Negligence in Motor Vehicle Collision Upheld
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party sought to recover damages for injuries sustained in a motor vehicle accident, claiming the other driver failed to maintain a proper lookout and control, leading to the collision. The court determined that the evidence, including photographs and skid mark analysis, sufficiently supported the jury's finding of negligence on the part of the defendant driver, whose inattention and excessive speed were deemed the proximate cause of the crash, thus affirming the judgment in favor of the injured party.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Negligence in Motor Vehicle Collision Upheld: The court determined that the evidence, including photographs and skid mark analysis, sufficiently supported the jury's finding of negligence on the part of the defendant driver, whose inattention and excessive speed were deemed the proximate cause of the crash, thus affirming the judgment in favor of the injured party.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive to order the appellant to pay the costs of the appeal.
Testo completo
!"!#$$% &!'#$$&
( )(* *+* (* +)
,-. "
#& / #$$&
!"#$"%%% !!" &$"'"!( )* %+
"!
( (( (((& (( ( %"%$ & (),"""!-.//0
601-06
* 0)
-7 $ % -8.4 "!#%%" +%"$ "!% 9 "7 "%"!$"%"!$ !: %"%%&! &%" ;%6 !: ( < "! %" !=% " !=%7
07 4>%"0//2!+&$"%"!!?"$9=!@#"#%"! =" !"$ ! &!!%:! ! "! #$,%7 &!$ "$ ? >!9!@! $%& A ! %%%+ !9+""B$"$%!!?""!#%"": >!7
27 &!$! !%"!#%0->%"0//2" !%#%"!%"" !: ! "!,%! !"%+7! !"2$C!0//2 !)D$%@$$! $%@"%!#%@% "6"!"%+ " %%+$ + "%" %#%" "!%"" & "! ,E! 7
47 !!$! !"9( .#!%0//4+% $ %@"% !#%@% "6"!"%+ " "%$ !%" ! !#% C %!!%" #! C! $!%! @,7 =%" !"%+!!#%08>#%!0//4+%%$#%!%! @" !#% # $C, &%#!% ! ,F%@%+ % ",% $C"" 46 5 " 56 . %@ =%" %6!%%!7 !! $&!#%$"%"%%"!7 ! !$%$ "!#% !" ,!@ " &$#%"! %"%#+ ,$#"7
57 &!$$"$"!%"$ !!!,"@ )D+% !!%" !!?""!#%02#!%0//40.#!%0//47!#$+ "%" 9 !: "" +% G%" "!%"" !: H,% , F! " !$$9%=%"!"%3#!%0//47
.7 "! ) $% @$$! )D "! $"C% !"%=%" " -2 I" 0//4 G "! + &!$ #%" "!#%! %"%+ ,$#"% !"!,!@!7 !!%" !!?" "!#% : -8 I" 0//47 ! !" $% %"!$%%!!$9( 02 "C!0//4$%"!%""!#$ !%"!9+"G"! :E""%$ %% %% +& $ !%7 "%" $"%" "!%"" ,E ! ;$%<"!D F,%"!7
