Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/72/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/72/2004 Generato dall'IA

Enforceability of Settlement Agreement Despite Subsequent Finding of Mental Incompetence

Numero d'incarto ATAS/72/2004
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

A party sought to enforce a settlement agreement that the opposing party subsequently claimed was invalid due to lack of capacity and a subsequent finding of mental incompetence related to the execution of the agreement. The court found that the settlement agreement was valid and enforceable, reasoning that the party challenging the agreement was capable of understanding the nature and consequences of the settlement at the time of its execution, as evidenced by their participation in negotiations and execution, and that subsequent events, like a finding of incompetence, do not retroactively invalidate a contract made by a competent party.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Enforceability of Settlement Agreement Despite Subsequent Finding of Mental Incompetence: The court found that the settlement agreement was valid and enforceable, reasoning that the party challenging the agreement was capable of understanding the nature and consequences of the settlement at the time of its execution, as evidenced by their participation in negotiations and execution, and that subsequent events, like a finding of incompetence, do not retroactively invalidate a contract made by a competent party.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
trattative transattive capacità contrattuale decisione esecutiva validità della clausola arbitrale contratto di organizzazione responsabilità contrattuale per persona ausiliaria

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Provision cited for the order regarding court costs.

Art. 64 LTF

Provision cited for the order regarding legal aid (granting thereof).

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

         

    $%&'($)) +$,)$)'

-+

 +!. +   !

# / 0 )'

&1  2 3





0 4444444444   !"  #$ %%%%%%%%%% !



!

55! +  67!8! !+ # &!'()*+ ""$









 

          !! "# # ,-.(, 

 5!+



/4 56%%%%%%%%%%)#$7/''89 :"$;"<)#!9 5=>#/!?%%%%%%%%%%)!"6@"!#!$""" 9!!>4

-4  6$" %%%%%%%%%% 5 "  / !+$7 -333 9 *+ !A  "# $) : #  $$7 76"" #5 !""! # B!#&4

84  5=> # / ) 56 !66 #5 7"$ 7")   " ! "$$#"$ 6" "+ # $ # #"! ""+  " #  #!$""95!C4"$)56&#*5=>#1 #&:!$!""C#!7#>>)"76""#$ #!>!#"&:!$!"")D>$4

14 ##/-!+$7-33/)!?%%%%%%%%%%!#!#$# # "! # 5,"+"#" !  => # $!" # -3  +!) !""  "  :> # $ $#" ;!:$!!>") >!:") &:!$!"") !>!#"< "" C # $!& ?""" ;<6+#6"4

24 E   $#") #  !" # -' !+$7 -333)  #!! %%%%%%%%%%"#"CC56!66"#!7#>>!C5" +"#B976""#5":>!:!:!"C+!#$>$ 9*+4

!#!#5>!:"7"/3#$7-333#!! %%%%%%%%%%CF

G56">@!:!":C"##"66" #"#!$"#!#+!$F

, E!",$!  ">"6F $# $!") !!#""! !! "$$) !7 #  >"! # !) $!"" 6" 7!") !7#"!4

, 66"6) !"  "!F "C"#) $+" >"! # $!"!) !$$#""!#6"#CC:!)$+""$# !"4



./012.-33- ,8.(, 

, "6F !7 +"!,"?) #"66" "C) #"66" # 57"!4

"""#5"$>"C5!!$"#56#"+"#+" #!B!!"!$7#!7*$)!$5!HI4

#!!"C56+"76""#&:!$!""+ !"+9*+C5""#!$""+"!>!#"4

 ! 7" # -0 $ -33/)  #! %%%%%%%%%%) !:!:!")  #">!"C!7#5""!#:!"!)##! #>>!""C5##5C"""!#>>"4

##5?$66#!!%%%%%%%%%%G  # "" "+ !  !7 # >>I)  !" #  :" !>!#"C   !")  !"> C 56 +"  "+" #" 5=> # 1   !>!#"  &:!$!""  D  #" $7 -33/ 9 *+) !A " +" >$ 6" 5!7B # #? !"! ! 7"$ 7" C" " +" $" #  5" +" # #? &?;!#0$-33-<4

 # /J $ -33-)  #!! %%%%%%%%%%  7") # ! ! #95,"+"#")C56!66"##&?"+!7 +"!,"?)!7#!!#""!$!")#>"!#!# "!#$!""6")!7#>>!"+!7# 5""!  #  :!"!) !7 # 5"!4  ")   !6"$C56+""+"!>!#"&:!$!""D #"5=>#1)"9*+#"$7-33/4

04  + # #!" $#") 566" ! # 5,"+"#" ;",* 5 <#!"#""!#6##/'-0+"-33-$!"6 C  $ $#"  $!& ?""" C" " !7B"+$ " + 5  E"  !+"  K "  :>  5,"+"#")$K$5""$#"$B"6")"!#""! #5 5"  $"4  5!) 5   !"> C  66"! #! !66" 56 +"  #">!"C  " + ! E""C#"$+"#5!#B9"+"D ! : # 66"! "+!C4  "# # + "" C  B"6""! ##"$$#"5$"C"!4

