Discovery Dispute Over Production of Construction Documents
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe petitioner sought review of a decision concerning the scope of privilege or immunity asserted in response to discovery requests during litigation over construction or contractual matters, specifically involving the production of internal documents and communications related to design, planning, and potential performance issues. The court reasoned that the claimed privilege was inapplicable because the documents sought related to the operational, planning, and contractual aspects of the project, rather than protected attorney-client advice or work product, and were necessary for the opposing party to establish its claims or defenses regarding the underlying work, thus affirming the lower court's order compelling production.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Discovery Dispute Over Production of Construction Documents: The court reasoned that the claimed privilege was inapplicable because the documents sought related to the operational, planning, and contractual aspects of the project, rather than protected attorney-client advice or work product, and were necessary for the opposing party to establish its claims or defenses regarding the underlying work, thus affirming the lower court's order compelling production.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Testo completo
!"#$$!%&&' !("!%&&#
))
* ) * *)
+ , - %# ./ %&&#
!"#$%&$''" $ ( $'')$*##
$
++ + + ! $"& $' *,-.!/012
$
!"#$%&$''" ( $''34)$ ##&
305/-3
0
/7 &$& + 83#9:&$&;!#&&'$%< ' " 4 #&$$ $ "$= ' # $! ' # #*4! ' #$! " $ ! ' $%$ #9 $ 8'&"$=! &%$ $$>= $ " &$$;! && ?$ /@@2! ($ AA& #9 ' $ =% ' "#$ 83 #9:;'9#$"B/@@27
07 $'($$$$A'&$&!&$B2?$/@@2!#$ &$$'C701(111737 &$$##&$'(#$' C7@(11173!'" '(#$'C7//(111737
D7 0 % 011/! "B& =&& <$' 7 &'&#$E #$ $&$ A""$&$&""&&=&$% =$'%'7($'#&%>$4"$!E "#$'/?%011/!F#A$$*='&$'4$&'=&$ '&$&F7#$!&'$F=$%&$&$$*=4 #$&$'A$$&/?%011/4(##)$$#' "#$'&$&$#"$&'%$F7 $""$ &$&#&&:F G&$&%'$E,$(B?$'(&"$''$$ "#$B&$&/?%011/!%$'#&$$>$ ''A$$& E$$'$!&'$(B= E#' *=! E ($9 '&*= $$ ' &$& 4 ' ! 4( '& %$=$'$F7
