Mandatory Minimum Sentencing Statute Violates Judicial Discretion
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns a challenge to a statute imposing a mandatory minimum sentence based on prior criminal history, where the defendant argued the statute violated constitutional guarantees by preventing the sentencing court from considering mitigating circumstances related to their criminal history when imposing sentence. The court reasoned that the mandatory nature of the sentencing provision, which fixed the minimum penalty based on objective, pre-existing facts of the defendant's record without judicial discretion to account for individual circumstances, constituted an unconstitutional delegation of legislative power and infringed upon the judiciary's inherent authority to determine a just sentence within the parameters set by the legislature.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Mandatory Minimum Sentencing Statute Violates Judicial Discretion: The court reasoned that the mandatory nature of the sentencing provision, which fixed the minimum penalty based on objective, pre-existing facts of the defendant's record without judicial discretion to account for individual circumstances, constituted an unconstitutional delegation of legislative power and infringed upon the judiciary's inherent authority to determine a just sentence within the parameters set by the legislature.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied to order the appellant to pay the judicial costs.
Testo completo
%&'()%& %+),%'--.
!!
/ !0/ /!
# ' 1 2 '--.
,3 45 2
!!6 7/! * /! 6! !! ! !"#$%&'%()
+#
# 68888888888 ,- .$ *""## +",#, /0000000000 ! 1-""2
! "#$ $&3%%$
6
%5 /0000000000! 1"$6(7+",#,2,#,""#8"# + () 1"$6(7 2 9' 6#*: %;95 <+"8" 6+#"# +* =0000000000! 1 %;9>%426"?0000000000! 1 %4>%@2)# <A#+,/0000000000! %@5 )"#:#")#7B+ +*" -+"#CD#"(#"#"E#+##")"#,#6:""#, *#"( #+"#"FE 6" # 8#"+ 6#""6#"+ G# #6"H5 I+" 0000000000 ,#, ""# ## F "# ( &% ,*:%4%5 #>I+"J0000000000",#, *""##"F ( &4 ,*:%&5 + .,#"#:,,-" <"8#" ")" 5
