Benefit of the Bargain vs. Recoverable Losses in Contract Damages
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party challenged a decision regarding the assessment of damages stemming from a business relationship termination, asserting that the trial court erred by considering certain out-of-pocket expenditures as expenses rather than recoverable losses. The court reasoned that the proper measure of damages in this context is the benefit of the bargain, which excludes sunk costs or expenditures incurred prior to or independently of the contract breach, as these costs are not directly attributable to the broken promise; therefore, the trial court correctly excluded these specific expenditures from the damage award.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Benefit of the Bargain vs. Recoverable Losses in Contract Damages: The court reasoned that the proper measure of damages in this context is the benefit of the bargain, which excludes sunk costs or expenditures incurred prior to or independently of the contract breach, as these costs are not directly attributable to the broken promise; therefore, the trial court correctly excluded these specific expenditures from the damage award.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied for the allocation of costs.
Applied for the granting of legal aid.
Testo completo
"#$%&"'&&' "((("'&&%
))
)* * * )*
+& ,- '&&% +. /0
1111111111 !" # $ %& ''()" '""
22 * * 3)* *4 ' " ") *+,% -./%0.001203
!
#.403#
* 2
06 !'7777777777 )8 0+//69: ":"% 2")(" )'&"')' "1'& " ;' ;6 ' '8 < "2" )< '.0=2"0++,6 =#<% :: ) ) 2" " '& "' ' " " (" " ")'2"#;>"?"60@2"0++@%'))'' ' " 1 ' &::" ' &#"2"'" ) A"#1 & B"10%:. C6
.6 )'") ;" 7777777777' '30');0++,< &" " ' "#'" $ 9 % " ( &) ' &"" ) '&D:"'".0=2"0++,6'"? " "2 E '" " ' 2" 2 )>) 2"?" # "(% 2"#;>"?" '" % " ' &) '" '" >" # "( ' #)"D '" 2 ) " '" ) ')": ) "6 )'" ') " F2 '&D " *>" "( >)'"(6 " (":") &) ')":' " ')21 :")(&"" " ; 0+++ A"1 /% : - B :6 )? ' @=" 0++@G"1 .% :3 H% '.-');0++@G"1-%:3 H% ' 05 ;0+++G"1I%:3 HC6
36 '''& %"""('&) ;" >" "& "2)< D " "'"""" A ! B "1 +% : 3 C6 ) ;" ' ' .@ ; .550% " ( &) :: '& ) ')":) "'&" " ))21%?)">?*>" "( )"") " "')'" "') '&D"* "(6 ) ) 2) ( )'" " 2" '&" "?) ) ')": 0++I')=<6
&) :" &;= '& " )"") ' > ?" 77777777776 '" :") ) ' 2"#?" '" >"(" ")(&&"" '&"" )' 2"' "2" ):"' )69"%& "2" )' "1 ' J"( " '&" )' < '):"" "% < '" " '&)2" ' ' >? ' K ) '" 6 :: % )'" 2) ( ' < ;"" " ' >" 2" & L" " "" " " "'" " '""6 D ' " " < ;"" "'&)'" %&2" )( ) "" " : "6 )'" M "?) &; ' "" "' "D 6
