Minority Status Voids Arbitration Agreement
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party sought to compel arbitration based on an agreement, but the opposing party argued the agreement was invalid due to a lack of mutual assent because one party was a minor at the time of signing. The court reasoned that the statutory right of a minor to disaffirm a contract, including an arbitration agreement, remains valid unless explicitly waived, and since the minor had not legally ratified the agreement after reaching majority, the agreement was voidable and thus unenforceable for compelling arbitration.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Minority Status Voids Arbitration Agreement: The court reasoned that the statutory right of a minor to disaffirm a contract, including an arbitration agreement, remains valid unless explicitly waived, and since the minor had not legally ratified the agreement after reaching majority, the agreement was voidable and thus unenforceable for compelling arbitration.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe decision orders the payment of costs for the federal court proceedings.
Testo completo
#$%%&#'(() #*+'#'((,
--
. - . .-
)/ 01 2 * 3 2 '((,
4 -5555555555
6 # !"#$ %& !!*+ '((())
!"
/),%)/
7
%0 1!2222222222+%34*5%-3-66!!+74!%89! %--3 4" 7 !/*7! : , ;!/4" < 4 = 5!#!7!0>='(8!)((.!+!5++6!7!> *4+*!0 ! 7 7*!! ! ! 4 + * 7 4!*7=75954+7*!!!+ !0
)0 =+ 66+ +7 7 7! $ =!9!+ 7 "9 #7 7*!! 4" 7 4 ! 8>=$ 6! 7 +7 '% ? %--30 6++ 7*!! $ "9 7" % 4*5 %--3 !6* @ ! !+ $ 4 4!* 7 =/5!#! 7 !!6!!!9!9+774!*4"7 40
'0 * )((. A 7 =+ =! 7 7! B 5!7 7 =/*7! 7 5 7+!9+ 4 C9! 7 =/*7! ;C 1< 7 +45!> 7 "90 4" 9+!6!! 4" 7 !+ 7 >! ; < 7 !+ #9! 5 6!*!>+=+!47*!!!+ !74!%4*5 %--3>=!=>!!7=4!*75450
.0 ! 7 %D * )((. !6*+ =+ >= ! +*! 4!*77!66+4!*!!#9!4!> 7!" +0 ! +!> 7+ $ =+ E 7*!!!+ $ "9 6! 9! > =7 ! =+! >=5F B0 7+!4E$4 4 6*7 4!*7=7544!5B+7*!!!+$"90
G0 7+!!7'%*)((. 6!*+$+>=!+*! 7!66+*74!*9547 ! 9547"9>=!!7?4 !77*!! 7$*47*!7*%---0
