Contract Modification Superseding Indemnification Clause
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA dispute arose concerning whether certain contractual provisions, specifically regarding indemnification for a specified period, were enforceable or voided by a subsequent modification to the agreement. The court reasoned that the modification, which broadly stated that all prior agreements related to the subject matter were superseded, effectively nullified the earlier, time-limited indemnification clause, leading to the conclusion that the limited indemnification provision was no longer binding on the parties.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Contract Modification Superseding Indemnification Clause: The court reasoned that the modification, which broadly stated that all prior agreements related to the subject matter were superseded, effectively nullified the earlier, time-limited indemnification clause, leading to the conclusion that the limited indemnification provision was no longer binding on the parties.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive to rule on the costs of the appeal proceedings.
Cited in the dispositive to rule on legal aid for the appellant.
Testo completo
#$%&'#(%%) *#)$+#(%%)
,,*
- *,.- * -, .
/ 0 (% 1 (%%)
!! " ## $ % & & &* '()%
!"
$/+($
2.*
,0 % * 1 ,(2/% 3&* & & 45 6783%9& *"&$: ;&&8%7:& :0
/0 < 3& 7 ,--= :& >- & /-->% "& ** *:* : & :8 "??& "$&3&& * @&$ :8 A ,B&/--C%3& 7" &" 0
>0 " " :*&*&"*:8": D& % && 9 & & .)0 :: * 7 " & *& & " : D&% % *& D**& % :* &D & *:& 3 :& *; &/-->%D &:& * 3&,--=7: >-&/-->0
C0 ":* &&& *B&8: D& &%%:*&& !E:'4& & :'4 4*:&% F: &*"* :*&D & ;": &3: ; & &F * & & 0:: "F: &,2/--> @ G /--CA% & *& % "D& :& * 3& G H : : 9 :& 3&*3& : & G.-=:& * 3&7 : ,)&/--C%& F&:8 3 ,--=:& * 3&7: ,CB&/--CH0
.0 :: ,) /--27" & " % :*&D &E:&,/&/--C *:&*:&?D3& * '!>/0,-:&&/-->0#&%"&:& * 3& ,--=8 >-&/-->0"F:: *&% *9 " &3& * F* B9" " : F&D&;% 9"& ' && & ,--=%9"&"':"*& &:&;:& * 3& : :* 9" : F&D "* 9" F &3& *0
20 3&>-1 /--2%#3&*&*D&#&$@# #&$A &3& & "F: & :'4& &9 &**9%:& 3:'4&9%"*3& ;& &:& * 3&>-&/-->,2&/--C%:&&:& *.-= ,)&,CB&/--C% 89:* 73:& * 3& 0
)0 ,- ;/--2%" *7"*:B *&&%F 9* & B *%89"F: &:'4& &9&: :": D&/--C3& ': I9&" :"*:&*:&?0
+,-.(+/--) $>+($ J0 & /> ; /--2% "* &?* " 9" * & * & : &% :8 F " % B 9" "3& : *:* : :;8 :'4D&90 &?* " 9 " : D& " &&* 7 ,--=% & : "F: & :'4& &90 F:* 9" :3& &3 & 4*:& 9" 44& & *& & 1 K ?? % "* & : 3 : & < : :& D0
(0 #& 7 :: "& ** ,C *; /--2% " % : *&& ,/?*3& /--)% B * : &% *?* 7 "F: & :'4& &99& 7*:&*:&?% &* 9""3& :?& *&:*&D% ? : *& :&D &3 & :'4 4*: &90
