Offer Revocation by Substituted Communication
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis appeal addressed whether a party’s attempt to revoke an offer through a substituted communication was effective when the original offer specified an acceptance method, where the court reasoned that revocation is effective upon receipt, and sending a document clearly indicating revocation, even if not received by the exact means specified for acceptance, satisfied the requirement of communication, leading to the conclusion that the offer was validly revoked before acceptance occurred.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Offer Revocation by Substituted Communication: This appeal addressed whether a party’s attempt to revoke an offer through a substituted communication was effective when the original offer specified an acceptance method, where the court reasoned that revocation is effective upon receipt, and sending a document clearly indicating revocation, even if not received by the exact means specified for acceptance, satisfied the requirement of communication, leading to the conclusion that the offer was validly revoked before acceptance occurred.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied to rule on the costs of the federal proceedings.
Testo completo
"#$%&"'((# ")*+"'(($
,
- .!- / - /.
&# 0 '(($
#1 2 3 4444444444 !" #$ % %&"'"%"" /55. / 6- .7. . ""' %"""'%()*+,-
! ./012.
5.
16 !"77777777778'1)4*89' :"%:.;"" %;"<&$/)-=1))*8%+&"'"-"' "%'%'6
/6 $'%' '15:'-"1))>%% ,%$::" ?". ,$ @-"+="$"% "%$"-"%"'6
56 # '%"."8 7777777777 ' %"A" "-B C(% -'= =" ;"& = "& "" =" =.'6 %""' ""- #1 6 #(% -" %" - (% % $, -'= , !6 #; =" D%"6E "'F6 7777777777"+122G $" "' % -" % " % " /) -= 1))*8 '"&$" "-"%%%$"-"'% '8 'A,8 &"'%%% "-';"8 %;A6
36 $' "A %$"'A" :"# 8%// -= 1))) /1 :'-" /2226 % :" % A '=" 5 /2228" &B
C$'-" % "' :" % $' + "=""' % '"'A % "" '"& 8 % "-"' % """B % % ;A8 % """&%=="%$6'" "=B -"%$"+$'="6
"'%-"%$''''-'+>2G?%%>2G " @6 ::"-8 A' % % = ""%42G8"&$"''$ ::" AA' % &$" $ % "=""'&$"'F6
46 %"-"" % '% " :" % $ 8 % % 1H /2228 '% '%+'-";'"&=' "' % -" + >2G8 % ' % >2G " 6 -"%$"8 9 ;I#""J":8AA5K422:6 "8 " '' %$ , - % 55KH22 :68 % 5/K*H2:6"$:%-""- %-9'" %( 6
013450/221 .5012.
"A " , % -" % % $" ( % $'8 " & " '"' /2228 "-"%"'8 " '' % H1K)34:6 '6
A" - "-"%"'8 " 55KH22 :6 % 5/K*H2 :6 A" "-"%"'8"H1K)34:68%"-""%'% " :" +9%$"-"%"'%34G%3*G6
H6 ' % 1) /2218 $ %, + $' %A' %$"-"%"'%3*G+ %/)-=1))>6
*6 $"''8 '' !L " #8 % 8 "%11-"/2218%A'%$"-"%"'6
>6 %'"" % /3 <" /2218 $ %' + $' & % %"" " %$"-"%"'8 " % '" <" :6
)6 $':"'/M/221"%"%'""6 " % # 8 &$" -" '' 9 ' '=" &%""%A%' " 42G6,A "&$"AA"%'<+8-%"-"'8H5K/4/:6 ;+ $ % $-" % $AA-" % ' % 'N " +'A%&$"=""-"/2226
126 '-" % 14 = /2218 $ '= + $"-=""'%"<' '%1)/2216 :%8 " '"&$-%A-' $'%8"'' '%'+- %9%$"-"%"':: " % A" ;'"& '% + = % - ""& %$"-"% % /2G6 ' = 9 %$"-"%"' % 338HG8 "::" -" %" + ",8 & $" ;"' 6
116 %'""%1*%'=/2218$ ":'$'&8= %A'%$"-"%"':"9'+3*G8"-"%"8 %"" :"",%"::""8+%".6
1/6 11 <-" /22/8 !L # :"' A:: % "" % #. & % %" < %A'%$"-"%"'%3*G6
013450/221 .3012.
