Statutory Interpretation of Tax Liability Amendments
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involves a complex dispute over the validity and effect of various statutory amendments and related regulations concerning tax obligations and reporting requirements for certain entities over several fiscal years. The court's reasoning primarily focused on statutory construction, determining that the legislature's intent, as expressed in the language of the operative amendments and subsequent regulatory guidance, mandated the application of the current, more stringent standards retroactively or prospectively as specified, thereby affirming the imposition of the challenged tax liabilities and penalties while clarifying the scope of required disclosures for future compliance.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 93 LTF; Statutory Interpretation of Tax Liability Amendments: The court's reasoning primarily focused on statutory construction, determining that the legislature's intent, as expressed in the language of the operative amendments and subsequent regulatory guidance, mandated the application of the current, more stringent standards retroactively or prospectively as specified, thereby affirming the imposition of the challenged tax liabilities and penalties while clarifying the scope of required disclosures for future compliance.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in order 1 to rule on the costs of the Federal Supreme Court proceedings.
Cited in order 2 to declare the appeal inadmissible.
Testo completo
#$%&'#() *#+')#)((%
*
*, ,* , ,
'- ./ )' 01 )((%
2222222222 ! "#$ % &'()*!+!*''**, !
!
33 ,* , 4,5,6* ' -./012345 *!*+
!"
916039
, 3*
0, #':::::::::: !*!%*+0.;2! *5+$* 0.<.'' '= > !)**,$+&! 5**!$* '*0.<0!!(?5 ,
1, 4 3 '+% 0..2 =*!+ + +!+ >>+ @ ! ! A::::::::::$ !!(=5 *4 '=&*!!*,
3, 0..0 45* +5! 5*= + !5* %* *'! ' 5*! 5 +&, *!* ' '& ! ! ' * ' 5*! *'!+ ' ! 5* 4 17 B '=% 5!*@=+!%*!B*!* !! **' ,
7, 03 !% 0..7 = + >*+ @ ! 5* ! =! %+ *>!' *!!%!, :::::::::: +'*9! *!!+**!+ '*>!*(+!*!*!*!**!+!!'! 5*'4 12 !% 0..7 C(= 30 !% 0..7 '! @ ( +!*! +5 *@82D*@022D'4105% 0..7,
8, = ++!!!'! 5* '401'+% 0..8,
;, 0 5 *0..;+!+&*+ +'*'= '*!' * !* * '=*'! E F :::::::::: +**! B* >*, *9*)*!+!!'= *!*'=-' '! *' *!!'= &!* ' ! % > *5! @ !! % + * ' *! ! @ 5*9' 5 ( ' ) ' +B* '+)! ' %**!+ ' =+ ' 5*9% B*>* ' *! -!+!*+ >+'*>'=&>+ !*!'=&!*, +(!*! )G! &*+ @ **( ' +'!!* ' =+!%*! B*!* *)* *!!*!* !! ' +*!+> )*5*!*%,
