Waiver of Arbitration Right by Litigation Conduct
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe plaintiff sought to enforce a contract provision requiring arbitration or mediation for disputes, arguing the defendant breached this requirement by filing a lawsuit, but the court held that the defendant's filing of an answer and counterclaim, without affirmatively asserting the arbitration agreement as an affirmative defense or by way of a motion to dismiss or stay, constituted a waiver of the right to enforce the contractual arbitration clause. The court reasoned that by engaging in litigation and proceeding to the merits through the filing of responsive pleadings, the defendant evinced an intent to litigate the dispute in court rather than arbitrate, thereby forfeiting the benefit of the arbitration provision.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Waiver of Arbitration Right by Litigation Conduct: The court reasoned that by engaging in litigation and proceeding to the merits through the filing of responsive pleadings, the defendant evinced an intent to litigate the dispute in court rather than arbitrate, thereby forfeiting the benefit of the arbitration provision.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied for ordering the payment of court costs.
Testo completo
#$%&'#'((' #)&%#'((*
+ ,+ ! - +! -!
'. !/ 0( 1 '((*
!2222222222
-33 ! ! - 4+!5 6 (()* !"#$%$$&'
! "
-%+$,-
3
$. /( 0000000000#*1$!22#('*)3435(.
%. %,)(%,,,#5*#6*)('3(# )7 36(. **)*3 ()4( 8('(( 67 )*(-9(7( :(-3&; / <. 3& '((# ( 6 *'(*)*(=&7(*. ((55(*()#%$)( %,,,# ( ** >)(* 8 6(* 67 3 9((= ?@3(> ('(( &' :(-3&; ?< A 0000000000 /0000000000 ('* > ( ('; * '(7( )9B3()4((*#(9*#'*( 34&) (* 8 6 3 6 ))( C(& 68>('(6'(>4(&.3(55()*D4( 328EC#(7'7.**(5)*=))( 6 *( >(' =6( (=( (() ) 4(. 6*6C)('76'(3*(*.9 )( ( 6 3 6(* (((. )*( 3* (7( 6(>(( (= (7F ' '( :G$,.,H< ) *386:G$,.%E<. *)*#3(#*3863( 3(*#5((6*3(3(6(((7F.
I. $E 4 %,,,# 6(** *3* ) 3( 3& 655( 6-('((* :(-3&; < '( 64( 6.
2. 33)*(*86 I$4%,,,#0000000000# (7# * 6 (3(* '( * (*)(* E,J 35( )34. 6>)# 6* ( '( 3* > 55 39 (= )( (39 )(=. 3(( (7(=* 3# 3*))*=('67#(5 ) )((('.(**=6** 6**(((. >#()(33739( *(* $H 1 %,,, ( 6 (( 6(5 (5*( ((> 8 6 #5()*9().739(*('()( (5 = ( ( 3K 4* 3 3& *3 ' (& 3(5(( )(( 3( '( 3( '( ' )3&) . (# 6* 55 6 )( ( 6 '( 5) 6 ( 3>() 6 ( ( *(*3*79)(3*(39*(3K&9*) ((=69 3L(*(*'&3*-4.3(* )3)(= '(4(*(*#6(((6*(63** 63=68)#(=*((8'(E,J.
+$"!%+%,,% -I+$,-
E. ($I*)4%,,,#655(6)3(:(-3&; < (5)* 6 = 6* 4**5((* ()(* 9@)7 M 5*'( $!!$"5*'($!!I.6*6*3&6 >(&)5( *(-6()((**' 5'33*(%2 ) $!!! %I ) %,,$. 3# 3( $, 1 %,,,# ( ** )( 4**5( 3( )( )(* :(-3&; //<.
H. 33 )*( * 8 6 %% *)4 %,,,# 0000000000# (( 3*(( )( 3)# * 6 (3(*'(*5((('$,,J&$,1%,,,.(7(=* )((#*3(>(#*9 ()#47() 3((6*3(3(:%,)(%,,,<.=(()3*)(3 4 3 9(=# )*( ( 3((3) ' * > (5(36(*673 9((=?.3*(*= *=43 9(=3(*'(*(()3(48 *'.=((>()(#('*=6() 47() 6* >(( 3( %! '( $!MH# 3)(& (.67(6>()(()3#=(*=6 (8*)((=3'(#)(63* ))739 (=)()3.
". %H ) %,,%# 33 6>) N'( )*( *7( :(-3&; N/< )( *'( () 3()( -)4((* 3 9((= ('(. 6* 3*( 3 *= ()3 =( 3( ()( 3(* '( ('(* 94(. 3# 6( ( 6'( = 3 6(5 5( (= 6'(3)*(76(55((=.5(#N/63 6(3(* '( E,J 6('(* )34 * 3 (7#(67(6('(**(.C*=63(' )*(-C((=#(3(*'(*3(55*)*( 3'( 3 D ( C(5(*. (# ( 6 ( 3((3 8 * =( C(5( (3( '( 6 3( ' *7(=#3(*'(#()((5(# 6('(*)34.