.7 +(<$$'=$'""8 ;! &$&$ =$ ' "" 8 ; "" & =&$ % =$ '%' '/.?$/@@2/@%011/!'$E4 # $$A$7 $E'" !&$&$""& '9/.?$/@@27
-7 #$'"'A&%011/!&$&(#"#>&'#7
67 /-$01A&%011/!''&"#$$&$&'&E&$&# $''$$'&0111$011/7
H7 /D " 011/! &$& & % &= "$$ &"& # "$&"%"$(&$&=$&7
27 /-I$0110!A$'&$&&$&#&7##'&A$ '($A $ $% / % 011D7 A$ &$& J$& # ?="$ ' 0H"011D7
5/6225011. 3D5/-3 @7 /- " 011.! ' '& # 4 &"& E &#$ ' '""=! A<& E C7 /-(@627617 "$$#&$$$$#$'D/?%011/$A$ $&,$ "$ 8D/(/H07@/ K$$ 0111L M --173 KA ' ""$L M /(-117-1K$&,$"$L3/2(0-17//K%"$LM26D7.1K$$011/L M-173KA'""$LM2/7@1K$&,$"$L;7
/17 '&'","?!&="$&"&"$$E 7
//7 ' ( # A$ ##$7 %*! ! # '/-%011.!($##&E'&$A$% 4("B&=&&%$'&4$#=$7
/07 '& ##$ ' @ ?$ 011.! $$& E (<" ' #9 4 (&$$ AA$%"$ ==& E #' #A$$*='&$'4$&'=&$'&$&7 %* %&4&'$!($3E3' !%$##$=$ $$*=&$$'A$$&E011/7##&4' $$&#%$,$%4&E(&=''&<$ ' &$& $ 4( %$ ' '$& #A$ $ &! #%$ ** ( ($ $ & =&$7 #'$ #&&4 (4$$$'"$$&"&! $B&&$'&'%'$B?$7
/D7 '@I$011.! $?$&$$$ '&7#="$'&%##&'##$!E%40 %011/! %$#("B''$$B=$ ' =&$ ' &$&7 $ E 4( $ $$& 4( $ B&& ' $$ '$$%!%$''
/.7 %$&E#!!'&#'H#$"B011.! ?$'7 $$4%$%4&#$$ B&'#B$(4##$$& $<$$#'%&7#!9%4 $ &$$ A$ '$ #&' # 4 $$ $ &"&3$(&0111$"'?%011/7!%$$# 4($4(E#$'/?%011/4"#A$$ *='&$'4$&'=&$7
/-7 '/1?%011-! $ &=&%#$$% &#< ! 4 $ ?" &#'7 '"$ 4 %$'0%011/(<9#E'$$#B$&$ $$#'&$"$'#$79%$$A4$$ %$(%$##B$'#"$$<&#< '"
5/6225011. 3.5/-3 &$&EA$"'(<#$!'"$$%$A$'AA E ("B ' '$$! 4! ! &$$ #A$"$ %=B % 011/7 &"$ (*>#$*9 4 &#< $ #$3,$ = '&B&&"$!F$$"BF&$&$#E","!&7$" (%#"$ ?"""A$' =$$$$4 '$A$$&$&""!($E$#&#< 7 $#'"'&(##$'''A$!'$ "#$#!4'&#< 7
/67 ' ' D/ ?% 011-! B ' & '& (##$ ' '$AEA$'&$&7
/H7 ' ' D A&% 011-! B ' & # ##& $"#$'&0.A&%011-# '&$"7
/27 . A&% 011-! B ' #"9 $ ""4& B'&#'''A$7
/@7 ''"#$#($$'$'/1A&%011-7
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