-' %"8 /3 = /22/8 " %$ " % $::"%$ "# %1<"/22/8& '"& "%" 'A' O::+$"'' %' % '8 "" &$ " % P%" '" &$" -" % " /H M /22/ &"' %$ (' % %"8 '" - =%342:6-"6
156 -"'+%'"8$ &"% # %5 /222-O,%$9 " :" $ 8,-& A::'+ " '-""%A# "%,&:"&$'-"<%$;"%" 'A' "A":" '" &$" 9 " "" "' % -" % %"=9"A"=6
136 O%3-=/2258 "=%':"'%"%$' +&%%$"-"%"'+%". '"=6
146 ' O , % "= :'%' % 6 "" "" $"%$",%$"-"%"'="%"" -" % + <"%"" A-" "" 9 " '%"6
1H6 O % / -" /2238 "= :'%' % ' <A%3-=/225 """'A",% "=8": &<A8%$'"-"''"-"%' "=:'%' /*<-"/2238-" "" '+ '%+%'""6-(' "=%' &$"+-%"%'6
1*6 " % 15 " /2238 9 ' &" $%"" % 77777777778'%""8 (;"6
1>6 % H <" /2238 "%"&' &$" " 7777777777 % " %'= /2256 %'' &$" -"" %" 'A'% 8+". 8%%%$ %$.;DA6
1)6 ''A%'+<A6
013450/221 .4012.
/.
18 " A-" $A"" <%""" ?@ '' %":"' ""'8 %,1M/2258 "=%"8 '%4 <A8% '"%-". '"%84 '1H<A ?6164H @6
#"+$"%$'"%1H<A8 "=:'%' /* <-" /223 ? P 152 12H@8 % " A-" % '8 15 :'-"8 %" "" "" A "= % " % "'A + " <A ""8 8 % $%$'"%-9<A6
#%%" ="8 "=:'%'8%O%1 <"/2238:"'&%" """"""" "'":8%L8%":'%'?O161>50/223@6
A "" % &" % """' % "= % "8 " %'' & '" % "= -" O "8-:%'A"%%":'%'8"$$6 4* % " :'%' % H = /222 " A'' % %" % "? @?O16/)30/223@6
/6 $ % "" '- $6 1H/ & "= % ' % '6
:'+K64H616;6/%"A-"$A"" <%"""?@8 "=%"L" "&%" '-+$"4H &""-+" $."-"%"'%1)<"1)4)6# ' <A%%$ , ""'="6
56 ":'%' "A''%%"%"%H= /222? @'-"A1<-"/225L%":"" %=%" ""'A%%"%$ #. 6%$ , :"'A" %" ""-"A<&$51%'=/22/8 'A% "" & ,A "= -"A Q:"<"%"&%'" %"? P1/*3H*8 "%61N1/15HH@6
013450/221 .H012.
36 $" 3 "' 1 %':"" $"-"%"' ' %""" % "' % A"8 '' % A %'8 &" ' %$ " + ' ;("&8 - %$ ":""' A'"8 %$%"%$"%6
&$ "-"%"' " 8 " '" % ;& &$ %"A" '%" " " ' '"" & " " '-"%%"""" % "'%-"? P1/*/))@6 R; % '%" " + <A $' % ' + "%"& %& &"-"'$'" =%-"6 8 %' '%" " '' " %'" & -9 "=9"A%$'? P1/4/H18114 1538113513812414>@6
$"-"%"' %':"" " %""" % "' % A"8 '' % A %'8 &" ' %$ + ' ;("& - %$ ":""' A'"8 %$ %" %$ "%6 " + ' $- % %" + % " % $ "-"%"' & " L " "' % A" '' %A%'?"3 @6
$" "'%A""%"""( '-""=% "=""' % A" % ' $= % ;' % -" '&""=' - "%'" ?:6 ;":: 121* % "" $"-"%"'$" @6
$'%"+$""-"%+32G"6 "- &%6#$""-"%+42G8"-(%"." "-"%"'"HH/05G",?"/>61 @6 9 %$"/>61=" 8% '"=8"-"%"'%32G" -%"+%".6
46 "%,&$ " % "''% -" %' 42G6 $ ,8 $" '%" " '="6 $ ' &$" " = % -" + 122G % " :" % :.;"" % ;"6 -;8 '%"."8 " " -" % % %$ "-"' % ' 'A, %;A6'%A " %$"'A" :" # &$" " O '"'A' % "" '"& %"-"' %"""6# "'%-"
013450/221 .*012.