40,-54.55. #3403# &))? :" &;= '& ")"")'*>" "6 7777777777)'"? "'&)"'')":)21* K *> "(% ' " ) < " )2" ')' ' *' 'D : " 6 ( " '"" " ')")"2 "2 "2" ) :" ("" )' 2") " '@5N2"6
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
-6 # %" <> ? ?>* L)')>" ')"(" %&);")" "' '@".5506 008 .550%:" 2> (" L): '?1' & '" 6 ) ) ";"" " ' " "6 %')'>*" >)" ) ))"6
/6 9 ; ' &D " ! % 2" )'" )?" A9!C% ")%I');.550%(&"&*2" '&"" )' 2"< "' :" ' " < ) "(%&D'* 1 &* ') ) ( ' )" "6 " "')) ( &"' 2 1 &D " &" :)" 2 &)" " ' D ( & " < ) *>"( ) " < &"?" ' &"" ) ' 2" A"105%:3 C6
I6 ' ) ' .@ :)2" .55.% 7777777777% >"?" >)'"(%"?) "" ": "'&)'" A))2 "
40,-54.55. #-403# '0I5OC ' "" 6"?)(')() " <"' : ' "" " : " '6 :"% " 2) (& ??2 " ' &) ' ? ?> ) " )? ";% : '& > # "(A"100%:3 "136C6
,6 99!%)) )?)7777777777) " ')=< ' D ' ! (" D"" "(&" )2() " ')?)) "2 L ' " ' "" " : " '&)'" ('??>6"(&"&" ""''"?>":: )"' ;.550%# " :") " &)2 ":2;(&) " '" '& 'A"103%:3 C6
@6 ' ; ' & ' ' @ .55.% &) "2()2: <&)'" ""('??"6
+6 ')""'3=".55.%& <&)'?)'&"2"'" )' I5N " *) '"# '&"2"'" ) 2 :: 0 =" .55.% " '& '"# :"% ) )") ( '8 < " ) ":)"''0=2"0++@30".55.:" &;= '& ')"" )"69&* &D " ! %& "'))( " )'?"'&)2" ) ))'" '" ")'1.0=2"0++,# " 2 "" '" < '"# '1 .0 =2" 0++@6 ) &??2 " ' &) ' ) ' &) < ' " '&2" 0++@%' < "'(2" D"?'&(& 2")? < D'-5N69 D '&"2"'" )'1) ) :"D)<I5N < ' 08 0++@ # " " " 1 '" ??2 "6 ) ) ") ( )) )?) ' &) ' '" " 2" ')=< ) ) " '&)2 "A"1, /%:0 C6
056 ')"" ' 05 =" .55.% & :"D) ' ' < " ) ":)"''0=2"0++@30=2"0++@A'"# '&"2"'" )% "''"# ) "=" '&) 'D: C6')""'0I=" .55.%& :"D) ' ' )"' ' 0:)2" 0++@ 30 ; 0+++ A '"# "''D'"# ) ": C% ' 02; 0+++ 30=2" .555 A '"# " '& '"# ) " : C ' 0 :)2" .555 30=" .550 A '"# "C6 D ' < " ) ": )"' ' 0 8 .550 35 2" .55.% :" &;= '& ')""' )'0,=".55.A'"# '"# ) " : C6
40,-54.55. #/403# 006 " ' - =" .55.% &) " = ) ')"" ' 3=" < & " '& "1 '&"2"'" ) ;) '?) '&"2"'" )',5N "6 1?( &)2 ")'" :2; < ( & '" & & " ( ) ' ) ') "" '" @ " .550% ' < ( ;" )" "6 D '& "2" ) >*"( ?) " "" ; )"'" 6 &"''"% '" ) ;" ' '.=" .55.7777777777(" (" ' " "' "( < ) " ' :)2"% < 2" ' ' "2 ' ? ?> < &:: 1 2" ?') " " "(6)'"12 (( " " "2" ) ''&>"P % ''"2'&)'" 6 ')" "2" )>*"(?) & "" "';)" '" 6 "? (&< >)1 "( ')?)) ": &= >?')" )" ">?A"1-6C6
0.6 "'0,=" .55.%&))? " = ) ')"";)( %M ":())' 6
