Disproportionate Statutory Fee Violates Due Process
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe litigant challenged the application of a punitive statutory fee structure, arguing it was an unconstitutional exaction because the fee was disproportionate to the administrative costs incurred by the government, effectively acting as a penalty without due process. The court reasoned that although the legislature has broad power to impose fees for administrative purposes, the fee's magnitude must bear a rational relationship to the actual administrative burden created by the regulated activity; here, the fee vastly exceeded the modest administrative cost, rendering its primary function punitive, which violates the due process requirement that penalties must be preceded by a finding of culpability.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Disproportionate Statutory Fee Violates Due Process: The court reasoned that although the legislature has broad power to impose fees for administrative purposes, the fee's magnitude must bear a rational relationship to the actual administrative burden created by the regulated activity; here, the fee vastly exceeded the modest administrative cost, rendering its primary function punitive, which violates the due process requirement that penalties must be preceded by a finding of culpability.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive to rule on the costs of the appeal proceedings.
Cited in the dispositive to rule on the application for legal aid.
Testo completo
#$%&$#'(() #&%#'((*
+, ++, + ,
*- ./ ! ' 01 '((*
2! 3333333333 !" ! # "! !!" $%"&&'%"&
"!
++, 4+ + "% 4+()"""!*+,,*!
!"
1/-*21
+ 5
*3 #!4444444444%2*!*.+2!5"!%67!""&!" 8&"9 6#�"!8 3"&:&%&"& ;63
/3 " & /< 9! /,,2 ! '$ &9" ! ; #! 4444444444!"!%#! 44444444449& 6& 6!6 & $= > )=" "" &!7!3 & !" &%89&"%668!"&88%!"""!&"!&&:) &!!"9:""""=%3
23 ? 5! #! 4444444444 $" !& : !6 & $@A " !%6 & 6 > &"! 4444444444 ""% &9! =! %! 9 & " & 96 '$ " 8" 9 & =! 6)3 $: !&6' %9& :" "%!! & $% 6) 6 %9&" & 8!"!3 $"%!% %"" =&"!9!;*,,B3
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
J3 !&&" ""'"%?5! 6& #! 4444444444&%!%9!""&"&9"! ?"!!" "9!"&!!#! 44444444443F9"""& " %"" ! 9! ' $%"" %3 !!9% 9! !" 9" "& 3 !7 $9! 9!" 9" 9 ' 9 "" 6 9 6)3 $%"" ; )!! &$!!?"! $6!9""%3K99"" !=!& 6 " 9" 9 &!! "=! ! "!! 9! &! & ' 8E 99""!&=!&39%""!!9%9=&68 &&!""9""!7 !3 $%"" &" !& !""!"7!"$%9%""9""&G8)H3
+3 /.9!/,,2#! 4444444444%6"&% % " %"! #!44444444443: '%9!!"!%&!!&!!&!& 9'1%""%&% !9&9"!"%""!99! $""&"'$$9"!;&!;8%"'$> 9"'');&!$9"'$;$!%8%!!;39!9% '$ & " %"" ! % ' $!% $9" ""! % ! ' " '$; " ; =6!! 9" %3 9 !%% '$ 9" & !"!!"!!&6"$F""!"; !&!&"="' &" "5!39 !&"9 "!"8"%&%"= 5!&$6!"""")%"&!%6!&6!88! !&)F=!&!"=! !8&$!!