5/6225011. 3-5/-3 ##$&=&%&$&#B'*$! '%$'4$*$3$""$A*'3?4( D/ '&"B01117+(=$ '$%'"$$A$'#&$$' &$&!&=&4(&$$#4(#$7+!N ! ##$'&$&!(*$#$$A$EA'"P $$$ ' % "$$ #"$$$ ' #> $7 4 ''AA$&A93'$'(&01113$#&$&! ($&#&'('<'"#>&$%$ 4$&#'4F##&$$'%F7 A'( 0111! ' "B A$ &$$ # " $ #&& 4 '("#$$ $& '(=$ &$$ &="$ $$'7 $" # #$ 4 &$& #%$ ,$ %&7 '4& 4( &=$ A$ A$'(=$'($$&'"$4('#$#'(Q 'A'#(4$$'*=7$&=&4*AA '(AA=&&&011/#N (&%$&$&EC7D-1(111737 # #&& 4 ' A$ &$$ E '#$ ' $4&$"$$&=9"$7
+(=$ ' >$9" A"$4! &=& 4( &$$ %&! 4 $'$ (9! 4 $ $$& A""$7
A! (=$ ' *94 &" " 0111 # $! ' '$ ##' E (' 4( &$$ #%7 <#4&4'#B9"#$E(%=&$'B4!4 "#$'&$&&$$##%&"4$=$%$&$&$&FE $*F7
017 ' / " 011-! '4& (% $&"EA$'7 %*! '"'&E4 $$' $'" 7
0/7 (''(4,$/@"011-7
<#4& % $%& '$ 4Q % ! '(B' # + + # # + ! %$ '(,$ "#>& # &$& $ A! # N 7 ( # '4<$"$'$4#&'%$$%&$& *=$ A&4""$! 4( <$"$ ' *="$7B&$'A"$!&$$F(*""E$$AF'&$&7 &$$$$$'*$7<#4&4$?$J' *A '(&4# $ '(& $ 4( ' #B9"! ('$ E !$7 '"$'$"$$! &$$#&$*$"$$7+$&"!$(#$
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
$ E '" ! '4& % $%& & # &$&! $$ 4 &#$$ E "3$"#7 & (% %$ '('AA$&A97+(=$'4$'*$!<#4& 4( ('$ $! ! B! E 7 $>$9"A"$4!$%4(&$$%&" ( # AA" E ?$7 $ ' A$! $%$ ' (" ' &$&! B E $7 ><! #$ &$$ $$ $ 4 7 ($ ' 4 ( #&$& $7 '4& # % 4 (%$ A""$ ==& 3 $$ ' $% &$ (>$ &$& &$B 3 " ## 4( (=$ '( '&?$7 &=4&$$#$&'& 9="$ ' A$7 %! J ' $ &$$ #$J$ $*4 4('"$$A!"E!#&&#%AA"7
007 '0D"011-!%&4$&$$&=&$ %=$'%'#'$#&''4'$$ $$&#$"$"#>&$4((#$'"#$B$&!4 '&"$4(<R$&"$A$'=&$$4#"$' '&=='#B$&7
0D7 #$!$E4($B&&'$$'$$E($' 7%&4'&$'$&"!&$$$$#&$ *$! 4 %$ J $9 $A '
5/6225011. 3H5/-3 =$'&$($4&$$E(='$A$'("#>& $ 'AA&$ &$&! 4( ' #B9" "#>& ('$ &="$E!4 '&$""#$!4 ($ 4 &$$ $ % B4 $ 4 %$ 9 < "#$ ' &$&! $ 4( 3"," % '&'& F' $## (*&"=F7 $$$4!'#&$!(B%$'##$&= '$,$'&&""A$%'$7%4E$ &=' ?#' ' B A&'& ' 8 C ; "$9 ' #'&$'$&$AA"%#$$"$%' &' $$ ' $' ' #"$ ' $$ #$ &#$'44"#>&$$$$($$$' (<$'#B9"7A$%4$9'('A"$# '&A E < # '&' (= '( # " #$ ,$ #% $ ## A 4 ! E $% N ! &$$ ## $ ' &$& $ '&'$ ' "$$ 4 $ %&E$$'9#$%<&&7
0.7 '0'&"B011-! B'&#&44 4$ ##&"$ E 4$ E #9 #'$ # $$ '9 *AA/!E%(&'$'"#$#$'&$&7
'/0?%0116!$$'9'(#$A"&:
3 4$$$%E(&/@@2%$&$&%&# &$&E'/D(-D.A76-'$'.?%/@@@P
3 4$%#"$"$'(&/@@@%$&$& %&E'//(6HHA761D"/@@@!#9""$ $%/@%/@@@P