,-0 ,> /--)% "& ** & B % 3 9 * * " : :'4D&9% & ;& :4'&9 9" * 3& 7 " *& & ?&9"&F:& &083 9" ;F: &:'4& &9?& &F & ; " F: :'* : :* & & :'%9":*3&* *%89& 83::'4& &%&;&:* "*&0F: 9" ?& : *D% 9" D % 9" 1 & & 330 *&&" %? 9 & *:;8:'4D&9 9"&3*& ; * *0
,,0 *:,- &/--)%" %? "F: &* ;&: ,2/--2@G,2/-->L/--CLA B 0:*& ?&99&9"&& %:?%& 7 &$ 3& < * ;&::*&&& * :%& B9" ,>B&/--C0
,/0 *:&9 /. & /--)% :: 9 "F: & :'4& &9* ;&:* *?& 7" :* &: D&0 & " : 9"& :' " : : "F: & % :8 &3*& & 9"* *3 7,--=:" &: D&6B9">&/--.0*& 3 :; 7"F: &0F:9" & * * :4'&9% :'4D&9% 9" *:* : & :8 "$&3&& *% 9 " *&;** &D*0 8D?&9* *"*":&0
+,-.(+/--) $C+($ ,>0 &; * 39* : & & : & : /- B& /--)0 &% :*&* 9"3& * *M:/--C%&' * * * : " :* & "&3&& *0 ** 9 9" *%3& "::&D & & :& 7 :& & *:F * & & &0 ' * * &F% & 3& < : :*0 :& &?& *&* ;&: ,(B&/--)% &?& 9" * * ";&D & "& : &3& * :?& : & *& :& >, & /-->% : :*&&* &*%&&9"*: &$&.)//B3& /--2 3 "&& *B&8::*&,B3& /--./C&/--.0
:* " &9"&':;8"& & &0
,C0 #9&%* *D*7BD0
,.*
,0 ?* 7 " 0 .2 0 , 0 40 / & D3& "D& & B&&& @A% &; & N & &9 &:*37O 0.2&?**: &D** & &2 ;/---@ A9& &37 &?**O$&3&& *,(B&,(.(@ A0
/0 #:* :BDO:8 &&* ;&0
>0 * 3&D , B3& /-->% N &?& & ; &:& & *D & &0 # : *&%:& 3&9& "::&9& < 4*7&8 :&&:98D::&; 3&D P ?& B&&9 * & :& @ !,>-/>-&0,0,K >>.&0,0/K !,/(C&0,0/K !,/)C2)&0,%,/2,>2 &0C; *?*A08D:*9 7"::&9 *38B *3&D@ !,,)(>&02;%,,/>2- &0CK ,((JQ>):0>,2&0>;A0
"& 9 &:& & *& 9 :* O::&9 ":80
+,-.(+/--) $.+($ C0 B * ? *& :& % 3; @ 0 .2 2- A0
.0 3& * && :* & 7 *&3& 3 & 7: &"$&3&& *0
20 # " 0 C 0 , % "&3&& * @ 0 J A : * " &?&& * D*& %"&"& 0 F " 0J0, > % *: * &3&& * O&:& * D& : & 9& :** : D *0 O&3&& * *: * 3 8 9O : D3& *% :: 7 3& & F : & &* &0
*: * &:& * 3& : % : &% O: & O*7:&:?&&O &3& * 3&9&: < &; F&D* &% & : * * :4'&9 0 O&:& * 3& D *% O &3& * 9& : < F&D* & : & 3 O :?& O & O &3& * @ 0 2 A0 *: * &:& * D& && & O; O : & :&;&& * D& O* 4* 3&*9&&;*9& &* &%& && &* O & 7 * :4'&9 9O :& :8 & *: &F&D&;@ 0) A0
# " 0 /J 0 , 3&D B9" >, *; /-->% "*& 7 &8"& &3&722/+>=&%7&$ "& &3&7.-=&%79 "& &3&7C-= &K :*&;% "* : % ":8 " 0 /J 0 ,;& % :* 7&$ "& &3&7C-=&0" *3&D% ,B3&/--C%C8*3&& &?&* " 0/J0, &? 7 "*4 F "&3&& *0 9" &8 * & * :3 7 * 8 9 D* "&3&& * &D& 22/+>=% &:& &:*3& *&" ' &$9 7 * :* D* "&3&& * " & 2- = &87& F :*&7)-=%& & &37" & " 9 " &$ &4D*0 34% :&&: *3::* B9" : B&: &8 "*3 & "&3&& * 3 3&& *% 9 & ":& C8 *3&& @ !,>->CJ&0>0CK ! :;&*,)&/--.% )+-.%&0/%2: ;/--C%/C(+-C%&0CA0
45 * &?% D* "&3&& * & < *3* ; " :& 30 % 3 9 "* & : ; & "& "* & : &3& :* 3 & 9"& :& ; & FM
