Enforceability of Arbitration Clause Upheld Despite Unconscionability Claim
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party challenged the validity of an arbitration clause within a contract, asserting that the clause was unconscionable and thus unenforceable due to procedural and substantive defects concerning the agreement's formation and oppressive terms. The court determined that while some procedural indications of unconscionability existed (such as unequal bargaining power), the arbitration clause was not substantively unconscionable because the essential obligations of the agreement remained enforceable and the dispute resolution mechanism was not overwhelmingly one-sided; therefore, the court upheld the arbitration provision, compelling the party to proceed with arbitration.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Enforceability of Arbitration Clause Upheld Despite Unconscionability Claim: The court determined that while some procedural indications of unconscionability existed (such as unequal bargaining power), the arbitration clause was not substantively unconscionable because the essential obligations of the agreement remained enforceable and the dispute resolution mechanism was not overwhelmingly one-sided; therefore, the court upheld the arbitration provision, compelling the party to proceed with arbitration.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the final order regarding the costs of the proceedings.
Testo completo
'()*+'+)), '-.,'+)),
##
# " " # "
/ .
% * 0 +)),
% "1111111111
" ! 2 3 ! ##+, !"#$%&''()*' '
!"# $%&
/'-(/
4
*0 *. + *((1 !# 2222222222 ,", 3 &# +& #4#, &5# 6 # +7#8 &9 #,, :2222222222;30
'0 # )%&+"'%%' 4#,,,##,455 )* ,+"'%%'&#,+#60
)0 1<4#'%%)=,=,3=55# =+&#> ? + ,3",,5## # +#, @A+8 9 0
$0 # =A= ,68# ++> B ,'*<#'%%$?=,4#,,#,8, :2222222222;3& & *CD%%%504#8# #4# ("'%%**(5,4# '%%$0 &# # ,# #, #6# 4 #8 # #4# 0 ,# < , = & *CD%%%50 # ,& ! + 22222222224#,, #, 8,&& *D%%%504 #8 # #4# <6=&+"'%%*0
.0 *15,4#'%%$==+", #, #,,:2222222222 ;30 &9/4"6=</36#,,,, # +##6# #6=,,,++,#6# >	*"#?0
E0 ,## E&+"'%%$= #5+,=,6=#&4#F , # 3 + =# +#, =# # #4#, # ,& 0
