Contractual Interpretation of Delay Costs Versus Consequential Damages Exclusion
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispute concerned whether a party was entitled to recover under a contract provision granting recovery for costs incurred due to a delay, where the delay was caused by the other party's failure to perform a prerequisite, despite the contract also containing a clause limiting remedies to direct damages and excluding consequential damages. The court reasoned that the clause limiting remedies to direct damages and excluding consequential damages did not bar recovery for the specific costs incurred because the non-performing party's breach of the prerequisite triggered the separate contractual provision allowing recovery for delay-related costs, which were interpreted as direct damages arising from the breach, not consequential damages.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Interpretation of Delay Costs Versus Consequential Damages Exclusion: The court reasoned that the clause limiting remedies to direct damages and excluding consequential damages did not bar recovery for the specific costs incurred because the non-performing party's breach of the prerequisite triggered the separate contractual provision allowing recovery for delay-related costs, which were interpreted as direct damages arising from the breach, not consequential damages.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court ordered the appellant to pay the court fees for the federal court proceedings.
Testo completo
&'()*&*))' &+(,&*))-
.
/ 01/ # / #0
% *- 2 *))-
'3 4 5
% 6666666666 ! ! " #$$ %&' '( $ &$ ' $$
#770 # 8/"090 0 $$ & ' $$$& ' ) *+ , -.
!" # $% / 012/
% :% ! '&$$ ' 5 '& 6 0444 %77$ ' %/ $.$'$& 8$/!- 9 $7 & "$ :::::::::: ( '%$.$'$& &$ !!$ & ;
% $& %77 !$7 ;
%& $<& !- ' $$ ' =/ 34 <.$ 0443 ;
% ' ' 3 > 044? && 7&& $6 ' $ . '$7$$ ' $ @.$ %@$$ <'$$$ ;
! A ' 02 . 6 044? 3- # 6 ' $6 !&$'& ! "' $ B <@ ' $ ( %& .$ '$ , ( ' ;
% %& A !- ' $6 7&'& ' ;
!- $6 7&'& & %&$ ' $C <@ $6 ' $ 0+ <.$ 044D ;
! A ' + .$ 044D $6 7&'& ' & <@ ' 02 . 6 044? ! !$$ $&@$- ' $6 '- ( 'E <@ ' %&$ .$ && $.$'& ! $6 7&'& .$ !$$!& , !&' , '&$$ ;
&& .)& $6 ' $ ! (%$ , . ' $'& ;
! &$ ' 2 $ 044D ' '& , ( %$$ ' $ !$ F ' !$$ ' $6 %/,/'$ . <@ $( ($ % 7$ ! !$ ! , '&$6&$ ! %A ' 02 . 6 044? G ;
! ' $6 ' $ <& ' ' ' &$ 2 <$ 044D ;
.$ &@ $$& $$ ' %77 !$7 ;
%$ , &@' !!& ( % .$ $& , . !' !&' %.$ & (% 7&.$ 044D ;
1324010443 / ?12/
%$ 7$ .$ ( !!$ ' ! $ 7 $ ' $$ 7$$- - '$77$$ ;
%$ -. 7$ ( '&$$ $$@$ ' 5 '& 6 0444 %$'$($ ! ) ' '$ ' ( /$ $ #& ' $&H
( %H *+ H 0 ' $ 7&'& %/ .$$ .$. / = !!$6 ! @$ , %/$.$'$& . ' %H 53' $ 7&'& %/$.$'$& / 8'$!$$ !!$6 %!- ' .$@ <(% ?3 '& 6 0440 & .$@ ' $ 7&'& !$ @&& ' '$ ' $ / 3 <.$ 044? I 30+ DJ+ 303 ?JJ9 % ! ' '&$$ !&.$ (% &. % ! '%77 !$7 A $ '&$$ ! !$ !&$ ;
% ! %H 22 H 0 , D ' $ 7&'& !&' ' $$$. / !!$6 ;
%$& ? ' '$!$$ %$& ' !&$' ! $ %77 !$7 , ( %$& $7&$ %.$ $& ;
' ' ' $$ ' %77 !$7 $& '&$ ;
% %!- !' 7 ' ( ' ' ' $$ ' %77 !$7 % ! && '&!& ! $ $ ' '&$ ' < , ! ' $7$$ ' '&$$ $$@$ , .$ 5 '& 6 0444 ;
%$ .$ ( % , $& , . !' '& ' !&' ! %A (% 7&.$ 044D ;
$ !' !&.$ ' ! 6$ $$ ' '&$ ;
%$ .$ ! 77 ' &!$ ' '&$$ ' 5 '& 6 0444 ( $ & $ $ , $ A .& ;
@$7 ! %6 '%$'$$ ' ) ' '$ ! A & & ;
' ' ' &6$ ' %77 !$7 $$ $.6 ;
1324010443 / D12/
($ (%$ $ $ % '.$ !&' , !& ' $&A !& $ !!K ( $7 ! 7. ' %E&$ $ &'$ ' '&$$ %$ !& E ($ !. A $.(& , %!!$ ' $ $ ;
% ! ( ( %$ ' $$@ 7' 7$ ' ($ % ! ( %77 !$7 ! A &6$ ;
1324010443 / 212/
#07 01/ # / #0
% %
; < = > =8= '+* #$
3H & $.6 ' ' ' &6$ ' %77 !$7H
0H &. 7'H
?H 7 !$ ' (L !. 7 !& A ' '&$ ' ') ?% '- $7$$ ! !$ '& '& $6 7&'& ' =#M$C#7($ J J44D $ E !$H '&$ ! A !@&H & $ '$ N 9 $'$( E ( '&$$ '&$ 6$ $ ! ' '&$$ (&; 69 E! ! ( $7 $ $ !.$ ' ' '&$$; 9 ! $@ ' !&H =$ & $ $ ! $ && & && 9 69 9 $/' $6 7&'& ' ! ! $- (L$ '. '& $.6H & $ ' $ ) ' !. ($ <$ $$ ( '&$$ (& L.!! ' ( && E!&'$& 8H 3?0 34J 345 9H
@77$- N &$' N
"$/$ O $ B
!$ 7 ' !& A $7$& E !$ $$ (L, L77$ 7&'& ' $ ! @77
1324010443