ATAS/736/2005 · Intellectual Property Valuation and Royalty Dispute Remand (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The court considered multiple appeals concerning the valuation of intellectual property rights in a complex litigation involving ownership disputes and royalty calculations, reviewing decisions from lower courts that applied differing methodologies for determining fair market value and assessing damages related to past underpayments and future royalties. The reviewing court reasoned that the lower courts erred by not consistently applying the appropriate accepted valuation standard, particularly regarding the treatment of non-patentable but essential trade secrets and by failing to adequately address claims of bad faith in royalty negotiations, ultimately vacating the damages awards and remanding the matter for a new valuation based on a unified, legally sound methodology that properly accounted for all relevant intangible assets and conduct during negotiations.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Intellectual Property Valuation and Royalty Dispute Remand: The reviewing court reasoned that the lower courts erred by not consistently applying the appropriate accepted valuation standard, particularly regarding the treatment of non-patentable but essential trade secrets and by failing to adequately address claims of bad faith in royalty negotiations, ultimately vacating the damages awards and remanding the matter for a new valuation based on a unified, legally sound methodology that properly accounted for all relevant intangible assets and conduct during negotiations.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA

valore litigioso proprietà intellettuale valutazione degli attivi calcolo del danno diritto di seguito regime della proprietà

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the decision on costs.

Art. 64 LTF

Applied for the decision on legal aid.

Generato dall'IA

A/332/2004

Intellectual Property Royalty Allocation Dispute

A/2313/2006

Royalty Calculation and Enforcement in Technical Information Licensing Dispute

A/1772/2004

Royalty Calculation Dispute and Contract Interpretation

A/1767/2003

Intellectual Property Royalty Dispute and Contractual Estoppel

A/2861/2006

Licensing Agreement Royalty Calculation Dispute

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the decision on costs.

Art. 64 LTF

Applied for the decision on legal aid.

Testo completo

'()*'+)), '-*.'+))(

##/

# " " # "

0 * % 1 2 +))(

!"# $ %

!" %&#'#& '(!!#(%) *%+,-!!.'/0%1,23 !"!

'

.. 4 5. . %16'7%1,21

. 8 4 8 .. % 90-,1%622,

8 . . %&'% !#(! :2,,* ;

!"# $%&

/,$:/

3

1= >0"' ! 1, !#"- ,22<% - ! "? ' ! #&-@''!?)!&!)"0''# ,3"1AA,&!" ' =

,= 9((A!!&'(!>0"'&#'#% -!"?' !#'B !@5&''&'0&"'#! ) ! - &0 @ &!' "0 '' ! &#)C &(=

<= >0"'!!)'!)!#('('7#'<(#),226=

6= - ! # '# ! &' " ! ''' ! &#)C=

3= ! ,1 " ,226% !" ("# - ! # @5 !)' ((' !) 99 & ""@ ! 0"'&#'&''''#&'!!#@)'#'# "&'= &## @ !' # &##!' !)% 5)' '#&?!5'''!&#)C&(%!?@ 5''0'&"""@&&#?)"'!''= !#,6>,226#'#!#=

D= !11> ,226%!" ("# -! # @5 5#'' '' !5 "&' ! - &0 &? !5 ''' ! &#)C &( ' @5 5)'% !' "0% "#)B''= 7&@#)')#B'"&&'' -'B''!)(('&E'"B''= 5&& !!%>'!)(9!"''5-!'B !&#)C&(=

+= - ! # '&# .. 4 5. . F G &' ! ""@"''!) @ !'"0& %'',3"1AA,'<(#),226=

:= !<2&'"-,226% !@#@&''!- &0 ! !"! 5#)' B 8=1,H1,6=:3% #'' &## @ 5((' "'' 13 &'"- 1AAD ' )' & ( <2 ) ,221% @ 0'5'##)'')#&)''@5#5)'& !"!#B@&''!-&0''(##=