036 2" )<%& %')2"'3 ;.55.% = ' 6 & " ) " ") ):1 < &D " "'"""" ' ! "" (&D 2" ' 7777777777 Q77777777776 "% " (: '&)'" " 2.550 ??" ) )" '&)" "'D 6"('" " ) '"?>" ' &) :: ) .- ; .- ;.550%& " )" ") "(#": ( :" " &"' '0.8 .550%"(& )2"';" " "" " ':? D6
0-6 "'+2".553%& '" "'&' ' ) ' ., :)2" .553 ) ' 7777777777% ?) '& "'" "' 777777777767777777777* (&) ;" - :)2" .553 " 2 " >"?" 2 ) " ' )" ' )"( " ' ? '" ' ' '& " :: " ')?)) "2% ' " " " " ' :)# "% " < ;)" ) " )6 "? ( M >)1 D" )? ' K ) ?>6 )2( ' ' 2 "" " : " ' ; )" '" ' < : ' & < > ' ?1% (" '"" "; : '&)>" ' ; )" '" 6 9&* = ) ')": ' ' '& "" (" '&2"? )" " :"69)'"%&"" )' 2"" % ') "') ")6 7777777777% ' 9!% 12 ( " "( ')=< 6 :" 2 )"'" '
40,-54.55. #I403# ' & " ? '" % '"? " ' ? > &* ) ) ) D) 2 :)2" .5536 )'" :" ( ( ! ' " ??" "?) " ' '&" 6 9 7777777777% " &"'"( ( & " ')?)) "2#'&" * >;" >P'&R?' &)# L'"" " ";'&??2&"" )' 2" ! 6
0/6 2) '"' " D" &2" ' 7777777777 7777777777% "?) ( '" &2" =" D")6 '1'')(" ')D ")'"6
* )
06 " ?2" &?" " ='""" AC ) ) '":") " " )% '1 0 8 .553% "; ' " A 9C% )'"(=?%' )"' 2"#)"' %"() "P=?A 60 6 /I C6
9" <& "'&) "'"P=? ";:)') A QC.,=2".55-A Q03505IC%' "?2"' )% 03:)2"%'"" " " "? A 60I.C 9 ' ")? % < " =? " "% ' & ' &) " ' 2D=?6
9 ''" ;"% Q%'M '0=" .55-% :") ( '"" " " " " " " " ) " %'L %:'" :)')AM 060@34.55-C6
? ""'( "'S)2 " " "" )' 9% Q ")() "' ";2" M "%2: ')? " ' '" :)')% ""1 ' & 6 /, &6
.6 :) < & 6 3 6 3 ' "" " " " ' " ' 0-2; .55. '":" % " '" 2 & ) 2"?'")" ) ' '2 "" ' "1 '&"2"'" ) ) ) " '&::" "; ' "6 ) ' '" '1 ) ;" L ') " "?6
36 " :)') " ?)) ' '" ' " ' I ;.555 A C ) 2"? 0 =2" .553% L '
40,-54.55. #,403# ; '":" " ' '" ' S#"2"'" )6 '&1 ' :" )?" '"" " 2"? =(& 30'); .55.% )?' "" ( =? ' "&<'"') "'":" "''" '&) ' :" )" < ' ') " ' ')"" " "?" A Q 0., -I, "'6 0% 0.0 3@I "' 0;B :6 )? '"" " " "% 6@.60 C6 ) " "?)(D")< "1 ''"" ")?2"?=(&30');.55.6
-6 "; ( % " = ) " A 6 I+ ' " :)')'0+="0+/+S#"2"'" )G H @-'":)')' .5');0+-I"" 2"2 G 9HC% 2; :6
/6 C S"2"'" ) '):"""'"" "'" ) '?"% )) ' ? ')% (" ) 'S " < ) >*"( %2 'S":"" )?)" %'S'"'S "' A 6- C6
;C &"" ) ' ?" " '"" " * )2""; ' ";"" )'?"')&;'>)' 2" )("";) 2 "') " A>6 050, ' "" ' &::" :)')'" &"2"'" ) &" ' &#"2"'" )G HC6
C&)'" < "1S" "2"'<-5N6 %"2 ( ' 69&" "2"'</5N%"2 *'"# %" "2"'" ) " II.43N% "1A 6.@60 C6
I6 S1%& " )'" " ) ;"E&):: '&) ')": )21 '& % ' 2"#?"% ; "( ' 2"% ; ')?)) ": ' &) '" ' ? ?> ;; ; :'D%'& 6( "" "?" ;" K '') "(""' " < ) " )' 2"'&)6