+,-.(+/--) $2+($ " &3& * 9& : &; < F&D* & :8 & *: &% 4* 3& *9&&;*0 :& 3"?? %8D&&%4&?? &F 9:&; F3 ? " 3" %&??* : F "&3&& * @* 4 D** :& 3K !,>->CJ&0>0C%,/J>-&0,%,-C,>2&0/ /;KB9">,*;/--/G 0/J0/ K,B3& >, *; /-->G 0,0, * &3" 0,2 K:&,B3&/--CG 0 /J 0 / * & 3 " 0 ,2 A0 :* 7 :& 3% & 3& : & & 7 K 3 3 &3&& * &3 < * &* : :: 7 < &?& & 3 : &; "&? & 7 % 3 B9" P *&& %&3 < :&: @ !,/(//>&0C0,%,/J,)CA0
)0 :3&D*"&3&& *%"&& &@BD%"&' A;& 9"*&%*3 " :*&& % &3 &?&0 R4*&& 7: BD "* * 7 &&9 9 : 9 &3& * "* % 7 &?% &:; 3&0 % * *& & ** & : * & 9 3F : % &; % F&D "* @ ! ,/. /2, &0 C% ,,. ,>C &0 /% ,,C >,C &0>%,-.,.J&0,A0 **&: D** ::*& & ;B &3 0 ": & 9& :3 < ?& 7"&" D";3 &:?&%9 : &; "< &?* : ** ;B &? &* : "* : D @ ! :;&* 2 & /-->% )2/+-/A0
*D%9&3:; ":: *&%9& * & " 9:& & &D&F& ?& ";B "* & &*% 9 :: ? F : % 9"& : *D &* &:& F:&*::F&*%9"&& * ** ;& :& & "8% 9 &: & F *& "::*& && &*&& & ?&9& "F: & 1 &3*0 % "** * & : 3 :; " & "&D& ' :3 & *&D & :: F: &%&; ;& @ !,/.>./&0 >%,//,2-&0, *?*A0
J0 ":8%&* :: * ;&: %*& & % ( ?*3& /--C 7 " & *&$& "$& 9 < 3& 7 ,-- = :& >- & /-->% & " *:& 30 ,) /--2% *& & * :: 7
+,-.(+/--) $)+($ " 9&:*&D &"*:&*:&?D3& *' :& & /--> "E :& ,/ & /--C% N &:& * 3&,--=:&>-&/-->0:*&*9"& &3& *"* & : F&D&; 9" &3& * :?& "* & 3&D;0
"& &*" ?*F&3 "F: &:'4& &9*&*/--C: : " :* & : D& "& :' : 7 "; " & 7 * &3& :& 3 :'4& &90 # :: "F: & * : ,//-->%F&* ,2 /--C03*9: & ;&& &3? &D & ; ": & 3 : ; & &F * & & 0 & ;% & :& 9 :& * 3& *3& ":& 3&7.-=8,)&/--C 7,--=8,C B&/--C0
&"F: &%:: 9" ::&:'4&99"3& *:* : &%&&&0 *D%F:&9*9"3& ::&&D &"?? &E7:&&3 "< F&*: %&9&"* & * &F9""3& :&*3** *0 %&* & D3 :& &0
&; * 83 9 "& & & ?? * : " &0 :& &% "F: & & 3& N :&3:; %P": %"F: * ?& &: % "' :%& & %&*3* * *% " : % P &D & ::&& & &3 &*& & 0 &&D& 9": D&": : &"F: & &* 7 && 0 &% "& &* &D* " & 7 * &9&D &9*;$ $&&/--C$9 : 3& *9 :'4&9 $ " : 44* 7 ; & &D : * &* :8 9& 3& : ;& &* 3 &D &0 ?&% :& & # 7 *D : 9"* % :&9"& " ?&* &9 & "F: &:'4& &9?? *:F3 *&&%?& ?& " & 7 * &9 9"& &** "' : *:&:& * 3&% &3 &0%" "; & 7 *"*9"&&: :&* &%&& 9*:&:& * 3&0
+,-.(+/--) $J+($ &9"&& % &;*" : "* &0 *9 3'* 7 "& &* ?& 9"& :8 : ;? *& 7 & & :* & :8 % :* * *4* : F: & &9 :'4& &9% 3*&&1 &3*0
39&:*8%%;&?*%& < &0
+,-.(+/--) $(+($
, "*.2 *,.- * -, .
3
,0 *3;0
3
/0 " *&&" ,/?*3&/--)0
>0 3& 7 "& &* : & & :* & &* 3*&&0
C0 * ,"---?074D" 0
.0 ? : & 9O :3 ? :* < *& >- B 8 &?& & :8 &; ?** @#4S&54?9&2%2--C A%:3& &8& :;&%?* F 0J/&?** &;?**,) B& /--. @ !AK *& & &&9 &% &? ':3 : &D &K&& < * &; ?** : 3& : : 3& * &9 F & & " 0 C/ !0 :* < :&8 :& %&39*':3%&3 < B& 7"3&0 D??&8 :*& #'3& E 6 &
:&?:* < &?&*F: &&&9O7O??&?** &:D??
+,-.(+/--)