Discovery Scope Limitation Upheld
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party sought review of a decision upholding a prior ruling that limited the scope of discovery, specifically prohibiting inquiry into certain financial and business records. The court reasoned that the requested discovery exceeded the bounds of relevance to the claims and defenses in the case, as the information sought was too remote from the core issues necessary for resolution, thereby affirming the lower court's proper exercise of discretion in managing discovery.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Discovery Scope Limitation Upheld: The court reasoned that the requested discovery exceeded the bounds of relevance to the claims and defenses in the case, as the information sought was too remote from the core issues necessary for resolution, thereby affirming the lower court's proper exercise of discretion in managing discovery.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis provision governs the awarding of court costs, which is explicitly mentioned in the final order regarding costs.
Testo completo
!"#$%!&''% (!##!&''$
(
) (* ) (+ ) +*
", -. / &$ 01 &''$
2222222222
*( *3 * !"""# ""!# " $ % &'
. ,(* .
4*(
)/ 0" 12222222222 # 3& ".! " 1 3 4 5"6" "/
,/ 5" 3#" 47" 68 4"!3" 4 " 8!5 3#"/ #9# % 4:;3" ), )< =#'" ,--+/
</ ".! " 33# % 4"## > ' 4 3#'?" > 483""" "'"" !! 8;3" 35" 4 "=!# >4 3" 86 483""" 5 4 ==" 9" % 4@" 3"/ " "" !5# @ 9 % +AA =/
+/ #"" ,* 9" ,--+ ".! " " ="!# >4 4!" 3 =" 48" 3"'# !# " "= % 83"""/
*/ 4"## ? =!# 33"" ".! " 3 #"" 33"" , B ,--+ 33# 4/ +C 0 !" ! 3## "/
D/ 4"## "9# )$ B ,--+ " #"" # >
E =" % =" "!3 F ' ! ! % 3#" 94" ' ' 2222222222 > 4"'" " " ), =#'" ,--+/ " 3 " ' 94" # ' 4:;3" 83""" 4 "/ @ = 3" 8"6" 4:;3" ## #6# 3 !".!G! !" 1 =# '" =" =# 3 8"6" 6 &6 E ==" 83"" H/ @ 3" ## ' =I #3# " !433J > = ' 4/ ,* 0 H/
$/ '"# % #!" ".! " " & '" "=" % 5"6" # 0 3 =" 4'" '# ! #>"' ==" 33"5 "'"" !! 4 8;3" 35" &' K/ ,* / , / 0 #" ' 4/ +C 0L/ & > ! !5! ! ,M$-- =/ *-* =/ =# 3 2222222222 38!6 N0: 2222222222 " 3#" 2222222222 !# " 8#" N0: #3' = ! 6 ?&! '" "=" ' 8;3"@/
()$*+(,--+ . <(* .
A/ #" + 5 ,--+ 4# " % 3#" > 43#" !! 3"># =! !5" >4" 4? 83""" >4@ =" " 3 6 #"# !3 O6/
C/ ## 6 # % 96/
+*(
)/ " 6'" 46"" 9 """ KL ## ! "="# ""# & ) B ,--< "5 " !3# * 96 3#" '".3#" * 33# )D 96 K/ ) / *D L/
1" % 4" 4#" )D 96 3 "5 =# # ,$ 9'" ,--+ K N )<- )-DL " 6'" 3# )< =#'" "3"" "" 6 3! "5 " "#6 % " 96 "" 4 4#" '@ 96 /
,/ =!#! % M/ *D / ) / 8/ + "5 " J " "> " 3#' % 4" *D >" "' % " =# # 4.! " )A ! )CC+ K 0L/ 1 !3# 3 96 43& "" #5"/
</ " =# # 3" 6## " " D 5 ,--- K L # '"6 ) 9'" ,--< J ! "="" !5 "3"" #6 !" "/
+/ "9# !3 " '5 K" *D D- L/
*/ 1 4/ +C / < 0 #!#" # 483""" 4== =!#! "= 33"5 % 48;3" > 3" 5" 4" "" !# " 4 "! " 4 # 3" !# " !"" 83""/ 1" "" 4 3 !3" "= 4/ *- 0 33"5/ @ ! "& "3"" #6 4 3 86 #9 #5"! !# "." K/ <C / < 0L !G! 3" > 3 "! !5" 3 " % !"" P " 3 =" '" ' 4#5"! !# ".
" 4 ! #!#" ==""/
()$*+(,--+ . +(* .
D/ 43& = > #"# 4 83""" 4 3 ## !" >" 3 4""!#/ ." 3 "!" 3" ==" 9" ' 4 4# 3#'? > 3" 86 =" 3 % 83""" "'"" !! 8;3" 35"/
$/ " & > % " > =" =# #3#! 3 438!6 4" 3#" 48#" '" " G !5#/ #' "3"" 4/ +C / , 0 " !# "@ !3" ==" ' 3 #!#" "! 83"" =!#! % 4/ +C / ) 0/
A/ & "5 > 4""!# "=" % 5"6" ' ! #>"' ==" 33"5 "'"" !! 4 8;3" 35" &' !"3"# 3 !5 9 483""" " @ 9/
()$*+(,--+ . *(* .
+(*4 (* ) (+ ) +*
5-6 7 8 9: ";& +<
6
)/ # '5/
6
,/ 9/
</ " > 3# 6"/
+/ =! 3" >4 3' =! 3# G #" <- 9 & "="" 3 3" !! # # "5 =# # 18Q"R8=>" D D--+ " @!3"/ #" 3 G 36#/ !#!" " F L " "> @! > #"" #" 5" " 3 #"" >#P 5L @3 3 > !"= " "! 3'" ! #""P L 3 "6 3#/ 1" !#!" " 3 " ##! #!## L 5L L ". "5 =# # 3 3 !"& >4" ' # "'5/ !#!" !" !? 3' >" 9" "" > #"" ># 4'33 > ## @3# "# K/ )<, )-D )-A L/
6=="&F #" F
0"." S " T
3" =! 3# G "="# @ 3" "" >4% 4==" =# # # 35"> 3 6==
()$*+(,--+