,6 C 9 ="'% ' ; : 'D 2 % ' " " % '" < "" ) ' 2" A Q 0.5 00+ "'6 .4B ! 0++I ./I 6 .0, "'6 / IC6 ; ' )?"':: "*>"(%(D " *>" "( "" )" (' " S?" ' S"" ) ' 2" (S" "; 'S L A9 .555 6 0I5 "'6-;B Q I@3453 ' 0. .55-% ' ") < ;" "% "'6.6.6. M " )C6 ' '"::" )% "1 ' 2% < ) ;" SD" ' '% " " ;= "2 '
40,-54.55. #@403# S)::" = ":""2"'" )A "1 "C6 ''SD''" D "'S"%S)? "' ''" M :")';2 ")'" %<'): ' (" )" " ' '" D " M ) ' "1 : < S)?" ) ' " ' ) A Q .@.453 ' @=".55-"'6-6060C6
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
C 9&?" ""1 ' R> ' )'" ( ' ; : '"? "()% ";:)')')")% :' "" ) ' ' !9! A9 :
9 T? E "> ' G*>" ">H > % " 9 9 0+++% 6 0 05/C% ( SD '" % *>" "(% '"? " ' ' 'S ":" " '?) ' ?2" ) ' S:: "6 '" )2 1 D"?"; ' " S) 'S "2" ) "26 " "' ''"2" 1% ' " ) ) ' " );"'% ;"'" ) *>" "(% ' :: " >"(% 'S" )? " "% )2 :" ") ' '"% 1 >"( ' #" )"" ';% ') ' " ) ' '" 2 '
40,-54.55. #+403# * K ; )2 "% S)> ' " : D 1? ' S 6 ' " 1 )" ) :' " '):2;6 :"% SD '" SD" ' *>" ' D")6 ' % ' " ' : 'S '" )? '"::) " 16 ;'D#":"? '"2? ' ')" ;2)% S)? " 'S" ' ' )" "( ' 2?% S; ' '' ' "% ?' '"2? ": " :" " ' S1%:" ('" 1') "2" "";SD % ""(S)? "''>'"?)2" *>" " A9.55560/.C6
'C 'SD " ) 'S " *>"( * 2''"# ' ; :'D# '" " ="'"( )"% " " ; ::" ' (S "" " ' " ) ' 2" 2M 1 "2"' A Q I@3453 ' 0. .55- )" ) "'6 .6.63 B "> ! U # 9 % > ;?":: ' ;" :V>"?J" ' " ' ? " ' 9P"2">?% "> :W ' "J2?"> " ' 2"'" V ;?% " E ) 9 $ QQ$ 9 4QP 9 $ A)'6C% 9>P ' ;" :V>"?J" % 9 6 .553% 6 I-% +3C6 :: % ="'% ; : 'D " S L %1??))%"" "'?')'" ) ' 2"2 '"<"2"'" )'S 6-60 A2" " ! U # 9 % 6 " 6 6 ,I% )6 6 @0C6 D " < "" '" ' X% S " " ' )'"% ; :'D": 2 )2)" )(%'S " ' 2 ;= ":% " 2 ' " ) ' 2" % "( %#)2''" "'SD?) "A9.553 06."'63;4;;B2""! U # 9 %6" 66@3%)6@,C# "; M D"?)'S)%(S" M" ; ") )A Q05.0I/B9.5506..-26"'6.; ):)B :6" Q0.,.+@"'6-":"C6
C '""; ''D "% 1D"?";'S :: ' 2 ) 2 ' ' ' )" )? " ' ' 2" % ' >( % " ) ": 'S ;" ) *>" "( 'S " ) 'S ') " % " 'S " 1) "" " ) 6 A0C ' :: " >"( 'S '": S) ' "))""';%A.C'S 'S" )? ""' ": " ' 2"% A3C 'S ) *>"( " ")% )2 " "; >) "(% ( " ) S)> ";) "'') "':" *>"(A:" "" ")'
40,-54.55. #05403# '"C% :" A-C ' S)> ' " ; " "" :D1?'S '')>;"" "%')" ' "2 " ' :: ' ) :: ' ; :'DA9.55560//"'6.B Q I@3453 ' 0. .55-% "'6 .6.63 " :"B ! U # 9 % 6 " 6 6 ,I% )6@5C6
:C1(SS;') "('"? "' ; : 'D ::" = ":" '" < ' " 'S "% " "; < SD *>" % ' ' ?'D%'S"'"(<S'"" "A =?'" "?C" ' ( ) '" ' *>"( (" # )?' )? D " 1 ") "#' # " ' '6 S?" " 'S) ;" ' "1 ;= "2 "% ' " "*>"(%S) D "2" )>)' 2"% ?) ' (S" A:6 Q I@3453 ' 0. .55- "'6.6.6-6 M " )C6