M. *((%)(%,,%#6 C*)3(4 333)(5)(*.
!. ( %2 )( %,,%# 6(** (C* *(( 3& ))(( )(& 6 N- )3*. (& = 6 )(()(* *7( *# 3(6((335(7*#*7(#*3()*#7(*#
+$"!%+%,,% -2+$,- 55* )3&) *3(* = ( ) *7 8 3(. *3 )6?3(7**33'(.
$,. 3*'(%H1%,,%#6 C.)(5 5 3( *(( =* 3(& '* (#33((&)336>)N/%H)%,,%.
$$. ** )( (4 ( $ 1 %,,I. (4 * 3** 8 (( *( 3& 0000000000# (7# 0000000000# ' )*( ( 0000000000#(7.
$%. ( $ ) %,,E * (4 *# 0000000000 ((=* = 6(3(* '( E,J =6( '( * %,,, *( 4* 55( (=. '( %,,I# ( '( )*(5(6(3(*'(33*()3(1 %,,,)%,,I=O('(5**('#(6'(3('(3( $MC(%,,$.
$I. 3( %% '( %,,E * (4 *# 0000000000# 7**( (( =( 3( 4( 0000000000# 3** )*( (# ((=* (' 8 ( 6 5( > )(. (& = )(5 (7(= 3 9((= ('=* 3 3**C(5(6(3(*'(.'(4( (7(=55*3 0000000000(=6(55( (=#3(6%,,,#3***3(59(=' >(** 7**(* =( K* ))( 6 *'* (( =647()9(=. 69#')3 (4#*())(3()(*.
$2. (!)(%,,E* (4*# 0000000000# (7#3*(*'(P83(#(!C'(%,,2. 55* *(7))# *9(739( (5)* 3( ''39( 3*( 8 3 >. )*( ( '( )* *3' 655 )( 6(** 6 C)( 3**. 5(# ( 3 3 *3 8 =( 3* *= *' 34&) ( ''( 3(* '(.
$E. 3($")(%,,E# (4*)((>3( **(I$)(%,,E33(6*'*(.
$H. ( %H )( %,,E# 6 )( (4 * 33 6>) 4(((3(( 3(=* 3 N/ M ) %,,% =( )=( (. 6 (** =# 33 0000000000#
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
$". 3&)((*(#33(I$)(%,,E# **7*8C7.
-
+$"!%+%,,% -H+$,- $. (7'(67((C(((:<**)(5(*((*#& $1%,,I# (4(#)3*EC7# 3*('(-3*(#E33*$HC7:.$. EH <.
N(86(6*($HC7#3 (45** %"C'(%,,2: G$I,$,H<# (7'(3*#$I5*'( %,,2# (3(( (( 7 3) (4 ( (*7 8 ( C7 ((# # 66*('>C7.
5)*)8O.I.I(3((((($2')4 %,,% )(5( # (( ' O* '(7 ( 3*(* 3 ' ))(( )(& 6-('((* ** )( O55( (4 (.)3* (4*&*4(3 C763&.
%. (5**3(7**((H4 %,,,: < * '(7 $ C'( %,,I# K )(5(( )4(3((*7)((.N 3)*(#3('(=(O33(=(D9*8)(& 3((3=&733(4'(7))A 5( C((=) *)( 3( : G $%" 2H" (. $# $%H $IH (. 24 *5*<. *=# *(( ** )(%,,%#3*((7>)(*8)(&(3(( ( 5** 6-('((* $! C( $!E! :(-3&; < &7)6-('((*$"C'($!H$:(-3&; <'(7 C=6I$*)4%,,%.
I. *3* 5) *( 3*' 3 (# 3* '4 :. H! M2 ( 5** 6-'(( '(' %, *)4$!2H#'(7C=6I$*)4%,,%<.
2. ((7 3 3( '( ( ( 8 * 55 K()((3(*7('(8 6('((*.
E. N 6. 2 . $ # 6('((* ()(( 3(* 7(# 3*)* 3) 7 *# =( * 6 ( 8 *
39 (=#)3'6(5()(*7*(#6)(6 (.
(8*)(*36.%M.$ =((3=6* ( 8 6( ('( 8 2,J )(. (& 3
+$"!%+%,,% -"+$,- ('((*HH%+IJ)(#6)(3('((*E,J )(6=3('((*2,J)(.
N O. %M . % # 3 O*'( O('((* ' '( = O('(3(4(>PO('(*=O3(4) (#3&>*(*')*3()3O (( *=((4* )9* '(# )3* ' =O( ( 3 4(O(O*(3('(.
((#3=6('((*(#(*(9==6 (7( 3( ( 3* 3 3*(( = ( )( *'( ()(( ()3 3(* '( : G $%" %!!<. S9 )*((83C7)6**8((== ) 3 = ('(* 6* (34 '(. * )*( ( **) ( 3 *)( = '> 3(4)>(76*: G$%E%H$(.2#$$E $I2(.%#$$2I$2(.I#$,E$EM(.$<. =( ' 34 6 33 )*( 6 >3(# =( *)(# 6=3(((7(>()3(5(64C6*5(*#= 33 5 >) )3# =6( 3 *7) (*(3(>3()*#=6((***4(3(( (:)&<#=(3(>)*(((5(= ( 6>3 ( 4( )('* : G $%% $H,T N %,,,# 3.$E2<.