37 ( =%$G !"%!!@7
1234310//5 621-06 J7 ! !!%! -/ >#%! 0//5 9 ( $% "!%"" !:# + "%"==!! !%""9+9&$ @,%!!%"#! &% " " C! @, %" G "?" #!"%@ "!C#%%%7 F "K" !#+$%% &G%$"$ "!C $%! # + "!"% " ="%@ !+$7 ( ! ) &!$ !$" "" F! "! "6"!"%+#=!" "$ !%#"#!%"#%! ! F,@7
87 ! ! ! !" &G !"% -J >#%! 0//57 !:# +&% &F &$$" 9 &: +% % ! + &%" %" %+$&"!"%!L%&"!"!"%%!"7!"!% F#!%CC", F,@%+G %+"=%"+ "%" &%" ! %!6?""&%"9&%C7%==$!"G !"%+$ &" "!$ $% %@%=%"%# F": "! " !#G7 %! " =" $"" & C%%"$ !#% ! "!"" # &% %C%%"$ !"%+" :" "" C%%"%+!&G !"%7&G !"!#$+&%$"$% %C !"C%&C"%! C!"%==%" !" "%"7 + "%" C% ! &%" %"!% !#% % @!$9 $C M)!B!#,$$""%+ "%==%" ! !+&$"$>%""#%"%&"!"% !L% " "" & "% $!$C! "!C !$"$ ! ""$""#!%CC" &!%@% F,@%++"%+7( &G !"&% !" !""!C$%!""!"% #" ?"! !"% %"$ "! !%"" # &$#$" %"6"$@!%%!6 & !:!%!7$+ "" + "1% $"$ ""%" 4 >%" 0//4 ! $+ &$#$"%"7(&@%""!C F,%+"" !%! &$#"%&$"" F,%"!&G !"$!$+&%!% !!!!"!"!!"%%"$"!#&$#$" %"B % " ! $ + &%" !#" "!: !"%" "$@!% %! % &$"%" !%% "! 9 "!'! "!C F,%+7 $% ! N%=N % % C%" %==%% &G%@! &!$+&! !"%#%"$ !=%++&%"&$"" F,%+ O !'" "!#! " % % $"%" % %C =!! !"%7
-/7 ! !!%!2 =$#!%!0//5( %=!$&!$+&$#"% %""% &C%@%" 9 !$G%! +"% ! C%%"$ " +& %"&"!%"" !""%&!#=="%$%"7
1234310//5 641-06 --7 !$"$ !%+( )* &!$=%"#%!9 ( +&""%"&!"$>9%! !"&G !"%! "%%"$$% !=%! !"C!#"%7
-07 % 2- ! 0//5 &!$ !:# + &G !" &" !$!"!"!"%%"$"!"!C F,%+" "" + &%" %" %" "$@!% %!7 !%" G G !"%#$,%%"$7
-27 &!$ $"$C!#"%"2>%0//5"#!$%! ! !"&G !"%#$,%+%"9%==$!#%""! #$,% % %+$ !% "! . " -2 M1,7 %% +& ! !" ! J #!% 0//5 + "!C +& !$" " "" 9 =%" "%C # %"7 G %+$ + % & %+!#&G !"&"& !" !+&"!!%#$9C%" &F" !"%+" !% %" !% ! " &"! !" !% #% !$,% @ =!P%7 9 ( =%! !$! 9 G !"% F,%"!%+ %% +&9 "!6 G !"% !@%+ # ! & "!"! !% +% !!%" %!9"!"%7
-47 ! $%% J >% 0//5 ( !$=$!" G % ! "%$+"!C+%C%""" 9&%" %G%#""!%#7&%"4>%"0//2%%$ %$ ==" !: !# %" 4 >%" 0//47 " G "!C F,%+ % " !"% %"$ $+" # &$#$" %" !%! #" ?"! +%=%$ "" @!#%"$ F7 $+( $%$!"""!=%G !""%# 2=$#!%!0//5%!7
-57 !&%"!$%%!"%!&!$=!$ %"%J>%"0//5 ! !," 9 ( &#%! !% " !!+ +& #%" =!$!" $!"&G !"%"$%"$&"!"!7 ! ! !:# +& G !"% F,%"!%+ " %% C !$"!C F,%+7
-.7 !$%%0/>%"0//5( !>"$& %"%&!$"%= + !"% %"$ $+" "! "!C F,%+ " " &%" &" $"C%7 ( ! ==" + &%" C% ! &!$"@!#%"$F9%%""$@!%%=$!%!!% ! +%!%"#%!&%=$"!%"& !%"%"!C F,%+7 %@"% !$% !"%= 9 &""%" F,%+ &" %% & "%%"$!"+%#"%@"%"9"$@!%"%7