'' '-' + >2G6 "8 -" % %"::' '"" ( =-' '%" & :" -A6 " + " L " "' % -" % "% '+""" ;("&6
&" $%""%77777777776 "." % % % Q %'" " & % :" '" + %'= /2256 %'"" ""A" %::%/3<"/2211*%'=/2216
H6 +9"&""%$"+' "'% A"%6
'":8%A'%$"-"%"'%"O%'"'=%$ "%-6 ::8 "&$"-"% " =" 9S $"-"' &$ "= % % "8 , 9'" '- % % '% " %$ "" '&""=' % ;' % -"8 + " &$" " =" $" $'" "-"%?"/>6/ @6 "%",AA'':"% ", & %9 - ;( ;'"& " ;"::' 9 "= " ,8 %"::' %A' %$"-"%"'6#" O%'"'- '""8"-"% % '- '' % "" % - 9""-""?#/222 6>38"%' 1=N#/222 651H"%'1@6
%'"-;( ;'"&&$' "="" + '8 " -" % = "%"" :" %" ( ?# /222 6 52> "%' 5@6 # %'" - &%"" #'' S?"/461 @6 " % ' + $'-" % " "9 % =; %$"-"' + %%'" $'-"%$"-"%"'?#/222 6515"%' /@6
*6 %'"" ""A"8 $ $ :%' A" "-"%"' % H1K)34 :6 '6 8 &$" -" ;' 1))* " % H5K/4/ :6 O &$" '" " "' % -" % " :" % " % -= 1))* %'<+6 " %, & " '"' /222 %-" O "' "" % :; % H4K222:6+*2K222:6 6
013450/221 .>012.
$ '%' + - 8 = "" ' #. (' $'="-%H3K>:6 "= %'&" %;"%$' %6
$ -%55KH22:6+"%A"-"-"%"'8 :% & AA -" %$" (' ;I #! T P 8 % 5/K*H2 :6 " $ :% -" "- $A" % -9 '" % ( 6 $ "" 'A '%'+-8" ""%'"""'% $ ## 1))> ; -" % % %" "%" :", ' + % R; " ' '""-8 " 45K45/:6 32; "6(%-"'8 <" %% "=:'%'%318); "8"$:%' "%=%4HK2*3:66 %%A='-'+>2G %$ '%" '" % /2G8 $ :"9' " %$"-"% + 54K>>*:6
>6 " %$"-"% $ ":8 &$" % "%'" :" &$ -" "-"% S" ,A A''"":'"6
%'"-&$' '"A'"+'8 <" % % "=""' % ':' + % " % =9""&N"""&8% "-% $" + '8 $' $ " %$"-"' "- % " $"-"' & $ "= % % " ?# /2228 6 >3 "%'/N 1))1 655/"%'5N 1)>) 655/"%' 5=@6 ::8 P ':,% "1))3+$&O" %"? ##@8 ="'%96
P :" '"' &$" :" " % :" & "%'8&";%" 'O%$ "% -9 9""" 'A8 %'-A' % ''" + % -" " " % "' % -" :" +OAA'8&$%"-A''= " " " '-' ?# /222 6 >38 "%' /=N # 1))) 61>48"%'5=N#1))) 6448"%'5=8#1))> 61>18 "%'5@6';'8"-"%%% '%+'%" %"""&6 :"'%"8 %: "A% %- %' A=/4G?#/222 6
013450/221 .)012.
5/18"%'4=@6 $ ,8"$==9""& ## & $ " - '"= ( ; % "-"'" ' '""-%% %""45K1)H:6? ##1))> 18 12.34B /@8 & $ %" - %' ;=%%"%318)2;?#1)))841@8&$%'%"/2G:"% " % % A= % %$ ,8 " /2G :" % " %""" ;("&8="-%$"-"%%53K>23:6
% "%A"%"""O '"B
H3K>U53$>23 H3K>9122V3HG
% =" O $ A" + /4G '%" '- & "%'-A' +%-"='8%A' %$"-"%"' = " ":'" + 42G6 &" % -" $" <":""%"9%/4G8&"99"%" P 8 %,O"""'-6
P%:"%"%+&%%$"-"%"'+ %". ""%$"/>61=" 6
#$" %-" =" AA-" % ' % '8 " " " ""= % %' %% ,%$ -"+'-""%%"6
013450/221 .12012.
/.5 .!- / - /.
9: ; < 69 #)' /
:
16 S"6
:
/6 <6
56 "& '%A"6
36 : " % &K - : ' O % %'" % 52 < %, ":"" " %' %' "= :'%' % 8 #;W"I;:&" H8 H223 8 " 9 "6 %'" O A'6 '" %" B @ "%"& 9 & %'"" %'" =" " % %'""&'N=@9 &":"" -"%% %'""N@ "A% '6#"'" " " '' ''' @ =@ @ ".%8 "=:'%'% ",&K" %-%'"-=6'"%"( % -8 &" <"8 "" & %'"" &' K- % &''9 '%"'?615/812H12>@6
A::",B '"%B !"." X "Y
":% 'O":"'9 """&K+K::":'%' %" A::
013450/221