/, = + +C + ' 02 C* 0..; 01 C*! 0..; @ **( ' =+!%*! B*!* , ! ' !* ' 08 C*! 0..; ::::::::::!::::::::::!*'+ + +!!!B+ !*( !*)*!,-' 5*9% B*5**!!**>!=5*!H! ! *!+(')I'*:::::::::: *' %+!*(' (+ ! '=+*' '=B- 5!*!* *5* ' 5 !*> '= *>* -B5+>+!!*5, ' 5*! >!+ ! *!! ! =+!*! +>!+!'@'=! !*' E%* C%F, +*!*(*+@=*'!=!!)*H! '*>!*(+,'**!* ' *!+ ' B > '! )**! 5 !*! +!*! ! *+ &
6073861221 936039 ' !!+*>*!'=!!&!*'-!J,=**!+'! 5* %*!!=+!*!*+,
<, = +'5+!+&*+ +'*'= '*!' 07!% 0..;,=))!'++!4 '=*'!+!*!+!*!!*-5*! ! !!(!,&+!* !*(+=5*!'+! + '*>'$K*'! %!!*('5 !+% ,
., ''' :::::::::: B!>= ++!+&*+ "::::::::::+**! >*'4 (=*>*!+>! '=B-!B+*B+* ' *!*!),$ !'0. )+5 * 0../=-''*))+ !'*!+*!*5*'*(*!(! % +!*!*'=H! >%*(!!! 4)* +5+*!-+! *' J!+ ' *!, %*! ' '*))** ' '*!* '= ' & ! % '+ *!*>*)*!*'=!!*! >*('-!4 5&,(!* *!'5* =*&*!*!BL!!!*!+!!&*9'+ *),
02, 8 0../= ++!+&*+ ::::::::::+'** '=))*!'=*E*9 4M F( !(= *' ! 5*%*!**%,=))!*+!*!B *(!'+)**!*5' !(=* 5*!''+ ''' !!*'= 9*5*'*!+,
00, '! ' 1 * 0../ = + '++ ! '' 4 ' =))* ! ' = 9*5*'*!+ E*9 4M F 5*! @ =%!!* '= *!!* )***(= ! *'' ' B* 5*!'% + * ' *!,
01, ! +'* ' 0; C* 0../ @ =!!!* ' = ::::::::::*'*(+(=**!+'! 5*'= ++!*!!!'40/ )+5 * 0../@' 5*9' >*$K' *! *' *!!'= +!!'+ *), !!'=+5!*'=+!!'!*!'' +!' =+B')) !! * !*(!@ *'=!*5*!+%*! % ,
03, 30 * 0... :::::::::: ' ! *! +'** @ = '(**'*(+(=+5!*5 =*5*'*!+ **!*& %, !*!* (* ' *! ' * '= * 5* )** *! !9H! !! ' !* '=*!!*)*>+,
07, '! ' 10 !% 1220 ! '=% 5!* +'* ' = 9 *5*'*!+E*9 4M # F(*5*!+!+'!+ = & !* *'**** '= + ' !'=& !*, # + '*>!* *5! -! *) *!+ ' ! 5*M ! % !) ' & *!! ) ' B*>* B *( ! ' 5*9% B*>*' *!B *(+*''+ *)''> +-,
6073861221 976039 *!'5 B!>*( +' 5*9% B*>* +'*! @ ' *! +!*! 5+ '+)**! '** * *!!*) '+)**!* ** ( ' B*>* '*)) 5 * '*!* ' '** ' !&! ' ! %!!*(!'+>++ !*),' !+ !*!=+!*! !*4 ! &*% =& B!>*( ! * &*!*! ! >*( (* '*! @ ! % !) ' &,*!'5 ! B!>*(*!+'! 5*+!*! '82D,
!!-B*! * 5+(=& !*+ +!*!+!!'+ *) + ! '! =+*' ! ' =& !* +!*! +5+ ' '> + - @ +54 , !% !+ **! '! %'*5**> '*'!*!'=*!**!+!'%**!+B+'*!B*! *'+!***'* !, !+!!+!*! ! 0..0!0..1 ( !*!5*!'G >!*')* *'=*5*'*!+' * ! N ) 4 +!*! ! >*(! '++'+ ' *'!, $ -B*! *( *!+ ' ! 5* C!*)**! **!+ ' ! 5* ' ' /2D,
! ' +''+**!*'**** & !' # ! & *+5*+>4 !'*))+ !'*'-B*! !! ( =+!! '+ *) 5*! H! (*)*+ ' - @ +54 * !J! ' -, =+!! '+ *) +!*! 4 = H! ' ! 5* ' '+% 0..8 ! !* 5 '+4 ' ) 4 ' =& !*+ 0..1, & ! =+*>*!'5!* !'=5*'-B*! !+(! @'! '= *!*'=+!!'+ *)**('+5+ *!+,
*'*!'5>%!!!'5* B!>*(! -B*! *( E(( '+ +F '**!* ' *!+ ' ! 5* +!*! !*+@82D,
08, 00 )+5 * 1221 K:::::::::: ' $ 5* +'* +>* + ' = 9*5*'*!+ E*9 4M $# +F (=* =- 5*! '=**!+ ' ! 5* ' % ' = 9*5*'*!+, =+*' '+ *) **! H! !*! ' ! +!* ! %*! 5* ' + * )' 5* * ' = +, * )*! ('> +'**!!*'*!+'! 5* *-B*! *() =%C!''*5 >& *+'!&!!(*!!**(* '4 ! =5* -B*! *( ' # '* +'*!*! ! '=& !* ! '*!*'*!%,
