Restrictive Covenant Interpretation: Deck as a "Structure"
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party sought relief based on a claim related to a restrictive covenant that allegedly prohibited the installation of a deck, arguing that the covenant was ambiguous regarding the definition of "structure" and that their proposed deck fell outside that definition. The court reasoned that covenant language must be construed strictly against the party seeking to enforce the restriction, and upon examining the plain language and common meaning, the court determined that the deck, being a substantial, attached, permanent addition to the dwelling, qualified as a "structure" under the covenant, thereby affirming the denial of relief to the enforcing party because the restriction was not ambiguous and the deck was prohibited.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Restrictive Covenant Interpretation: Deck as a "Structure": The court reasoned that covenant language must be construed strictly against the party seeking to enforce the restriction, and upon examining the plain language and common meaning, the court determined that the deck, being a substantial, attached, permanent addition to the dwelling, qualified as a "structure" under the covenant, thereby affirming the denial of relief to the enforcing party because the restriction was not ambiguous and the deck was prohibited.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the appeal, citing Art. 66 al. 1 LTF.
Testo completo
%&'()%( %+,-%('
.
/ 01/ " / "0
$ (' 2 ('
&3 4 5
0 " 6"0 " 0" !" #$%&'() " $ 7777777777 !* $ "7777777777+ ,- " ",- "" !"! .//////////0 1* 2
! " #$ -3453-
80
58 !"! .////////// 0 + 9" : ;" <#"+ )"+ " ;" " <,: "" ": "":: " !':" " < = !"! !! ' () *!) 5>678 <= " : :" < " ? : " = "" <@) ? " A //////////+ #* <#"85% 5>>555B"5>>&+A //////////+A ////////// " A ////////// !" " " "" " " < =" ) 8 A ////////// :! ? "! < "" ?8 : 5>65+ A ////////// "*" ") =" ) !="8
38 !"!"!?? "!: ": 5>>C!D'+'" = ? : : " " !"! "! " =) :" 1 -:( 2"?: ""B$" ==! != ("8 : : " ! C7 :"; 5>>E:""< !!B'* D 5>>E!"! ":D) 5>>>8 !"! !"! " : ! <;! =!! 55 5>>> " A ////////// !"! ! ? "8 ; : ( ":!* " !"!F!;5>>>8 ? " !"!:+:" G 3& 37778
C8 ! 5& :"; 3777+ !! ' A //////////" //////////: ">H7>F*8E%+'" " !:" = ; : " < " " : " 0- : !"! : ! 5>>C+ 5>>& " 5>>F+ ?" " <!5>>E8
&8 A ////////// *! :: " 33 :"; 3777+ !=" < :"+ ? "" : " : ' :" ! : ' < * " 6H35C *8 6% " <" :"+ ?< <!" " : :;" " !#)""! !"!8
%8 A ////////// !=" *! :: " + :!"! : AI" //////////+ 57 "; 37778 = ? !"! <) " : 9:9" " "::? ;? " !"! ! " " " !: " * " ? ,- <":!"!" (":9!8
45&3643777 -C453-
F8 !:! 5> "; 3777 :( " 0- ) "')!:: " 8 (? A ////////// " ////////// " ! :!D ; : :""!""!= ==)<"8%3 0"() ?< 5>>E " " < !"! :9!+ $ :" " 8
E8 ) "! ' !" + AI" //////////+ = " : :: :" ?: A //////////+,: ?!?<" ) < ? 0 + : : ! ( !"!+ ?< ) " !"!! !"": "<" ) "!+ ?=!""" ; )"! ; * //////////+ " !"! ) " !"! * " ! ! 55 5>>&+ "" <!"" : ! !8""><7>F*8E%<":""!+""?< :!" ""=+9: "!$"D?< :!!"* "8
68 A //////////+ A ////////// " A ////////// * J//////////G 0 +=!) !"!+" !"!"C5377C8
!":(-);!"; '< ?K L !"!<D !"!"(* "+*" !; D?<5>>3-5>>C+"'?:;(* ") : :""8AI" //////////") "" ? !"! ( 55 B" 5>>& :" ; * ;" L DM+ " * )" "8 <0+ ? !" " : : ! ( !"! ) " = * A ////////// " <" : "" ?<!" "<)" " !"!80< <9) ": " :" <0+ !:N" ; " ) ;;" !"! ! !8 *" ? ; !" " #?!'<0"?!!" ":"-: " !8 "" +< !!" "!)::"") !" =*""G1G 2+ =+ ="8 <" * A //////////+ //////////+? <: ": :" ("8 : " :) ! = 8 "<8 ""+ <!"!: ?:"8 ! :(" !" " * + : ,: <= ":9< "8 ,= "" ) ,"'A"!"!"!8<)::" O " * : )"= * : :9 * 8 " * =:# "( :"" : "!=*?:) * ="M8 >8 AI"//////////)! ":"; !"! ! 5>>C ' 5>>E+ 36 "; 377C8 !" "" ?