&5 6#" <,%&+",#,+,>+# "--"#,>,8 +#"#"+ +" F" " ,#"# -#, 6 " "#6+-"+ <$)"" # )")# J, ,#"+ K "# 6#+.
1 ) 6" + " "#6+-"+ <$)"" # )")# J, ,#"+ #6" +* L"$6(7 "M2 > F<,#"#--"",5
95 &; +)*: %& " ,6+, 6"# 6, +# I+" J0000000000 6+ +##"+ +#"#"+ # +*""+ -+" ,#"+ "56"#,#,#",%@ ,*:%&6(6"*#5
@5 +",#,+#"#>* # 6"*#" ,6+, +) 6"# 6, +# I+" J0000000000 %' N" %95 ## 6"#,#,#",&@N"%95
O5 &@N"%@"-+"+ ,6+,6"#6,+#I" J0000000000#0000000000"+ +6"*# +#"#"++" --,# . *+" 6#*: %9 > -,)" %@5 <K# 6 P <"-+*#"+ + +)+#"+ 6# + ,, " ,6+,F#"(*6"#6, # &N"%O5!"#6"*# *+## >#"# 6#6, .6"#+#,#,#",6+" @N"##+Q#%O5
;5 N8*# &4 )" %O ": 6*"( "# () 1"$ 6(7 26++,-""# +",#,5
45 +" %9 +#+: % <--" 6+"# # -""# "-+*, " ,6D# #: "#":#"+ -""# # < *""+ ,&(*>C# %&G@%4-5%O5
3%&43% $93%%$ 5 &+#+:%<--" 6+"##-""##*">"# ,-# :"6(-""#6++ %&G@%4-5%O5
5 &4 N"# % " +#"-", > I" J0000000000 # 0000000000 ,""+,6#"+ +86+*+## G@O-5&'C 1+#"#"+ <+#+: %& > * %9 # <+Q# %9 > N)" %@ +*6,*#%%#-"25
%'5 +" &O +Q# % I+" J0000000000 -"# +66+"#"+ > ,""+5 !+ " + 6"*# ## "+*:"# "F*# > I+"0000000000F",#"#>)+""8#+*6# +",#,5" +8,#"#)"*::*#+#"#,6#"6 +#"#"+ I+"0000000000 +#F<""66#"# ,8## ## *+R",#"#:,,-" <"+-+#:5
%%5 I+"0000000000<,##6+66+,> ,""+""-"., #"* ,"6+,8 +86+" 6#*:%5
%&5 &96#*:%" ,6+,#"+*"), <+66+"#"+ I+" J0000000000 )# +""+ + *#"( <$)""#)")#5!+6+:""#, < *""## ,#"# 88, # " ,#"# ")# )+" F " ,#"# +#"#"+5 <8*# ")+F, ,*+#"# 6+ 6 F <+66+# )"# #+#*# -"" > +:"8#"+ < *""## <.P# 6 C# )"8#"++6,,6 "# +",#,5
%95 ": , F ,#, #*" <+--" % +Q# &''9 # 6#"+*6#"+6+%+Q#&''@5 ##+"+ ,- " "F, F<" <)"# 6P ) 6+ + #")"#, < *""##*"F<")"#")#":+6 <8# +",#,6 6# +"# )"+ &O'G'''5$ -5 " F<,## *""## " "6+"# < "8# *" )"# F "# +",#, ,6"# :+6 <8#F"<,#"#6:+*"( 8,<#6"5I8,-"# F "# " +"# "-+*#"+ *C --" " <)"# 6 ,*""+, F" +#"#"# 6#5 -"# F +#"#"+ +" ,#"# "*6K, " ,#"# 66 +F<" )"# ,#, +)+F, 66+""#> ,+"#"+6,5
%@5 # ,8*# +#" ## " F I+" 0000000000 ,#"# "#+): # F<" )"# F"##, !" 6" , 6+ J5 !+ ,6+" "F,>"6)+"+R"#+)"#5 "6#" +##, F ," 6"6#"+ "F 6+ ,* > <"#,, *+## Q)"#>,C,5
3%&43% $@3%%$
!
%5 +"8)+"<+8"#"+N """12,#,*+ "-",#"#"#, ( %+Q#&''9 ":#+ +"1 !2+*6+, "FN8 +# 6," # # )"$6," # "F 66,# # "S N8 1#5%#5#O; 25