-*.+*-/,,0 10-*21 '"!7 &6" & 6) '$ "%8" ! & & &!"3
L3 *2 /,,2 #! 4444444444 : '% ; KK KKK K $ K M1 !7 K N 9! "!" 9 9 ' F" !%67!" 6 " ' ; !" " 9 $%"" ="% ! !9! 9 = & 68 &" G'$"8!H3$!%$%""5"%!= !$ ?)!&8! !3
<3 /2 /,,2 &"! 4444444444 &6"'% "%8" & $% 6)" !76! !!%6%"'M#N"" ":"!%&"&$% 6)98"&"?")%!& !" "%!! 8!"! "!1 6 &%)!! 7" & =!!" 6%O& "%!18%!! ! "! & "& 1% : " % )" "!1!"! 6%1)%!3 "" %"" "5! "% & "!9 ; *,, B3 %& !9% 9! %6" ""% &% ! !9 !%" $!% %"" "!7 !'% ! $6! 88!"&$F" !&$?"!6!%" !";)'8'$ !"&$6!3
.3 25/,,2 !"!%&6%! !";$"""&K " % ?&6"3!9%'%%""'"&;$&" "'$ "%&"!9;*,,B%"""3
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
-*.+*-/,,0 1J-*21 $9" ""% &$%"!6! #! 4444444444 '$ 9" "!& !! !3"! !%%'$$9" ""% 9 = & 68 & " ' !' 6 & $!% %"" !!9%$%""'9"=&"'&!!9" &"IG!6!&9'9"8! !H"'$9""5"%= ! "!! 8& & !!&!3 9 %"" % )!)! $%"" !)%&89=&683
3 "=!/,,2 6&$!%%"%"!!6% ! " 8!%8""'$9"!"%!& !7!&"3 &%"9!68%9""8!"$9!"% !'$9" !3 !%8"%8""' !%"% !9"!9%'$%"" &!!'9"=&683
*/3 /+ "=! /,,2 #! 4444444444 %6" %"% !%"!!6% " "%6!""9!&8"3!9!!&9 &6""&%"$9!"%3
*23 !!&&*,9=!/,,2 !!!&!% ='""& !% 1 ; $"! & $"%!% & 6 " & 9 ' !" ! " !% !' ! 9 & 8" % ! ! "5!!&9!"!&"!"8& !"'$=& !93
*03 ! !& & ? 5! !!! &% 9 ! ; & & /,, 8! !"" ' &!! 9" =!& = & 68 &!"=6!!9%)6& !% !'3
*J3 ! &% & /< 59! /,,0 K 8!% $!% ' 9 & !" & $&" " =! "!9 ! &$ =6!! !%&" & J, B &9" ?"! '% ! $&"% 5!7! &7 &%="&9!"&1*!/,,23
*+3 !"!""%% )'&*+8%9!!/,,0$!%""%&% &%!")'% !"3!9%'$$F9" &$%)6& 99'$%""'"%&"!9&!!!' 19"%"%)!)%=&68 !8! !3
*L3 !!!!&/08%9!!/,,08!% ";&%"" !&P198& 9!"9! "3
*<3 "& *. ! /,,0 ! K $!% !9% ' & !!! ' F !" G %)6 !% !' & H $%"" "!7 !%3!"%9!&8"""6"'$$%""&!% 9 & 8E ! !!" " $6!! 9!="3 1
-*.+*-/,,0 1+-*21 9"!% &9!"% !""%"""%$9" !9'% ; =6!! $9" % & 8! ! "!3 9" ! "! &" ' $ "" !" 9! 3 $!% ! ! &! "&$6!&"9"%"%9""'$$9"8"; 3
*.3 !&%! "&/*5/,,0K "&%&/< 59! /,,0 " !5"% $ "3 : '% '$ !!"" & " &!""&! !"&$'?"& &/+ "=!/,,2"& $!& %& *,9=!/,,2' ""$!%'"6" #! 44444444449"%"%=%!&$?%F"="; %)6 !% !' & " =&3 !" " =5"9 ; =6!!8" &&"3K 6%'99"&$! ="!"8"%&5!&=6!!"'$""""&% &!%6!=!&!"":3K$!$!% 9"5%!A&%"!"&& " "'$&9"9!' !"" '" !' !" &$ & & "!= " &$ "''%""!!9%3!"""&$%"""66% & =6!! " 9" "! '$ 9" %"% =% &$ 7! !%9="""&3 $%""&7!: %!'&$?"!=%" !%&"&&"%&9"?"! %!%3
/,3 !%!"!&/* "=!/,,0$!%"!5"%!!"!""&% ";"3! !: ""%!!;9!'$ 9"!"!%9;$ !9"'$9"&&%& F! 6 " ' &!! 9" !%6 & 7! & ! !"%3 !'$ 9""! !&&"!99 9" 6!"" '&!!!")!)!=&68 !8! !"!"'$ 9"&%!!!"!9!"9% &%3!!" !%% ' 9 & K %"" " & ! > !9";&!')'8'$"&9 ! ' !"6 ? )& !" "&"!!' &9!"!"&%6%%!!"&8"! ' !!"?"! %)6%3$:"" &&"%"!&&!!"9 9"""8"'&!!"&$=&68& $""&8! !3
