Scope of Arbitration Agreement Covering Statutory Wage Claims
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involves a dispute over the scope of an arbitration agreement regarding claims for alleged wage and hour violations, where the initial complaint sought relief under both the contract and statutory grounds, while the arbitration clause only explicitly covered contract claims. The court reasoned that the claims, although potentially cognizable under statute, were inherently intertwined with and dependent upon the underlying employment contract that contained the arbitration provision, meaning the statutory claims were not entirely separable from the contract claims. Therefore, the court concluded that the arbitration clause encompassed all claims arising from the employment relationship, including the statutory claims, compelling arbitration for the entirety of the dispute.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Scope of Arbitration Agreement Covering Statutory Wage Claims: The court reasoned that the claims, although potentially cognizable under statute, were inherently intertwined with and dependent upon the underlying employment contract that contained the arbitration provision, meaning the statutory claims were not entirely separable from the contract claims. Therefore, the court concluded that the arbitration clause encompassed all claims arising from the employment relationship, including the statutory claims, compelling arbitration for the entirety of the dispute.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the court costs.
Testo completo
!"#$%!%&&" '!($#!%&&)
'
'* *'* *
+, $ #& -. %&&)
!"#$%&'()* +$#
,&#
,-#.//////////",+0#&12&-,$ 26$# $,+--32&$$4&# % 5.#12
,-#//////////",+0#&12&-,$ $,+--32&$$4&# . -1-#
':7;'
* /'
! :9 1#- ()<" =//////////% 2&2 -#-& #>-&# $ ,++#! 621#-#(( "#-,,-$&&,-2&2?>2&'-$,0&2,+ $@A/////////// % B-'0#CD ,-2&2E! %,F& ,- 2&-& $2,#+- #2&-,$0#,>#++-6,#+&-G0,#&,&#,6,$"$-&#-F&-, & ,++#--&-, $ 0#,$-& -6,#+&-G" -- G $ 0#&&-, $ #1-" ,- & 6,#+&-, $ $,+- -6,#+&-G! ) 621#-# (( " ,-# ///////// / 2$2 H $+--&#&# --&-H $ =//////////% ! $#-#2&2#+02*0#&-#$1#-((;0#,-# //////////" $1 $+--&#&# 1 ->&# -$-1-$! -'- $2+--,2 $ && 6,&-, :; ,&,F# ((; & ,-2&2 3 0 $3$+--&#&#-#-&#>-&#$,++#$0-&&$&!0,1,-#$ ,-#//////////,&2&2#$-2:+#(()!
:! ,-2&2 2&-& 66--2 0#C $ - -�#,6-, % $ 2$2#&-,$�#-#,+$B-'0#C-E!C#1#-((;" $2#2$-#!C$20#&"#,$$-66-&2$0-+&! 9$2+F# ((;" ,--&2 0 $ 0-+& G- - 2&2 ,#$2 (621#-#(()!
8! )I-(()"-$20,20-&02,&#-#//////////& .//////////0,#1,-#,+-$-1##,&-&-,,-$@+,&&$ <38)6#!(662#&H+,-$I-&((;*+#(()G-1-&2&2#& # -# 0J2 H +0,J2 $ ,-2&2" -- G 0,# 1,-# 2$2 $ 0J#,&#-F&-,+&-C#$@,&-,6+--$@+,&&$39<(6#! 89 0$& +K+ 02#-,$! &,&-&2 $ ,&-&-, 0#-&-# $ @21-& ,#*(3()6#!;9!
<! : 621#-# (((" - $2,2 * ,1 ,-# .////////// #,##>22#0,#1,-##&#-#1#2,&-&-,,#& +,- $@1#- * $2+F# (() $@ +,&& $ <3((( 6#! 9" 1,-# >#2 * -" & 1,-# 2$2 $ 0J# ,&#-F&-, +&-C# $@,&-,6+--$3<)96#!0$&+K+02#-,$"--G0,#0 1,-# 6,#- $2#&-, $ -# 0,# &#-+&# 1#- * I-" I-& * 0&+F#&,&,F#*$2+F#(()!
9! # +# (((" #-F $ 0#+-C# & 0#,,2 6--& $ ,-2&2!
! #&&#$:;0&+F#(((",-#.//////////,++-G2*- G@-@1-&2&2G#0#2&&$@$&-,-#$,-2&2G-1-& $2& 9L $ &-, $ '- $,& #&- ,+-&-1! %, - 1-& ,-&2 * K&# 0#2& ,# $ +F2 >22# & * #$# ,+0& *
789:7: '87;' @&-,-# G@- 1-& #0#2&2! 1-& 0# -# 0#- ,&& 1 &-,-# G- - 1-& $+$2 $@-6,#+# - G@- -& K&# +#$0J#,++02,66#!