!"#><#"+ <,#"+ "SN86 ":-, ,
1 J2&4N)"&''@ 1 J%9' %';2 +"8)+" +6#, %9-,)" &''@ "6+"#"+ #"#+" 8# 1#5 %;& 2 6*### ! ",8>#+"N8#"#" <### <,#"+ +).N85
!### + +"# 6:" J A# %N"# &''@ +-"*, F ## "6+"#"+ #"#+" +#"#"# +#"+ 6 #"+#,#"# +T#+-+* +"#-, ,1A#%5%93&''@25
8*# "" F#"+ <"+#"##"+"#, ": #+ +"" ,,F,#"+ #":6+)"#A#*" )-+ ,+8#+" +"#-, ,+"#<+<#5O4 +"-, , ;+#+:&'''6#"8,, +"# +" 1 25
&5 +-+*,*# > <#5 9 5 9 "6+"#"+ #"#+" "#+ "# )#<#,)"8 +"#6 # )# +""+#+ + +# ,#, #*" <+--" ": #+ +" ###"#"F+###"+*#"( G$)""# )")#1-5#5O;25!+*6,#6+N8 <6(#"" ,#:"5
95 +" -, , 6#" 8,, +"# +" ;+#+:&''' 1 2 # #, )"8 % N)" &''9 #T# +*:*+ "-"#"+ +*" <$)""+## F"+<#"O& +"-, ,<$)""#)")# &' ,*: %@; 1 !25 ,+*" 6+:""#, <*6+K K # ,8, *"(6 ,#",F<6)###"%#& (8*# <$)""#)")# 9%+#+:%@41 !2+#,#,:+8,5 <6( * #+#-+" ,8" 6 "6+"#"+ )"8 NF< 9% ,*: &''& ,8 6""6 + F (8 66": +# )"8 *+*# +R -"# N" "F*# ,#*"# +#
3%&43% $O3%%$ 6+ "#1 J%&4@;4+" 5%25 "6+"#"+,8+# (+"#, "#5
@5 2 . #* <#5 & 5 % ! +"# * ,6#"+ < +86"#+F" +*6#"+-"#6)+"6 ,""+ ,6#"+ <,6(F<+" +8# #+#><.6"#"+ < ," "F>+*6# -"# +8:5 +#"*#># ## "6+"#"+"<8"#<+ < ," 6,*6#"+>+" , <+--"1 J%%9%%U %465;'4 J%%& +" 5@U %;65@925 +F +"# ,") <#6": +*"6+ 6,> ," 6"6#"+ 6+8 , ," #66":1#5&5& !25
":-, , 1"$6(7 J 26+,6""6F<" +*6#"+B+" +8H "6+"#"+6,"#, > 6#" *+*# +R +"# +T# K 6A## <###"+ F<+ # +"# <## <###+*6# 6#"FF"+# " 6*### 6 +) +#"#"+ *" 6+"# N#"-" +:"8#"+ ,6 +81 J%%;4O+" 59:E%%9%%+" 5 &E %%& +" 5 @ %OE %' O& +" 5 OE %9 65%'25 -"# ,#*"## + +##F<"<KB" +#+6"#"6+-"#"> "#":H1J ! V !C :#":8 W+X&(*, 565%%&2 <+R ,#6# , "5
-""# + ++ # 6 : + <#"- " < 6 ,"*# +" +8 *+*# *# +R 6# +# #: "#":#"+ # +*6# -" ,#:" 6 <--" -""# + "F" # + > # > F P+"# # ,-# :"5 --# " F" :"# 6# -""# + 6+, ++ #"#)#"###"+ +8$"#,A#8,,+ 6#"F #":. ,N> --"# +" +8 *+*# +R ++#"+ , " # +#"-", + > " +R <,## ++#"+#<")#"+#,#, ,6+,#6)#A#+#,5 *+*#$ > ," # + )"# A# 8,, * +T# <,## #"-++#"+ ,# ")" 6+::1 J%%&+" 5 9E %' %; +" 5 9E ! %O 65 %;$%4' +" 5 &E J %%; %;% +" 5@E%%;4O+" 59:U %'65@%O25
