Contract Breach Damages Calculation Affirmation
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party sought to recover damages for breaches of contract stemming from alleged improper performance related to the handling and delivery of goods at various specified dates. The court affirmed the lower court's decision regarding the calculation of damages, determining that the relevant contractual provisions and established methods for determining loss due to delayed performance—specifically referencing market price fluctuations between the agreed-upon delivery dates and the actual delivery dates—were correctly applied, thereby upholding the final judgment on the monetary award.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Contract Breach Damages Calculation Affirmation: The court affirmed the lower court's decision regarding the calculation of damages, determining that the relevant contractual provisions and established methods for determining loss due to delayed performance—specifically referencing market price fluctuations between the agreed-upon delivery dates and the actual delivery dates—were correctly applied, thereby upholding the final judgment on the monetary award.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for the allocation of costs of the appeal proceedings.
Cited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of costs to the respondent, implying a ruling on legal aid or exemption if granted/denied.
Testo completo
!""#$!%&&# !##'!%&&#
((
) ( ) )(
* + , ", - %&&#
! "
!"
## $ %% & 0"01 '!()&*!"+,-&.,.. ./
6,2)6
.
.7 & 1 + 80 .(3.& " 911:0 $ " $ 60;00"1 *0 , 8;0 .(4.7 $ 1 $" $9! ; !" !' ""0< & *1* 06 "&=!*" . !;9 .(4+& *0=!; ""0< =* "0 . 80".((/7
,7 100! ./ 8;0 ,553& $::0 "! $ 60;00"1 >06 * <$ ?& * < ;!0 1!; " @ $ 1 ;0" * 0 ! "0;0"1 A90"!*"9=35B!0:1; 0 ,555&*0=.55B*08;0 ,55/& 01 ";::" 1" !"0:. :1; 0 ,555&!0"=* "0 !0! @$ 1;0" * 0"0;0"1 0171"1!1= $ 1 @$ 100! "0""0! * ""0! 0C" "!A1 0 * ;0 0""1 0 "7
/7 100! ,3 8;0 ,553& $ 1 = $ 1 "0""0! !""@00;0"1"10C"; 1 "0@ 0< 1&!0" .,4$5/5: 7 "!" >,+ D ,$53576 . 8;0 ,55. /. 19 ,55, E ,+D,$..576 . 8;0 ,55/ /. 19 ,55+ E ./ D ,$.-576 . 8;0 ,55-/.8;0 ,553?7
+7 ! 0 .,:1; 0 ,553&$ 1:! 1!!0"0!=D100!7 0 ;!0 ::"0;" ""1 * "0;0"1 * !:0! = 35B:1; 0 ,5550 1$;!0 0" !*80"F1 0!!1""*A'0@@00* ""0"*!"0 7 1G1 ;!0 *!G1& *0 !;9 ,555& " 1< ""& 1"" 1* 0:7 D*0@1@$"*! ! !"""10! !1"" @$ ,55.& ! @ !01"1 *! @ ;0" " ;01 $ !00"1& *"1 * " ;07 *"!"@$"@$; 9!*0::0"1@$!"01=" ;0 8@$=:0!0$!C" ,55-"@*0! $*$"0;0"1* !:0!H!" &1"1 A!*0"010@0; 0,55/7