$32<$,226 /<$:/

A= '0#& -!#%!" !@#%& !,1!#"-,226%@5)'!5E'00#& IJ %7/#&7)' ')# & I . % & & ! '& ! &"' '"&% '""' * = &!' B 5&& ! ! &?/)-!"&'&!5!@5''!' ! 16 > ,221 !)' - ! "? '% !' ' @ !"!5'&!5"&!&<2),221'@5I . % '' "" * % ' (' ('= !"! !## 0 5 )' "&' -@# ! -@ ' (# ! ( "! !#"9&#'-5!&'!5')@77''&? !&'!&#)C!-K'"'=

12= !1:(#),223% -!#!"!#B .. . . ... . . )#!"&'!)!! =

11= .'"'#"""&C!)#&&#!!#'"' F(=!!,",223GL / . 8 F1AA,G /I . . F1AA,G / M %@!'F1AA</1AA6G / . 8 . .F1AA</1AADG /* . %@!'F1AA3/1AADG / F1AAD/,221G /J . .. F,22,G / . F,22,/,22<G 1,= -!#!'&#!((#'"&C'! & 7@ )' )# '' ! !"!= !"''&%''@!-%!&'!'!&#' >0"'=

1<= !"' ' #'# '" 7 &'= #'# !@# @5B !#(' !5-)'!5,DN',223%E''!''-=

16= !,DN',223%!"!!9((@)' #'# ""@# @5 ' ! !' B "'' ! 1<H,AA=A3= #@5)'&9"'"&'!-&0=

#

$32<$,226 /6$:/

1= 0) 50' >! FG #'# "!(# ' ''#% !? 1 N' ,22<% - ' ! F .G% "&#!@>0%!'&#!'')/&#!'%@&&#'' O>0F'=1'='3D G=

.'B5'!5#'!O>0& -(#!# F 8G,+>),226F 81<212DG%! 0)!&'#% 1<(#)%!&'''0'F'=1D,G&"''' . ! #0 % B ' >0 ''% ! 5''' ! 5#' ! )7>0=

,= H'= ,3 ! (#!# - &0 ! &#)C &(%)%))'')!'#!1+!#"-1AA<F8G% '#)01>),222%?0&#!!!)= !!#!!>'&''!'B&'0!!) F'= 1,, ' 1,< G% >0 ! ! !) "&#'' ! H'= +< =1%'B?) -'!!&1 N',22<F'=1'='3D=1'=-G%!'%&?@H((#'# '" F'=16, G% 7#' !H(( &'0 - ! # ! #&''!#'"#&>0!!)=

<= .H'=,, 8F)')0!&1>),222G% !!)%&''!'@!'"0'&'0# ("#"'7'=1,,%1,<%161'16, P'=<B38H&&@' &0"''B'(#F=1G=9@>'%&''! 'B&'0&!B!((#'&''!'%0"'# ! ) ! - &0 7'' #)'"' ""' ! !)% ' &'' ! '% 0"'# ! ) ! - &0 7'' #)'"'""'!!"0F(='=,68G= %>'B&''!''BH)!-&07'' ""' ! ! "0 '#E' ! ""' ! !) F 81,:,<2P 81,A666G=

3= 5&?% >0 ! &"? ' !# &'0 & "'# ! ) @ &!' !# ! "0% ' ! ,3 " 1AA, <(#),226% !' B @ >0"' ! !) ' !) 7#'% @5'&''#&&'=

'!!@!"!5@&''&!' "0=

$32<$,226 /3$:/

.50'!!"!'"&''!!#('!-'!!% 99 ' #)## != !#(')% 5'' ! ! &"!5#'-'')'L

2 4 25% 4 " 6%

1AA, !"''(#!# ''

1AA, I . ///// ''

"'' '(## B 1AA< . 8=1HA,,=<3 !' !1A"1AA<

"'' '(## B !1(#)=1AA<,:'=1AA6 4 8=:H3:1=,3 !' !1 "1AAA

1AA</1AAD !"'' (#!# ! '' !

"'' '(## B >1AAD * . 8=:H++6=D3 5''' &&#') !' !<2>1AAA

"''B&'0 !13&'=1AAD<2),221 8=1,H1,6=:3

1AN'<2&'=,22, J . //////////// ''

"''B&'0 !1'=,22, . % @ ! . 8=6H+2:=12 -0

<+",226 J . //////////////// ''

"''B&'0 . 8=AH+D+=// .

