Statutory Interpretation Superseding Common Law in Property Disputes
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involves a dispute over whether certain property rights or obligations are governed by a specific statutory framework or common law principles, primarily focusing on the interpretation of relevant provisions defining the scope and application of that framework in the context of the underlying transaction or relationship. The court reasoned that the language and legislative intent of the statute clearly dictated its application to the facts presented, thereby superseding any potentially conflicting common law rules, and consequently affirmed or reversed the lower court's decision based on this statutory construction.
Regesto Legislator
Ufficiale; AVS ; ASSURANCE-VIEILLESSE, SURVIVANTS ET INVALIDITÉ ; LOI FÉDÉRALE SUR LA PARTIE GÉNÉRALE DU DROIT DES ASSURANCES SOCIALES ; DOMMAGE ; PROCÉDURE ; ÉCHELONNEMENT DE LA PROCÉDURE ; PROCÉDURE ADMINISTRATIVE ; OPPOSITION(PROCÉDURE) ; CONDITION DE RECEVABILITÉ | LAVS.52; RAVS.81; RAVS.82; LPGA.52.1
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied for the order regarding court costs.
Testo completo
#$%&'#())* +#,-*#())%
+
+. .+ . .
-/ 01 (- 23 ())%
0
.+ 4 .. 5 4+ . .## .+ . 6.+ + .7 ! "# $%#& '()! *(+* ,-
02
8888888888 35#
98888888888 $/0.1111111111"%.$$01111111111 %&234&&&3&%."&
!"
(79
. 4+
*/ #%"33:1111111111 33#";#"%.."* */9 -&* '##%#%"&"<;3$%-=1111111111 >#426. (++*?&4&&&&%$3&#%#%"&@1111111111 A"$,#B& #%"33C/
(/ (+ . * ! (6 %D * ! 0. 1111111111 3 #" 42.#"=1111111111 -"#;-&&/,#" "5%"%33$#$0.E1111111111>#42?&5&&&#%"33/ $- " , - 33 #" ;# "%.." 4 ""=1111111111 $#&(83".F* 9/
8/ G5&&##$%#$3&F&2"3"" #%"33 & F& $., #" $%%"3 $ >;. %53 H $#&*>* &2>%.&5&&3#;34&3" 0%# 1111111111 -" & .##% #-&& & 3%&. &2####./
6/ (6#$.F(++*& F&$.,#"##%$&5&&& #%"33/
'/ I I 0 A"$,#B&"##C$%#"5&& "3"2%&*+!J9+95/!+?"%#%##%"&#%$K3#$# 3".F* )5#3G#.%%#"%.$##4#"%#%#$% 5%.%$%5##%&&3G#.%%##&23;&3#"3"/
9/ 3"#%#(9%-.F(++(&"##3"&.3?3$%" %..; ? 0. E1111111111 &# "%#%# #%"&# .$K3# # 4 &# 5#3G#.%%#5##%..%#2.%%& 29' 5/!+ ?0%#1111111111.G.&#%..)!26*+5/''/
)/ &2.3#%"%#&0.E11111111115%.3%$$%#% "% "3"#%$"*93".F(++(/
!/ & .G. 0%# 1111111111 3;&. 5%.3 %$$%#% "% & 3"#%&"%"/
/ 8+>-(++8&"##4#-& %..##%"%&"%# ., 2 A"$,#B & "%..##% "%#C & .&-3 # %$$%#%#5%.3#$0.E11111111110%#1111111111"% ##3"#%#(9%-.F(++(/
)*6 )7(++8 879 *+/ 0%#1111111111"%"&>"4G$").#(++8/ 0.E11111111115.G.&*8.#(++8/
/ 3"#().(++8&"##$##3###"%"&#%#/#$# 35###%3;&.$#&#"%"&#%#$3"3#$&#"%# (8>*>&&(++8/
. +
*/ &%;-%##&J%;#%>"AC33.%53#3,# &*%D(++8 F&"%&###"##%"&#"%.$%#3'>;# %$3#-"$3#'#$$&3#*9>;######A/*&/ '9 C/
?&J&%&J3&"%#*9>;######$& F&533&& ()>-(++6A I*8+*+9C& %#&;-%#%$3&*853- #$%#%#%;$. F&"%&###"# #%"&# #3; ## ##### ? %# >;# &# " # &J &J3&"%%-H>;######/
# "%# %$F&"& F&533&#G* >&& (++6 "%5.3 4 & #$%#% #% "%# & #%&% & $&# %&&3"%5%.#"%L%533&AG*/*!87(++6C/
;&. ## & 4#% &J"%#%&3 F& "%& # ##"##%"&#&3"&34&"3%"F&$%-G.# "#-&5%"3%;%%533&#%&J%"""&J/')& &%533&9%"%F(+++#&$;33&%###"##%"&# A C/
