Agreement to Agree on Essential Terms vs. Enforceability of "Standard" Prepayment Penalty
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case addresses whether a contractual provision requiring a party to execute a financing agreement that includes a "standard" prepayment penalty constituted an unenforceable agreement to agree on essential terms, specifically when the overall agreement was contingent on securing financing. The court reasoned that while a "standard" penalty might generally be enforceable as it relates to a known commercial custom, in this context, the requirement was insufficient because the precise terms of the penalty were material terms that the parties had failed to negotiate and agree upon, thus rendering that specific obligation too indefinite to enforce.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Agreement to Agree on Essential Terms vs. Enforceability of "Standard" Prepayment Penalty: The court reasoned that while a "standard" penalty might generally be enforceable as it relates to a known commercial custom, in this context, the requirement was insufficient because the precise terms of the penalty were material terms that the parties had failed to negotiate and agree upon, thus rendering that specific obligation too indefinite to enforce.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the federal court proceedings.
Testo completo
()*+,(*--+ #(.,-(*--+
#
#$ # $
"/0 )
' )* 1' *--+ !"# $%&' ( !" !"# $%&' ( ) * )) + (!(, ("# -% $%&.
! " #$#% ! &' '
+%/-+
2$#
$1 !#!%&!#"2%&&- ) * )) + 3+45 ) 6 7"# !" # ( ,8((9(#!#4!( "#!49"2%&&&( 4( ! !, 7( " : ;< = "4( ( ! 9 !#("(%&&' 9(!(:2!"!*+"!4 *#%&&.!>&71
) *(7!#9!#("(%&&'36!-&*.'>713?"4 $/$'5"!7(((61
%1 !$'@9%&&. #4,(7"#44( "(7= 4(""24!!!(9(# !#4!( *9( 4 #(# 4 !#(1 ( @( : #( 4 ! "4( !*,4(( >$ !#"2 %&&' != #( A4!(A;779(B # 1 >%*%&'1&& ( + C$*%C$1&& ;<;77<( + %*%&01&& <2(<# + $$*%CC1&& ( 1 '*C'%1-& (4!( + '*.D$1C& ;< !*,4(( *#9( : $>*>-D 71 .& #(( !*,4(( #<(7 (!+$D*$-$71$&3+'*.D$71C&(+$>*>-D71.&61
>1 !#44(!%07#9%&&. ) 44#= 2!=!(,2!!*+"!!(E(#!4 $@9%&&. (#(22! ##"((4*!"(( 7(4(,(!#7(9(4((9##!, 9(*#!*9(!!(:4(( "(!#!%& !#"2%&&-1
C1 !, ( !#4# %D " %&&. #4, ( (@(# ( !(!#44(159(=9!#("(= 7! ) (( 4 "4( ! 4( "" 2 4 ( = (( 4( #(# 4(# !#!( ! *"2 ! 9!#4,2!(7,"4F((,("", %&&'1(:=*(!#) !*#(29! =4"4(4(""(!(?2!! *+"!44(9#1
(#(#<(# G! /$%.0/%&&.( /$%.D/%&&.1
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
-1 (#(#(",#(<!#:@<1