30 =+ 6*+ 44!! G *! )((. *!6 > !+ !! > #9! ++ !6*+ 7 H#* 7 7*!!0 ! >= %--D ! 9! 6! 49! $ =# !! =! 7 5!7 17+!9+4!+#9!>=!!!+++47 >=!49!5++6!! !75!77+40 =!5+#4*7!6!!+*+!9* * 7 4!* >=! >!+0 = 4 +! 46!* 7H#*77*!!7>=577! ! +* +!9* 4!* 7 7!66+ 7 4!*0
,%--&,)((. /',%)/ +#* 44+ $ ! ! 7 4 4!* #9! 7" =+)((.0
D0 )G?)((. 8+=44!!+*+$=+4!*7 7 GI%&' 60 !+E B 4+ 7!66+ * 74!*!!4 +*7?!6#9!7"*! 7*%---0 +#*6+!!44+4 =+7">7+!!!!#!=4458=!67 4!7=0
&0 1! 2222222222 !8+ 4" 7 !5 7 + )D 4*5)((.0B4>4"+!*4 +6+7+>6*! 8++66!!+4"7 0>=!66!+7$"9! 9!9+7*!!7 !HJ4>!4 ! 4!*06!*>74!%4*5%--3!7*!!!+$"9 *! ! > !+ *4+ ++ !6*+ 7 H#*0 6! 9! ! >=$ +4! 7 =! 6! #9! 4 49! 5++6!! 7 5!7 1 ! =9! H*!+ $ @ ! !! ! 9! 66!*+ >=! 49! 5! 7 5!7 7 ! 5 7 =! 7+!9+ 4 0 6! ! ! >=5+#4*$ 79!+!9**7 4!*4+H>+4=+>=4!/*7!= 45!#+77+# "*74!*!>*!>=46!0 $=!77+!!>+$=!7=!7*!++>!5 >!!*47*4*7!74+4+70
-0 +4 7 %% 9*5 )((. + 9! ++ !6*+ 7 H#* 7=7 7 + > 6!! $ 79! 7=!6*0 B4>6*+*$=03%0) 16!#76+> !6+!!76!B4!*6!7?$444 4 +#! !6 >! A =445! 7 ! 6+7+0 =+ + 7*!!!+ $ "9 74! %--3 = !6 #9! 7 4!* >=! 79! >!>=!6+=!9!+H#*77*!! 7 7+! 7 %. 8 7!! #++ ! !*4!0 !!74 7!66+74!*+!9*!> 0 8 7 $ 7*! 7 4!*7=!7*!++>!50
%(0 +4!>7)(89!)((G4!+7!6! 9!>4+!7!79!E7+7!7=*7G((60>=! 6!!9!!75!74!*7?44*!7+4*!4 8*!4 +0
,%--&,)((. /.,%)/ %%0 *! 4!! 9 > =+ 9! !7?* 46!+ 7 4!**49#7>=+!7!7!+* 4!*77!66+!GI%&'604!+E$GK0
%)0 !5 9>+4! 7! 7*4!4%' 9! )((G0 +66!*+ 9! !>+ %--& =! 7 5!7$=#!!7 @=#!7H#*7=7! 9!!6*+7!9!+*!9!4=!9!!6*+ 0 7*! = 9! 4 490 66!*+ 9! 66+ 7 HH 4" 7 =# !! *! 7= ! 7 5!7 17!6*!!9$H#*77*!!= ++9+77!7=+0C!#*57C 1 7 "9 =+ =9! 4 6! 9! 7! 5!7 4 + %--& $ )(((0 = 7++ 4E $ B !+E *! "94>=#!74!* 9!+$+* 7!66+ 9 *7!!+ 7 *0 $ *4! !9>+ 4 6!>=*!67+!= 47*4! 4!54!* 1 0 9+794!"$ 4+70
%'0 44+ $ 7+*! 7+!+ 9 45 7 4!" 47! 4 7 * L 5! 7 ! !! +4 +!4+!+*>!!9!66!*+>9* 75!7#9!!*4!>!H#*7=66!!!
%.0 =!!*++#*4!+7!++#7+$8#0
-
%0 !#9!=#!!87!!!;<++*7!6!+!!+7" %?)((' !57!*4+7G8# 74+!79!/4+!7G44+%38#;0%0 G3 <0