(4 ##/2$"-33-)!?%%%%%%%%%%!"B!!$#  6" !  !" #""! $"!) !"  # /' +" !$$#"7"$)#-0+"!9



./012.-33- ,1.(, 

5>!:"&:!$!"")""C#-0+"-33-"+9 6!$"! !" " ;!>!#"<4  ! " C5"  !"""  !"7"! ? 6" !" + "  "+" !:$!!>"C $" #$#" C 5!   $""$$  #$# # "! # !>!#"#&:!$"4

J4 !+"#83B"-33-)5 !">C5+##"!""! # !+"!6!,"#"!")!#""!#5! 5!7"!#$##"!5"$")!">C 5"7"+!E"C56+"7!")!7B"+$  !  $"* 6!") # $ $#"  #  6!$"! !" !""4 5   !  B # !   $"" # #""! C4

'4  ! 5!  6!$ #5!7+"! #  #" "$"   !$$""!!#!4



 !+



/4 7$)"!+"#"C!"6#"># #!" #  !" ; <    +">  / B+" -338) L#!$7$!#"6""!##!$"#5,"+"#"4

#5*#$!6!">"#"!""!+">BC58/ #$7-33-)>#""!C*>"7!  +">  $!$ !A  6" B"#"C$ #$"  ! !#" ; D /-(  10( !"#4 /<4  !)  B> "  >" # #""! C)  *> >) #5* 5 # 6" ?"  $!$ !A  #""!"">"!#; D/-/800!"#4/7<4

-4 6!$) "7#!C!)"B$")  +7) !6!$$ ? 4 0' #  !" 6#  5, "+"#"#/'B"/'2';",* <J1#!"6#5, +""+"+#-0#$7/'10;",* E<!"74

-74 ")"!+"#+C!">+!"5!>""!B#""" # -- !+$7 /'1/ ;<   $!#"6"  C5 "7 ! #



./012.-33- ,2.(, 

!"""#*/!M-338)""C) !$$   !"! "+ 9  !" 6#  5, "+"#";644/4204/4:4/<4

$"#5!66" "7)!6!$$954848 ##"!""!"!"#/1!+$7-33-$!#"6")C"#! !$!B>##5*4

84 5"+"#"  #6""   !" !$$  #"$""! #  " # >") $ $ ! # !> #) C"  #5 " 9   :&"C ! $) !+ #5 "6"$" !>") #5 $#" ! #5"#;41 <4

5414- "C5"+"#"+#*C5)     >+") ! 9 !+" #!" ? "!   !"#"!4

54'48 "F

G >=># $!"#-3+!C"!#!$"" "#:7"E"!#!"?$##"!;H<"F

4 ! #  + # 5"+"#")  * ! $* !$) 5" 5>" #5 ! >*)  $!"   "* # !""! ! #"? #"#""!$E""

74 ?,$K$ !  "+"#  E" !) ! #  + # 5"+"#")"#"E"""!#"$!" !#""I4

14  ") ! 54 /- #  !+"! # " !"   !6#"! "   7"C 6@")  6 $" 6@" +#?$##"!#5,"+"#")#!6! "  $ $#") "  $!$ !A 5"+"#"  +) " ! "#  E" # $"* ""!$ #    $!" ! !C5"!"+"#E"! &!"##$"*""!$ #""4

24  )""##C56 /J#$7/''8") C""!"6@"#!"!E"/!+$7 -33395=>#0/3$!"4E!#!#$### /- !+$7 -33/  + #  "  :>  5,"+"#" #



./012.-33- ,0.(, 

$ $#" ;!>!#") &:!$!""  >!:"<  # $!& ?""";<4

 ! !6!" $"6$ # ! $#"? +  #!") C 56 76""" #B9 # $ $#" $"! ! C5" :7""  D  C  + # 5"+"#" 5 !#" + 5"+E"#!4

 66)  !>!#"   &:!$!"" "" C  "$ !:$!!>"C!#">!"C#"7"+5E" !+$7-3334!>$!"+#" E"4 95>!:")#">!"CD#7 B+"-33/9*+)!"!"$!"*5E"4

04 D!  # ! C  !  $"  !#""! ! "  54'48 " !+"!$"!4

+#C"*#)#""!#/'-0+"-33-5  !!6!$#!"#!"+K!6"$4







./012.-33- ,(.(, 

  +!5  +!. +   !

#

 9 0 

/4 @!"!4

# 0 

-4 B4

84 6!$  " #  CN + 6!$ ! !   K #  #" # 83 B! #*  !"6""!  " !$$# #  "7 6# # ) E:O"P:!6C" 0) 0331   )  !" ?$"4  #"   K !!>4  $$!" #!" F < "#"C ?$ CN #""!  ! #" !7"  "   #  #""!CQ7<?!!C$!"6""$!+!"#$# #""!Q<!">!#!4E"$$!"  !"   !" $ $ !  < 7<  < ",#)  "76##!$"*!CN" #+#"+74$$!"#!$"!!$!& # +) C" ! B!") "" C  #""! C  N+! # C?#"!;4/8-)/30/3J<4  "#F >66"*F  !"R    &E 

",B"F ?#  



!"!6!$#K!"6"?"""CN9N66"6# #!">66



./012.-33-