Construction Contract Lien and Payment Bond Interpretation Review
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns the review of several lower court rulings regarding construction contract disputes, focusing on the interpretation and application of various lien and payment bond statutes. The court systematically addressed numerous assignments of error related to the scope of lienable work, timely filing requirements, notice provisions, set-off claims, and the calculation of damages under the relevant statutes, ultimately affirming some rulings while reversing and remanding others based on the court's interpretation of legislative intent and application of established commercial law principles to the specific factual findings in each underlying claim.
Regesto Legislator
UfficialeLOI FÉDÉRALE SUR L'ASSURANCE-MALADIE; AM; ASSURANCE DE BASE; TRAITEMENT AMBULATOIRE; TRAITEMENT HOSPITALIER; NÉCESSITÉ D'UN TRAITEMENT HOSPITALIER; SÉJOUR À L'HÔPITAL ; OPÉRATION ; SYNDROME DU TUNNEL CARPIEN | LAMal32
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied to decide the costs of the appeal proceedings (order 7).
Testo completo
!"#$"!%$$& !'&(!%$$&
))
) * )* *
*+, % ( -, %$$&
!"""# $ % !&'( '!'( )#("!!""*#(+(' ")"'
!('
,- ,, . ,/ / 0(!"12 "("# 3'('45 $- %
.:6<.
.
7/ =".&'1 '!'(> ( ??""# &'1 ,- ,, . ,/ =".&'1*"("#>&!'*'!@"2(!"' !" "" A A(' ' !&#("' = %, ( >/
:/ '!'(#(#!&#'#('&"'!"((49&(@':99B( C!&"("#&!'(('"!49&(@'7'!(!@':99B/
4/ ( 77 !(!@' :99B ""A '# $ *"("# 2'(" *C!&"("("!/ ." *( '# ' &' &" 75!(!@' &!'!+(''"!A"!(!(")#*C!&"("("!/,'D !''"'#"&!'(#("! E'##F!'@'" G2#'#H/
B/ (B!)@':99B #".!"*"("#"?!''!'( A**@*"?!'("!!&#("'"&'#)"#2(")(&'" C'2 *C!&"("("!/ &'1 #".!" '#"(1' *"?!'("! &'1 #" '!'( " &'#"( A*C@"(( ("(')("!&'("A'!@(!"' 1/
I/ '#""!:":99I *"("#"?!''!'(A**#((!"' ('"((@(!"'?('#! ''&'"C'2/
;/ ,"( $ *!&&!"("! '!'( *"("# '# ( !@("( ?"( #"'!'(!&"'&&!'(!&#'(!"' (49!)@' :99I/ '# ")" &!(!&#'(!"' ( F("?"# *&1 &' '"A *2!'!0('!&C"(*G"#(#&("(/
</ ('&# ' '&&!'( #".!" *"("# ""A 78 #@' :99I A'"A#!#&(&"2!("A':BC')!"'B5C' &'1 *!&#'("! A ('"(( &'#)("? "&# &!)"( *D(' ?J! @(!"' DA('"((!('*G"#(#/
5/ #" '!'( &'" &!"("! ' ( )" 79 F)"' :99;/ !"1'E*G&#'"A*(2"&!(!&#'(!"'@"!"(:B$ B5 C' CK &("( &'#(( &'!?" &0C!!2"A 2!"# ! G@#'( )!"' G F! 'L &'"!'" @! #)!("! &!(!&#'(!"' ( '&""(# '#&#'("! H A" " @ E&'(""1'()#'"?"#H"(')("!(0&*"(')("!/ "("(@".?!#*C!&"("("!*"(&!'!("?/
8/ *"("# *( !' '# $ ' &#""( C"''2" &("A ( '!('"( (") " ( '? &#'"&C#'"A/
678976:99; .46<. '&&!'(8?#)'"':99; ."""AA*"(E@!(G&("!H )!"'C!&"("'&("(&!'(("(')("! !&'G& ( '&" "2 ' C#!''2" ! ('"(( , ( '&" &!(.('("A ! ( '&" CK &'! ('1 M2#/ *(*!&#'('A"!"(F2'#"(#*C!&"("("! (0& *' &("( )( & ('' "2 !&(/ &( #('"''*&1/
79/ &'1!)#C2*#'"('('&'(" *"("#'#""! '!&&!"("!:I)'":99; &'A'F((*!&&!"("!/
77/ ! '!' :; " :99; '!'( !( $ '#?!'("! #""! "("2" A ('"(( ")" 49 &(@' 7' !(!@' :99B !"( D(' "(#2'( &'" C'2 &' *"("# ) "( #&/ ,@"""'( $ !&'("! &'! #" ( $ *!'!*G&'("#"/