#*B8,,H"8"-"#F6""6" +*6#"+# * <#"*--"#<,# + +8*+*# ,6D# <,## ++#"+56##+#-+"F###"*#"++"#6+":F 6C#," "F" #"+6.*66F*+## #"- ,6 6+ "# )# :""+:""#F< *""##"+ -""#6#-+"" "#"+>6+6+ ")" 6,)"":1
3%&43% $;3%%$ %& 65 &;; +" 5 OE !! I " +*6#"+ ## F 6#" > 6+, ,6#"+ < +8 + <#5 O& ! %%65@';25)*#6#",,6#.6#"+*#"+ "+# 6," F," +" ," )# ,6D# <,## ++#"+E <# 6#"" +F< 66 < *""##"+ -""# > <+"+ < *:, ," F< ")" 6+A# "#":,.," "5<."# # "+# 6 # *" F<) #7 "*6 * + "8*# 6+)# 6+ + #+", 6*###6+ -+ # *+#") * N#"1 J%% %;+" 59:25
" <" -# > N# #"# *+# ,)( <66,"#"+ 6+:""#, <*6+KY#6.#"+ +8<"<8"# <6+*+YF"+"+ +8>" +*6#"+ <+:)# 6 "##"+*# + 6 ,8"8 8) 6"6#"+ !1 J%%@&&')52"-# *A**+#."8#><,8 < *""##"+F"+6# + "#"+-+* <#"+ 6+:""#,-+ ,<#5O& !1 J%%;U!%965%%'25
:2 <6(<#F< # &N"#%N+ 6:"#"+ J" <)"+--"" ,6D# <,## ++#"+><--" 6+"# F"6)+"+" +85 ,""+,6#"+ +8+#"-",&4N"#%+#6+,F#"#) ," 6,*6#+" <6"#6<#5&5% !5
,- 6+ 6# -+*, +66+"#"+ 6 # 6+#, &O +Q# % +#F<",8*#8"#*6#"5
-" " K# ,6+, FA# *"), &9 6#*: % " <"# F ## <+66+"#"+ F FA# *"), +# ): > -+*1#5%59#&5& !25
O5 2 )# G#5 O& ! G*6+K F" "##"+*# + 6 ,8"8 8) G+:) 6 6"6#"+ # "" +8 > " +*6#"+ # # > ,6#"+5 !" G*6+K # 6+ *+6+:""#,6#G,# >#"#:" "".+86+: 1!%9659+" 5&E J%%@4+" 59U %65;9%E J%%9 &O;+" 59U %65%9;25
6"6#"+ F +"# 6# G*6+K +# #+# G:+ +" -, , G$)"" # )")# # "6+"#"+ G.,#"+ +##+#G+:"8#"+ , ">CF6"*# " +#"#"+ ", 6" ) > " +*6#"+ *A* #*6F6+6+#"#"+""FG+:"8#"+ *##6,"+ "F*#>
3%&43% $43%%$ " 6"( +*6#: +# " ), . *6+K, *"(>F+#"#"+6"#"6"#A#,#-"G+:N# ,""+1 %O65;'4+" 5OE %O65;@;+" 5925
G+:"8#"+ 6K +#"#"+ # -+" ,+*6# # 6+ G*6+K#ZC +"#6:"6"#6+"5 #,8 ": -, , ,, > ,"#,, 6" F 6+:""#, G*6+K G#5O& !#",### +"#6:"1 J%%& %OO+" 5OE %465&&'25G*6+KF"GF"##6 ###ZC +#)"+#"+ 6"6#"+ G#5O& !F"#T 6+"G+:"8#"+ ,6#"(*# +8""+"+,1 J%%% %49 +" 5 &E %' %; +" 5 % %& +" 5 &E %O 65;@; +" 5925
:2 G6( +8+"#6# , +#"#"+:" 6 " "+ -""# +",#,+"#G@O-5&'+-+*,*# . ,+*6#F<N+"#> ,""+ ,6#"+ +8#F" +#6+##,6 ,- 5
;5 2 G#5%@5% !+,#"+) #59@#")# !6"# G+:"8#"+6+G*6+K , "CF"+#"#"+ ",# ) $" > " +*6#"+ ) 6+6 +#"#"+5 *6+K +")# )+K . " 6,"+ "F*# 6"( +*6#: +# " ), > ", *"( > F +#"#"+ 6"#"6"#A#,#-"G+:N# ,""+5
