Petitioner Liability for Subcontractor Injury on Controlled Site
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe petitioner appealed a finding that they were liable for injuries sustained by a worker when the worker fell from scaffolding while performing demolition work, arguing the work was subcontracted and thus the petitioner was not responsible for the scaffolding setup. The court reasoned that the petitioner maintained overall control and responsibility for the site, including safety, as the work, although performed by a separate entity, was integral to the petitioner's own project, and the general duty to maintain a safe workplace extended to all personnel under the petitioner's supervision, thus affirming the liability finding.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Petitioner Liability for Subcontractor Injury on Controlled Site: The court reasoned that the petitioner maintained overall control and responsibility for the site, including safety, as the work, although performed by a separate entity, was integral to the petitioner's own project, and the general duty to maintain a safe workplace extended to all personnel under the petitioner's supervision, thus affirming the liability finding.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe costs are imposed on the losing party (appellant) according to this article.
Testo completo
"#$%&"'((' ")'*"'((+
,,-
, . ,. .
#* / '((+
01 .2
3333333333
44. . 5 ,. ,,-. !"#$%&'#(&(()*(+
!
/&01/
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
0('!10&22& /+01/
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
0('!10&22& /%01/
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
0('!10&22& /'01/
.<- .*>. ,99,. @ -= @ 99 3 ((3 $.*, & -, &22&# 8 7 * @ .,, &% 7*, &22& $$ 8A- D5 .-&C*-4&22(3 (&3 ,4.#$J+2$-4&22+#-,3 (+3 8,,-. ,7. $) ,4 9.. : M ;O ,@8,8.,,F7< ,4 , )* $ ,4 9..# &" 7*,&22%# M #$J'*,&22%#.7<-$ ,4 . * . 9, >8, -$,, 9-@,3
,
(3 ,<*,8<,,7,,,:;..-,9,.,,.# )(K&22+# ,4,#-$.' 7<#$.,*,/$.,#'$$.(C7< :3(3'C ;3 D,@8,8.,(C7<#$ ,49.. &"7*,&22%: M(+2(2C;# ,<*,$.#(+ 9.*,# ,$,, ,, < $- ,4 , ,.< @ , 7< ,,# # 88.,*A7<3
D,$4,# ,49..#J( 7,&22%#9,-.>,$,,,,,,,$ ,.,9-#L#,9..:J(3(1+0&22%;3
<-,,>,8,,,,. ,4 ,# , .. > ., ,4 $*, J -, # * 9 .<, , 9..# , 8 83'",9..C4&222$,<.., ,: ;3
8 -$,, $.* @ 83 (C& > ,4 . $.3
9-.- @ 83 + 3 + , <*, -,9, , 8<,, 7,,, :; (% *-4 &22&# . *,< ( K&22+#$.#,,&29.*,&22&* --,, -,) 8/*,, *,*#
0('!10&22& /C01/
8/,*,,.# 8, $ $ <,# $, 9.. -$.-, @ 8/*,, *,* @ 8/,*,,.#$, .A=B- 9, ,8/-,.#..-,899, ,4. :933'C3(=3&;3 &3 D83% P G8,*,,.,-,,$,.<,$.-.$- < .# >, . 8 , @ . $= ,># - $*8,9,-,.<.,#8-,8,3 8,*,,. .$. * ) >8 # $ <*,.# $$@*,,A$,,.,I3 83&13& $.,P G 8.*, 8,*,,.# * *, > 8,*, $, 4,AN8,*,.>8$,4-,#$) A.,.*-.$,-$8,, .>,,4. -=. *,# -$. * >8, , $ 4, 8,8.,$,*,I3 #8313( $.*,G>.,*,-.8 ,*,,. ,--,# , @ - .$, >, ., @ .4, $,. <,# @ 8-.,# @ *< @ 9*, 8<3 , .-,. 9, .8,*,.$44I3
+33 ,49..: M ;..>Q$,,$#7< Q .$-,9,-$.,A#H=QA$.$.,.- -,$.,@,$,,7,9,Q., $-.,AQ.9,.3D7,$#$* ,,Q.QA$,9,>/,, ,, >Q A$, . $ ,4 ,9,- , -,) *,3 # > Q $.,, .- $,, , $ @ - .,- $, ., QA$# $ A# # ,$.,,*<,,$7<#4,# ,,-$.-,9-Q* A$,-., : M((1&1C,3(4$3&!2O((&+2,3($3+&.9.O 5 (!!2$3(1"O 314&22&;3 43 8$)# 8A$, $,,,$,, &% $-4 &22( ? -$ -)# $, . 47,* 8.# ,,># ,<, ,, > 8$$.,, $,3 9,#.$$.,.-A>,,*@8,94 $,. *,3 A$, 9. 4*, $$9,,*,<,-$)3
0('!10&22& /"01/
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
0('!10&22& /101/
, . 4 , . ,. .
67
(3 .*43
67
(3 -#
&3 .,,8 &%7*,&22&3
+3 *,,@8 $*.,,,.3
%3 9- $, >Q $* 9- $. J ., +2 7 ) ,9,, $ $, --. . ,4 9.. # D=S,F=9>, C# C22% # , A-$,3 ., $ J $<.3 -.-, , P ; ,,> A- >Q .,, ., 4, , $ .,, >.O 4; A$ $ > -,9 , ,- $*, - .,,O;$,<$.3D,-.-, , $ , ..- .-.. ; 4; ; ,/# ,49..$$-,)>Q, *.,*43-.-,-,- $*# >, 7,# ,, > .,, >. Q*$$ >..A$.,.:3(+&#(2C(21;3
'3 ,9, $. J A $,# ,, >Q@ Q99, 9.. ,3
<99,)P $.,P D .,5
$,9-$.J,9,.A$,,,>8@899,9.. ,$<99
0('!10&22&