3 4 $% '<9" $"$ ' (& /@@@ $ &$& #>& E ' //(062A7H- 0. I$ /@@@ #9 ""$$%/-?$/@@@P
3 4 $% $9" $"$ /@@@ $ &$& #>& E *$ ' //(--HA7/1 0/ $B /@@@! #9 ""$ $%/0$B/@@@7
'($#$'4&!(=$'$$0111:
3 4 *94 B ' /1(.-HA700 4 &$& " D/"0111 &$$ '$& #"$ ' #" $"$ 0111 $ 4(&$'%"$&$&<$&/.?01114 *94($%&&,$#%P
3 4#"$"$0111A"$&$&#>&0I$0111P
3 4'$"$0111&$&#>&0$B0111P
5/6225011. 325/-3
3 4((>#'($%"$?4(E'$'A$P
3 4! (=$ ' &=$& ' %"$ #9 ""$! &$&%$E#>$$$"$"$!#$' /1%!/1?$!/1$B$/1?%%$P
3 4#(&/@@@!%"$$&$&=$&D"! 0.I$!0/$B$HA&%P
3 4(#$'9#'&=$&"%$'P
3 4#(&0111!%"$$&$&=$&0I$ $0$BP
3 4$'$'%'9/1%0111!'$E4 $$'#"$"$$'I,$#>&7
!A"& B'&4 %$ #&'& E ' %"$ E *$ ' 0(-11A7 $ 4 "$$ ' '""=(&%$''&"E/D(.62A7617
067 #9""$'<#$!&$&='&E?=7
)
/7 =%S=$?'8;&$&"'A&$$$&!'9 /I$011D! B$'!"#&'-?=! '$ #&'$ $ %3#&'$! - ##&$ $ /6 ?= 8$7 / $7$-6 ;7
+$ES$'S&$'/6?=!# BA&'& 0H?%011.8 C/D1/16;!' =%'#$&!/DA&%! '#$$$=$#"$$$ B$' ' &= E $ ?= $$! ! ' S$$$ ' S&$'%<?=7
07 A&'&#$=&&''$''6$B 0111 8 P 2D17/; $ $& %= / ?% 011D! $)$ ' "B"'A$''"'S3%!$""$ 4 S$7 -0 ' A&'& ' 01 '&"B /@.6 S3 % $ %%$ 8 +;7 &"! #B$& ' S"#> $ &=&'"9#'&$&4S#%$ES$7-0 +$$72/$20 ' 9="$ ' D/ $B /@.H S3% $ %%$ 8 +; $ &$& B=&7 % '#$ &= $ $""$ "#& #&'''&'"$$%!%!'(##$!'($' &#$''""=8$72/ +;!##&''
5/6225011. 3@5/-3 '&!''&##$$'''$'"$$A8$7-070 +!'$%='#/?%011D!$7-0$-6 ;7 #&' ' ($ &#$ ' '""= ($ # ##B (#9!'94 &$$%=""$G' '&&#$''""=8A7 C/D1/;7
D7 A"&"$ E ($7 -6 ! B $ ' )$$4$""$'$$$#&%ES$7-6' A&'&#$=&&''$'8 ;$%E A&'&'01'&"B/@.6S3%$%%$8 +P $7-67/$7*7/;7+"#&$#?=''S#9$' &$B7
.7 < $" ' ($7 -0 7 D +! '$ ' '"' &#$ '( '""=#$'<#94'"#$"#&$$ ' '""= $! ' $ ! 4 #9 % ' '""=7
#&%$#''#$$$$%<'&'#&"#$ $ ' ##$ #&% # ( $7 20 + $ ($7 -0 7 D +7 (B '( $ '#$! #$ '& "" &$$ ' A$ 'B & &#$ ' '""= " E ##$ #&"#$! $ ##4 % &="$$ '9 $& %= 8A7 C/1HB01D%7'7HB!/1001H%7'70P C/@@2#7/2@ %7 '7 HP /@@- 7 .6 #7 //- %7 '7 D;7 #&"#$ ##$ $ #'$ ' $$$ ' '$ "$& 4 $ '$"$ (<$ ' & &#$ ' '""=! E 4 $'&$$"$&7 '<$&#$?$A'"$$ '&&#$''""=$#&"#$##$ E $ "," &=" ' '$ $$! 4 '$ ( E (##$'($720 +<%"$8 C #B&T@651D' D1%"B011.!'7-707/PA7 C/06 0%7'70P C0110 #7@.'7-B;7