+FG*6+K#6+*++8,6+ #+" "*# > #"# :" "" +8 , 6 "$" +## F 6+ *+ G."# 6 *+*# +R 6+:""#, # 88, 1+ ;''9 "#") <--" -, , +" 66#"+ +#"#"+"$6(7E J%%@4+" 59E%%9&O;+" 59E %65%9;+" 59E J%%%%49 %O65;@+" 5&525
[+8[ " -# # #+# 6+ 6CK"F F" 6,# 6+ *+>G.#,"+F"6#."- ,"")+*6+#*# $"1+;''@25+FG"#"" G+",#,+K* J G# #+N+ ,-,, > G#5 4O@ 5 % +,#"+ ) G#5 4O % 5 +-+*,*#>#"#+#6+C8, G *""##"+ 8#"+ + +#D ,6+ # > G,8 +",#, *A* FG) CF#"+"+,"+" +8FG*F# "##"+*#+6,8"8> )+"#6+F",6+ # G *A* +8 +# # +" "*#5 !+# ,6#, C8, G *""##"+ + 8#"+ G#5 4O; [+ *# +8 ,""+ ,"8, .6,*# + # *" ,8*#
3%&43% $3%%$ 6+ F" 6# --#")*# ,""+ )# +8 + F" *# 8#"+ 6+6*# "# # +# "" 6# 6,6+ ,# > -+*#"+ )++#," +",#,[1 J%'49O9+" 5OE J%%& %O # GA# &% )" % E J! I! " X#"C#"C#\+#"CX"#&(*, 565&'#25
N#"-" G66"F*A*6""6 G#"O& ! 6+:""#,:" "" +8 G6+*+ +*" G$)"" # )")# ,+ " "#*# #" OO5 9 + ")" 1 E !&%'2 # 4O@ +" ,, + G.6"+ (8 8,,1 J;%&OU %4%65@425 *#*+#"-F"+#> : G .#"+ +#"+ G+8 +"# ")" # F" 6+( # )++#, G+ 6+##"+ --" . ," +". +# #+# " ): G8"# 6+:""#, +"# 6:" "#"#, 6 G#" O& !5 -" + G8 6""6 G,8"#, #"#*# # N#"":""#",F"#:,C,# CCF6+ ""# F6,",*#G)"#6#$A#6+)+", ,""+1 %65;99+" 5925
:2 <6( " +# G.#"# F I+" J0000000000 ,#, *""## +",#,:,,-" G"8#" ")" >+*6# &4 ,*:%&#NFG>-""# +",#,5#""" ,":FG" )"#F"#, G+8 +",#,-""FG"+## G"65
45 2 +)"# > 6,# <.*" " ,- <# +6: G )"+#"+"##"++6,8"88) 6"6#"+,8"#G !5 --# G+:"8#"+ ,6 +8 G."# +# F G" GK 6 "+# -"# 66T# + N#"-", +*6+#*# G*6+K + .# FG" "# +" -# "##"+*# + 6 ,8"85 # + +): FG *6+K # +8 > " +*6#"+ )"+# "##"+*# 6"6#"+ G ! *" +"# ,*+" 6 # ,6 " "+# 6," 6*### +F++:)#"+ "#6"6#"+,#"#6*" +6,#"#6-#1 %O65;'9+" 5&#,-5"#,25
" +*6#"+F"+##FG:" +86"# +$+:)#"+ 6"6#"+ 6# *## F G*6+K )"+, $" "##"+*#+ *+"6,8"88) *+R"G."# 6 G" "-"#+">,8"#"*"#, ++*6+#*#+>G: G -#1 J &N"%& %965%'%25
N"6 +## J + F<" K ,8"8 8) +F G*6+K+-+*6>F"6#A#"+:*#."8, #+# 6+6: "*# "##"+" #"F# *A*
3%&43% $3%%$ "+#1-5 %4&65;'25* FG+# +"# G."8 >#,8 +"# +A#,), G6(FG+6#+ ""*### *#"( +*6#:""#,# 8#"+ G*6+K *A*#,8+"F G"#,,$5 +F<" <8"# < +",#, +K* + 6# 6 6""6 6+ ."8,)(F"+<###"+F< +"#+ 6# 6"6#"+1-5 %4&65;'E %465&;%25 "--,"#"+ *:: <"*6+ ,8*# +F<" <8"# <66," 6+:""#, :" "" +8 <*6+K 1 J %' &'& +" 5 9E %O 65O%+" 5A@+" 59:25