"'" ")'" )*>"( ' '" S) " ; "'"; > ( " A="'"(C'2"" '( D"?'"#"(S" 2 2 ) ' )" )?'' 2"6''";)" "' "'" %S'"" " =?" ""? "':" ')'"%":" " " " )'" "2 < " ) A)"'C ' 2"%)'<D);' "'" '2' '" '"6 S" ""(SD "" " ' " ) ' 2" :') "( '"? " ' ; : 'D6 % " " D " ) '"" "2 ='""" 'SD" 2 " )" " S " ")'"' S"" )' 2"' "') " )? ')) ) ?<S"2"'" )A ""': *>"D "# C(" " '" '2'" A Q 0., .++ "'6 /B 9 .555 6 0-+ "'6 3C% " "" " A " C'" )' 2" = ":")" 1="'"( ') " % ))) "#' A:6 Q I@3453 ' 0. .55- )" ) "'6.6.6/C6
@6 &1%)'"' ! '"? "()%;'& )' D )("" ' ="' ) % ) ')": )21% ' 2"#?"% ' ; "( ' 2"% ' ; ')?)) ": ' &) '" ' ? ?> ; : 'D6 ") ( " ) ' 2" )"' &)2" (&<-5N' "2" )' )6
40,-54.55. #00403# C 2''"? "(" D 2''"% ""( "'S'""'S;"'" )*>" "(69 ' " )'" A:6 4!!49 $! G$?6H% "Y":"J "*>">9 T?% #05Y" GQH%-1 )'6% 6 0+0C ( S" "; :)') ' % ) ')": " ' ": " A) "2C 'S? ' ; : 'D% ' (S" " :" S;= 'S '"? "))A! U # 9 %6" 66@0% 03/C6 %SD" 'S;" )*>" "('" M ")' ""6
;C9'1( "'))2 'S " 1%' 'S)" 1 "2"' ' ; : 'D6
SD'&D ":"? '"% ") ;"SD" 'S:: " >"( A2"#?"% ; "( ' 2" ;')?)) ":'&)'" '??>C6
% " 'S;) < 'S" )? " " ' ": "'2"Z?) D :""(":")':) ;) "(6 "% D D") &"" ( ' "2;" )")A>)"'C6
2>% ";') '&2"(& <SD" 'S ) *>"( " ")% )2 " "; >) "(6 %D D")&""(&">?*>" "( ? " M " ( )'" "') " M )'& 6 :"'& ')=< ) D M "" > '&)" " ( " " L6
C 1 % "; '&2" ( " 1 '&' 1 "2"' ' ; : )" &1% " (&2"'D ' ! Z" -5N'" ))"'' 2"#'" M "2"6
+6 9&?" '& )2 ??2 " )" < ')"" " "?"% " 2" ' 2 (% " < ( " & " ) " ")% D %&" :: "2 >)& " <&)% ) ') ") )( ' ' ?6 "% " )") (&" ) " ) ) ' ( < &)2 " < '&)2 )( " # >" ' @ " .550 )"&>* >1(&&;'" " ""1Z(" & "(& 2 "' 2 " '&8 .550 Z &)2 " ['2" "" >)"( \'""'"1
40,-54.55. #0.403# 1 "?":" "2 " ) ' 2" ' ' ' & "2" ) >;" ' "1'?"6
&>* >1'&??2 "("" " 22 ')""" "?" '2" M " '" :" M ) )6 :: % &??2 " < (:" "7777777777' )'"'.@:)2" .55. &) " )") " 2"?) )2 " ) < 2"% :'&"; > # "(6 "'&??2 " ; :: "2 &M )") " % "" (& ' 7777777777'.,:)2".5536 "#":" ) '&) "" 2 :)2" .553% " 1 ')"" " "?"% '& " :: " ')?)) "26 ??2 " )2 '2 ' :" &;= '& ''')2""'X:" )"<')""" "?" 2 M ""') "''') )'6
056 )?'D"') "(")1' %"&*"'&) ' ' ! '')""'& "'&'"# '& 6
40,-54.55. #03403#
) 2 )* * * )*
9
A:) <'"" " " "'& 60I.C
5,
06 ( 2;B
5,
.6 = B
36 " ()' ? " B
-6 : " ' (& 2 : ) M ' ')" ' 35 = '1 ":" " " ') ') "; :)') ' % 9>]"P>:(" I% I55- % " D"6 ')" M ?)6 )" '" E C "'"( D (')"" ')"; "" '')"" ()B ;C D ( ": " " 2" '' ')""B C "? ' ) 6 9" )" " " )) ))) C ;C C "#'% ";:)')' "1(&" '2')"2;6)"' "* ' 2% (" =" % "" ( ')"" () &2 ' () )D)'") A 603.%05I 05@C6 ?::"1E )"' E "QQ Y"9 Y
":') M ":")D """(&<&::":)') '"?::
40,-54.55.