4( $! 4$ #$ $ %$ (! '& '( &&$$'$$"9#$&!A$!''<!4 $'4$7
F""$'''""=F!A$$'!9==&&! ""$G$'I'"#$!A$#%'($$$ B"$ <=B! 4 $ #"$$$ # ' % $$! " #%$ $) (B=$ ' &# '""= 8+ 011/ '7 D #7 /@-P + 011/ '70 #7 @2P + /@@6 '7DB#7/H0P+/@@-'70#7/6@P C//@@0'7DU+/@@D
5/6225011. 3/15/-3 #7//1P C//2/@-'7D$&A7$7U+/@@D#72DP+/@@D'D #72.P /@@0'7-B#706-P C//6H-'7DBU /@@1#7./-P C //D /2/ '7 0 U /@2H #7 61HP C //0 2 '7 .' U /@26#7.@DP C//0/-2U /@2H#70/H;7A$'&$"$$'' $$4((>F'$#$#A$!E'$BF8A7C$*! F+*'B$B='VWF!09"&'7!#7//0;!'(G#$'7
+ A$ S$ 4'& #&' ' #&' ""!A$'"$$4$%''""= $%$9==&&""$'#'4'$' A$A$'($A!'$'#B$'$$"'C+ &$$ '&$"$8 C/0D/6'7-U+/@@H#70/@;7
(#9! A$ &$& #' '$ ' / % 011D7 $A$ '&&#$''""=/-"011.!'"#$ '#$&'&'(#&%E($7207/ +!A$!'& ''<#&%#%'#$&=7
-7 + ($7 -0 +! $ 4( %= ?4( D/ '&"B 0110! ("#> 4!$$"$#&===%!(B%#'##$$ '""= E ' "#$! $ $ E &#$7 + (=$#"!#B$&#$(&$'!E$$B'! <=4$="8 C/0D/-'7-B!/0066'7 .!//@.1-'70$&A&;7
## '"$ ##B (#9! '9 4 ?#'! ' *="$ ' 9= ' '$ $ (B ' &="$$$$!'$%=""$GA$?'4"$ '&$"$ $ #'$ $ #$$ 8 C /0H .6H '7 /;7 '"$! ($7 -0 7 / + %= '# / ?% 011D #' ( $7 -0 + 4"$ "'A$7 $" X ' "#$Y $ "#& # XY 8 "' : "#"$ ' X =*WY # X*=YP $ : ## ' X ' "#QY;!4($)*="$4$<'$' #B$&'("#>8A7 C/0@/D%7'7D7-;7
67 ##$ 4 '$ #$ ("#> $ $$ '(B' ' A&'& (3% $ %%$ $ ' '#$ '(<&$! $""$$(B=$''&'!E*4#"$'! $$ ' &! # ' % E ' "#$ "," $"#4##$$!4(B=$'"$$#&'4"$E #9 "#$B $ %& < "#>&! ' "9E4$$#$#$,$&$A(B?$' '&8 /@2-#761H'7-P /@2-#76.6'7D;7
5/6225011. 3//5/-3 (B=$ ' #% $$ $ ' &= "#$ $! # ("#>! $Z* ' '$ #B #$ # 7 4 &== ' ("# A$ ##$ ' ($ -0 + $ '$! # &4$! &# $$$& ' '""= & 8+ /@@D #7 2D '70P C////HD'70U /@2-#76.@P C/12/26'7 /P C/12/@0'70U /@2D#7/11P /@2-#76.6'7D;7
H7 (#9!'""=$#$'&'$$B# ' A$ ' &$&! 4 #&$! # #&' 01113 ?% 011/! C7 /-(@62761! "$$ 4 ($ '( # $$& # $7 $ $$A 4 '""= &$$ &'$! /0 ?% 0116! E /D(.62A761!'A$'%"$# '0(-11A7
27 4("#>$#"!=&#'$'"$! E $$ B'! ' '""= & # 37 '(%B$& ' ("#>! #%$ ' ,$ '$"$ #% 8*7H11. ' '$% '(AAA&'&'KC +L##$'$$ KLP C //. H@ '7 DP C //D 0-6 '7 DP /@22 #7 /D6 '7D;7
