97"## !7!7"" "4
7" "# !?= 7"## 7" #!( # 7" "# :77" # 7 !7"9 C"# " D #!"! ?:7"8 " !8 " C# ( C"# " " 7# # "" # 9"# 7" "# ! # " # 7 9C! #"E!98"4
( !#! "9! ? 7 8 9"! " !7D 9 9 # !7"! > ## 7 *& (!9" " 0,,' # > ? "9 #? ##!89#:!# ## #!9 7"8 7"!!# !7 > )74 # "! ?99 "" #7"!9 " #9!7D?" "" # #"? " ! # 9C!"#" # 7"8"#4
14 """ "039" 0,,1"! " 6#" # -" ) #"B#! "" #" ## ! 4
/'0&&/0,,1 2'/32 ( #9 "?: !# #" ! 9!(#? # ((" # 7"# #A" ?F(# #( :"!9 ("# 7"66 #! "!7" " ( !7A # ? :# ((# 9# ? :# 7" # 7 ? 8 ( " 0,,& 7 ? 9" # !7D !#! 7 9"# # # D7 # 4: #!"!# #"7?:" #G=#"# "7"## #" #7"!7D48C? ##9" "#!:#7"?A( A!7D: 7 !?#"!4 "! #8" 79 " #" " ! 2 # #!7" 4
+4 " BC# + B # 0,,1 " 6 # " #-" )! !7!###" " 6!4
34 """ ""0,,1 "B#""4
"77?:>#" #" ##" "H:"! 7"!? "#7"# :C #!? "# ! "7"D""" #"7 "6 C# ? !: " " 7"( "9 "F" #?! (! " ## = #" #! )6 #! > ##" " "" #" ! (! " " " 7" ! ! ">:7 ####I)#( # ""76# "" 7" ! ? " # ! " 7" !#" " " 7"!## "!" ":" "!4
54 " "" " + #6" 0,,1 "! " 6 ! ""# ! 9 ( > 79 " #" " ! !(# " "# (>:# 7" 7##4
*,4 " "" " 0' B9 " 0,,+ ""# #" 7" # ! "7")6"7! " 6## # 0+ !6" 0,,1 :77# > :(( BC : #"# #">$ 4
""#H
2 ? " !#6 7""# #! ' " 0,,'? (!"!>7" 8"!7$7 79 "7"C!""(#"7 ##"" "J
2 ?##" 8"7" )"CC# #"# 9#( 8" #!"=#D2" !7"!"7!77 *551J
2 ? #"8 C"9# ## # #! " # 9( "B" #"7"8( #"8"J
/'0&&/0,,1 2@/32
2 ? 7" :7" D2" $ ! !C# ',,("4 7" 7" 7 # 7"# 7# 0,,("4 7" 7" 9 "7C # ##FC#
2 ?:>7#"0*B 0,,&#>? " !#! 7! !#6 # ! 2 ; ? G# # ':'1,("4 7" < $ # 7"9 > ? "9 D2!7D ;*:1*'("4 "# $ K ':@,'("4 "#" # < 7"## # 7 9"" #" 6# :#"# *:'1*("40,(9"J
2 ?:#? ###" 8">C "7"9 7" ## 77!J
2 ?:" 7"C" "6# !# ### # 7 #! "# " 7"=#! > !#! !"! (( # 0,,@ 7" D7"# B " # '* 0,,& 7" )6" 77 " " #?"(! ##"6:"# ( # !#" J
2 ? 05 96" 0,,& " " ##( ("! :#" #! "" 7"?7# #2? "#" # B"2>> 7"F( "9 2:9 #7##7 #!J
2 ? :#" #! 77 " " !"! ? "" " # G =#" ":!# #7!!!#"2#7J
2 ?:#"2#7 1 #6" 0,,& ## !#! "# "! 7# 7" 9! " ## *@:@50(" 6 ( ! 05 7#6"7"!!#7""" !"!:# 7" 7##J
2 ?$:# #!># "? ## !# # # ! 7# ?: :7 # # 8"# D2" J ?: :9 " ! 7" 2= " ? : #!"!!B" #!B>)7 0*B 0,,&J
2 ?7"!" #"057#6"0,,&!7! 7 ##"7" 8"!7!(#"
2 ? ## 7 # !#! ! 7" BC : #"# 0, !6" 0,,& #!8: #!"!