1234310//5 651-06 -37 &!$%"!>""!!0/"C!0//5=%"#%!+&"9"!"+ ( %=%9 !""%2=$#!%!0//5!?+&G !" &" !$!"!C F,%+7"%"!+&G !"% &" $!$ &C & "!"! +% G %+ $=" %"%!#$ !!7!! "!$% """$""G !"%"!$=:!! !"!+%"% +& # G !"% " $%! # ! & %"! !:" $"$ %"# F,%"!%+7
-J7 !$ -- #C! 0//5 ( "" !%" + &G !"%&"$!$%:! !" !"%%:!!:#+&G !" !"%"!%!#%% "+&%""F N %N "?"! !":!+!!"& !$"$"C %%+ "F %+04930,!7 &"+02 "C!0//4%" & !: &%" + $% " =%" $"" &%% " $ !% =="%+%"%"" 9"C%%+"F %+7(! "%+ "" + "1% $"$ ""%" !: &%" %"4>%"0//47 "G"!C F,%+ ! 9 %" !"% %"$ $+" &@%" & %" !#" "$@!% @!#%"$ FB "! !%" ! ",$! "%+ &" %%+$!$& $"$!"@"%&F %"% ,! &@@!#"% F,@%+7 ( %:! + &G !"% %" #%! !'"! % #! !C" " " !>" !!7
-87 ! !$ %+ 3 $C! 0//5 !!" !%"$ % ! " + !%! $% "$ 9 ! ! $% &G#%"C% $%@"% %%%+!9 + " "7 "%" +& !% %==%"$ "%:! !$,% " &G !% @ =!P% & %%"%" $!%! :""$""&""+&&" &"! %"%=7
0/7 #%"$ 9 $"!%! ( ! !!%! 2 >#%! 0//. %" %"%7
0-7 (!$"$@!$9>@!7
1234310//5 6.1-06 * +)
-7 %@#%!Q!@%"%>%%%!;<$"$%=%$"%"%"$: -!I"0//2 !%C"!% $5>@ " !$%""#%6 !$%"5 $""-.>@!;!"7-"7 !"5. <7
(%"9Q"%Q$"%-.>@! ! !%C=$$! 03>#%!0//4; )-2/-/.<! %@#% "$-2=$#!%! % %"%"!%"%!!@" !""" !%C"! % %$@! ! 9 "!% >@ "%"%! Q""" Q$"%#G>@!7
07 =!$" 9 &!"7 5. 7 - "7 ,7 5 !%C " !%'"%"%+"""% !$#9Q!"75. %=$$!! !"%@$$!!%"!%."C! 0/// ; < +% " !"%# 9 % =$$! ! Q!6%" 0/!-8J-; <7
( $" !>@!Q :"%%$"C%7
27 " "!$ #%@! -! >#%! 0//2 "!'" %=%"% C! % %"% $@ % ! %7 (! "$!% %"#%!+!%"& %+%"?"!"!,$9%:! !%% +!:@ %C"#%@!"O =%">!%%+"$"!%"" !%"; )-2/02/%7-7-B 225%7-70B )-084%7-70B )-034.3%7--0.-2. %74C"!$=$!<7!:@ !$!+"9& %+" !$!#:>!"!$#%@!; )--382%7.C--02./ %74B -88JR23 72-.%72C<7 Q %+ Q :7
47 (&!"75.7- $%%! %"%">""9!! $% 2/ >! ;!"7 ./ 7 - < !: "!%C ! " %% &!$ ;;!"7 5J 7 - <7 "%:! &!6 %"""=%$!@"%9&!"7./ $%!!""!% % ! $%%! %"% !""! !""%&! ;!"7 -/. <7
"!>"$" "%"=! !!%"!!"!#C7
57 %"%@ !" ! !%" !!" 9 !""% &! "$!%!"2!0//5!%&%"!#4>%"0//27
1234310//5 631-06 .7 G"!&!"7.7- %%&% "!" !""% &! " $ &%" !=% &%" !=%"% !=%7! C%%"$&!!6%" &$" !%% 9""$+@C+%"!#" ! !"%"$"!; )--8223%7---J0J8%7-C "!$=$!<"$+"#&$#$"!$; )-054.-%75" !$=$!<7
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