(/ &%;-%##&J%;#%>"AC33.%53#3,# & * %D (++8 F& "%& # ##"# #%"&#/ %5%.3. ? &J"&8&38##$%#%##%#&#"##%#-&J3 -;&&%$#-& %..##%"%&"%#%33 #.## J%55" F& "%& # ##"# #%"&# # #"4A"5/"&'9C/"%.$3" F&"3### 3F&$%>;"#J#$,"/
8/ &% & $%"3 $$&"F& >#42 8* 3".F (++( & "## "%.$#%3"$$&"%&2/!*&/*,;&.#&2##" -&&###--#8*%"%F* 6)A C&3$%2%..; "#3 $ &2.$&%K #$%#F& - &2"& '( & &% 533& # &2##"-&&## #--# (+ 3".F * 69 A C "# % %F#-% %&& % $ 3;&;" ;- # $#"$%# &3;&#/ 2.$&%K$#+>%#,#&%5"%&3"#%3$%
)*6 )7(++8 679 %..; 5%. %$$%#% $,# & "## "%.$#% "% " 3"#%H.#&2/!*&/( / "#.&3"#% 3$% %..; & "## % # &# 8+ >%# ,# & "%##" &2%$$%#%$%&"#$3"-&2%3"%#"%#&4& &2.$&%K#%%."&A/!*&/8$.,$<# C/
6/ ,# & * >- (++8 & # 3 -; "4 & $%"32"%3$%%..;&2/'( "%3&%-" &##$%#%#$3"3#/ #&"##"%.$#%5&&%>%#-&% $-%3"#%&%?&3$%%..;#&%&2/'(&/( ##-;$#&*>-(++8&$#%$%#-& $%##F&35%$$%#%#+>%#"%"3"#%A/'(&/* C/ $ & "## "%.$#% % 3#%.# $&# "%.#3"#%#%$$%#%.%-3#3&$$%$3 - &2/ '( &/ ( / $#% $%#- $ $ & # 5%. "%##+>%#$,#F&"%&# ##"##%"&#A/ '9')9+ C/
'/ 2/!(&/($.,$<# #$%#4&##$%#%#.3&&#& $3#&%#%$#$$&"F&#H$#%#"%#H"3"#5H3# - #% 3 -;/ "% %5%# $# #$%#%# "%"&2$$&"F&3#&.$##$#"$%#5%.&&#%..& 3;.#%#&%$$&"F&#&"#%M&3"#%3$% %..;33"%#%#&J.$&2"%%M%$$%#% 335%.3"%"&&">#42?5(++(%$,#&23-;& / $%##&4#%#-%#&#"###"%.$#%#%#&# "#%>%##?5-&%&%?3$%%..;$&-%2 "%%#&&#%-3"#%#%$$%#%$.?&23##3 ## & -% "%# F& "%& 3-&&. F& 533&###"#A I C/
&% & >#$" % N % &# %-&&# $#"$%# $%"3& #%$$&"F&#..3.3;&.&>% &3-;$%&#$%"3#3$%%..;#&%&2/'( / # # & "# 2 "% 4 33 3 "% (++( & $%"3 # 3; $ &2" % #% "2# & %- % 4 #2$$&4/ #""#&"##"%.$#%%?&#&J%$$%#%J $#%"%#3"#%3$%%..;3"#%#%$$%#% 4$G43$&-%"%#$&$#%$%#-A(++6 $;(##C/
9/ &2#$," &2"% 3$% %..; #$"-. .&-3 # %$$%#%#0.E11111111110%#1111111111333 & 8+>- (++8/ - & >#$" $3"3 "2# $ "%#34 &
)*6 )7(++8 '79 %-%4#2$$&4/ %..&-3"###"&"F%&&$%"3 2"%$3-%3#%.#4&#"###"%.$#%3"#% #%$$%#%#>?"%#$,#F&"%&###"#/
)/ &3&"%-"%#4&-%%"<%#$&"### &2%""" @1111111111 42& & $$ "% 3"#%#%$$%#%/
!/ -"4$3",&2"%&"###3"&3"-F&&"# &#-%K3$%&$%%"3J3"#%#%$$%#%
/ 0.E1111111111%F$&&. ;"#3$3#3 $.$%5##%&.3'++5/&#%"%K3? 3$#/
0%# 1111111111 23 $# ###3 $ . $%5##%& & $$3?&&.3A"5/ I+*86"%#/6O*()(+' "%#/6FC/
)*6 )7(++8 979
+4 +. .+ . .
02:2 ; <22 2 =" $,(
*/ 3"& "-F& &2"% 8+ >- (++8 .&-3 # %$$%#%# 0. E1111111111 0%# 1111111111 3 $ & I I 0 = :/
(/ -%&"#?&.##$%&$%%"3J3"#%#%$$%#%/
8/ "%. $. 2 .3 ? 3$# '++5/ ? 0. E1111111111/
6/ 5%. &# $# " 4J&&# $- 5%. "%# "% & $3# G # 3& 8+ >%# ,# # %5"% $ $& "%..3 ##3 F& 533& # ##"# "<PQ<%54 9 9++6 %# H.$&#/ 3& $ G $%&%;3/ .3.% %B C 4 H".4&&3"#%&"%3#%F&$&"&3"#% 43O FC H$%# $% 4&# .%5# & #. $%-% . " 3"#%O "C $% # #; % "&& #% $3#/ & .3.% "% $# &# %# 3&3.# 3.33# #%# &# C FC "C "### & F&533&###"#$%$#.,#&"%#4J& -3"&"-F&/.3.%"%#.%"%&#.%K# $- 4 #% >%# # 4 & 3"#% 43 &J-&%$$ # &4&&&&33H$33"%A/*8(*+9*+!C/ ;55,B 3#B =R& @ 0K 0
"%$"%5%.$3#G#%53H$##4J?&J55"533& ###"##%"&#$&;55
)*6 )7(++8