!"1' @( A *C!&"("("! #("( &&'!&'"# ??" ( #!!"A '(" :I ( 4: / !''"( '"A #)!&&' 2!'!0('!&C"/ ('!@ 0(1 '!.)#2#(("? &( '(??("! ((!)('#2#&'*#((&0C!!2"A&("(/ ' #("( G" ( 2!"#/ *'( #" &'(("( ! ( ''' " " " &&!'(' !(" &0C!!2"A &!(!&#'(!"'/ &'(("( #2( *&(' &' !2 2#"A/&'" ?" ?)!'"''#&#'("!'&"/
7:/ '#&! :; F" :99; *"("# !( 'F( '!' @"""'($*"("!'/,*&&0(')" (( '"1' ( ! #".!" '1) A '"A !' &!)"( D(' #)"(# &' ('"(( @(!"'/ '&& A ! F'"&'?##' !"("!@!"*C!&"("("!*(!#A" '"2!("A((C#'&("A#"'&)(D('&'("A# "1' &&'!&'"# A CL&"( ( *(' &'( " &!"@""(# * ('"((@(!"'!(#(##&"#/
74/ '&";F"(:99; '"@!"A#((#'"('$'!'( ( " !# #" &!' !(' &"1 ( !"A' *#)( !@')("! 79!N(:99;/O((( #(#2'#$F2'/
)
7/ !"2)!"'P!'2"("!F"""'=>#(#!"?"#("("(# 1 7'!N(:994 '"@(!'!" !&!#IF2 !(&'#"(()".&'#"( I&&#((7;F2'='(/7(/ '(I; >/
678976:99; .B6<. ,"($P("!P#("!7;F2' &' '"@?##' :<F)"':99B= Q74979;> ' !"2)!"!&(# 74?#)'"' "&!"("!('"(!"''2(&'((( '"@(!' !" "#2' ' $ ('!" F2 ("("' P((( P#("!!)GF2'/
:/ !?!'#( $ *'(/ I; / 7 (/ C/ B '"@ (! '!"!+("("A!((("!&'#)$P'(" I; A" !( '(") $ !" ?##' ' P'." 75' 788B= >/
,!&#(&!'F2'P&1(""#(@"/
4/ !"?##''&'("2##''!"('!";!(!@' :999= >(('#)"2'7'F)"':994 ('+(!"?"("! !@'"&!"("!#2!"'!"/,' &(#'" &!"()!"'A'!"(*&&"A!"(D('('C#$"1' &'""&!A'12&&"@!()"2'!(!R ?"(F'""A(#('"(!(&'!"(= Q749:49!"/7/7S 44I!"/7/:S Q7:8B!"/7/:S Q7:<B;<!"/7 7:;74; !"/B@('#?#'>/'12&'!#'A($*&&"A( '#')1F!'!('#)"2'= Q77<84!"/;@ 77:4;9 !"/BS 7885T4<&/47;!"/4@>/ P&&"A! P&1/
B/ ('F(#?!'(#"&'#)&'!" '!'(')@='(/I;$ ;9 >/
I/ )'( *'(/ :B *' !@"2(!"' !" &' C'2 !N(&'(("!#?""G'(/:I$47((!&(!"("! '(/4:$4B/ &'(("!!&'( !(( G ('"((( !" "&# ! ?!' @(!"' !"" &("( "" C!&"("' ! ".C!&"("' ! #(@"( #"!.!" &' #" C"'!&'("" ( &'! ?!'"( &'(("! ' &''"&("! ! ' ( #" ='(/ :I / : (/ > ( #F!' ")""!!*CL&"(='(/:I/:(/ >/
,! *'(/ 4: / 7 &'(("! ("!# G '(/ :I $ 47 !")( D(' ??" &&'!&'"# ( #!!"A/ *G"2 '(1' #!!"A&'(("!'!'(#2(*'(/I;/7 !A ?!'"' &'(("! !"( ""(' &'(("! $ ' G"2# &' *"(#'D(*'#( @(('"((/ ''."!( '!"( '?' &'" C'2 ' (C#'&("A "(" ! ' A" '"( & D(' '&# &' *(' !" !#'S 0 !( *"' !@"2# 1 !' A* !( ( )"' '&( &'""&
678976:99; .I6<. *#!!" ('"((/ &'""& !' & "A( '("! (' '' ( ?!'"' !"/ ( #2( !&&!@ $ *'# A" *'!"('@!'(*('"((!#!!"A= Q7:<B; !"/:@('#?#'"(#>/
*!@"2("! &!' ''." *!' &'(("! ('"(( C!&"("' &&! *G"( * " A" G"2 ('"(( &!' !" "2 ! ' #" '#&(("! "" C!&"("' ='(/ 48 / 7 >/ !"("! @!" *C!&"("("! ( !# * &'( " ' "2!("A ( (C#'&("A #"' &)( D(' &'("A#"1'&&'!&'"#ACL&"((*('&'( #2( " &!"@""(# * ('"(( @(!"' !( #(# #&"# ( A (C#'&" "" C!&"("' &'#( C 1/ *!@"2("! ?!'"'&'(("!&("F("?"'A*#(("?&'! #"(&?!'#(#F!'$*CL&"("A #!" ('"(( &( D(' &'!"2# A* "" C!&"("' &!' '"! &'(""1' !((!'A*'#M2#!)")((*"&!"@""(#')!"'$ !""')"(!"'A"&'!#((= Q7:;4:;!"/:@>/
!"!&#?""("!''#&(("!*'(/:I/ : (/ / ,! 2(' =T'U)'"C'2 " V ,CW"K'"C )'W(2'C( X,Y C/ 7B: > ' #" '#&(("! '(#'"( &' ?"( A ('"(( " ( ".