C<!+&$""%= !$G%"""@@!#$%:!@$$! !'" $"%#" 9 %" #%! &!6%" &! !""% % &%" "%" "! ;" $+"< @ %" !+ !%! !$" G%#" $"!@:! 9 &%"7 "!+&$"""$&%"$!$"%%%!9%+% G%"%" %$%"" #" &%" ;"" + "< 9 % +% !%" !# "K" "! ? &%" ! %" & $# " !%%! ;"" + %< ;=7 -880 -40 7 35 %7 4CB (,H%E!%, =#!%,!@!," 7 4.8 2 " 4B 1 (%@","@#SM,T!-88/ 750BU6 ( % V!C%" # %,"! !E" % ! (E%#!%,!@ "%$%%3-1-88/ 7-/82<7 "!!%%@" + "" + % # " &" !$"C% &!!6%" %" !! 9 ,!@"!%""&$""%= !$G%""!O%$"$$ @@!#$ !&%"7
1234310//5 6J1-06 <"%:!$%!,%!#% !%""F W %X ;(,!"!H,% ,6%>!F< !#&$=%%"="%!@%+ &G%" & ! !" %"$ "! %" !:@ ?"! ! !+& " "!"% " %@"%+$ " + &!$ !$" "C %%+"F %+; %""+G"?"%==#!"%@"!C "!"% " $%! $ ="%@C%%"$ ! "!C #%% %!!%"C%%"$ C%%"$ $"% $ !% %=%"% !":! "7<7 =" " + $%" %" %" ?"! %:! !$%C""!%C$9""%"9"$B6%%" !'"!#@!$ #!%C !$ $!"$+&%"; )--8 22J%70--32./%74C<7
37 %"$"$+"%& !:!!%%!,"&G $!% #%=%"%$!$$"%" ! !9"!'!=="@!%+%&" !%"!#!$"" !%"=P@$$!=#!%$ ! " %!" ; ) -05 4.- %7 5 " !$=$!<7 "=% !$&""%"9"$ ,F%+ !C:%"$$+" @:! ! &!!6%" !$ % %"% %@%:! " @!# +% !%" ,C%"" &G $!%$%; )--J08-%72--32.5C%75CC " !$=$!B )( &!6%" C%@"%! % Y (,H%E!%,#!H"@!,"728<7
! "!C &!! F,%+ $"%= 9 %" & !$%"% %"$ $+" = ! !%":! %==$!" + &!$ $"$ #%"%&"!"%"F W %X9!#% & "!"% @ ;( -885 Z 02 7 .3 %7 0< & "!"% !%6$!$C!7 ==" !+ &G%" & " "!"% "F W % X " $"C% % =" % &%" " @!#%"$ F G%! !":! $+" % %"$ =" ! !%":! $$!$ G ) --3 2.. %7 . " 2J0 %7 4C +&% %" $%%= #%! % "!C " " ""%" &!$ " "K" "! "%+ F,%+ ; ) --3 2.3 %7 . !%! !@! ,B -888Z24- 74/J%72C<7!#,"!&G !":! $+" % %"$ %" =%! ! %" @!#%"$ F ! C !%":! $$!$ G ) --5 -4/ %7 .1 " 4/8%751; 0//0Z43/ 752-%74<7
(% $% !"" $%=%+" "C %%+ %" & "!"% "F W %X 9 !#% & "!"% @ & "!"% !L%6$!$C! C% +& !"% $"C% " ""=%!$@$ !! !"G !C:&!! F,%+ "!%":!$$!$G )--5-4/%7.1"4/8%751" G$$!$G )--32..%7."2J0%74C+%
1234310//5 681-06 %#" =! & !$%"% %"$ $+" ; ) -02 88 %7 0B 0//0Z43/ 7520%74-885 7--5,7.<7
J7 ) ! $+"G" !%!%"9 !""% !:@+=! !# !"%"9 !"%+%%#+ !%!%"; ) 03"C!0//52J81/4B 0///Z2.2 7 4. %7 0 " !$=$!< "! " %$!"% &% &" %C ! !%% %+%%"%! &$"C%! ! C & !$%"% !# $"" =%" +% @!$ #!%C !$ $!" !! 9 !$%"$ ; ) --3 0.4 %7 2C " !$=$!<7 !# % !%"% % %"$ "! %" ?"! !"$ ! !# ="! $"!@! 9 &%"7 " ! % +"%&G%@!&!!6%" !#$@"%#+&""%"9 "$C%" + !!$"!$#" !=%""$7 "$%%= %"#%!%%"&""%"9"$ >" !K"%#"%%?"!%$!$F"% !;!!?" 7 2/ #C! 0//4 0001/4 7 -4 "C! 0//4 ..1/4 " 7 4 "C!0//4-581/4<7
