Judgment Enforcement Validity Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns a dispute over the enforcement of a judgment against a debtor entity, where the claimant sought to recover on various judgments obtained in different jurisdictions, with the core issue being the applicability of certain statutory provisions and established legal precedents regarding the enforcement and validity of those foreign judgments. The court reasoned that the specific statutory language and controlling case law, as interpreted within the jurisdiction, dictated that the asserted grounds for avoiding enforcement were inapplicable or insufficient under the facts presented, thereby affirming the right to proceed with execution based on the established judgments.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Judgment Enforcement Validity Dispute: The court reasoned that the specific statutory language and controlling case law, as interpreted within the jurisdiction, dictated that the asserted grounds for avoiding enforcement were inapplicable or insufficient under the facts presented, thereby affirming the right to proceed with execution based on the established judgments.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the final order to rule on the costs of the proceedings.
Cited in the final order to rule on the granting of legal aid.
Testo completo
$%&'($)(() *$+,$)((-
.*
*!/ * !
# ' 0 )((-
%1 2 3
# 4444444444 !" # $ %&' '( # &# '##
55! * 6 !7! !* ##& ' ) *+, -.-- -/
!! "# #
0 .1-/0
5!*
-3 !# 4444444444, & # -*5+, 67 7# ' % # 84444444444 $ , & #7#& #7 ' # . 9# -+, # : ;<3 '& & . ; -= '' > ' %??# , 7# : ;# # @< '% ## ?#, '% ' 7 ?# #' 3
.3 $ &'# # 4444444444 ' ' 7# &#& ( # ??# ' ;<# @#( ' # 9# -+, '% '# @# A0$-, '% &#, '% > <#(3 # : -22B # #& ' 7# : ' . 9# -+ C?3 ' .= ; -=D3 ' -2 E .222 ##> #& ?#, &# ( !# 4444444444 7# ' ?# ' 67 F (% 7@ ' ?#, # # ;# ' ' -22B3
/3 -* '&; .222, 4444444444 ?# & ' # '%#<# #'&#& ' # .= 9# .222, ' 7#<#3
G3 & &'# #, 4444444444, &## H!I <#, &'& : J & @)#<#( & %; '%# && @< @#(3 % '&# %#<# ' # ' ?? !# 4444444444 #> ?# .= 9# .222, &#& ' #, ' , #7#, ' 7 #0#( # & 0 ##( ?#< # ' # @ C?3 ' /2 E .222D3
1-+/21.22.
0 /1-/0
A3 '#7## ' &' # ?# ' %??# & ' !# 4444444444 : < '%;7# $ ?# ' '&# ' ' %& ' #7#& ' &3 !# 4444444444 ??& < ' /2 7# .222 .5 E .22-3
53 $ &;# -- ; .22-, # & ( %& K &' & ' ## &#( : # 7 ' #& +A -22B, #7#&<# ## # 7 (( ## ';, ' #7#& &<>, ( 7 ' @#, : %&;# )& '## &<3 " ' &' # #'> ( !# 4444444444 ; ' #7 # #( #, # < '% # : % , 7 ; #7# ' %&, ?# ' # '%< '3 <# ' # # && '&#'& ? '% ' ' &' # $ , # # : %# ' & # ' #7#& #'# &<>, #7# ' < #3
+3 < : % ?#& #& &#' ' 7# ' +AB C' ' +AB # D F < # ' ?# '%7# # 7@ &7&& ' ' A2B # 3 $ " ' &' #, L # ( & ' '# < #<#?##? ' #& ' 7# J #( # '%#7#& : $ 3 ## ( #& &#' ' 7# ' +AB ## C' ' +AB ## # D #; J#<#; ' ' #7#& ' & M3 ?? & ( '> %# N !# 4444444444 ?& ## &#(, # ' #' C( '%<<D '#??& ' ;7& # $ C?3 ' -2 97# .22.D3
1-+/21.22.