2 ? "!:#"7""## !") # ( 9 " ?: !# # 9 "9 !(#" #""#!6"0,,&
2 ?:"7!7!7 #7!7!# "#" 7" 8"!7"
/'0&&/0,,1 2&/32
2 ? 7" ! + 7#6" 0,,1 BC : #"# ! :(( " (# 7 # 7! 77 6 7"8 9 " "9! ? :?=#:9 #77" :!#6 "?7"!9 #C > :#" #!"=# " ?: :!# # 77"7" !9" 77"##
2 ? *3 7#6" 0,,1 :# 77! > #
2 ? )6" 7! " 6 # # # !! 0+!6"0,,1?: 7"# # D !#" ">7"# "? "9 #!#!7" 9! 7 #! "#J ?: 7" " BC! ! " ? ?=#"6# #$7 8B# ( # 9 #### :((## ## "# "! 7# 6 " " J ?: BC! ? :!# # > #"# ? BC : #"# 9 # ( " 7"!" > 9# C# 7# 6 :77"#" !!# ! ( ## 7 6B# ( ? 6B# ( ## ?# > )( :# :6 ( C# !FJ ?: !? 9 #! BC : #"# >7!#":?=#7"! "# ## " 8"("D"? # D7!# 8"4
4 # 7"# 7" + B 0,,+ ""# !C! ? " #C"!! !7"# B "#9!6 0,,*>(!9" "0,,'#>?D2!7#( #9)")" >A!#6 #)7 # "A4""#( "!:9 "7"7"# 7"!## > ( " 9 " > :!C" " 4 D7 ?! ?: ) # # 7#79 "#" "!7D( 9 " ? 9 ## 9!:#" :# 7" 7#4" #((#? :"C# #!#!!#"!>!#" #4
""# 7" # 7"829"6 : #""C# " !(# " ?BC 9 9 #7"!!'"0,,&" 9"? 9 #!#! #" ##>? 9 #( #"!4# " ?7 #! "#" !# #!( ##?: " #777!>?:7 #" "! 4
*04 " "" " 5 B 0,,+ ""# " #! 7"8 " 6 !7"9 """?:4
*'4 "" " #!" " #! !C# 7" # ##" BC : #"# 9 #! *0 B 0,,+ > "! ? BC ? 9 " 7" # "?=# # 7"7 :F" #!" "# !7E# " ! # 9" # ! " > 7"!) :(( " ( # ##( ""?" ? ( # :6# " # 7" 7#
/'0&&/0,,1 21/32 7"# 7 7"!#" ?: F 9 27 # 7 # "4
*@4 $"!#!C"!>BC"4
, ('*
*4 ("!#>:"#4&14*#4)4* C9 "L"C # B "0096"*5@*;< " 6#" M# # ?### 7"!9>:"#4&1 (!!" " 7"# C!!" " # " 1 #6" 0,,, ; < ? #"# 9> (!!"0,!6"*5@1"L"29 # "9 9#; $<4
04 # C7"#"" #99:"!#" "# #! " :# 7" 7## !7! 7" " " # " ? !B>!#!##!4 "?!"##6"" "7" !#F"7 #7!!7!#"7" 8"!7" 7"6 ( #C# !F##4
'4 7##( #? "! (""6:"#4 @5 ? 7"!9 # ? :"" # "" 7" !" # ! ? 7"##" B# 7"##9?: #!"!:#7:" " 6!#7!##"# #" 4:#!C#"# ("!# > :"#4 &3 4 * ? :# " 6 # " # ? 7" "! ""# #"9? #7!##4((#""## !>894
@4 #":"#4@+ #" ##" ""N #!"=#7" 9!7"!7!"##9C"!H <:"!7"!? "# 6<7"# :C #!? "#! "7"D"" " #"7 "6 C# ? !: "" 7" ( " 9 " F " # ? ! (! " ## = <#" #!)6 #!>##""""#"! (! " " " 7" ! ! " > :7 ####I) < # " "76 # "" 7" ! ? " # ! " 7" !#" " " 7"!## "!" " :" "!4
/'0&&/0,,1 2+/32 &4 :78 (" # ##" ? ""# "7 # # 7 ?: :# ( " 9 " " # !# : " " 4"! #!>79 "#" " !(#" :7 ":F#"9" ?#>7 #! "# ( 79 "!#F"7 #7!?:!7!#"7" 8"!74 :# 7" !?# > B# # #" ? : # ! "(! " # #" " :"! !## 7"! ! ?: # 6 > ""# BC ! "":77"# "! !(#" 7"BC : #"# 9 )"C! : #"# 7 #4 "89" " 7!#" "BC" #77"#B# ( 4
/'0&&/0,,1 23/32
' 1 *0 '*+), , , ( )', *
23 -
*4 !""""964
23
04 "B##4
'4 #?7"!"#C"# #4
@4 (" 7"# ?L 79# ("" "" #" 7"!# ""=# ! ', B" 8 # ( # 7"8 " 6 (!!" ;$)O P")(? 11,,@ <7"9 ""# 8"" # 76 ("!#D"#430 (!!"" " 6(!!"*+ B 0,,& ; Q<J ! " "" # ?" # ( # F7"9#7"#" C#"""## "J # =#" "! " 6 (!!" 7" 9 7# 7" 9 !#" ? D # :"#4 @0 Q4 7"!# ""=# # 7 8 7 ""# 9?!F7"9 9#=#"B #>:9 4 C"(( 8" "! #H QQ R" $ R
7 ("7"!#""=### ( !D7"# ?L>L(( (!!" " 7"C"((
/'0&&/0,,1