/*3 !!% &<"=!/,,0K !5"&!!3 !9% '$ !!"" & !%&! % '$ F 9" "!" "! !"9&$%)6!% !'& F" !%'! =!3 !!" 9" 5% !A &%"!" & & " &9" $""&!;' !"" '!'!"&=!&" 9" %"% 9"3 K 6% ' 5! !& %)6 & ! "!Q" &6! '$ 9 : 9 & 8" " ' 88"&%5; !&""! !" ";=6!!3 ! !%%
-*.+*-/,,0 1L-*21 '""$%""&%!%"'!!"$9"&%!" 9" &&! !' %"" !"% ! & !"! !' 9 $%""="% !!)!)! =& 683! ! "% '")%!&!!"'$9"8"'&%8&!&$""' & 9 9" ?"! !"6% 9 & % ' !!" 9" !9'% ; &!!3 9" &7 ! !%"&! 9! %"% 9" &$ 6! !" 6!"" ' $"!" " 9" %"% 9" '$9""%9;!)!)! =& 683 9"& '""! !" ""9&!!";$"!"" !%'" !"!"!'"%'' '"3
+
*3 69!$!6"5&!MN%"%&8%"""%&7 *!D"/,,2 !="&! %&J56 &" !%&""91 !%&"J %""*+56!M!"3*"3 !"J+ N3
K";$"&$%"&*+56! ! !=8%&%! /L59!/,,0M (*2,*,+N!& 69& "%*28%9!! & ""!"!!6" !""" !="&! & %6! ! ; "! 56 ""! & $""" & $%"&9:56!3
/3 8!%";$!"3J+3*"3 !=Q""' &""" !%9;$!"3J+&8%&%!! !"6%%!&&!" & ! & + "=! /,,, M N !"9 "" ; 8%&%! ! $!1&" & /, ! *.<* M N3 K %" ! 56!&&$ 7"%"=3
23 $!"3+, !%9"'!!&"?"!&% %&"!"5!9" "8" & &% 5"" ; !!3 $!"3 *,+ !%9" &" '$ &%!6" ; $!"3 +, &% & !! " & "! ! &%! " !""! !""&$!3&%&"" !! %"" "!9 /* 5 /,,0 !! & /* "=! /,,0 %"% "!5"%" """&7!!9=3
"! "!5"% & 8! %6 !! &" ?"! &%!% !9= 8!%":!"3J+"J. 3
03 "6 !" ! " & 9! R"% %"" 8&% ; !%&! !"" 73
-*.+*-/,,0 1<-*21 :"!&$!"3/* 3* $!% 66!9%!' !% !9'%!%"""""""!&%" !"" 7 9" ?"! " !!" &%8"9" !%&" & !"7!"6!9!8%3KR!"32. 8%&%! " &%6! &6! :"!!&! " "! ! "%%!! ' & R! & &" !8 "9" !8 & "" !""!%&"& !"" 73!%6""&& !8 & !%&" " &%!6! ; $!"3 /* 3 * ; 2 3 " & ""&%%6"& %" 8%&%!%&"%R!"30.&$!& ! $!1&" & /, &%=! *.<+ M N ' !"" 7 " !%&" & "% &R&" !8 !9 1 "" 1 ! &R !" " ; !: ; =6!! ; ' R!% " %"% =% ! !"6" ! 'R !" !";!:;=6!!'R9"&; ! &%8M!"30,3/"3 N3
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
!%&"& !""&R!"30.3/"3 &"%"! !""&R!%'&"?"!'8%& !" " ;!:=6!!"&6!93!56!&&"% 9"&&%"!!!%"! "9" !""&!%""'R" !&" "&'!R"""&&R!% !Q""& R&"MK*..J/. 3<JN3 "%6!&&9! )&R!: 8!" "" " 9" ?"! &%!% &% &" R & R"! M ( *.+0 3 LJN3 " 8 & 5! !& "" ' 56 & !R" % !R !%"'8"56 %&R!:
-*.+*-/,,0 1.-*21 &R=6!!3R%!"!""8&R%""&8"!" !&!! '& !%"5!&''R88!" !;!"'8&" !& ! !""!M (*LL&3J.L /*2N3Y
J3 K5! !&"&"!$"!"%&"!"956&9" &%!! 8" !9% ' !'$ " 9 & !%"% MX## !&! & Z9 !P!)" 07 %&" ! *.<0 3 *2+S [&9!V"6!)" 86/7%&" 3/L<)3JN3& &!568&&%8& ""!!& !8"'8"&$?"!%"=&7!!!%8"= !" 9!== $"1;1&! ' !%"" &6!% & 9!= !% &%!"3 88" & '$ 8" ?"! &%!% " )F ")7 =3 ! " %%" & 8" %6% 96= 56 &" %)%" !"! : ' !" !== M ( */+ 2+, &3 J "3 = */J *.J &3 )3 / " !%8%!N3 $:"1"1 &!" & ! ! '$&"!"56&9!"""!&&"89!& $!%M (*/+2//&3J"3N3
