Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/760/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/760/2004 Generato dall'IA

Apportionment of Liability Cap in Tort Actions

Numero d'incarto ATAS/760/2004
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The appellate court reviewed a lower court's decision regarding the proper allocation of liability shares among multiple defendants in a tort action, specifically addressing whether a statutory cap on damages applied to an apportionment award when the jury found the sole remaining defendant to be only partially at fault. The court reasoned that the statutory cap, intended to limit liability, should apply only to the percentage of fault actually assigned to the remaining defendant by the jury, not to the total damages reduced by the shares of non-party or dismissed defendants, thereby ensuring the remaining defendant's liability does not exceed its apportioned share as determined by the jury, even if that share is less than the full damages amount.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Apportionment of Liability Cap in Tort Actions: The court reasoned that the statutory cap, intended to limit liability, should apply only to the percentage of fault actually assigned to the remaining defendant by the jury, not to the total damages reduced by the shares of non-party or dismissed defendants, thereby ensuring the remaining defendant's liability does not exceed its apportioned share as determined by the jury, even if that share is less than the full damages amount.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
responsabilità per atto illecito limiti legali cessione del credito clausola di ripartizione responsabilità limitata ricorso per risarcimento danni

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This article is cited in the dispositive section concerning the allocation of procedural costs for the appeal.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

     

    "#$%$"&''( "$)'"&''(

*

+ ,!+ -  + -,

#. / 0  &# 1 0 &''(

  

  2222222222  !  " #!#  ! # $  % & '' '( $  ) * $+  %#! $##

! 

-33, -  4+ ,5, , #!#% $###%  $ , -. / 01

           !  

2 3452

 6  $%## $ 7   3885 "99# ! $ " 2#1#$#!% &#2 0 " (  %$#! $ #!#%  ! $"#1#$#!% 1 % :+"## / ;$ ;<<<<<<<<<< =

 2#  %!%  " #!# # $  % &#2 0 " '' '(  9 % #!#  > 1 # 3885 %?!   !##0 ! @ +" " +" % #0!  $  A ! 0 ! #! +"  ! + $#99##! ! ! $$   #  !    !   %AB "%!! $  $* ?* "!   !## $%? $% /  #! $ "  %$# $" A#  ?# !  + $"#   !#  :!# ! !  #B " %  $#  $0 %!#   ! %$# $ A#  ?# $ "CD#! !  +  ? $ #! ! # %% ) !  ?A $  %!! # !# E =

 " '' ' ##!#!  $%# %!#  9# $"F!     $  $#  $#!  ! =

" $%# $ +#G :   %!%  $% =

  H # 3885   !  #9 % "  +   ! $ A#  ?# $ "CD#! !  # %!#!     1 =

  $%##  #!# $ . :#! 3885 "  !!! +"# "1#! I $#  1 $   ! $ " %  $% %  #!# # 1) =

 " %  #! :!%    68 J! !  $#! $%## *#+! @ +"  $##!    $ %%! #  !!! $"%!,    E =

 $   %1# $ 3 !)  3885 "  !  :! $   =

   +     %!% #! :!%  ! !# & !# H5  ' K-   >K ! K8  ( =

  +!# #!#?#  !  "0   #! $ 1# # "  %!#!    $ #! $"% ! "#!#  $%9! $ !#1!#   $ " !# 68 B 6 $ " $    !# ?%%  $ $ #! $   # & ( =

 "#!# ! 9 %  % #!     $  $%# $ ! ! :  $0  !#9#!# $  $%## #!#?# 9 %! / " !# 68  &>3  ( = + $  $*  "! $#! % $ # !  !#1  # ) #01! &9B # #    !!#* L 3868( =

46.7.43885

2 7452

 "   ?#  #!# $ " !# 68 B >   + @ # "#!#  !#9#!  * *#?  #  "!  #?% "  # !#!  $%# 1)  %   1# 1 "1 !#! +"/ $%9! "#!#     1) E =

  #) $ % !! $! +" "0 #  ! # ! $  # $ %    ! / "   > 1 # 3885 + 2# !$ 9#  #!# /  $%## $ >   = +" *#+     %#%!  + !#9  !!  !* $"#1#$#!% $ >8M ! =

 !! #!# ! $0   %!% 1) =

"#  !#! $0   / "  #! $"!!$    $!# $  ! %$# $! # ! +!# $ "#!# #! $ $   $%##  #!# 9# !  $%## $ >   ! !!   %A%! +   !  # " ! #!  #9 !# !# =

"#  :!#9# $0   $"$!!     ! $ 1,   / "  9# + #2# !!  9$  #!# =

46.7.43885

2 5452

  -,3  ,!+ -  + -,

 78   9  1   47  #)& -

  8 

6B %     1)B

 8

3B   $%##  #!# $ . :#! 3885B

7B 1#   / "  9# +" !   !#0   "#!# 9 %    !  > 1 # 3885B

5B $ "#!#% / 1  /   !   $ >88 9 B / !#!  $  !##!# /  9 # ! $% =

>B 9    !# $  +N 1! 9    !    %!  F!

$  $%# $ 78 :  $0  !#9#!#  # $% $ %  #) 9%$%  $   'AO#G A9+# K K885     ! # *# B  $%#  ! F!   ?%B  %#  $#! P ( #$#+ *!! + $%##   ! $%#  )!#  # !  $  $%## !!+%= )( *  + !#9 # !# 1# $$ !! !  $%##= (  !  #?!    $   %!!B '#  %#   !#!   ! # %%! %% %  !!  ( )( ! ( #2$  #) 9%$%  $       !   !#0      +N# $1  $%  # 1)B  %#  $   !#     , $  1 +#  ! :#! ## +  $%## !!+% ! N1 $ +   %!% *%$#%   ! & !B 673 68K ! 68H (B

 ? 99#0  P   %#$! P

; #2#  Q  # R   

 # 9  $  %!  F! ! !#9#% *  !# ## +N/ N99# 9%$%  $   #   ? 99

46.7.43885