-7 100! . ,553& $ 0 * "0" $!!0"0! I 0 !0:01 100! ./ 8;0 ,553 @$0 $ :0" !" $::" 1" !"0: 0! "@$. 8;0 ,55/>0. :1; 0 ,555?7 $ ;1 @& ! *0< 00 " * !1 1;00!& 0 ;0" 1"1 1!" 1 @ $ 1 ;0" " ;01 9" :1; 0 ,555=!C",55-&* 0 "*=35B*0&<8;0 ,55+&=.55B&" @ ! G0 ;0" G"1 >,4$.5): 7 ,555& /5$))-: 7 ,55.& --$/)4: 7 ,55,& )5$.--: 7 ,55/ " 33$(-5: 7 ,55+?7 $ "0 1 !0!@$0;0"1"11"90;G 1; 09* 1*!1 "@ *0"1 G0 $ 1 $1"0" * !G 0;" 10! 1 *0 :1; 0
2..342,553 6/2)6 ,555"@$1"0"* !99" 1"90*08;0 ,55/&"=@0 "01@$01"0"1"90; "0"@$ 1$;0"* !0"= "7
37 100! !!0"0!.+ ,553&$ !" :0D1!""= "0" =)4$-(5: 7>,+D,$..576. 8;0 ,55//.19 ,55+E./D ,$.-576. 8;0 ,55-/.8;0 ,553?7
)7 ! 0 ,; 0,553&$ 10" 8"1 ! !" 100!7 " ;!0 * 0 "0;0"1 * !:0! :0 $10! ! ! 0 !"0"@!1"""1$"0"1"1 0! 1**&090@$0 :0"1"1!;@$@0"" 0"!*!' =:0!0:1; 0 ,55-H $" @$ 0! * !9< "1 !" 1 * ! *!' @""1A1;0"1"1 *! "1=:0!0$!C",55-7$ 1<G $;!0 *D 1"0;0"1* !:0!*0! "" !; &*0 0! "& ;7 * !*! !"" = D10:0$1"90 90!1"""17
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
(7 1*0@ ,, 80 ,553& $ 1 0 ;!0 * 0 "0;0"1 * !:0!:1; 0 ,5550 1*1"1@$;0"@0""1!*!"80" F1"@$"@:=$00"!*!' @$ ;0"*"1 * """0;0"1=:0!0 ,55.7 <G @$ $;0" $0 * :! 0 A 0 $"00 " *! " !& 0!*! @;!'0"!90G1$* " "D07
2..342,553 6+2)6
(
.7 !0G;!0 K! G0"0!8000 >?1"1!0:01"0"0"1&< . !C",55/& 09"! !0&!*!1-8G& !" * 10" " ;06* 10"& - 1" " .3 8G > "7 . "7 "-3 ?7
%0"=K"0!K1"0!.38G &* 09:11 ,)8;0 ,55+> #./5.53?& !0G;!0!*"1&./:1; 0 & 0*!0"0!" 0"!0 G"* """ 09"! !0 01G = " !0 8G "0"0 & & K""" K1"0!!;D8G 7
,7 !:! 1" = $ "7 -3 7 . "7 A7 , & 09 "! !0 !L" 0" 0@ !"""0! * 1; = K "7-3!0:11 * "0G11 !0" !0 3!"!9 ,555 > ? "0; = !0 :11 K 60;00"1 .(80.(-(> ?7%!*1"*! 8G K*<"001"907
/7 " " 1 ;0G . 8;0 ,55/& " L" !0:0"0! 1G0"0; !"" !0" $ 60;00"17 *!0" ; "*! &!"* 00*09 <G !0";0G !"!M :0" 8 00@" 1" 0" !" * !0" " 8G !0:!* 00*&*! 10 & $1"":0" 101= " 1" 0" 100! !!0"0! 0"0G0 > # .,( + !07.7,H.3(!07.H/-3!07." F"0"1?7 !M * !1 1;00! 19"1 ,55-& * 00* !0" 0" "*! !"$D906:!1100! !!0"0!=0< !;0*!0"0! " > #./5//,!07,7,",7/?7 @0 ! * !1 " = 1:" <G " 0"!0 !" 0 & !; !0"$0@ 1 ;<8! !" 1;0G > #117 V 93!0739H..,/35!07+H .((4N/)*7/.3!07/9?7
+7 09 1 !"" @ ! & 0" 8"1 :! " 10 * 0"* !0&" ;9=:! >:7 "735 ?7
-7 !; "7.)7, @0"0*@0"DK0;00"1911:000 " 90" !0:0"0! !"9& " " K!::0 ! & 1;01 *! K;0 & = ;!0 G"1 ! 10" !1@& ! ! 01& $ * ! "1 !0:0"0! D * 00* 8 0* "0 1;!1 9K "7+. ! 1G0 !0";0G 8@$ /.19 ,55,> # /5; 0,55+&3,325/&!07/7-?7 !" AG" 0*! "" 0 !"& * !* = 0: G 1 $0;00"1& ! !0" = "& *" ! 0 = 1;00! 607 *!0"
2..342,553 6-2)6 ;!0 0"AG"$"* !0"!0"F" " A1!* ":0"" @$0* 1"0"!"100!00"0 ""0 !" 1G"=$1*!@100!0"0G0> #.5(,3-!07+H.534) !07 .H .5- /5H # .., /), !07 ,9 " /(5 !07 .9?7 !" & ! K "7 4) 7 , <G" K 60;00"1 .) 8;0 .(3. > ?& 1;00!0K!::0! @K* 1;00!K!0:0"0!0*! "" *!09G 1K0;00"1!K0*!"&" 1"1:0D1!" K!" !0 " ! K!"0! *! 0*!""& ! ! @ ! G K !" !0 :0" ! ! !" @0 *;" " L !0:0"0!0*! ""G 1K0;00"1!K0*!"7