;! 0#& 02 6-& @,FI& $ $2,-&-, $ : 621#-# ((( $ ,-# .////////// J& 2&2 0J2" 0#,2$# 02 ,#& $#-# 2&2 2! G- ,# $2,-&-, $ ) I- (()" && 0#,2$# 2>+& 2&2 2" +- +F'&'- 0# ###" , ,++-&-, &220?,-G$,20##G&*-!
)! # I>+& $ 8 +- :" 0F-2 < I- :" #-F $ 0#+-C# -&,&&2$26&$@&-6&0#,,20-,$6--&!
(! # $2--, #20#&-, $ $,++> $ ) +- :" - #2+2 * ,-#.//////////,++$:93(;6#!9*&-&#$,&-&-,0#-&-# %' ' & ?M+>" -- G $ ,&#-F&-, $@,&-, 6+--" J ,+0#- 6#- $+--&#&-6" -&2#K& +,#&,-#" 6#- $ 0,#-& & &H $ ,++&-,"&*,-#//////////,++$(38;(6#!)9 +K+&-&# 0,#02#-,$$+-*0&+F#((;!$&-&-#$$2--,,&&, $H6,#+2,00,-&-,!
! 8 I-& :" - ,1#& &-, #20#&-, $ $,++> ,&# -# .////////// & ////////// $1& ,++--, &, $ #,# +&-C# $@ % B-'0#CD ,++--, $ #,# %E 0,# 0J+& $ ,&-&-, 0#-&-# %' ' ' " & $1& ,++--, &,$#,#+&-C#$@,&-,6+--B-'0#CD,++--,$ #,# E0,#0J+&$,&#-F&-,$@,&-,6+--!
! 8I-:<" #-F$2"G2&2&#+-*-&$ #2&-, & $ ,  6,&-, $& $ # ,N& :8" $+- $+$G312,00,-&-,6,#+20#$26$#,&# $2--,$-$)+-:!
:! %# #,# $ ,-# .//////////" #-F 62$2# $ # B-'
0#CD E 2 I>+& $ #-F $ 2 & - #1,J2 0,# 0#,2$# ,6,#+2+& H ,-$2#&! ,&# .& ,# ,&& G ,-# .////////// 0& K&# ,-$2#2 ,++ ,#> $ 6-& $ ,-2&2 6-- G $C +,- $ +# (() & IG3* 3,1#&# $ 6--& & G3- 3& -- #0,F $ 0-+& $ ,&-&-, +2 1& # 1#- (() G - ,-2&2 32&-& 0 $ -&&-, $ #$&&+& * +,+&! ,&#-#" - #20,$#-&" 0" $ $,++> #2&& $ 3>+&&-, $ $&& $ ,&-&-, 1# - $0- G3- #-& 3$+--&#&-,1$-G-$&-,! #1,J2 #-F$ 2"6-G3-6-H32&$$$,++>20#-G-$&#$6-&!
789:7: '<7;' 8! I1-#: "$+$#3&$2&#+-2#*G&-,$32&&$ #$&&+&$,-2&2*6-$+,-$+#(()"--G+,&&$ ,&-&-,$$C&&$&! #C1G30,C$0,+0&$ ,-2&2"&GH'-3H-&&0#,FF+&0"$+#,O,#21-#" A////////// % " $2+--,2 +,&-6 G ,-2&2 6,#--& 0 $ ,+0&F--&2!3-&-+2,&#-$-G2G$&&$,&-&-,321-&*6- +#(()* 3:;6#!9!
<! ,-# ////////// #,2 * $2&#+-#" 0# , ,##-# $ < I1-# : "&,&$+$&3-2&-&&,I,#0#&-*0#,2$#!
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
! # ,##-#$:1#-: " #-F$2-1-&2$+$#*- -$-G#0#&$-&2#K&+,#&,-#662#&*$&&$,&-&-,8+# (()!
;! #,##-#$ +-: "$+$#&#+- #-F$2" &F -$-G& 1&-&-, 0# 02#-,$ $ +,&& $ $,++>" ,&++& $-&2#K&+,#&,-#662#&*?G02#-,$$,&-&-,!
)! ;+-: " #-F$2,#$2*,-#.//////////$2- : I- : 0,# $2&#+-# # #->+& 6,#- 0# $+$#" $2- 0#,,>2 * $+$ < I-& : ! $26$# #,2*$2&#+-#$$2-!%#"2&2>#$2*I>#!
789:7: '97;' * '
! 0#+-#-"-,1-&$,&&#G3##K&$ #-F$2$8I- :< & $1 $26--&-6" G- ,# ,-# //////////" $ +# ,O $#-# 31-& 0 -&#I&2 #,# ,&# & ##K&! # -#" - 32&-& 0 $+--&#&# $ ,-2&2 0$& 02#-,$" 0$& G ,-# .////////// 2&-& -G-$&#" ,-& $C +# (()! ,&6,-" ,O $#-# $1-& K&# #0,F $ $,++> #2&& $ ,'0-+& $ ,&-&-,,- &2#-#*1#-(()"#0,F--&2,-$-# &# ,-# ////////// & ,-# .////////// $1#-& K&# $+-! # ,2G&" ,-# ////////// 0,##-& K&# &,?2 $ $#,-& 0# #2&& $ 0#2& 0#,2$# ,#& #0,F--&2 $ ,-# .//////////"$,#&G3-,#1G-&2$0#&-!