# ,8 " " 66 F< *""## 6# ":, 6+:""#, )" 6+*# > F +#"#"+ 6"#" --,# . " ), +"# 6K, > " +## F<" -""# +-">+(8C8, < *""##"+ 6+ <#6"# )*# "#+#"#"+>" +*6#"+5+#" )+" <.C#)"6+C8, 8#"+6+ < +## F< +:)# +" ### (8*# # "##"+ +, 1#5 4%; 5 % C5 O 25 !" **: +" < *""##"+F"+#6C8, 8#"++##6# )"CF--" 6+C8, 8#"+# 6,##"+ *"6)#"*"#+#D "#"+# *C --"" +")#6 ###+:"8#"+*##,8"(*#+# *C --" ."8 66+# # ,# " *"#"*# # :+" * "8*#+*6,*#"#K #"" <,)#1 J%%@&&9+" 5@E J+6:",V&;O3'& 9 N"#&''925
:2 ( <, %& +",#, +, > +# "--"#, #,+"#6" # )*# +#"#"++"5 ,- *""##"F +",#, 6" "S" <,-"#)+"+ +*6#"+ 6+ F<" <)"# +" #")"#, +",#,5.6"F,F "#<)"#6,6+ > * +F<" )"# $ 6+ "F*# $ ##, <+:#" "8*#5 ": () 6 #F"")"#,"#>6"6">+ 6"),6+ <"-+* "--"#, +#, 6 +",#,5 )"# ,#, "" %'N"%& & +#+: %& 9 *" %9 & * %@ @ +)*: %@ # %;*"%O+"#>;6"6,"+ 6F#+",5 ,- 6# +-")+"F<"<,#"#6+# "*6+##6+:(* #,+" +#, 6 +",#, +# " ,#"# *""## F :" *A* "# +",#,,6+ "#6> * 5"+T# <)+"N*"6"+##)"6+<"-+* "##"+### ,8 "--, 5+##")"#,#,+)+F,6+# 6+"%&"#> ,+"#"+6, ,6+,6"#)"#F+#"#"+<)"# 6 ,#, 6K, #*6 )+5 *""## ""8# "# "F",#, 6
3%&43% $%'3%%$ ,"*# 6"#, +",#,>*:+ ##5 # <## 6 )" F ,- "# 6-"#*# +*6# "--"#, 6#"F*#"*+#:.F+",#,"#>-"-6+6# 88*#5
"#+6 ,88 6+:""#,,8#<)+"N*" ., 6+)+" 8#"+ +",#,5"66#"#6,",*# F"#, < *""## <. C# )" + 6+ C8, 8, +",#, # < F +#"#"+ ! ,#"# ,8"(*#),>"5
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
5 ) F" 6,( -+ # ( + +## F ,- +#, +8>" <#5O& ! +#"##> ,6#"+"+6+F * *"),# *"
3%&43% $%%3%%$
! 6 !0/ /!
# 94: ; 1 7$ &+' <=
:
%5 P+"#FA#*"),E
# :
&5 < *##()<+66+"#"+-+*,6I+"J0000000000>+ *+## G@O-5&'5
95 ,:+#6#" #+##++#"+"+E
@5 "#F6+, #8#"#5
O5 -+* 6#" F< 6)# -+* + +# 6,# A# ," 9' N+ ( +#"-"#"+ 6 6" + , , ": -, , !C\"SC+-F" ; ;''@ #+" .*6"5 ," 6# A# 6++8,5 *,*+" +"# 7 2 " "F .#*#F ,""++# ,"+:#""#6 ,""+ ##F,E :2 .6+ 6+ F *+#"- " #"* 6+)+" * ## # ,""+E 2 6+# "8# + + 6,##5 !" *,*+" +#"# 6 #+" ,,*# ,*,, + ## 2 :2 # 2 "$ ":-, , 6+6#*#"(+F<" ) ,"):5*,*+" +*#"++*+K 6) F" +# N+"# "" F ,""+ ##F, # <)+66 F,#,.6, ",+#1#5%9&%';#%'25 8--"(7 ," #7 "JJ W"! W ,#"$N"#7 I"V II +6"+-+* 6,#A##+#"-",.6#"""F<><--"-, , +"68--
3%&43%