D ('"# ( A ?!' (C#'&" !( " & &!' "( ('"((/ '#&(("! #" ( !#(") ('"(( &'!&'( "( *??("!()" !0'#" $#""' (!("(#! &'(" !2 # G &"(# &C0"A ! &0C"A/ "C'!"A '($"("' )!"'$#"!'' ?!("!'((/ &( (' $ '#"'("! &'!?"! ?!("! ! !"/ '#&(("! #" &( )!"' " ! ?!' @(!"' "" ".
C!&"("' #(@"('!!"!!'""A &#""# ("1' A #F!' "" C!&"("' !"( D(' #"'/ #"(# * #F!' "" C!&"("' #('" *&'1 *"("(#('"(( 2'#C"& 2'!"'A" 2')"(# "&'""&!')!&"("!!?!'!) ")(*F!('$#F$&'#(= Q7:;4:<!"/:S)!"' " Q 77/97/9I T;69B ( Q :8/9;/9B T4I69B>/
;/ *&1 #"'!'((!(*@!'F("?"#*C!&"("("!&' !"#'("!A'#"&'""(&G2#'#/,!#&'*"("# !(")' )(2 #""! " "( G&"A# '"A *??("! !' &'&("(""A*#((*2!"(*G"#(#A#("(/Q!'( &(!(('A*"*&'#&!?J!!)"($A("! )!"' &!'A!" '"A *'"( & & D(' #)"(# &' ('"((
678976:99; .;6<. @(!"'/ #".!" *"("# !('"' @" G&"A# A *C!&"("("! &'(("( A!" A*" !"( & *#)"(' '"A *2!'!0('!&C" ??("! A" &!)"( D(' "2!("A# & (L( A :B C' &'1 *!&#'("!/ D &'+(." "' A* ('"(( #"(G&'#)("?'"(&D('"&#$'!'(&!'#)"('(!(#(( G"G/
</ &&'+( &'!#A( A*C!&"("("!*#("(&#"' F'"&' ?##' ( A &' !#A( '&"( & !"("! *??""(# *#A("!(*#!!"'A"&'!"/
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
8/ A"&'#1 '!'''F(#/ ___
) * . ) * )* *
/0121,, 3 -1 1 1 45 "&% 6
21,
7/ #''!'')@/
678976:99; .<6<. 21
:/ 'F((/
4/ "(A&'!#'(2'("(/
B/ ?!' &'(" AP &)( ?!'' '!' !(' &'#( ''D( #" 49 F!' 1 !("?"("! &' &" '!# '# '"@ ?##' ' ,CW"K'C!?A" ; ;99B ('!" G&"'/ #" &( D(' &'!!2#/ #!"' !"(V > ""A' G((A#""!'!'(#"'!@("'"(&#""! ((A#S @> G&!' &!' A !("? " (" &!)!"' ' (( (' #""!S > &!'(' "2(' ! ! '&'#((/ ," #!"' !("( & ('!" ##( ##'# ! ((' > @> ( > ". '"@?##''&!''&(''("1'''!'AP" )'#''"'')@/#!"''!'("!'!'!0 &') A" '!( F!"( "" A #""! ((A# ( P)!&& A#(#G&#"#'!'(='(/74: 79;(795>/
2'??"1' '#"(V ^` \ @,
!&"!?!'&'#(''D((!("?"#G&'("""AP$P??"?##' (#&@"A&'2'??
678976:99;