45&3643777 -&453-
!"! !" " 5>>C !D' !"" """ 1*8 ::" <= !) '<;!=!!" +, 5>>C28
578 37 ); 377C+ * " ) ? "" " " B : #? !+ " : "( !)!+ "" " :" )? !"!:) "'<!) * *+?< "! : !+ "5>>C'5>>E88
558 A //////////::!:?<0:! "+D * "+! " !"!C&FH3F6 *86%"?<<! ":; "!= !"!8* ":) ? #= )""!"!)!' + "K - 5>>CK G8 &HC35877 - 5>>&K G8 CH&&6837 - 5>>%K G8 CH&E68E7 - 5>>FK G8 6H6FF856 - 5>>EK G8 5H%F>8F% < =? :!"?<)"< "!"!"! :<!5>>E+":! ? !"!)!CH&77*85>>6?; $ <) " : #= "" !-'8 = * ?B!;"5>>&!" "6H&%7*867+?< <!" "?FHFF7 *8%7C5!;5>>68"? "" <!" "! !: :! "? !" " -$ ""+ "5>>&'* "8
"0
59 =) <= " D 12 !"! * ! " " "!+ (5B"377C+ ;" +:!% D=+":! "") -:! "+%::!""5FD= 1"85"8"%F 28
0 "'<" <!" 5FD=+: ;*!! 3E D) 377& 1 G 5C7 57F2+ =) :"!+ 5C *!) + : " " " =" :""" ; " != ' " D= " " + + <"""<!" ),D=8
0""" ":; + ;*!!+$"5 D "377&+* !? : " " " " " "" : " "!" "*+I"+ "*!!1$"5856C4377&28
45&3643777 -%453-
=" ?" " "" "! ; " + !! ? !" " ; :) " $" +)*!=" "*!!+ "<<"8 %E *!! F "; 3777 :" =!! " 1 28
38 *!" ' <" C ! C : " " " + " ")"<"!) = ":")" " " !"! " < ; " + """ " ? """ " ( < 0- 1*8" %F280:!":D=<:(" !"; 8
C8 *!!:" =!! " F"; 37771 2""!) =5D) 377C+"I" * " ; : " != < 0+"" ? <" %3 08! +:; "!<:9" !=! (:!" !?<:)"'<" %3 0"" 65 " 63 0 " !"! ;=!8 <:( " ""* != : : " ) = D?< C5 !; 3773+ != : : ? (= :: ; " ) = " O * " D ?"!" "": "1 G53E&FE 8528
&8 , " H" 63+ ! 5 (=" H-) " ) )" C5 "; 5>&E 1 02+ " !:" H = : " ? :" * " : ) : ! !:" ! H!':""O ="+""+'H,: " H! ? ':"* "=;8
" "'""" : " + H= "HH! :!:" ' !H 1*8 G5536+ 8&P 5>6F:8 &>C28? "! )H": ; ::!' ! : :" : = !+ ! " :: ; 1" 63+ !3 028
; *!! 1 G 2 :! : : ?H :" Q =Q : " :! "!+' :" "O "I"+9:$""H""" ?H" " H"" H " "" :" :" ?+ ? " :""" : ) " " + : " D" * ; =" !:=1 G55FE%+ 8C;P55C565+ 8 3P 553 6+ 8 &+ 5%6P 576 %3+ 8 %P 5>6C+ :8 57628 * " !" """"?H H9Q ": " :* "+ '
45&3643777 -F453-
" ;Q 1*8 G "# K Q0#;" ;= RS + 3( !8 :8 5532+ HO!":"! 8
* " " : ; H" *+ H : ! " = " " O :" " "; " ;" " :" * !"; : H * " ? "+'"'? T ""!*" ; 8 "+ ? ; ":"* ":! " ")" """ =- "!$"+=!!+ :" ? " ;,+ !D' " =+ " O " ! " " * !+ ' O H!"" " "H )" "!"!!:!":)"$""!8 "- '+ ! "+ ) " $" =!!+ I" H!"" " *+" !" ) :;;1*8 G55F 5F5 8&P55FE%+ C;U 5>>7+:8&5%+ G55C563 83 )!*8U 5>6E+:8F7E28
0D :+="!:"!)?" " :)" : $" :T+ : " * D ? * " 1 G 55C 3%6+ 8CP 5>66+:85CEP 57>>3+ 8>"$" "!P 5>6C+ :8 &EE28 ? " " " :9! H ); "! H:9 1: 2+ = " !:"! ) " O ! " " " !);+ H"-'- " O+ != ' H ); "! H:9+ " " :)" :$":T:! 1 G5535%E+ 83PA+ 0#V W #0W ) #=#"+)+:8F>28