0 G1-/0
=3 ' -+ 97# .22., '#7## ' &' # ?# ' %??# ( # ; ' ?#, # % #< '% 7 #7#&, 7# && #, # ', # 7 7 #, # ' %#' ' %& : ?# ' 3
*3 .A 97# .22., % '& : !# 4444444444 9 ' '&##, J '( '<& '%#7#'#& ' G+B # &# '> . 9# -=3
-23 && !" # $, !# 4444444444 & '# 93 ( &'# #& : -22B # #& ' 7#, ( ' & : %# ' < # '& # &#& A2B # , ?# ( H 7# 9<& (%# 7# ' &' : &'# ' .AB ' # 7 #7#'#&3
--3 7#& : '&#, '#7## ' &' # ?# ' %0#7#'#& #'#( ( %&7# '% # #& ' 7# ?# &'# '## 7 %;7# # (# : #& ' +AB3 > , L &7# &'# % ?# ( @&#(, (% < ?# > ( ?# ?#, 7# '# K #7#&<#&3 #< ( 4444444444 ## #; ' ' -22B ' ' & M C ' -2 E .222D3 (# ' 7# ( #? ' ' +AB 7# && ( A2B 7# && &#& ' ' ' < #, '#7## ' &' # ?# ' %0#7#'#& & ' # O
L '% < ' ? 9 C' ' & ??#7D, & '# ' ' A2B # 3 $ << && 9<& #??# %&
1-+/21.22.
0 A1-/0
% & #&& #7#&3 & & #( # '%#7#& : $ 3 7# ' ' #7#&<# ;7# < '& P ( > '&3 % # ( ' ' -2 97# .22. : #& &#' ' 7# ' +AB M3
-.3 $%<# ' # ' <#, '#7## ' &' # ?# ' %0#7#'#& #'#(& (% 7# ' '% > &?&& &@' ;& # ## '% 7# ' 7# @ ' J &#( ' ' >7, &#& ( ' %### ' , # 7# ' &' : &'# # ' # ?# C ' .A 7# .22.D3 $ ;## : '<& '%#7#'#& ' G+B3
-/3 .- # .22., '#7## ' &' # ?# ' %0 #7#'#& &# ??& # ' <# ; ' ##( # #& ' $$ C(K # ' #D3
## # #'&# O
0 $# #7#'#&, &#& .22. H3 52Q=.-,AA
0 $# $$ .222 @ 7# ' ' '# #'# ?#> & : ' R@ # & &##7, &#& .22. H3 A=Q5.+,00
0 ### ' ' ' .AB H3 G/Q*+2,00
0 &'# &# ' .AB H3 /.Q*+=,00
0 <& '%#7#'#& G5B
-G3 '&## ' -5 # .22., % # !# 4444444444 ;&&?# '% ( ' '%#7#'#&, '% '<& '%#7#'#& ' G+B3 '&## && '& '# : !# 4444444444, : '#3
1-+/21.22.
0 51-/0
-A3 <# ' !# 4444444444, !" $ #9& -+ 9# '# '&##3 # : '# ( ' K &7& : ' A2B F # >7 ( ' < $ , #& ' 7# && #& +2 +AB, ( % ## '% '<& ' +2B # # ' ;&&?## '% '#0 '%#7#'#& F (% 7 ' '## &7#' &'#J ' <, # : (% J # &'# # '& ?# ' '&# #& ' 7# &#' ??#7 F # ' 7 J#<#; ( #7#' &;# % 3
-53 &7# ' .- E .22., % 9 ' : ?## ' '&## (&3 ##> (% < ?# ' > (% & ; ' &#, ( %&7# &'# # ( % @&#(3
-+3 '&## ' G -- ?&7# .22/, % ?#J& ' &#?
'E : !# 4444444444 : ' - 9# -= /- # .22.3 % # % ## ?& !# 4444444444 : ## ' $0 ;9 ' &, '& (%L 7 ' ##< ' '7 ## #? K ;9, # ; ?? ( &# ' &', ' ' .+ ?&7# .22/ &#& '# K #& ##, # '# M3
-=3 9< ' -5 7# .22/ GG-1.22., ## ' $0 ?& '% #>, #'& ( J ' %# A. 3 - ' # ?&'& # <&& ' '# ' # C D &# # # # &# F (%# # ## : % ' ' '&## ##3
1-+/21.22.
0 +1-/0
!*
#9& # > ' ## ' $0 7; C# =G $ 5* D3
&& # '%??# & #; ?& : %# /, 3 / ' # ' -G 7; .22. '#?# # %<## 9'### CD3
# ?&'& # <&& ' '# ' # ' 5 ; .222 C D & 7#< - 97# .22/ " '#?## ' ; '# ## &< ' '# ' % $0 3 '% > ?# &<# '# ## 7#< 9(% /- '&; .22., &<' ## ( >< #; 7#< N ?# 9#'#( '&# '# C H -.+ G5+, #'3 - F -.- /55D3
'&## ##<# && #?#& '# : %&, ( !" $ 7# 'E #?& % ' (%# ) 7# &# ' '## ' C# +5 F ## &' S /2.2 3 F ## #J S -2-.D3 %& %) ;# &9'#, # 9#?# ' ' #'& ( '&## && 7; #?#&3
%#7#'#& '&?## # '### ' #& ' <#, && ' < '&, (# & '% : & @)#( 7 '% #?##& <&#, '% '# '% #'3 # : & %7 ' '# : ' # ' % #7#'#& ( # " # #& ' <# && ' < '& C# G D3
1-+/21.22.