10 )% &+" '%%$ =#,, 5+, ,+# ,##0 #46,4## &##& "5#0G,6= +### =4# +# =#8 # # & 6 # =4# & &, ,3#6# # #,,++## H5#0 ++ =4#G#8, #6=##6# #,,&"# # +#,0 = 6=3,&# ,## E&+" '%%$6=# +=# 4# &, 3 #6# # 6=# 5# #++, #+0 & & ,+#&<#5# =, ##3=#,# ,#/ 0 =#&6## 96=84&,< ##,,#,0 & # 3 =&&# # &# =G# &9/4" =+", #, #,, *1 5,4# '%%$ # 6 #,,,, #3+F+ 6=#,,++,#6# 0
C0 ')5,4#'%%.=,,### 6#, =#,#6# & & *CD%%%504#8# #4# 0
-*%('-'%%. /)-(/ (0 ,## &&## '( + '%%. = 5#+, ,## E&+"'%%$0 # ,,6== ###&+ 4# ,## 5++ &, 5 ,# ,#, =,#+#5+,05#4#65#6=#4# #,, # ,, 4 6 =&# # ##4 &# ,# =# 5# =8 # #,,=, 4#&#"##, ,#4+&=#=4#&, =G#0 ,, 4, 6= = =, =4# & +& # 4 #,, 6=# 4# #, 3 ",,5## = ## # &+ =4# &## ##8 =#5 ,## &# # #,,0#=,=4#& ,+,6 #5+#,3 ,8 #4#,,5##"#6"5## 9F &## ,##= =,4 + +#0
*%0 # *) 4# '%%. =, #<, ,##0 5#4#6# @A+8#4 ,#/ =# +## 9 1<4#'%%)+F+6&#,### 0&4# 9 +&6#4#++#055#+6=# 4#6=###+"# #6# #,, # #=# 5# #++, #+0 # =I 4# +@ 3 #4 6 #4+#& ,+#&<#5# &,# ##6# &&4#&, ,8+G# +#, @A+80
0 4#,3&= ,& *'+#'%%.< 0 5#4#6=,=<+## #6,F#, 8, ;36=#4=##@A+80 ##+6=# & #,##8,J2222222222K#"#6=#,##+,&4#3 ++/3 6=#=8##,#, #8 ,# ,& ! + 2222222222  #9 =4# # #6, 6 + < 5#0 = " = , 5# #+&6= #3=# +#,,,3=,0#=#, ##+,946#+36&, #,,#, 3F#4 &#'%%) +",#,,55, 1<4#'%%)E&+"'%%$6#&,8##+++ ,8# =#,,0
*'0 5# &# 6 "# &# # &,<8+0
#
-*%('-'%%. /$-(/ *0 #84#=8##< ###>?,,+ #5#,##, 9 *H'%%) #" #+&, .<8 &,# 4#/&,# . &&, *E <8 >0 * 0.E ?0
;#3=# =,# *E<8& #"5, , '1<4#'%%$> L*)%*%E? #84# &,*)5,4# #&####8&+ #" # #,8 3 # <8 ## = =,# 4G<80
'0 5+,+ 3 D0 .E 0 * 0 @0 C #" # M # #6 # &,4 3 =0.E # 5, , &# 8,, # # > ? #4 3 # 5, , =/@A+8 "#8# =# +#, =#4"##, '. <# *(C' > ?0 ; +&, & <8 =&9##,"#0
)0 <, +& # 4 <# ## +&, 4" >0.E0*0@0CE% ?0
$0 ##8&&# 4##=,+&# ## #3 D# +#, @A+8 >0 C0 ? # =#, ##+, ,# #, 3 &, 3# ,# ,## =# # +#, @A+80
.0 5+,+3=0.)0' D +###& +&4# D55# ,## 5++ &, 5 @ <8, 6 #, < ### D & &, D8 +,# 3 ## 6D # , 6 #5## 4F #+&"0"## # ,##8&&## ### , # +F+ 6D # , , D&&,## 5#> L1*1# 0'B.)*$# 0$-?0 G#8 ,4# 6 # ,# 4# #+ # 4G+ ##3" &# 8 ,0 &##8 D&&###&, +&3 4 &&,## ## &9 G+ & &&5 # 5#0 ## #G# +#5 # F +# 6 D# &# ,& ## +,# DG+ && &4# D&&,## 6 3 # & ,,+ 6 ,##&M +##"+& ## 5# #>F0 *( ,+"'%%''''-%'# 0)0',5,?0