87 (&%"%$>!% !!"%#9%""F N %N "& %+!:!+&,!%!#%@%!!"& !$"$ $%04930,!"C%%+"F %+&""!"%7
>! ? &%" !!" $"$ G%$ 9 ! @! $% &G O $% $ %@"% N %N " "$+ "%" %@%"!9+""7!$" =%,"%! ! !%:!""% !:"!"%&$$!"% !%6!#% $"C% 4 >%" 0//2 + !!" %@%" $ ,$ % #!"%@ $ #%"7 !$"%" "!C%%$%"$+ "%"#%""!: ! !:&%"7
!!" $"$ %#% ! %" ! %#! $% ! !#%@% "6"!"%+ !%""B C$$=%%$&"!%"" ,F%",$! % & "!"&%=%"!"%!"%"$![7 & !#% !"%+$08 >#%!0//4& "!$$%%&"!%!@"!#%" % ",% $C"" 46 5 " 56 . %@ =%" %6 !%%!7 &"! !" "C!0//4+ ! !%:!=% ! ) %@ !$ &%% " $ !% ,E !!"7"$!%!"%!:#+ "%"==!! !%"" >! " %" 9 + &$ @, %!!%" #! &% " " C! @, "G"?"#!"%@"!C#%%% %%"% =! %# C! $!%! @,7 % !#+ ,E
1234310//5 6-/1-06 &%% &G%$"$ #%! &@%""% "!C $%! # +"!"%"="%@"!:!+$7
! !"&G !"%!=%"$""+ !" &!$ ==!" %$%"" !#%6C!,%@% "% #!"%@% " C!,%@% @, # + =! C! $!%! @,7 "% $@" + ! !$ "%"!!"%%"9 %!!#%6$ ,$ %+"C!,%@%@,"!C#$%!" "!"%7(&G !"%&F &$$"9&:+% %=%! ! + &%" %" %+$ & "!"% !L% & "! "!"% %!" % ! "! % F #!%CC" , F,@%+ G %+" =%" + "%" &%" ! %! 6? "" &%" 9 &%C7 (&@%" &$"" G%6$ !%= !$"$ ! !!" ! $!$ #%! !! ! % !" " !"% %"$ # &$#$" %" : ! +&% &" F,%"!7
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
!!O+"%"% !>@!!%"G !""% 69 2 ! 0//5 " #%! % =="% +% C%"" ,E &!$ !!"%" $%=%+" "C %%+ "!"% !#% "F N %N "%"" ""%" 9 "$ %! %$ " " + !%@" F,%"!%+ =" """ $=" !%C $ %:! +&% " $%! !$! 9 %#"%@"% $"%!7
1234310//5 6--1-06 ! $+ !#F$ 9 &%"%$ =% +& !: 9 %"!"% $"%!"" !:! %%+ ! % \#! & G !"% !6 F,%"!%+ # ! $,$"&%"! !:"7&G !"#! !%@"% !$%!"! "!C %! % G6% "!#" ! !" %"$ "! # &%" % !! ! %"$ "!#%7 % =%" &%"%$ !! #$%%7
-/7 #&%%"%@!!"!%"9%%"$9"%"!$ + !%C=%G9-&///=!7
]]]
1234310//5 6-01-06 +)0 )(* *+* (* +)
12343-- 5 633 3 78 '&# + 9
43-
-7 $!!!!#C7
43
07 Q"7
27 $%%( 0/>%"0//57
47 #% 9 &%"%$ ! %"!"% $"%! %$!""#$%%7
57 &%"%$ 9 F! 9 !!" -/// =!7 9 "%"! !"%% "%9=!%"$ 77
.7 =! !"% +Q #" =!! !! "! !$" !!?" $% 2/ >! : "%=%"% ! % !$ !$ !%C =$$! ! (,H%E!,=+% . .//4 "!% G %!7 $% " ?"! !@$7 $%! %"Y < %%+! G""+$%%!!"$%!C"%!%" $%% ""+$B C< G ! ! + "%= % "% #%! ! "" "! $%%B < !"! %@"! ! !$""7 (% $%! "%" "!% $$" $$!$ ""! < C< " < %6 !%C=$$!! !! "!!"%:!!!!+Q% #!$!!%!!#C7$%!!!"%!!F !# +% !" >%" %% + $%% ""+$ " Q# +$"$G $%$!!";!"7-20-/."-/J<7 @!==%! !$%"Y ^% %
%=! !$"!!?"""%=%$G !"%%%+Q9Q==%=$$! "$ C%+ !@!==
1234310//5