37 D" $ "74 &$0;00"1"00"0!*0"1 G0& * 11 * " ! !G 1& @0 1" $ ""0" = "1 *A'0@!"&* !;"$0:0 0"1!G10"&$0!$ 0"7
'0* 10 @!8 0* &!"0!K0;00"1& !0" !0&"!"0!1!!0@"!10H!" !1@ 1!!0@ !98"0; K0*0"1 :!"0! @K0 0*! "K1; > #..5,)-!07+H.5-,5)!07,?7
)7 ! *!;!0 G 1K0;00"1&K00" "0!>!8G&K0' ! ? 9!0 !" @ 10& 1;"" 0 K" *100"&!0;"0:! 0 7"OA10!0"=*! " 8G" K1"""1"=00@ @ "*! @"0;0"1K 1 "0*9" ;0 7 !" &!110!"0""11" "0 *! 1" 0 @ " ;D ! *" ! & 0!9"& D0G K 1> #.,-,3.!07+H..-./+!07,H..+/.+!07/H .5-.-4!07.?7
8G !0!0"D0 0< !98"0;"!!' * ;& @ @$ !0" * !;& *0 10 0 !" = 0*!0"0! * """ *! " 8G" ;9 !0" 0"0G0D7 %0 ! " 10D !" !" 0"!0 & 0 *" 0@0 $::0 10 $9* ;"00@ 0!*! @0 :! !*00! 10 " ! * " 7 $" 00 @$0 0*! "& *! !:1 *0; * !9"= ! "10&@*!0"0"0G0D0" :0" $!98" $ 1" 0 !"01& @ ! " :! D !*"& @$0 * 1G" !01 "0! *0" D* 01 * * !D01&@$00"1"11"90*0!0$<&@ 0*"0! !"D" 10 " $ 10"0! 0""0! 10 !0" 0 " :0 @ !0! 10 !0" C" !"0;17 "& $11" 1" 0" *! ; * !9" $" 0 $! 0G0 !'* ;010G"0!! ! "!!D* "0&09"
2..342,553 632)6 90!!"> #.,-/-,!07/" 1:1 H.,,.35!07 ." 1:1 ?7
!;0" :0 * 10 @ ! 8 0* !""& 8G !0 10 1G0"1 100! ""@1& <G G11 & K* < K1"" :0" D0"" !" !M 100! 0"0G0 1"1 > #.,./33!07.9" F"0"1?7:0" ;*!"1 0 "& "@0!"!0:01""0""0!&!0;"! ":0 K!98"K!; 100!00" "0;> #.,./33!07.9" 1:1 ?7
47 $! &0 ! "@"0!0 *0* $*!' ! " @$" ;01*! 0):1; 0 ,555/.!C",55-7@"0!;!0 0$ 1$"::"0;"0" !*&!$::0 &!080" ,555!0 ,55.*" " !; "*0@&@!0@$0!0"&$0"01 0 11:00"0; 9! "* ""0!@$00; 1@$= !*" . 8;0 ,55/7 ::0" ! $D0 0 $" = 8" "0" @ $0"01!01 1@$ 1 !; 1*0*0"1" ;0<"" "7
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
" = *1 0! *!"1 0 /. !C" ,55-& !1 10 :!" ::"0;"1:"&"! "@$0!;0"0; * !*!0"0!$0"01 "0 ;!' *! 0;"0G"0!1"0 "!;100!7
;!01 "0!@0* 1<"&100!0"0G0"!:0 1*! *1 0!. 8;0 ,55//.!C",55-7 & ! "* "0" 0" ;!'1=$0"01*! 0" "0!!*1"0 $G0" *1 0!*!"1 0 /.!C",55-7
2..342,553 6)2)6 ( . ( ) )(
/0121 3 411 1 56 "#% 7
21
.7 1 ! ;97
21
,7 $"* "0"!01 "7
/7 !:0 0! "=!*" . 8;0 ,55/"8@$/.!C" ,55-7
+7 ;!0=$ *! 0" "0!!*1"0 ! "*1 0! *!"1 0 /.!C",55-"!;100!7
-7 0"@* !1 "G "0"7
37 :! * "0 @K *;" :! ! !" * 1" F" 10 /5 8! < !"0:0"0! * *0 !1 1 09 :11 & %AR0S A!:@0 3& 355+ & " !0 D*0 7 10 *" F" * !!G17 1!0 !0"I ? 00@ D""@100! ! "10 !9"0 0"*100! ""@1H 9? D*! *! @ !"0: 0 "0 *!;!0 "" " 100!H ? *! " 0G" ! ! * 1""7 %0 1!0 !"0" * " !0 11" 11 1 ! "" ? 9? " ? 06& 09:11 *! *" "0< ! @K0 ; 1 0 ;971!0 ! "0! ! !' * ;& @0 !" 8!0"& 00 @ 100! ""@1 " K;! @1"1D*101 ! "> "7./,&.53".54?7 G ::0< * 10" 0## N 0% N
!*0!:! * 1" F""!"0:01D* "000@K=K::0:11 !0* G ::
2..342,553