E0 =&9 # +#5 6 ## &+ 3 =#, ##+, &, 3 # ,# ,#####,# +
-*%('-'%%. /.-(/ N ,##,#",, 5##+&04#3&, ,+## #3 �
10 ?;<#& &"#,G L*')')$4#6#<# D ## &5# +&" 3 D +&I D & # 3 D# +#, @A+86"#6##,5++&&# ## 5#G ,## D+&I3#5/# +#9 ,+#0 # 55 ,# & "## D #&## D# +#, @A+8 ,8+# +#9 D# +#, , # D@# 4#&##D0)*0)0 0 ; #&##,8D& #3D# +#,&6#5#G ,##6& D+&I/&4#5# ,"+/ 6#, D#, ++" D8 ##8 D&# , D &##&# 5##9 D&#B # 4 +F+ <# &6#&, D�
## 4@ #55, 6 #, 4 &## #+#" 3 D+&I 6# ,5###4+ D&# # 5+ /#B &# # & D +&+4#3, #0
4 +F+6D&## DG#+#6#,&# ,### +& ,5###4+#4#,,0 ++ DD#,,&&##&&, # +#, @A+8> L*')')C# 01"-""B;'%%* O*$&&0$*/$'# 0 'B '%%%O*$&01%# 0'B L *$4#'%%) ('-%'?0
#"5, , > L ?&&,+#56#&,# 3 G#80 D8# 4 &+ A & 4# + D+#= ## #3D# +#, @A+8 >50 0 C 0 * 0 " ?0 # A 5#+ G," D8# D+&I,6#& 4##/6&#+#D4 & +F+ & & 5# ##8 6# "# 6 5++##,#4#,&+& #,, 6#4##0&&##&##9&&4 55 G #5 & 4# 6D "# 6# <+ @A+8 #55##+ A"0 D # & 6 L &, #9 # &+ 4 D+", +"#8P, #4+ 3 DG# 3 D#+& & 4# D, ## &5# +&" 3 D +&I0 ## #, #G# +#,3+&I,,8+ +###6## #6 ##, & # ,+#6 6# 4# &# #4#, #, ## #,,>50 L E+'%%' -('-%'?0
-*%('-'%%. /E-(/ & L #+,6=#D& +##" 5 5Q8,, # G &# G +&I, +#5 6D# &4 88 D&#VD###8# ++0DI & # 5 5Q # &## 5+ D8 3 # ,B # 5 "# &A ,"# D, &4# ,## 5# #90 D #+,# D8 ##86# ,+#D5Q 8#6D0)*0)0 6#4#3+""+&#"<#5>;*((1 O*%*&0) # 0 . ?0 &## 6D# D8# ,+# 6 &#"##, 55#4 D ##8 D#5 & ,## D&# # 4# & +& && # G# D� ,"# D, &4# ,## 5# # 9 > *((E-*((1O$*&0''140# 0*"'B;*((1 O*%*&0) # 0.?0
G&# 3 &##& 6 M #" 5, , ++" # D +### # #& G 8 >01*E31*E" ? D&4# ,+# D0)*0)0 > *((E-*((1O$*&0''E# 0*",5,?0++" # D +### # G &# & F G 6D# # ,# ,+# & 9+ &"##, 6D# G # #,, >50 L *'' '1) # 0 )B '%%$ O '* &0 *(C # 0)0'B L '1<4#'%%. $.-%$?0
# +F+ 4 #, D ;30 55 5+,+ 3 D0C0* D#D& #&,+#, #,,3 &"##, #+#, + # +# ,8+ D"#8# &##&38# #,,0 , # #&##,8# &# &##&6&6# ,##,, #4,8+ + ##0 # #, + #,/8, 6D#,, ,#8,+&##+&"3 # D +### D#,,I+> L )1-%' ''4+" '%%',5,?0
"? ; =##+, <#& &,#, # F #&,, +#9 65#&=, =F##++#,/8,G &#"##, =F # +#,0 & <#& # G &# 8 ##8 F G 6D# # ,# ,+# & 9+ &"##, 6D# G # #,,>50 L*'''1)# 0)B '%%$O'*&0*(C# 0)0'B L '1<4#'%%. $.-%$?0 #" , ,<3<8,6=+&# 4" J&4#K # #6# 6= &4# =&&,## ,# #, <8 & ,+#=#4# =#4#8&9+5# ,+# &,#,+ &"##, G, & =, # #,,