6 ( 33 =# C(3# = C7 33*( 33 *4( 3 )*( (# ( 3 ( ( )3 5( = 6>3*(#)*((7**)(##8 33(33(((5(=(6(8 (. ((C(333(>(5(3 3*(( =68 633*(( 6(3(* '( 5( 3 )*( 5)(: G$%EIEI(.I4+*5*#$!!E#322T $!MM 3.E,2(.%<.
N3739$,EM ((6('((*6()3 6-('((* :(-3&; <# 633*(( (( ( > 3( 3( ' )*(# 8 6( 33 )*( 6 ))*(>#&')3*N/. (-((3855 )*( (55* 3*((*. *) 4( 6 ) )*(>*((3*()8>))*( N/.N()3)3633*(55())(( (>3(3(')*(#N/))8655( >) )*( 33*)( 3( 3*((* *(7 67333(*.
+$"!%+%,,% -M+$,- C(3 *3 )) O()# 39)*3 >()(# *3 (3(('((*(. '9#C@ O-('((* =O 3'=* )( ( =( K(8*39 (=)#(83(*7(# ( * -)D) O ( 8 * 39 (= ) =( ')(:N$!!H33.I$"#I%,I%IT $!!%3.$M%(.%4 *5*TU$,$I <.
H. 63&# &7 *7( * * # *=#(3(*'(3(O((%,)(%,,,.
*7#( (*5*>))*(>(5. 6# M ) %,,%# N/ 6 ('* 8 >) ((= 4(((3((4=(33=(*3>*=(( C(3# ) A 3( ((7(> ()3 5( 64C 6 * 5(*# A 33 5 >) )3# 3 (*( 3( >3()* ** *4( 3( ( (:)&<.(#(3(>)*(( (6>34()('*.33= 3*()9(=*=:3 -39())4 (5*( *4# *7& 7)( 3 7 ( )9 *7&) Q*4(R (7< 3 ('( 3' 3 D3()3()((3(*3($!M!. 3* *7) )( ( )-( =( K ()((397*3**3EL7()3 $E L7 ' ('(* 3 *(. * )34 35(# ('(* ) )3(4 ' )( (. (#(3*3397(3 9((=*(3'5( (* -*3 )) (. 6() 3()( (3(* '( * 3 3( $!M!.
# 33 I$ 4 %,,,# 0000000000 6 (3(*'(*(*)(*E,J35()34 46)((6'(((=69 3L(*( *'& 3*-4 9B 3( )3)(= '( 4( *(*. 3#3(>3*(-#3333 3() 6>) ((= 4(((3((. (# (7( 6 3 (( ' (7( (7(= 3*( N/. # 000000000063'3($MC(%,,$33 3 (3(* '( 3*( 8 . >(&) (7# 0000000000#=('!C'(%,,2# *7)834&)(''()(33
+$"!%+%,,% -!+$,- *=*')(3(*'(. (& ()46(3((=77'(6** 83)3((.
)*((#0000000000#((( 3** 0000000000 '( (4 * 4( (7(= 55* 3 0000000000 33 6 **) 3(.0000000000#%%*)4%,,,#6(3(* '(*5((('$,,J46)((#6*3( >(#6*3864=(>(3($!MH6 3(( 6*3(3( :*3( %, )( %,,,<. 3*( = >()( *()3))739 (=)()3.
' =( 3*&# 6>) ((= 4(((3(( *(* 3 N/ )3 '(( (4 *. 6)& :5)((# 3# 35(# 7**# 3 &)# 3 9( 3 9((=< *(* *(*# ( ** 4* ' )*9 ( )('* 3) ( 3 '** =6( 6>( 3 6( 8 * ('(C(5(6('(6-('((*.
*#(63*(6>)(=)4( ()((3(*7(.
". *78(*(#(DC*.
+$"!%+%,,% -$,+$,-
! - 3 ,+ ! - +! -!
789 : ; 4< $)' -"=
9
$. *'4.
9
%. C.
I. 5()*((6 %)(%,,%.
2. (=3*7(.
E. 5) 3( =6 3' 5) 3* D *( I, C & (5(( 3 3( ))* * (4 5** # N9V(B95=( H# H,,2 # ( >)3(. *( 3 D 37*. )*)( (; < ((= >)=*((*(4((3*(( =*T 4< >3 3 = )(5 ( () 3'( ) *((T < 3 (7 3*. N( )*)( ( 3 ( **) *)** < 4< < (-# (45**33)(&=6( '*('4.)*)()() 3'# =( C(# (( = *(( =* 6'33 =**>3*(*:.$I%#$,H$,M<. 755( *( ( N 4N
3(5)3*D(5(*>3(((=68655(5** (3755
+$"!%+%,,%