0 =1-/0
%# #& ' <# # '### ) &7##; ' #;##& ' <# ' & %; ' @& ' 7# &(##;& 7 #'&# C?3 @#?? -2-+ ' ## %#7#'#& %# D3
%& '# : %# #7#' : G2B #3 # 7 ( ' 3 $%# #7#' : A2B, # 7 ) '#0 # #7#'#& # 55 .1/B #> C# .= 3 - D3 J ' %# .= 3 -;# , ' &#;, #7#'#& ' G2B # 7 '# : '#03
% >, # % & ( !# 4444444444 J #7#& ' 67, ' # 9# -+ C?3 ' 4444444444 ' .= ; -=D3 # ?# : %# ' < $ , # & ( %& J #7#& ' & 7 ' #& ?# : +AB # , & &#& ( L #& &#; M3 < # 7@ &7&& ' #?&# ' A2B3
H ' (%# %) &#& ' '## &'#J ' <, & & ( 4444444444, !# 4444444444 # ;# ' ' -22B ' ?# ( 673 9#?# '> ' %& : J # &'#3 $%<# ' '&# ( & # ' # : & #& ' 7#, < # : %&7#' & ) '&( '&?## (CD #7#&CD J %& ' ( , &@&3 % ?? # ' ?#J J '%#7#'#& ' : %# #& ' 7# &'# C?3 -*5., 3 GG-D3 % '# 9 J# #, ;# ' ( , #& ' 7# &#' ##; #J ( 7 # K &#& ' % # ' 7J #; J#<#; C?3 , @#?? /22GD3
1-+/21.22.
0 *1-/0
# 7@ '## ' & ' < $ , # +AB < #, # A2B3
< $ , # ( %& 7# && ; '%< ' 9(%: +AB, ( ' ' '% #, # %7# ?# ( A2B3 7# ( ?# '%K ?& ## &#( & K ' : '&;## & &' #, # ' '## (( '3 @< '# ' ' 7@ #J #;3 #; ' & '%7# (% > &#' ' &' # &@&, ' '7# #' #' # ;7& ' <3 < # %& '&& ' -/ ./ 7; .22-, 7 'J 9 '%;, % #<#?##? ( '& 3 9#?# &( ' # ' ' +AB3
#; ' ' 7 R<, (%# ? ?? &# %' : 7 ) '% # C ## %#7#'#& %# S-2.GD3
: J# #& ' <# ' !# 44444444443
$%<# ' %&7# ' %#7#'#& ' & (# J #7#& #7, %#& . ' %3 .= '# O
L %&7# ' %#7#'#&, 7 ' 7# ( %#7#' # ;# JT %#7#& (% ' ' #, > J&# &7 ' ' &' # '% ## &(##;& ' @& ' 7#, & 7 (%# # ;# %# %&# #7#' M3
&@' ' # ' 7 # : '&# J '%#7#'#& 'J 7 @) @&#(, # 7 @) @&#( '% #7#' 7 @) @&#( '%#7#' C?3 ##
1-+/21.22.
0 -21-/0
%#7#'#& %# ' %??# ?&'& ' # [ ], @#?? /2-/D3 # '# >< <&& ?# ' #> ( 'J 7 @) @&#( # @#??& J #; # >, '#??& '<& '%#7#'#&3 $# K '&#& 7 &##, # 7#' ' &7 && ' ## ' 7 J##7 ## C$ .222 3 =G, #'& -; F $ .222 3 /-5 #'& -D3
' 7 @) @&#( '% #7#', # ( & &## 7#;;, &<' : %; ' #, # %&# '7 #7#' C?3 -*+/, 3 -*= F -*5G, 3 /== F -*5-, 3 //=D3 # ' '& , ' #'&# 7 '% # ' '% #, ' K R<, ) K ?# ## ?# ' < ' K 7# C?3 -*=*, 3 GA5 F -*=5, 3 G/.D3 7# ' ; #'## ?# '# ) C$ .222 3 /2= #'& /D3 $ '&# 7 ( ' ## $ && T C# .A 3 - D3 # ' & : %&7# ' # #J ' ;@ '%#7#& : ' '&# %&7# ' %#7#'#& C$ .222 3 /-/ #'& .D3
7 '%#7#' ' 7 (% @'# & # &# JT #7#& ( % #; ' '%, > '%&7 ' &' # '% ## &(##;& ' @& ' 7#3
'&## ##<#, % % ?'& ' # # #7#'#& ' H3 A*Q=.2,003 % &3
1-+/21.22.