C!$=!7=+!7%38#4 !56+7+ )D89!)((.; M%'(%(3<7 !#9!74+%'6+9! 7!4!!!!#4* !57
,%--&,)((. /G,%)/ ! 7 !+# $ ! 8# !! 7 = 7 =+!79B8#0
)0 6*+* $ I0 G3 0 % 0 H0 . !5 7 !F!!>7!4+9$=! G3 7 ! 6+7+ 4! #++ 7 7! 7 ! 7 3 5)(((; <>!!9$!6+7+=/*7!7 %&*%--.; 1<0
C*4+48#77=4"!!+5!0
'0 + 9!# % 89! )((' F *7!6!! 7 *5 7!4!! +# 7 7*! 7 !0 C 4*+!4!79!>7!I44!>7!EH+$*!" 74!!4>"#44!59!#**L 6!8!7!>*7+*!47!; M%'()'(!70%0%@ ''G!70%0)@ M%)-.!70%0)@ M%)D.3D!70%%)3%'3 !70.5+6+<0
"# 7 4+7 7 ."* H4! 7 I44!> > $ +9 7" 8 7 + 9!# $ 7+6 7 "# !! !; M%'(%!70'0)%%D-'!7035%%)'3(!70.@ 1 %--&:'D40'%3!70'5<0 =44!>77=4"0 8+76*7+!+#4!4!$+#7 95;0G33( <0
.0 =58 7 !!# ! $ 7+*! ! =!!*+ 7! 7 +* 4!* 7 7!66+ 4!* 7 = 7 5 4 +77 !>=!!7?4 $"9! 77*!!77"%4*5%--30
47*!!$"974!*!74*5 %--3!66!!!$ 4=5!#!7!0 "# 47 > 7+!! >+ 4 4 5 +# 66! 7!4!! 7 1 4* $ =!!*+ 7 9! +!9**7=4!*4+H>+4=+0
C=#!77!*+!!!779>=5874+!!# *4+*7!!+*+4=!!*+44+!77*%--- $*)((.!44!+!$=+9!#7 4 4! 4+! % 89! )(('0 =0 ). 0 % "# B4+*>!77!*+!4>7!4!!! 44!5 4 !/*40 C =0 &) 0 % %" 4H 7!4!!*+!74+!444!5B4! B+6!B+9+9!#04!
,%--&,)((. /3,%)/ >! 6! =58 7= 7+!! N 4!!4 6* N + 6 ; M%'(G.3!70)<0=7+!!!!#!++ 74"=+9!#7 01E*!4!7 !!79%89!)(('!!!+++*+ 4 7 4! 7= ! 7 + 6!B+ 9 % 89! )((' *! 4" 70 +> !4+! O !P >!+#!4 44+!+*40).0% 0
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
#*7>7+675+#!!*67+0
G0 754!!4B7 177=/*7!5!#! 4 =*5 7 44! C!0 =0 ' 0 % 1 4 !! 4!!4 7 =5!#! 7 = 4 4 7*!!!+ C! ; M%)3)3&!70'5+6+<0=66!!!$!/*7! 4+>8!7!>!*4+!9=5!#!74 7!!;0 3% 1<74!!4B?74!6*7=6H! 7= >/4 4 6! >! 7+4 * 7 /! ;0 3. 1<0
,%--&,)((. /D,%)/ = 6!B * 7 4!* $ 4 4 +0 C6 7!4!! ! 7 4+ ! = 4+"9 7 4!* +# 4" 7 + ;0 3% 0 % 1<0 6*+* $ =0 3% 0 ) 1 = 4+H*74!*=!+5!>?7!66+ +#!0 ! 7 +!7 7 =+ 7+*!0 =66!7+!*!+#!!6*+*40
C 4!!4 7 *!+ 7 !7!+ =+#!+ 7 !* !9>+ 4 !/*7! 4* 4 7 67 7+!! >+7*L=03%0% 1+!4!!47=+#!+ 4+9 4!*!>4+@!67!!! B4!4!!47=+#!+>!=466!0
!5 7 + "9 47 > 4!!4 7 =+H* 7 !!7=4+!+*+$=03% 10 /!6+7=+H*74!*4+#! =5!#!0 = 7* 4 *! > 44 7 !/*7! 74+!!!>! !;03%0) 1<0