$#
$1 7"#"( : *(1 '- 1 $ (1 ;1 C 2 ( ! H((=!(((4#9:I(1'- !7#!#4(<##!!(!!-(2 %&&&3 6=((9:7#!#I+"!!$0" $DDC3 61
)"4#(4@<!!I45(#(21
%1 !, /$%.0/%&&.( /$%.D/%&&.(!7(!"E"( ( 4(( ! =( @!= "" ! ( =* @(7 ! @! ( ! =! ! ( "E" E( 3 $%0 $%- !1 $ ( #7# $DC !1 $J 71 ""( ! 7#!#!*<(@! 91 !(1%C41>C>61@(7!5 !@! G $%.0/%&&.1
>1 I45 #(#!#4#!7"(!#"4#4 ! (=I(923(1>-!I44(!7#!#I+ "!3 61
/$%.0/%&&. +C/-+ C1 *2@( ! (< 4( "(( ! 2! 4 *+"! %&&. !#,(1
'1 44(!(1-'(-- (!59!!2! !(# : 9( (( 4( ! 4" ! *+"! ! #!!(#"="!(3(1$D1$ 61
-1 )*(1%$1% !(,2!(449(= 9!#("(!#44"(7,#4 !*((1
.1 9!#("(!(,4(((!$D " %&&' 36 9 (( 4(( ( " : !( ! 91 !9( ( 9< 4 4 !5 %&&01 4 ! " ! >& " %&&- !*(( !#!# !*## 44(1 !4$@9%&&.!#@: (?((??( !(,2!!*+"!(:*!49(2##7! 9(< ! 9 ?(5" 4 "4 (4( ( #=(21 #<( !"! ! 4(( (!( 45 (# 9< ==(4!( ""(!(#9< (!54424#((<3(1$.61
01 9!#("((!#7*457"#"(:1
) *(1 C 9 !#("( "4! *"2 ! 9 (""(
64!(!*(9(#(9!#4!(!I(%J 264!(!*(9(#(9!#4!(!(> C('! J
*(1 ' 4#9( = ( !#!( : 4! "4( ! !9!#("( :9(""(B A747!I(> #$(% 3!#("( ! 9 (6 4 4 ,8( (9(# !#4!(J 7 @(7# 4 I< "" ( 47 ! I( > # > 4 4 ,8( (9(# (9 !#4!( : I,4(!4(4(#(!(#E(!!((78(4(4( !*"%&K4(+(4(!*#(#!4(, !*#(#4#(9!##9("(""7(""A1
D1 (!((=(,(!*(1'"(#(B7 47 !9( E( 4 !#( 4 ! 9 !#("( :*,4(!4(4(#1
/$%.0/%&&. +'/-+ $&1 *45 ) *4!(44!#(4("" 2 4 ( ! ! ! (9(# !#4!( : ;( ! $D*$-$ 71 2 =*!" 7"( "(7 = (,( ! !9( E( (4#(# 9(# ! #<( = ;(( !#7 9 7#(( ", 9#(2 4(# #"= ! (221 +(+ !#!#=*9(!4+#9((4(##"=<L, !#!( 7 4 4(5"(1 #75 : ( #<! : *,4# ! "(7?(!(:*#2(!1
$$1 (4(#!!4(#<!9(E(!#("#5< !*(4#((!1 7(4"7!(( !!4(3(4#((((#61)(,(!((!5*( 42"( 4(4#((!+(42 @< ;; 9#(2 4(# ! " !#<<( ! ( 9 !*( !4( ! (,( 3(4#(( ?(#"(=6 ! 2( 49 <5"(!*(#E(4(#<#3(4#(((##<=6 = !9(#!((=*((""(!(9,4#4( 3(4#(( ;(=61 = 4! !4( ! (,( ( #<"( "4(( 3 $%D %-> 1 !1 '1$ ( E( (#J 9 $>&.$!1C1% $>&'&!1>1%1$ $%D>'-!1>1> $%D $-'!1>1' %0C!1C1%(#7#$61
$%1 (9=**45 (7(#(( !*,4#!"(7=#75 ) !*("#79!#!(7J?((7! (( = (( "#7 *, ("( =*9 !#!( 7=!"((7"(9#(24(##"=!*?(+ !(1(77(=(!*<A!#!(7=(((4 !"(!49!*;(A"( (371D$>'41$'61 4("" :*#9! #!(49!*;(1
"(7!54"(!*#(!(,(! = 4(4(#!9(4E(4!#(1
$>1 ) (( 7 = 4=* *? 4 ! 9 ( ? 9 ! 7!*=(!"E"91
*(<7(=(#(###9!>%*%&'719 !=9!4H((;<!*,4((4=+ !#4(1(4((4#(!=**?4!91
$C1 #= ( !"1 ! ( 9?# ) 7 =* !#!(!M"(7(!4(""!$D*$-$71$& 47,:9"((!2!!*+"!!M,( 4*#%&&.1
/$%.0/%&&. +-/-+
3#$2 #$ # $
'
0/
$1 ! @( ! /$%.0/%&&. ( /$%.D/%&&. "# /$%.0/%&&.1
4 /
%1 #921
' 4
>1 !"(1
C1 9:*("#49 (9!#! !!#(1
'1 (=4#!(<((1 <775 #!( + N O
47"!4#(E(((7#,4(=I:I777#!# !(#42=4<77
/$%.0/%&&.