Contractual Arbitration Enforcement Over Ambiguity in Forum and Procedure
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appellant sought to enforce a contractual clause requiring arbitration for disputes arising from a commercial relationship, but the lower courts refused, finding the arbitration agreement unenforceable due to ambiguity regarding the chosen forum and procedure. The reviewing court reasoned that while the agreement contained some vagueness, the parties clearly demonstrated an intent to be bound by arbitration, as evidenced by their subsequent conduct and explicit references to arbitration procedures; therefore, the court reversed the lower court's judgment, holding that the agreement was sufficiently definite to compel arbitration, even if certain procedural details required external reference for resolution.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Arbitration Enforcement Over Ambiguity in Forum and Procedure: The reviewing court reasoned that while the agreement contained some vagueness, the parties clearly demonstrated an intent to be bound by arbitration, as evidenced by their subsequent conduct and explicit references to arbitration procedures; therefore, the court reversed the lower court's judgment, holding that the agreement was sufficiently definite to compel arbitration, even if certain procedural details required external reference for resolution.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACosts were imposed on the appellant for the federal court proceedings.
Testo completo
'()*+',* !'++-'.,,-
!
/ !0/ 1!% /1 %10
-2 34 .) 5 .,,-
0 6666666666
1%1%0 /1 0 ! 110! !"!#$!#%&'($)+" ,-
!"#$ %! &
0+.10
70!
'2 34 2 5555555555 % 3 2 5555555555 4% %4 6 , !# 3 7"0! # 8 !4 #9" 4:# %4 42 '( 4;: ++$ "%%#4%-,<"=","49 %%4!!4 #9, +/ %$ ! ,"4 4!!4%4 '> ?##% +/$ "4-, # 4;##!,%%,#9--%!-<9,;%#"42
+2 +* 4@% +/$ # , 4% %?%, "4 ! :# ", 4##"%%#%%%4#9--%!-$"A# :##-,!B% +>!%:+/!;4!4",,<!,%,B%!,"2
/2 14"%4:+/$#,4%%?%,"44%%%-! :#-,,#"7"0!# C 8%<"A#9B% %!4%#,%#9--%!-%%,2"4D-,;+>$# 4%"4,A9##4%4,"%AE#9--%!-,%%-4"F ,-,%<B% :#-,,#7"0!# C8+1?;+>! #A# # 4 4% !:#" C ;% #, #9,#"%4 & ? :# ", G ! #A# 6 ;% !%"!, < # ,"4"%#% 2
>2 B%+;#+>$# C ,"#,#"4";:#-%4 ,!:# % !!#, A #9#%4$ ! # C$ #9,#"%4 6 ? H%!%"!,<#,"4#% %;4!4"4,A"$ 6# $#,%:#%#9--%!-%,!# 2
(2 ,!,+*;#+>$#,4%,!4,! :# ",,;4#9B%+>!%:+/4%-A" ,%% # % # --% ; # "4!4%4 "4"% #9%4%,2 # 4% , #% 4##"%, ,# !4 ,% # %% #9--% !-$ ,#A#,%,""4,!# :#",% ,+'+>2
)2 ,"% '' +>$ # , 4% 6!#A, A # %% #9--% !- ! # ##0B$ !% #% $ "4%% ;4#%4!"!4%<!4",A%:#2#4%, #%#;,A9# ,%%9%%!#,"%%#9--%!-<#,"49 % # ! +/ A # %%4 "%## % ,"44A # "%% ;A,%2 %-4$#,4%"4"#<#9#%4 ,"49 %%4!+/2
12 ,!4 +) +>$ # "4"# < #9";:#%, AB% ,;4 6!#A% A # C ;% 94 % ,?< %%, " !4%%A9#;%,"#,#"4";:#2 ? %,%%%,-4"%
.'(/).+/ 0/.10 ;%"A-4""=4? ,2 "A"4"%!###"4"#4 #-4$# #;,A9##9,%%!";:#$# :# H%6!,%,;,#-42
I2 4#!#$#-%%##, ,!%%!%4%!%%A :4#!%E4%F"0!2
%0!