= =0 )D 0 ' 7 "#* 7= +7!! %--3 44>4!*7=7!+H+=!49+> ? 7!66" +#!0 ! 7 +!7 7 4 + 7+*!0 =0 '( 7 "#* 4+! > =+ >! H#7=77!!6* 7%.80=4$ 7 =0'(0%7 7!!#++7=; < +7!!%--- +!5+$!*4+4!!L!7*!! +#0
+>=!!*++!7!76!B74!*4 +9+4 + 7*!!!+ 7 7 "9 > 4 B 7*!!!+ 7 7 ! + 7+ > ? 4 +9+ 7 7 "90
6*+*$=0-)0% 1=7*$=M C !674!*7=5!#!7!*7!6!! 47!>*!944!!0 =4"!674!*4 E 44!>+4=!!*+>!!*4!>>=!++449+4=M C 49!7+>>=!6*B?* 7+#! !7++;600-)0' 1<0
=#*7*5!!$6B0
30 9! 7=B*! ! =!!*+ 7! 7 +* *4+* 7 !!47!66+4!*75+4+!77% *%---'%*)((.0
,%--&,)((. /&,%)/ 7*! 7 !! +#* = ! 7! 7 +9>7+!!67"#!9$!7+!7 7+!!4+ 6; M7%D9*5)(((Q%DD,((!70G@ M %)3 .3 !70 )5 +6+<0 C 4!!4 #++ 7 7! 7 ! I7*!!! 4 !7+ 7+!! 6** 4+ 6 7 H 8#+ > !+ 87!!! I 4 4+>67$7!!>I!7+> !6!!9E!*45; M%)D.3-!70)E !+<0 4#!9+9!!77+!!74!+ 87!!!I7*!!!74+7$+9!!7I7+!!+ 6 6* > 7+9 7 6! 9B 7 9B * 7494!577!$44+!!8!7!>7!66+ ; M %)D .3- !70 ) +6+<0 > +9!! !7+!7+*!B4!!*+#+$=0G' 0
7+*4 !6!!6 7 !! * 7 49 > 67!7+!+9!!4+74+!%89! )((' 7 > =0 G' 44!5 ; M 7 %3 6+9! )((G )3',('!70%0%<0
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
,%--&,)((. /-,%)/ 4++7*!>!I9!44E49+7+!*7>+0 49 !7++ >I! 6 7* >I ! 7!8#$*I!9!!74+7 4!!40B* 7497!49!$I44+!! 76!**!$I+5!*77!; M%)D'G&!70 G5%%(%.%!70))-'!70)%(&%D%!70%+6+<0
=4" + 7+ > 7*!! 7 =+ 7+*! 4 =+H* 7 4!* ;1# 7 3 9*5 %--% 7 ! 6+7+ +9!!7=/*7!MM%--)40%DG<> =!+7*!!$"947%4*5%--3 7$>!=+$=66!744!77"9 4!* 7=/*7! !7 5!#! 6!B+ 4 4! 7=74*5%--3$)((.+>=44!> 7!! !! ! 7 #9!0 4 4 *+! 4 =!!*+ 7 H#* 7 7*!! 7 7" % 4*5 %--3 ! 7 =5 7 !! 4 =+ 7 H#*0=!!*+7+96!*)((.4">! !!>+=!77!B5!77=/*7!7+!9+ 4 C 1 7 +45!> 7 "9 9+!6!! 4" 7 !+ !! #9!0 =#!/$ +* 7= 6! !*44!>=!*7!6!*7!!740
D0 =!!*+ +* 4!* 7 7!66+ * 7 4!* #9! 4 + !6 !! 4 !> + 4++7!7+>9!+79!7=!6*7 =0'(7 0
!44>=774!*!*45$ I577!!!747=!!*+7>=!! !*57=*+>06!9!66>!4*$ =!!*+ 7=66!* >=! ! ++ 4! 77! @ 7= 4 =!!*+ +! 7 7*!! $ "9 74! %--& >=! 9! !!+ 7 !+ #9! =! 7 5!7 >=! 9! *! !7C 1$!!!066!*>!9!"# 756!4!!47=!7!!7=577!0
!57+"94+5*>=0G'0% 7!! 4!6!!7=$67==74!0 66 +!+7!6!=!H+4!!47+!+8!7!> =B+! 7 7! 58!6 7 *E* > 4!!4 7 I+#!+ 7 !* B!# > !! >! I 4 ++ 4 + I ++ !66! ! 4A 7 * L 4 4! ; M%)G'-G!7037<0