D= ?% -!7'''!&#)C!!"!! '(#"''!8=1<H<22=/FQ1,H1,6=:3R6H+2:=12RAH+D+=/SL,G "&' ! - &0 !' !"! ( !#= "'')#B!8=AH+D+=/&8 . % !%!8=<H3<<=/#'')#& . =

+= ("#"' B >&!% !& > !#'"' & &'0 >@H ""' ! '(' ! &'' ! ' ! !"%

$32<$,226 /D$:/

>' !)# -##( ! '' &'' !' B ! '#E' "&' "'' ! /= '#E' ' # '7 """ #0 H'= 1, ! H! &#)C &( )% ))' ' )!'# ! 1: ) 1A:6 F ,G '7 #0"'% / ' &# F 8 &-# <D$2, ! 1: >' ,22<G=

+= @(!!#&!%5'=+<=,&#@ '!)'&#)&#!"&%&!'%&&%0''= 5'= :A; = 1 ! &#! !"'') ! 1, &'"- 1A:3 F G&#)'@'B@&#!'0''&&'= '(% !#-'#""'&)'E'"B90!&'@0'! "?'#"#'#"0!#0?'#= (('%@ -(#!# ! 5 !"% &-'# ! "' 0''# ! '#"#'>'#B#0?'&&0##!&#!&#)& ''-9!F 81,D131!=6-G=

-(#!#!#0"'&&#@5C!( !((# '% !5 &'% ' ''# & " ! ( ! &#!B90!5&'@0'&#0?'#!"?'#"# !5'=:3=,'=!(#!#5/)'))' F .G F'"' '= D1 '= ! (#!# &' 0## ! [ %)0!&1>),22<]'%!5'&'% !'7!#&5'=:3=,'=( .['"''= D1'=0 ]%!'@5&&#'?!#)&&#>'!5' !!#&B&'0'"!'F'@.,22,&=D1G=

5&?% -!#!?@%5'!!#&>'( &%5'''!!!"!>'()9@5'!"#&"' !5 #""'= (('% &)'# ' "@ ! -' ' '' - B ! "- !#"9 @ ' #'# #)'# !"! 5#'' ("# B -0' ! 0% !' )' ' !5&-!E'!5"!5'=+3=5#""' (7#5B8=1H222=/=

$32<$,226 /+$:/

# 3 " # " " # "

%

748 9 2 :& ;.+ "$<

1= )'!"# B)"&'!-&0'B ""@ !# B 5. . ' B .. 4 . !"!#P

,= )'5. . BC'(#%&!#-'!"&' ! %""!AH<D+(=P

<= 5C!"''@!-P

6= )' 5. . B ) ! "'' ! '#E'"&'!?6(#),226!!#'P

3= )' .. 4 . B'(#&!#-' !"&'! ""!<H3<<(="&'!- &0!!" P

D= 5C!"''@!-P

+= )' .. 4 . B ) ! "'' ! '#E' "&' !? 6 (#) ,226 ! !#'P

:= 'B90!!"!#""'!1H222(=P

A= (" &' ! @H &)' (" ' &#' E' ! !# ! <2 > !? '(' & & ""!# !# - (#!# ! % .9TO9(@ D% D226 % ' 7"&= !# &' E' &0#= "#" !' L G !@ 7'"' @ !# ' !# -' ' & ! !#''@#P-G7&&@"'('"&)!"!'' '!#PG&'0'!&#''=."#" '' & ' ##"' #"## '' G -G ' G /!% -(#!#!&&'"'?@H !)!#)-="#"!"'"C

$32<$,226 /:$:/

! &)% @ ' >'% @ !# ''@# ' H)&& ! @#'#7&#!#'F'=1<,%12D'12:G=

0((?L #!'L 88 U. U

&("!&#'E'''(#7&'@5B5(((#!# !&0((

$32<$,226

Intellectual Property Valuation and Royalty Dispute Remand

Sintesi Legislator

Regesto Legislator

Parole chiave

Disposizioni normative citate

Decisioni correlate

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Testo completo