0 --1-/0
'&# 7 7 #7#'#&, % , ' # &?&& ' #'&# # ## ' 7# ' 7# ## ' H3 G.Q.A2,00, '( # '&'# .AB # ' ' ' +AB CG.Q.A2,00 # .AB U /-Q5=+,00D, (# # #( '<& '%#7#'#& ' G+B3
$ !# 4444444444, 7 '&# '# K & ; '% ' ' +2B3 ;# ?# ' H3 .*QA+A,0
0 CG.Q.A2,00 # /2BD3 #'> (% '&# : # ' .AB '# K '&'#, (# ' 7 ' H3 ..Q-=-,00 '<& '%#7#'#& ' 5.,*B3
H : &<' &#& (%# ?# # ' ?# ( # ' &, (# @'# & K ' % # ' 7J J### &<, '&7<& ' &&# : ' 7# # # ' #& ' 7# ?# : K <<&, (% '#7 <&& ; # # # &7& C$ .222 3 =G, #'& .; F $ - 3 -=A, #'& /; F $ - 3 AA, #'& /;, $ -= 3 -=-, #'& /D3 &@&, # 7#' ' ' &' : &'# ' # ##(3 ?# &'#, ' ? #< ' '7 '& <; .AB C$ .222 3 /.-, #'& A;D3
%#7# ' #> <&& ' @( 3 '& ' ' %; ' # ?# ' 3 % >, # ( &'# '# K ' .AB3 H % ' '% &'# ( ' ?'& % $$ C$ -=, 3 -+* F $ -, 3 -=GD3
1-+/21.22.
0 -.1-/0
% ## : 9 # ( % ?& ' # '% '&# ' %### ' 7# ' 7#3
9, # #' ' 7 ( &?& J # ##J ?#J& 7# #7 % #, # , ' ?# ( # #; 7 @'# ' &# ##& : '# ##, #7#& & <; ' # 7#& ( J ' #, 7 ' @#, : %&;#, )& '##3 &<', ##( ' %H$, (# '##< # #7 ' (#?##, '# '%#7#& J # '%#?# ?#; C?3 H ' -A 9# .22- A=-122 &?&D3 ) ' # ' &?& : ##( ' # ; ''#&, ?' 9 &'# 7 C H -.G /./ F $ - 3 -=. H ' .* 9# .22/ G2A12/D3
$# % ; ## ;J ##( $$ # % # 7 &#; ) @ ' #7#& # & &##7 ' ' '#, # H3 AAQG-5,00 C $$ .222D # % '# 7 #'J& .22. '& @;''# ' G-,*2 @ C$ - 3 A-D, # % '&'# .AB ?# ' # ' ' <; ' '% >, # .AB K@ : ' %&, ;# 7 '%#7#' ' H3 /.Q*+=,003 # ' <#, '% 7 #7#'#& ' H3 52Q=.-,AA C# &#& .22.D, ' '<& '%#7#'#& ' G5B3
'&## ' % '# '> K ?#&3
1-+/21.22.
0 -/1-/0
*!5 *!/ * !
#
8 0
-3 T# F
# 0
.3 9 F
/3 ? # ' (Q 7 ? & K ' '&# ' /2 9 '> #?## # '& '& #; ?&'& ' , $@V#W@?(# 5, 522G , # J #3 '&# K <&3 &# '# O D #'#( J (Q '&## '&# ;# # ' '&## (&F ;D J ( #? # # 7# '' '&##F D #< ' &3 $# &# # # && &&& D ;D D #0', #; ?&'& ' #> (Q# '7 '& #7;3 &# ' # ) ' 7, (# 9#, ## ( '&## (& Q7 ' ( && J &'#& C3 -/., -25 -2= D3
<??#> O &#' O
!#0# X # Y
# ? ' & K #?#& J # ## (Q: Q??# ?&'& ' # <??
1-+/21.22.