'2 #4 ;4#94 %4?"78,%,4-,%%%,$ # ' 4@% +/$ :# "%4# " 4"# 7"0! 8$ "4!4,(? $4%!,%%;"0!,%$(!!#,%%')? 7%2'#%2%() 82
%<#9#%4#9,#"%4')? $!# :#-,,## +1?;+>7 C'/*'*)8$# 4# ;44!%,$#'/-,;$ !4%4%%4 %!%%% , < %4? %%#$"$#9%%%#9,#"%44;6? 2
%%% "4 4%!:#"$# :#-,,#$B%' ?##% +>$ "4-, A # !4%4 %%4 "4%%% # 4#%4 # !# %4##%,%%"4-4$"4J%$4%-,,#7B%'2'I/.+>82
#%#A%4#9"4%%%4#%, $#,"#,A# ",%4"%:#!4;%B%"$;#-4",4 %4 4%-,,#$4%#94"""#9%2(1##4-,,#)4"%4:+# !% ,,#4%"4"#7 82
+2 #4 #9% I' #2 ' #4 # !4", %%; '+ !%: 'DI( 7 8$#,;44%-4,"4-4,%<#K%2ID 2 6 % " $ # 4 # "4 % , + 6!# 4% ! #%%$ 4% ! ,4 ,$ "4!4%% 8 # 4$ !,4$ 4"# 4 ," !% 4$ K# K % K !4 4#$ %4% % , %4 !,"$ :8 6!4, """% -% 4 4%- ;4A,%"8"4"#42
"4!,%" !4? "9!"%,%:#2
/2 ##$#4#9%2I'#2' $!!#":#!;4#9%2ID $# ,;4 4% B% , ! ,"% < # ?"%4 A # ,"4 # / 4 # ,"4;% 4%- ,;42 H%!!#4%-,;4!#%L%#D-,;+>$%#"4
.'(/).+/ 0>.10 ! C 4##"%% A9# # 4% 4, E"% " A #9--% !- ,%% %, -4"F$ % # H% ,%, %4% # +* ;# +>$ # ,# !"% ! #9%2 I' #2 ' ,%, !"%, % # ,"% 4% #4 ";:#2 ##$ ## !"%% # 6 " -4 !,; ! #9%2 ID 2
>2 #H#!44"!##A%4#,;4#9B% :#",+>!%:+/2
8#4#9%2I*#%2 $#H#<,;4#4A$--, #, ! ,"4 ,-%;$ # !!J% A # ?"%4 A %%, 9,%% ! "4!4,"4##4#9444A#!4%4#,"%44%,%, ;4#,2
:8 #9!"$#9B%%+>!%:+/#9,%,!? " % 6 ? 2 $ ! B% +1 ?; +> # " '2>I1.+/7 C'/*'*)8$# C#,#9,#"%4&? $ 4%- A # !4%4 #, # # % 9;% ! ,%, !"%,2 $ # !!J% A # :# %%, "4!4%4 , ##+>!%:+/$4!4#A###,;44%B% "2
(2 #% !4%%##%#%%%4,;%###9--%!-2
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
:8 #9!"$ #4 # !4;4 96 %:6 " A "4" # A%4 # -6%4 ! 9"0# 4:# %4 % # ?!" # % 7"-2 4%% C O '+*.*' /'
.'(/).+/ 0(.10 ++8$ # "=" "" :#% #K,%% #%;% -:#2#;"4A$,-,"-%<#9B% D+/# " .>)>.+/$#,;% ,#%%#96,"%4,%#,"4 !%#9 %%4!9"0#4:# %4"4% A% < ;4 !H # --," !6 % # ! --,% ,"2$#4#;:#%,#"0#-%!4%%"##0 "#-$##;%B%!!#,<:4#4%% !Q%4!2 4%$"#"4%;%!!"!#!4!4%4#%,2 4%4%"4$#?%-!%%#9--%!-"42
.'(/).+/ 0).10 1 %!07 !0/ 1!% /1 %10
8 9 : ; (+. %
8
'2 Q4%#,;4+*;#+>%?4%#"4#,4 .'(/).+/M
+2 %M
/2 #"4,A"4B%+>!%:+/M
"-%$
>2 ?%%#%%%4#9--%!-+*4@%+>M
(2 ,;#-4M
)2 -4 # !% " A9## !;% -4 "4 "4% # !,% B% ,# '* ?4 4%-"%4 ! !# "4, , :# -,,# "$ "=R&=4-A )$ )> $ %4 6!#2 ,# !% B% !4#4 ,2 ,4 4%S 8 A 6"%%A##,"4#"4%,4:%#%!#"#,"4 %%A,M :8 6!4 !4 A# 4%- # % !4;4 "%% % ,"4M "8 !4% % 4 "## 4 !,%%2 # ,4 "4%% ! # %4 ,#,% ,,, 4 #%% 8 :8 % "8 "0$ # :#-,,#"!4!%%#"4A9# ;,"#";:#2,4"4%4"4#4H !;$ A 4% ?4%$ A # ,"4 %%A, % #9;#4!! #A####,%,6!,,"4%7%2'/+$'*)%'*I82 ,%S --S # T# 3
.'(/).+/ 01.10 ",%0?%S C#43
"4!"4-4!,%B%%4%-,6!%A9<#9--"-,,# "4"#!# --
.'(/).+/