:! ::" " " ()(=:: ; " 5&" )" 080H" 5%+ !5 0+ " " )! :( " " :T ! : ) : "+' ?H: "$":!)"!#8 " " "+(==!!+)!:) !=" "!; " ': ":) * "1*8" 5%+ !3 0P" &C28
: " : ) + ! ? H : !"! :9! "!=" : " ! " T " " !*" ; !* " * :( - ? " *! !"" ! " - ' ! H" !*" ; :) :( + ? " *! H" " H -:"" :9!+H"-'- :"" !)" 1*8 " 5&>+ ! 5 P !+ " : ""+ * """+ " D ?+5>6%+:833&28 :" ) ?H " !*" ; !* " * :( " ! )! ! " :!;8 +:(-); )""!*";
45&3643777 -E453-
!* " *+ ?H ? ? ; ; *" " (" !*" 1" 55%+ !5" )H" 5&>P G55C3%6+ 8C 2+ 5>66+:85CEP !+:8 "8:=5E>+33&28
<:( * " !"! :! F !; 5>>>8 : ? " !"!:; !G 3& 37778 <"'"-'? ?< ; " =8 G ( " "" ?:" !:" =" * !5&:";3777+ :"!! :!:" <( = :!)'<" 6385 01 5>>7+:8C7328
%8 !*"*!:: " 33:";"57";3777+ " ":" 1" 6583 028
F8 !:! ?$" )! <:: " :( " 0- +:!""" (D?<C5 D "377C+5>";3777 "! C7D+"?- ");'*1" 658C 028
E8 0 <" %3 0+ <:9 ? "" " : != = =) <;) : : :" " = ' :" ""'!:" 8
""=:':"; : 8 ::" "' "" " " : " 1" " :" " <:9! ) 2 : <:9+ " ;" + * < "" + "!$"" +"," "* : "1 " ) ::" " " XF75728
<:(+ = ; : " :" ! ?< :! " " !"!+ :!"" :!" " " : " 0- "! :9!:"">H7>F*8E%8 ; !:"'"!=?""<":""!8
68 H" 5& 8 5 0+ !" ) "8 C& " 8 0+ : " H; =" :H:9! #? " " ! " ) - ' :" ) :: " " 8 :9 )" )9 , :! ?" : ( :"; " )!' !+ ('?" " : " : "$"!"* H;D"! 8
H; =" :9 " " " * !:" " : H:9"Y# ":; : ": 8 "!=+ ; *!!1 G 2!!'! "!!: ?:; "! H:9H"8%3 0" !""" ":; 1 5>6E
45&3643777 -6453-
:833728H:9? H? "":"""Y#") " : :" H"8 %3 0+ ? "I : H; =" !:" ("= !1 5>6%:8F&F28
G !,:!"?<; =" !=!:= " $" ? O = " B ' ) " "" : != = =)+ : <:9+ : :" != " < 0 1 5>E6+ :8 3%>P 5>E3+ :8 F6E28 :" ? "" ?< ; = : " - ;)" : :" :" "" ? <:9 ) ! - "" " : != = =)+ O <, " : < * " ' != " "! :"" ' <;<*"1*8 G 36D 5>63+ 5>6C+:857528
>8 ? H:9 " : + = !:" "+ ' " " ; + = ! : - + "" ? : H, " : " O :; "! " ==!1*8F77C " )HG 0::" " " - P G 55& E>+ 8 CP 55C 3%F+ 8 CP 5>66+ := 5CF+ 8CP G5555EC+ 5>6%+:=F&>+ 83828
Q=Q+ *""""::#9 ?? :!": ' H,"! ? :" , * ! ) :""- 1*8F77&28?H " H !"! 9+ G H" "D !*!! ' H" E%&+ 5 !+ !" ) H" E%>+ 5 ! 8 *!" ' " + "" :#=!H "" +=" "N+!:"+' H!= !"!+$?H)#?" ! + =?H?" "" ":!= =' ) ":? !:"H$="" "80"!:"!#=!H "" =" H" E%F Q " = ! ! =! ,:!" "+ !=" : ? :" " )" ! )"=+? "=" ::" """ :" :!:!" ' *" )"! !"!Q
1 G 57E C%C+ 8 %P G 553 5>6% " H$" 35 ) 5>66 P G"+ S" #" # "V" #S "+ 3( !8+ := 37>"28
<+!*+:" )" "" "" ? !"!+ " " " = " 8 " ( ";" ? "! <= * !"! 98 1*8 G"+ :8 "8 X F%& " F%%+ :8 376>P #+ AW Z R+
45&3643777 ->453-