?= # #$ ,$ ' #B $$ 4(= '( #"!AA$#'(##4'$9A"8'$'= #$ =$ ' "";7 > &="$ '(<" # 4$ # ' '& 4 %$ ' = "&=$##"$'$!AR$'("9'&$"$ A"$'%$&'&$&7
'&$&>"! C ($$?&A&&E($7H-.7/' ' ' B=$ 8 P + 001;! &$ % ($7 H-@ 7/ 7 A"&"$E'#$!$$#*=&'('"$$! ' =$'$J&#'$E(&=' '&$&!'","4(% *4 $ & ! ' '""= 4( $ "4$$$"$#&==E'%7#4 &#'$'(","'""=$$'"$7+$&#$&*=& '('"$$'=$'($H-6 "$ = ' '& '&=& <#&"$ "" $ 8= A";! " &="$ # 4 #$ AA$%"$ ' '& %$ ' = 4 "$ =$ ##"$ '$ $ $ #$ #&#'&$EA"$'%$&'&$&8='A$PA7 $""$ /@22#76D0'7D;7
?$A'(##4","##'''($-0 + #B$&B''='(#"!''"' (3% $ %%$! '& '$"$ ' $ --& D
5/6225011. 3/05/-3 ' ' % 8 P +0/1; $ H-. ! '&& "" (<# ' 9= =&&8 C@6/0-U /@H/#7.H2;7 '"$!"$A4$E B '( <$ ' $ '(= '$ % $ 4 #9'$ ' %$& '(' #$$ AA < & < $ $$ %B (=$ ' #B$& ' '$ #B $$& # ($ -0 +7 A! (= ' ## ' (&=$& ' $$"$ $ ?$B!$&4$B!&*&$!'**4# $ !4!#&&"$!(%$#$3,$#%&' '&8 /@22#76DD'7D;7
#'$!##'#B$&'+ $,$##4& $ 4 E +E7 + S$7 H/6 7 0 ! 'S'"$$ =9 AA ' + ' " G S # '&&=& =$7 $Z* $! &"&& E S$7 H/6 $$ $$A &B7 + &="$$ &=! #B$& ' 'S'"$$ $ #"#'+ 7 %*!&'S+E#%$'&&=' #$$=$8=$S$72/0 ;7'#$ #B$& ' & =&$ $ ##B < =&$ ==& ' $$ "9 8$7 2/0 7 0 ;7 9 ! =&$ 'S + ! 4 $ # ","$"#'"$$!#%$#,$"#&%<4!' +E!S$#4$&'S&7#B$&'=&$$#&$' ' +E! # 4 ?$A ' "$$ &="$ E #B$&A"'=8+0110#7/HH7'7D;7
&4!''(+E!#$'(&"#!($)#E 'B=$'$J'%7 &$'($72/@ 7/ 4#&%$#(&=&$4('$'='8+0110#7 /H67 '7 DBP C /06 0D2 U + 0111 #7 00H ' . $ &A& $&;7
%*! (& # ' +E #$ #'$ E '( =&$! $ " E ' B=$ # &$' '$ 3 #$ #$ == #B$& 8$7 20H $ H-. ;7 +$ "& < =&$"$#4$<#&"$&$&""&$$4 $8=&$A";"&="$#4"$'A$A$ '(=&$!$#$''&&%&E=&$!$"$ '$ AA$% ' ($# $ <R$ A '&$"$ A"$ ' %$& ' &$&7 A$ $>#4"$ #$ # 4! ' # A ' #$ 8& "?$ # <"#; '$=&$A"'$$'$'AA'&$& 8+0110#7/HH'7DBP C/060D2U+0111#7002'.A;7
(#9$'(<$$' 4$&$&&3=&$' &$&'$$$#&''$4$$($#&$&%&7
5/6225011. 3/D5/-3 $'&B4(%$4$&'(='&$&A!4( $$'(#7
A$3 <" ( ($ ' #B '( %$ $$ # &== =% ' ##$ &=$ ( +7 AA$! (B=$ ' &#'""=(<$!'$!4((>#'$ A$##)$""?$A&"#$"$'("#><$4( $""A$$$"$#&==7$'%B 4( "#> $ '""= E ' "#$ %$ $$"$##$'( +"$&"#$' &#! ' $ #& #"$$$ ' 4 B%$ ''$ ##$ &$$ #" #&$$ # A$ 8 /@2-#761D'70$&A7$&;7