+3 $ 7 K " ' !!" ! !" ; =6!! 9 %)6!% !'& "'R:""! !""&!!"" %=&"%! !'5"8&!%&! &"% & J, B3 " !!" "" " & 9 : '" "" '$ $ 8" ' &"! 9 9 ' " %"" "%"!:"'="&$""&!!%""%)!)= &68 !!"""!&8! !'9"=";=!; $% 3
"!!";' !%"&K !!" & !%&! % '$ F !" %)6 & !% !' "! !"3 " '" "% & )! & $!& & &" & *, 9=! /,,23 !9) & $!& & 1 & ? 5! !!! 6%%! "% '$ $%"" = & !%&! 9" ' !" " ! % ! ! 6!9 9 & 8" " 5! ! & 9! "!&"! " 8 & !" " & 8" '$ !99";$ &&:")7 %M83 7J8!! !%N3 $ !" !" " !: &$"! &%"3 &"&%#! 4444444444;&&$""&/,, 8!3 !9!%$!%&8! !;$&&$=&68M83 70 8!! !!"N3 $" '" ; "1; ' 6"!" 8" !%8%!;%)6!% !'& !'&$"!!& $" !% !"% & !" G 8"H 9! &9!6"& !"3
-*.+*-/,,0 1*,-*21 !! !=&% "$%!"!&$%""&8"!" !$"!"% % " & !%" 5!&' $ 88!" ! ; !"' $ 8&"!& ! !""!3! !=& %$"& $%!"!&$%""&8""'$$%"%!" ! !!! &$ 7! 6%%! !%! % ' ' ! $ !%" & "" 9! & !!" = = 9!=='&% !9 !"8%%!%1 !73
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
" $!" & 9 ' !" % )!)! = & 68 & $"" & ! !!" ! ' &!! $9" 6!% 9 3 88""" !!=!"!8" !" !9 & 6" > !" !%"&" &3 "!!"$9"!& !'9!99! !%&$=&683 "!! 9"1!!'?"9" "%!& "$%""!!?"%;3
!79! ! ' =! &" K = 8! 6!& ! !"! '$ F =6!! !" %"" & & 6!9"% "" &%893 88" !"8" %& & &"! 4444444444 8" %"" &$)%" & !%6 ! & 6!88! &$)F=!&!"&$=!!"8&!!"&"%8"
-*.+*-/,,0 1-*21 !&&&!"M 7/L":8!!"%N3""%!"; " %6!& & ""! !% & 6!88! ! ' "F & =! $ !" !%"% ; & =! &%89 " 8893 )F =! " "%8" ""% ! & & =" %6"?"!&=!&%89!'$"8!""& =!&''$ !$ ?)!&8! ! !: 3
9&%%" !=&%"9&!%"%&8"" '$"%"%&%!" !!!":1 !%""&6!%&9!= !% &%!" M ( *// 0+. &3 0 *// //2 &3 2 */, = //. &3/=.200&32"!%8%!N3
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
8&" ! 9! & 8" !== F &7 ! & !"!'$$F &&"%"! !""&$!%" &6!93
-*.+*-/,,0 1*/-*21 L3 ! " "8 !! ! & " &% & $"% & /* 5 /,,0%3
<3 !!"=""6&&"%&*RJ,,8!3!%; ""!&&% 3
-*.+*-/,,0 1*2-*21 5 , +, ++, + , !
6.202 7 822 2 4" $&' ,9:
02
*3 %!!!&/* "=!/,,0!9=S
! 02
/3 $&"S
23 &% ! " !& ! K &" & /* "=! /,,0S
03 !!"&"%&*$J,,8!3;""!&&% S
J3 "' !%&!"6!""S
+3 8! !" & '$ 9" 8!! !! "! !%" !!?" & &% & 2, 5! &7 "8" ! !&% &!% != 8%&%! & ! K)VP!)8' + +,,0 "! : !3 &% " ?"! !6%3 %! &"I N &'! :""'&%!!"&%!="!" &&% ""'%S =N : ! ! ' "8 " 9! &&! "" "! &%S N !"! 6"! & ! !%""3 K %! "" "! %%" %%!% ""! N =N " N 1& !=8%&%!&! !! "!!"7!!!!'$ &9!&%!!!!9=3%!&!!"!!F & !9 ' !" 5" ' &% ""'% " $9 & '%"%: %&%!!"M!"3*2/*,+"*,<N3 6!887!I !%&"I [\ Z #F # !%"!15!"I (!#
8!& !%"!!?"""8%: !"'$;$888%&%! &! !6!88
-*.+*-/,,0