#V W # ; =" #"+ E( ! " + :8 F>5P G 6F 3E5 " >C 3328
578 A ////////// (= ?< <" : :; " " !#)""! !"!+55B"5>>&8
0D : G +) "") ) "" )" " " " ?<' <? """ " " !!+? "::! :? * "::" < "" + 9, '" " < " <= " -: " " " 1 G 55> &7E 8&P 5>>3:83F> 8E;28
"* + "!!?"") " "" :!= = =) : :" " ) = " $" ! ?< !"! 9 " ); " <"! *" ) ""P: #9:"#(+ !::=!D' )'"1 G55>&7F 8&;28
+ ::" :" !"! ? <" * ) " : "" 5>>C!D'8 !"!!" " );'""!:?8 =:!, " " ? A ////////// " ) "" B" 5>>&8 "!:" " !#)""! !"!8
558 D :""+ G ?< 9!= ==)? H:9*:'? :"$" ;", =!"" ::; "+ "" " ?"$ " 1*8 5>E3+ :8 F>728 ? H " " H, ='"!= "$"!)!H:(?H:" " ""+ " ( :"; "! " =" + H :9 $ "!= ? H "!!-8 ?< <= " < !"! 9+ :"+ : : :+ : , = !)( ? <""" ?< " :": :" 1*8 5>E3+:8F>7P 5>E6+:83F528 ! " ;;< :!="+?< <= "<::! :; "!; =<:91 G576373 8CP 5>6%+:8%5+ 83":8F&6+ 8C;28
538 0 H" E5F ! 5 + H "" " " :" ) : #=! =" " * = != (" # 8 " H? "" "" ; =" )"" =! +"":" ":! :" 8 : ? ""+ : H "" + H; =" H " , ! H "" + * =:! ?"# + H@ " ?
45&3643777 -57453-
::" ? " + ; =" :!" " H ") ? != "! " !"! ""!8
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
; $ !"!!" """!5>>C!D'+!*<" : # "! !: ; P " " : ) <" ) "!+ <"" ): :! (+<08) "<: <=")"" !=!8 ,: ?") : (": "" < "" + ' ) !):: "" ) = *)""= ":9< "+OB""; !)!8
0 D : G + = <" : !:"! ) != = =) <"8 %3 0+ ?< " !"!!" ": ;"O !!: "" " :<? "" *"* 8
<:(+ : : !* <:: " : 9" !"! <;! !! (P ; " + !" " " )"<:""':)?="" "" )"+"<":"+' * 89!=" )?<' :"; 5>>CC>HF3E*+) "!!;!!* F&H&%5*8<!
45&3643777 -55453-
)"+ " ? : " )" ) " "! 5>>% !=( ! " +?) ":$" !!:""8
!": """" !"; :!5>>%" 5>>F+ ? ! <" !"! ' A //////////+ : 53H777*8"'A ////////// //////////+:3FH&77*8P ": : " 5>>E+ ' "+ : 5CH377*8 G " "" ? ) " !"! ! " 8 :+ !"!!<==)=; : (D "5>>E+"' ? !"!!""" ) "!8
" : " " ? < :) " , = <, ) "8 " != (" "! )" *) +? !" ""<? "" ," " ? "!' : " 1 5>6%:8F&F28") ?<: " < !"! = "! 5>>E : " " "" !-'+ < " : ) ? !"! <" ? ""! 5>>6+ ?< <) " : ' #= +<""CHC>F*8
; (+)? :!(+?!*": :;!= ==)<" %3 08
: : :
45&3643777 -53453-
"08 01/ " / "0
$
; < = > =?= &+( "#
58 * )! :: " *! : A ////////// " //////////8
38 ' ) ' A ////////// 5H%77*8'" ":" :" '* "!:8 C8 *:" ?H:)"*":!"$" ! C7 D ( " * " : : ! ! ;*!!+0#V W#*? F+F77& +" ,: 8 ! " K 2 ? ,"" ? ! "! ;" ":! ""?!P;2,:: ?" *"" :) """! P2:" ="":!""8 0 ! " ": " !!"!!!""2;2"2 -+ ;*!! ::"" (?H )! );8 ! " 9 :)+ ? " D " ! H H= " : ( : "8 0" !=" D " ! ! ""?! " H):: ?!"!,:! !"1"85C3+57F"57628 = (K :! "K A - [ \
: *:!"$""" * !,:" ?H'H *!! :=
45&3643777