?#' $$! > &== =% 4 ("#> A"#E4#$,$B"$<=&'$$##B' '"$ ' $$ '$4 $ ' "," $7 "'4($'$'(<=E$&='',$&%&'(#9 4(#$'"$$$'!"$9'"#$B$&!'("#> '","$&=4($&&8 /@22#76D.'7-P C//0/-@ '7.U /@2H#70/HP /@2-#7-/'70P C/12010'7 DU /@2D#7/16P /@2D#7DHH;7
@7 (#9!''##4$!4$&'(&3=&$!%$ (B=$ ' A = &=9"$ "* ' AA % $$ '= &7 '( '" ,$ $ ' A$ 4 $$ (&$$ # 4$$& $ (,$ *=& ' #"$ '($ A$!##$7
$!?#''"$AA$4(#%=4("#> '""= E ' "#$ %$ $$"$ ##$"$9 '( +!4$)#$$B=$ ' &# #&?'7 $ 4 (B%$ ' ##$ ##)$!%'$!""&=$"$A$%8 C/12/26 '7/B!/@D'70BP /@2-#761D'70!6.H'7D;7 ! #$ % 4( $'$ #"$ ' $$! ("#> #% E "$ $# %! # <"# '( # '&$ ' $&7 A$ ! # 4( $ "#$"$ $"B # $&"$ # ' ($7 -0 +! 4 ( # '"$$ 4 ("#> %$! ""$ G # '&! ' & $ B?$% ' # 4( #$ (4$$ ' $$ ' ' '& B8 C 0HH51/'0@I$0110'70P C/12/22P /@@0 #706/'7.B;7
5/6225011. 3/.5/-3 ?#' S'"$ &$& 4 ' "9 $9 <#$ 4S "#>#'&''$'#"$'$$A'"$ $#%'S#'&$'$&8 C /-.511' 00I$0111'70;7A$!S$4S"#>'#!""$ G#''&!'&$B?$%'#4&$& # S4$$ ' $$ ' ' '& B! 4 "#$"$S$#A$A8 C/12/22P /@@0#706/'7.B;7
$9 '&$"$ # 4A "#$"$ ' $! ' ($7-0 +!&''A$4$''#"$'$$ $&$''$#'(&7 #$! $'"$$4$%$'&$B?$%'# 4 $' ' 9="$ ' $$ < (&$$ 4 #=! ' ?#' 8 $! % C /0/ 0.D;7 (&$$'#$&!<'$#&#?#'$ = #&'! E 'AA& #"$ ' $$ 4( %$ $ #>&!#'""$$&===%$&#($7 -0 +8 C 0HH51/'0@I$0110'7D;7
$ &&"$ '$ A$ $ "#$ # ##& #B$& ' ("#>&''(*B$'4(#$%#'AA & ' ' "#$ $$ (4$$$ '($ '$$ # #$! A ' B&&A '( A"$ $ ' $# # '#B8 C /D.510'D1?%011D'7D7/PA7 C/12/@6 '7 .;! 4 &$& (#9! ' (% "," ' $! 4 <#4& 4( &=$ A$ F A$ ' (= $ ' =%$& ' "F! A$ # >$&"$4"$ ' "#$ '#7
&='<'&$4#&9'$!$$,$<&&' #B$& '(= % ' "#$7 &4! $?$&7
5/6225011. 3/-5/-3
) 0 ) * *)
12343 5 633 3 78 "#% 9
43
/7 &%B7
43
07 ?$$7
D7 '$'4(/0?%0116!"$$''""=(&%$# 4(E /D(.62A761! "#$ $ ' %"$ # ' 0(-11A7
.7 $4#&'$=$$7
-7 A" #$ ' 4S #%$ A" $ #&$ ,$ ' '& ' D1 ? '9 $A$ # # ""'& '& B A&'& ' ! +*[Q*A4 6! 611. ! $ <"#7 '& #$ ,$ #=&7 "&" '$: ; '4 <$"$4'&$'&B$$#''& $$4&P B; <# # 4 "$A $" #% '"' $$ $ '&P ; #$ =$ ' #&$$7 + "&" $$ # $ &&"$ &"&& $$ ; B; $ ; 3'! BA&'&'##$"$94S '%'&%B7"&"'"$"> ' #%! 4 $ ?$! 4 '& $$4& $ S%## ' 4&$&<#&'&$8$7/D0!/16$/12;7 =AA9 #&'$ CC V+ V
#A"'#&$,$$$A&<#$4SESAAA&'& '#=AA
5/6225011.