:! % & ,# -&->-H 30C +,&& $ ,&-&-, ,- 0,# 0-+&$G,-#�,F! 66&" #&G3-2&-&" $30#&",#>$6-&$,-2&2$C+#(()"$+#,O-2&-& -G-$&# $ ,-2&2 6--! 3&# 0#&" ,&# .& ,# $+- #0,F--&20,#,'0-+&$,&-&-,,-0,#02#-,$$# 1#-(()IG3# +#((("--G"$3?J0,&?C,O,-2&232&-& 0 #$&&2 +,+& $ ,  $ 6,&-," 0,# ,&-&-, &2#-#!
8! 0#+-# -" - ,1-& $3H+-# - ,-# .////////// 0& K&# & #0,F $ $&& $ ,-2&2 +2 1& # 1#- (()! ,6,#+2+& * 3##K& $ #-F 62$2# $ # $ ( ,1+F# :9" #-& K&# $+- G - ,-2&2 32&-& 0 $ -&&-, $ #$&&+&+,+&,O$26$#3&?#>2-G-$&-,!
1 $ ,+F# 0,#-& $,& ,-2&2 6-& 3,FI& 0,# $ #2 2 1& # +# (()" -- G3 1 $ 3H&#-& $ ,+0& F-# $ ,-2&2 8 +# (()" 6-& 2&& $3 ,$ 2>&-6 $ 83<< 6#! )9" & $ 0#,C'1#F$--$9+-(()",G,-2&231-&G$F- +,F--#$31#$8396#!"&$-G0,#-&321-&*:;3):<6#! ;9" - J - $3$+&&# G ,-2&2 2&-& $2I* #$&&2 +# (()! # ,2G&" 3-&2#2 #-& #20,$# $ $&& $ ,-2&2 +2 * &&$&!
<! C ,#" ,-# .////////// & & $ #20## -G+& $,++> #2&& $ 3>+&&-, $ $&& $ ,&-&-, 1# - $0- G3- #-&3$+--&#&-,$,-2&21$-G-$&-,!
%,-$-&-,$$+$#"$&&$,&-&-,8+#(()"J ,+0#- 6#- $ 0,#-& & $ ,++&-," 3& 212 * 3:; 6#! 9! ,1-&0#,2G&$$2$-#&&,++$0#2&&-,--&-$:93(;
789:7: ' 7;' 6#! 9! # -#" $ +# ,O '- ,+0#-& 2>+& $ -&2#K& +,#&,-# $3 +,&& $ 3 << 6#! )9" - J - $3 ,&#-# -&2#K& +,#&,-# #&-6 * $&& 8 +# (()! %, $2,+0& 6,#- 0# $+$#H$,,##-#$ +-: "+,&&$-&2#K& +,#&,-#&$3<:<6#!89!
# ,2G&" - ,1-& $3$+&&# G $,++> $ $+$# >+&2$C#1#-(()$)38996#! 9B:93(;6#!9' 3:;6#!9'3<:< 6#!89E!
9! ,-#.//////////&-+G3-,1-&2>+&$$2$-#$0#2&&-, --&- ,++ $ 83;(( 6#! #0#2&& 0#& 02 G3- 0J2 :! ,&6,-" && 0#& 02 &#-& H ,&-&-, 0,# +,- $ I-& ((; * +# (() & , 0 H ,&-&-, 0,# +,- F2G&! 0-+& $ 83;((6#!#-&$C,#K&#-+0&2#$#-C#!
! #2& $ G- 0#2C$ G ,-# .////////// & #0,F $ 3>+&&-, $ $,++> $ - $0- 1#- (() $3 +,&& $ )38996#! 9!
;! 2&&" +-12 $3,00,-&-, # ,#$,2 G3* ,## $ +,&&&$+$#I&20,##0!
)! ,-# .////////// ,F&& 0#&-+& >- $ " -$+-&2 $ 96#!-# ,#$2*&-&#$$20"2&& 0#2-2G&&-$+-&22&2 #2$-&#-,$3F$,F,#&-,BF*&,&2$ ,+0#&-,0#,$0#&-,1,G20# #-F$2E!
789:7: ';7;'
'/ '* *'* *
01-2-,, 3 4-- - 56 ")% 7
2-
! C13,00,-&-,6,#+20#,-#.//////////,&#$2--,$)+- :$$+$#*,##$)38996#! 9!
:! I&&$+$0,##0!
8! ,$+ $+$# * 1## * ,-# .////////// -$+-&2 $ 96#!*&-&#$$20!!
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
,0-,6,#+$0#2&##K&&,&-6-2H0#&---G@*@66-62$2# $#,-0#>#66
789:7: