Platform Liability for Copyright Infringement Despite Notice-and-Takedown System
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns whether an entity can be held liable for copyright infringement based on vicarious liability for content uploaded by third parties to its platform, despite implementing a notice-and-takedown system, when the entity was aware of infringing activity but allegedly failed to take reasonable steps to stop it. The court reasoned that while a notice-and-takedown procedure provides a safe harbor, actual knowledge of specific infringing material and the failure to expeditiously remove or disable access to it, or a direct financial interest in the infringement coupled with a right and ability to police the infringing material, can negate that safe harbor and support a finding of secondary liability.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Platform Liability for Copyright Infringement Despite Notice-and-Takedown System: The court reasoned that while a notice-and-takedown procedure provides a safe harbor, actual knowledge of specific infringing material and the failure to expeditiously remove or disable access to it, or a direct financial interest in the infringement coupled with a right and ability to police the infringing material, can negate that safe harbor and support a finding of secondary liability.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied because the appellant must bear the costs of the proceedings.
Testo completo
!"#$"!"%%& '!()%!"%%#
'
* '+ * ', * ,+
-. / 0 -( 1 "%%#
* ! ! "! # $% #! &'' # ( ) *#!++
2222222222 ,-!- , * ./# 0 1 ! 2 - ! #
#!
3* ,+ * "! # $% , * ! -
3
+ 54: +
4+'
(' *# ;<<<<<<<<<< ! - 3 ! ! #= %!# #! ! ,#> # ! # ,#> # ! #! ,#> # # # >-- 1+ ! 58 (:7( ,$ # %-- #,% 1 ? +,$ 1+ !@'
5' (: A 5889 A#! = %!# 1- = ,! ,#!+ !! 2 !# 1 B # !'
1- C, 2- 2! # 1+ ! , (D A ! 5889 21 A# ! = %!# !2 ! A # >$ !
21 E ! ! - !! ,# , $ ># # #!
,! !# 1 B ' !! # -! ! ,, # ! # # F >>#! =2 G' 1% ! 1 F >C , # ! G'
# 2- 2 > E ! -!- !-# 1-E-!'
H' - # 57 ,!= 5889 1+ ! >#- 1- 2 ,#E ! I! , B% 1% ! , 1 ! 1!' 9 # ,! %-- # ! # ? +,$ @'
9' + ! 1- #! > ! #,,# ! # 3 !! - # ,! E! (5 ! (7 #!#= 5889'
6' !! 55 #!#= 5889 - 3 1+ ! #! <<<<<<<<<< ,- - J F # ,! ! + I 1 ,! 2 ! >/# !2 = %!# 1 -- 1I! -,! #- 1 ! --2 = = >- # ! E #!! # E##! ! E #! %!#- "! ,#==! =#! 3 -B !# 1 B !' 1= !#! ! !! !- ,# #!!
- # !", ! #,!B B# 2 1= !#! , - ! # >E# ! ,! ,#!- ! ?#! #K 2 ##L@ A , 2 #! # ,! - # #! #>> ?1-@ 3 - # - 3 ! ! # #E! , E#! #,% G'
D' - # #,,# ! # (6 #E= 5889 1+ ! #> - - #' E- =! 2 # ! # 1 >! C!- F C!# G 1-! ! , , 1!' 9 # >-- D #!#= 5888 ,! %-- # ! # ? @ ! 21 1" E ! , >! C!- 1!' : ' 5 1## 1+ ! 58 -= (:75 ? @'
4567545889 + H4: +
M' 1+ !A!! # #! !! - # #,,# ! # , ! C,- - 58 -= 5889' #! 3 2 = - 2 1 # ! , 3 B% ! 1-E-! (: A 5889 !
,!! 2 # # ! ' 1,, # # #! !
#!! 2 -,! # = >- # ! 1- ! = >! C!- 2 # #- -B !# 1 B ! 21 !
$ # #- # - 2 1>>! # ! E 21 >! -B! % > ! > 1 # ! ' , > ! 21 1% ! 1 ! E !- ,#! E !2 >> ! # , 3 C 1,, ! # 1!' : ' 5 '
7' -# -,# 59 -= 5889 1+ ! ! ,# ! # # -! 21 1-! ! , #!!- 2 1!! ! #,# F ! -!- #%= # ! E##! ! 21 > ! = ,! ! - # --- 3 1!' : ' 5 ' #!># , ! , # ! # - - >! C!- '
:' ## (H AE 5886 #! > - = - ,, 1- ! ,! ! - M >-E 5886 ,# -! ' 1- - ! ,##%- (M >-E 5886'
(8' ! C,- - (D >-E 5886 1- !A!! # #! - # 1+ ! #,,# ! #' #! 3 21 # ! ! 2 ! # ! , B% ! 1 ! (: A 5889 #! -!- E ! '
#! ! 2 #! E - # , ! !#! # ! # - ,# ! 1C ! 1 ! 1!' : ' 5 ' F >C , # ! G 2 ,#E#2- - # 3 # !# 1 B # ! >>! I! # -- # # C!- # ! -E-! 3 ! C! #, B ,! = 1I! #!!- $ #=A! E ! 2 ,-! ! ,#!'
((' ; ! - 2 ,! ! ; (6 5886 E # ! #- 1+ ! ! ! # # # - !
7 5886 -,-!! 2 # ! # , B% ! ! 1!' :
' 5 #! , - -' $E 2 1 ! # 1 F >C , G ,,N! ,! # F -! # ,#! # >#- ,-,,#- 2 2#2 #E! !N - # 1! 21 - !
-!- ,!=- 1C!- G'
4567545889 + 94: +
,+'
(' # %E# 1#% ! # A ?@ -!- # > - ! ! !- $ ( #O! 588H = !# # ? +,$ =@ #,#- 6 A% #! ,- ! ! E +,- ! 6 ,,-! ! (D A% ?!' ( !' ! 6D @'
; ! 3 1! # 1-! # (D A% , = >-- 5M AE 5889 ? . (H8 (8D@ # %E# #,!- (H >-E ,# ! # ! !# %! ,!!! = !# # -% 3 !# A% ! ! 1!!! 1-! # #EC A% '
; #,-! ,# A% 1,$ ! -!= '
5' 1!' ( # >-- 1+ ! 58 (:7( ? +,$ @ ,# 2 ,# ! # # >-- D #!#= 5888 ,! %-- # ! # ? @ 1,, 2! 3 1+ ! 3 # 2 # 1" -#% C,-!'
1!' (8D ' ( C $ ,B -#%! # 3 1!' D8 ,-E# ! 2 - # ! !# # ,# - # #,,# ! # ,#!! ,!! # 1' - # - -! # ! # > C- , # ! ,# ! # ,-! E # ! ,= ' 1! , , , ,! = PI! ,##%- ?!' (D ' ( , $ ,B @' 2 P% ! , - , ! ! >## ! - # 2 ! ># #= %!# ? . (:79 ,,' 558+55(@'
# ! >-- - # # 3 # # ! # # #! > ! # 3 8B88 ? . (8H (6M #!' (6:Q ' ; !- # ! !! > (:79 ,' 77:@' ! #,!- 2! $ 2! $ ! 2! $ # ! , I! #,!- C ># ?# ## ,' (D8Q B' (9 -= (:::Q ' : -= (::M #> - , . (9 AE (::: ! -- ; (::: ,' ((:@'
P,$ - # #,,# ! # -!- # 2- 3 1+ (D #E= 5889 , !R!' 1! # 58 -= 5889 !! $ ! $ # E= ? S 4567545889@'
2 # 1- - # "! #- 3 # (M #E= 5889 3 8B88 ! E- 3 -B- (M >-E 3 59B88 #! 2 # E#"- %>> = - (D >-E 5886 ! E= ? S 4H6H45886@'
4567545889 + 64: +
$! 1- -!- ,,- , ## = - (9 AE 5886 ! - M >-E -!- ,! ,# -! ' ; # ! - -!- ,##%- (M >-E 5886' ; # # ,, C,- - (D >-E 86 #! = ,E - ,! ' #! , C!# 1%!! # ! # # ,-!- # #' #!># # # ,$ 1- ! ,, 1 , # 1I!'
= - 5 5886 ##- A#! # 4H6H45886 ! 4567545889 # S 45675 E #C !-'
H' ! ! % 2! # E# ,! !# 1 B #! #>> #! ! 3 ! # ,! I! 2 > - - # - 3 !'
! 1!' 9 ! -,!- ! !#! !! ! #%= # ! E##! ,#!- #, B , C!- C!# 2 #,#! !- ,B" 2 ! # ,"B 2 # 2 !N #!'
;# P!' D ' 5 # >-- ,! P - # #,# 2 #! == C #-2 P !' C ! 1!' : ' 5 ?! E % , ( AE (::7@ - !- , P!# !- C-! E E! !! --%! # #,-! ,# !! 2P # ! , >!! ,!= 3 # 3 ,B-#$ -%--! > - # #,# E! #! ! ! CB! E #!
- 3 ! I #! , - , >! C!- !$ C!# J ' >!Q =' -=#N!! P! ! #Q ' -B - 2Q ' -B Q ' -#%! # Q >' -B !#Q %' - # %!Q B' - # !",'
#! # - # - 3 ! !! ,# ! # -%! ,# =! P!!- >E P- % -!! ! ! # 2 # ! >-- #,$ ! ! P !' + ! # E!+ 2 2 # ! ! # ,- !- E ! , , I! #E! , P+ ? .
55 >-E 5885 # 57M488 T! # ' 5 Q . (5H 99 E # ' 5=Q * 588( S 9H6 ,' HHH E # ' 5@'
4567545889 + D4: +
= >-- #> - -! PC % P >! C!- # # ! # # ! C ,!! # ? . (5: 9DD@' PC,! # !$ FC!# G C!- !#! ! # ! # #! !! E #! # P ! # E! I! - -'
,! 3 ->! PC ! P C!- + # ! P -E-!
3 ! C! #, B ,! = PI! #!!- $ #=A! E ! 2 ,-! ! ,#! + >O!+ # , >! -B! - # #,# --- 3 1!' : ' 5 !#= #!!- #! 3 B% P+ '
PC ! P - # #,# - 3 ! # ! I! - !# #U >! #%= C!- #># E P,, ! # ?,# , $ ># @ # ! > - # -!! ",!R - # #,# --- 3 1!' : ' 5 !' 3 B ' I $ PC % P >! #%= C!- P! , , #2 P- > !
-!! # ,, ,# , $ ># ,$ E# #, %! E #! ? E! P"! #B! -,/! , $ !'@ 3 # 2 %! P ! 2 # !! # #, ,! = , -E- 2 # ,# ! E ,B" ##% 2 ! -, 2 ! #! N! - ,# ! E' #! # C!- ,,# >>! -E-! %--! 2 - # ' !
#!! # P B%! ,# ! # #, 2 ! >-2!
! 3 ,#E#2 - # #,# # #!! # - ! ?=2 ! #, 3 ,! ,# ! # #, #, ! P %! E #! # P #E! -!! #! B%- B%! ,# ! # #,# $ #!R- # P > ,B-#$ C!- @ ? . 5H #E= # 5889 H(648H # ' 5'5 -%! . 5H -= 588H # (7848H # ' 9'H@'
9' 1,$ 1! , #!!- , ,! 2 - # ,! !# 1 B ! -B !# 1!' : ' 5 !' > ' 1! , E!% #!!- 2 !! !! ! #,# -!- #%= # ! E##! '
! ! % 2! # E# 1!! ! -!- - , >! C!- ' 1! ! #E ! 1C # A , ,- !- #E! 2 ! 3 1# % -B # ! I! # -- # # !! # = >- # ! , -E- 2 # ,# ! E ,B" ##% 2 2 E I! # -- # -E-! %--! 2 - # # #! # ! I! # -- # > ! ,! %! E #!'
4567545889 + M4: +
;# A , ? . (9 E 5886 # (D9489 # ' 5'(@ ,,! ! 3 P- , = #! #- !! 2P !' ! # #,$! , ,- # #! !# -#! P-E-! ,E! # 3 P#= %! # ,! P+ !' #2 P !! # ,! , ! --! P ! ,# -!= # # ,# E == + , ,# = !- >> ! , + A% #!! P= ,E # P ! , #-2! P C ! P ! ? . ((D (98 # ' 9=Q * 588H S 976 ,' 56: # ' 6@'
,- C E # >>-! #! P ! >! # A , # ,->- 3 2 P- #- , # 2P %# ! #-2 A 2 C, ! # #E ,#E! I! + # ! # # + ,# ! ->C # !- ? . (5( 9M # ' 5 ! ->- ; 5888 ,' 58( # ' 5=@'
1# 1- C, 2- , !, E# > ! F >C , # ! G' C $ !, ,- - , 1! #! <<<<<<<<<< 1I! -,! #- 1 ! --2 = = # ! >- E #!! # E##! ! E #! %!#- "! ,#==! =#! 3 -B !# 1 B '
1+ $E 2 -B !# ! E 3 -,! # 1 ! -2 = 2 #! ! = E 1 >! C!- "! # #- !! - #' #! # ! # 1,, ! # 1!' : ' 5 -!! 3 # E , 1+ ! # ! , B% ! 1-E-! (: A 5889'
1+ ! # $ ,# ,! 2 # ! # , B% ! ! 1!' : ' 5 #! , , ! , ,- -! # ! # >! C!- ' ;# 1 ! # 1 F >C , # ! G ,,N! # -! # 3 ,#! # F >#- ,-,,#- 2 2#2 #E! !N - # 1! 21 - ! -!- ,!=- 1C!- G'
#! ! 3 2 #! ! 1- C E # #! #! !# #U , ! # 1 F >C , # ! G ! I! - 3 -,! # 1 ! --2 =' ; 1- E ! >>! = E -,! # 3 ! # % # - 3 -B !# 1 B 1 ! , 2- ,- ' #! 1! #!!- 1C, 2 2 !! # -! ! ,, # ! # # F >>#! =2 G' #>#-! 3 A , = # #-2 ,->- 3 , $ E # 1-'
4567545889 + 74: +
#U 1! , -!= %- E = ,-,#-! 2 = >- # ! 1- ! -!- # !- 1 $ ,! $ # 21 ,B-#$ C!- # ! E !>- -#! #E! #E ! 21 -E-! 3 ! # ! ,# !' , > ! 2 #! 1 ! , = ! !! !- ,# - # !", ! #,!B B# 2 # 1 ! , , - ! >E# ! ,! ,#!- ! >> ! , # A , ,- !- 3 # 3 1C ! 1 >! C!- ' >>! !! # ! # ! - #2 1- # 1,$ > ! -!! # ,, ,# , $ ># ,$ E# #, %! 2 1 , 2 # !! # #, , -E- 2 # ,# ! E ,B" ##% 2 ! -, , 2 ! #! N! - ,# ! E'
#-2 = A!! # !A!- #! - # 1+ ! !! , 1+ 2 , 1- ! #> ! - #'
4567545889 + :4: +
,'+4 '+ * ', * ,+
567 8 9 :; -(" ,<
7
(' - E= # 1 ! *# ;<<<<<<<<<<'
7
5' A!!'
H' ! 2 ,#- ! %! !'
9' ># ,! 21 ,E! ># # #! ,-! I!
- H8 A# $ #! > ! # , , #- - = >-- ;BV WB#>2 D D889 !# C, ' - ,! I! ,##%-' -# # ! J @ 2 C!! 2 - # #! - #=! ! , - # !!2-Q =@ C,# ,# 2 #! > ! ,#E# !! ! - #Q @ ,#! %! # # ,-!!' ; -# #! ! , !# --! --- # !! @ =@ ! @ + = >-- ,# , ! ! $ # 21 E - E=' -# # ! # # #" ,E 2 #! A# ! 2 - # !!2- ! 1E#,, 2 -!- C,- - #! ?!' (H5 (8D ! (87 @'
%>> $ J - ! J
* +# & # X
-! +A ! J ;
#, #># ,-! I! ! #! > - C ,! 213 1>> >-- !- ,= 2 , %>>
4567545889