-*%('-'%%. /1-(/ ,@, M6 #+#,," ##&# >50++ ;.)'-'%%$ 1<#'%%$?0
C0 ? =&9# #6,,8 ##8 #,, :2222222222 ;3 <6=3 ## #9 *1 5,4#'%%$09=#,##+,&4#5+,+3<#& &&, & # , 6 # G &# ,# G 6=# # ,# ,+#9+&"##,6GQ# # #,,0
;## +F+6# #" , #&& =&4# =&&,## & ,+# =# 4# =#4#8 & 9+5# ,+#&"##, # #,,0 = # &&M 5# +#5 6 #++ @@,3# ##R&+#### #6, + =# +#, @A+8 6=# 4# ,, ##, & J ##K & # ,+#6 8 "# &,#A #,,5#6 J ##K36#5###,#5#,&0 ## # #6, "#6 6 #9 4## &0 # ,### ,, #8, ## 6 ,, +#, & ,&+ <5#6##&&&M#4 0 ,8 3 ,,+ # , =,4#, 6 # &,+&+4#3, #0
,6 ,## 5 # +#, =#, ##+, ,# &#+<#5#,0
(0 5# # 3 G+# # 8+ #46, & R &# "5#0
*%0 ? ,#+3=,4#8 L <8,S = , 6# 5## 8#5 G 8 =/@A+8 =4# +# =#5+ 6 5# ##8 G# 4+ =# +#, @A+8S68 =/@A+8& #8 &,+=,4#,,6#,&#/# =#=# #6 =&,< #0# +F+#6 & &# =#> L *$+'%%) *'%-%'?0
&&#" =&9&,4#30'16 #+# +# +&,8 =G,# #4 # #8&#,, # "#8# >0 *?0 @ # =F #, &##& 8#+ #"#8#0
-*%('-'%%. /C-(/ "?#&##&6<#& , ## #3&# "5#&,3D0$0* =###5, ,> 0?4 ,8+ ,8#+ D0 ( 0 > L *'E )C1 # 0 )?0 D ## 6D #8+ ,## , &4 "#8 D +### 3 # 3 D +##, 48 # 3 # # # ## / +#4/,#0 56D#, ##4 ## 93D,8 D& ,+#,6D#8##,4#8# #+# +&, 6 D +##, D# & & +& #++, #+ D#G# #8+"6D##5 , #/# & & #&## 6D# # + #5# "# &,< #B # 5 5# 6 # D# & @8, &# ++ N #8+,, ,> L*'*EE# 0',5,B L '. +#'%%*T)')-%%?0
# 3 &# " 5# && # #, #8+" #&##&#&D +##,0#G## D& +6#/##+&,+#8+ , & D#,0 4@ # #, # F #, # D & + 6 +F+ #8+ " D +##, # &# +F+ #&## ># U /V @W #+ X55#@ @ Y *(C) &0 *%'B +F+ L@ 7Z5 4 @X #R[*((*&0*E?0 6#&4 # #, # & G#8 & #0 55 3 &# ++ N D +##, + , #8+ # , &,+&# 5# 6D ,& ,8#4 #/# # &, +&+0 9 &4 # #, # ,, ++ , D# &&M 4#+"" DG&,# 8,, 4# 6 D +##, # +&,+#8+"> L*'*E1# 0'"BF &"#, 0 1+#'%%*\ '1-%*]B L C+'%%$T*$(-%)?0
? =&9"5##46,&&&M&+#< 3#/##6 ,<3,,4,0##=&,,,"##+F+ ,8,6=#,##+,##5# #8+,63 #G� ,68++",8+35G0
+#9 G&##6#&,9 <,0
-*%('-'%%. /(-(/ # 4 " # " " # "
%
567 8 0 9& (:+ "$;
7
*0 ,4"0
% 7
'0 <0
)0 #6&, 8#0
$0 5+ &# 6= &4 5+ &, F ,# )% < 9 #5## & &# ++ , , #" 5, , ;@^#W@56# E E%%$ # G+� ,# & F &8,0 +,+# #R ? # #6 G+6 ,## ,#"##& ,## 6,B "? G& & 6 +#5 # #+ &4# + ,##B ? & #8 &,0 ;# +,+# # & # ,,+ ,+,, ? "? ? #/ #"5, , &&+#96=# 4 ,#4"0+,+# +#+I &4 6# <# ## 6 ,## 6, =4&& 6,,G&, #,>0*)'*%E*%C?0 855#9 ,# R #LL _#; _
+ &, F#5#,G&#;,# = 3 =,+#&855
-*%('-'%%.