,%--&,)((. /%(,%)/ =4!4*7=66!*>=!!*+9!4!!475 6!!=4+++5!>=+!7H#*77*!!7 0
=0).0% 4+9!>7!$7!!!++=+!!> 4" 6! 7 =+ !9! 4 > !! 79! E 4 + ;60 +#0 M7)%89!)((G:--,(.!70)0%0)<0 747!4!! +#! = 6! 7!!! !! !! *+44+>+7!!4#++ +!9!;MM%--%%&%70'%<0
97>!4+"7 !57+>=!!*++!7! 7+*77+!74+*4!7!>4!*7= *4+* 7 !! >= !*!+ $ 4+!7 7 % * %--- '% *)((.0C7+*4+5!4=!!*++4 !/!!7?4 4!**$"97)-'60D(%---! 7)(-60.(7'(&60.()(((!7)%D60&(7'%D603()((% !7)''60%(7''%60-(!7)G)60D(7)3.60)G)(('! 7 %&3 60 -G 7 ).' 60 D( )((. ! 7 %G' 60 G(S *4+* 7 !!=+"9!!$GI%&'6044+!7!7++0
=!!*++*7!+E*4+7GK=7"*!7* %---0C=0)30% +7!!+H*!$ 44! 7=!+E *! + +H !! 7 !!!7?*9+*!9*7=!+E+*+! ;60 +#0 0 D <0 7! +> =>! 7 !+E >!4=!!*+6*+*B7!4!!+#4+!+0
D0 >! *4! 7= * 7 60 G((@ 47! B 5! 7 4!* 7 60 )G(, 7? 4 =!!*+ 7 7 7= 4*! 66 B **5 7 M+7+! ! 7 T! ;MMC< >! +!5++6!7=*4+*!0C=!!*+*4! B7*L!=#!7=5!44+777 >=9!4!!+$*44*!0
! 7 8+ 4! 7" > =58 7 4+!!#!*!+$7!!!++7+7 1>= *4!9+N7*+5!N7 ! E66+0
167+8+0
&0 =!!*+$>!7*+4!*7=!7*!+ +>!50
,%--&,)((. /%%,%)/ C=03%0 4+77!E!*44!7!!>#! 44!0>!5!#!77!*5*7 6!7+4;03%0# <0C8!47!+ #!! H#+ 7 UH 7 7! 45! !/*7! =4!!447!$77+4>=5!#!7; M %)('G)<0 B4!*77+449E+>=! 74!!+77!66!+7$9!7+47+! +!; M%%-.G3!7035@60!>C)(()403(<0 =4 4 =4" 7 > =!!*+ =5!7 4 7=!7*!+ $ !0
4 7 +** 7 8! 6! 7 4+7 49 E *!$H#74!>!#!7*!"+*+!+*!#7+#"+ ;60+#00&-Q7!4+77*!!!97%)4*5%-&GN <0 !7 6! 7 44 >= 9+ $ =+H ! E !*!+$4+"7+#"+7+*+!+0;60 M %).)&G!>C%--&40%-.<0 =!$ *4*+*+!+*!#7+#"+@4+**7 4+7*!$H#70
VVVV
,%--&,)((. /%),%)/ - 7 - . .-
80494 : 344 4 ;" $+' <
94
%0 +950
94
)0 877!7+0
'0 +54!7!!0
.0 !>4+7#!0
G0 6* 4! 7 >= 49 6* 4+ E 7 7+! 7 '( 8 7" !6!! 4 4! 7+ 7+ !5 6+7+ 7 CHR!JH6>! 3 3((. ! B*4!0 7+! 4 E 4#+0 *+*! 7!S < !7!> B*>7+!!7+!5!!477+!! >+@ 5< B4 4 > *!6 ! !* 49! 7*7 7+!!@ < 4 !# 7 4+0 C! *+*! ! 4 ! ++* +*++ < 5< < !/7 !56+7+744*!">=! 797+!950*+*!7*!* 7 49 >! 8! !! > 7+!! >+ =944 7 >++B4+7!+;0%')%(3%(&<0 #66!S +!7S W!7 1 !
4!6*74+E!6!+B4!!!>=$=66!6+7+ 7+45!>4#66
,%--&,)((.