0;, 8 1221 = !*)*+ @ = + C! ' '+** ( * C!*! '' ' !!* !*) ( =!!*! @ !+ (= +!*! =5*! 5 '=*5*'*!+ ' *!4 +* *%
6073861221 986039 )+'+ ,= + +!*!'5+ *!%HB!'!*5*!+ ! *! @! 5* 5 *4 '=&*!!*,
0/, = + )*! *!* @ C! * ' 07 1221 ' :::::::::: (= *>+, =+!*! +B*% ( = ) !!* ! @ =! ' & ! ' ::::::::::'= !'*9H, !!'+* !%C!*5 ' ( ! 5*! = + ! )* * '5 *!*H! +,
0<, '+**'1; 1221= )* + C!''+**! C!+ ''' !!*, =+!*!*%'='!! (=!!*!@!+ +!+ = +G!5 '=*5*'*!+,
0., !'005 *1221= +*! C!+ ! !!'+** 4 ' **!' !*4 '= 9*5*'*!+E*9 4M ** ' F ! @ =!* ' !! '+** =! * '= !'=*5*'*!+!*4 !%*'** !@=! *' ' +'!!* )*,
12, 07 * 1221 = + +!+ , 5! *!* ! '*!* &*!! ! & ! ' # &9H ! ! ' * ! $# + ! +!*! '=5* (=* - 5*! * ' *5 =5* ' +**!, ** % ' ! ' =& ! -B*! $ $ *5*'*!+'/8D*'5*!*H! ,
10, +5*'08C*!1221= C!' , ! ' ! ' # ! '= *! ' 5 !*( * =&*!*! !!*! -! + * *!+ ' ! 5*, *! ' 5 -B*( * - 5*! * ' !! ( ! % !) ' & '! )) *! = + =+!*! *+ @ %*'*!+ -B*! *( > 5 ! =! O*! ''=**!+'! 5*'= 9*5*'*!+, )*=+*' '+ *) +!! +!* * +!*! ( =!!*! @ !+ =5*! !4 *5*'!'*,
11, +*('11G!1221 ! *!+'*' , =+!! '+ *) '! )) *! =+!*! +!* ** ( =5*!&**!+& !' # ,$ *!4 'C * ' > 5*!+'!!*!-B*! *('5*!H! (*)*+'+54 !*!+' ! 5* +!*! *'+*%! +'*! +!! 5% H * = *! !(*!'5 B!>*(,
13, ''0/'+% 1223 *%!' * @ (* =))* 5*! +!+ ! * '4 0 G! 1223 '+*'+ ' )* & !* -B*! *( :::::::::: +**! -B*! * !
6073861221 9;6039 -B!B+ * 45* *(+& !*(!*+@=& ! ! 5* * !* '+* +! ' *! '! =! )*! >,
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
18, $*! @ !! & !* ! '*)*+ * ' '+! *!*'1/*1227!''+@(=*5*'*!+'82D**! !'022D++**!*!,
1;, * '1<*1227= *) + *%'+(=& !* ' ::::::::::=+!*! ' !! +*!*' , =& !* 5*! +!+ * $# + (* 5*! 5+ ( ::::::::::=5*! **'+ !*' *!4 'C * '' !(=*-5*!*'&! ' !,=!!*!-B*! *(+!*! +>4 ! **! *!4 )* '! %!) *!! !B>**5*'!,
, *
0, *>5* = >*!*C'*** EF+!+'*)*+!*!*!+'4 0 G!1223 *%!' *+'8C> '! +*'!!5*9 +*'!8+!!0;C> E !,0!, !8; F,
6073861221 9/6039 $*!@=!*'=+!*'0;C> *%)+'+ 1/C5* 1227E "03202;F ' *>5*'!+03)+5 * '**!*! *!* >! !!! *%!' * ' *+> @ ! * C> !*!* ' =!!! ' =+!*'5&C> ,
$!!! '' *!%* *%)+'+ ' H!'0 C*! 1227 )* + ( '**!* ! *!* !*!*! !* !*!+!*!) ' O!' *!)+'+ E H!0,0<361227F,
>! ** ' (!* ' =*!*!!**!+ ' *% ! ' **'+ +( +!*'! *%5*!H! * 5) '+ >!* '' *!)+'+ *!= = !,8/' * )+'+ !* >++ ' * ' ; !% 1222 E*9 4M F! +5*> 0 C5* 1223,
1, ) +!@P !,3,3''**!*! *!* '*'075% 1221 '*)*! *! '*! 5! P! + 5*> ' * +*!+ ! '! '5! ** ! ' !*4 'P 9*5*'*!+ ! +!+ ! * 'P))* *% ! ' *,+!' *%'+!'4 +!%* O! ' +!*!*>,
3, ! O+'% '*)*!*''*'= 9 *5*'*!+, '=4 ' !!)* +>* '**!* 5*> C(= 30 '+% 1221 +> ' ** ( C> ' *=@ ' *'+ !*'*)*!*'' *! ' =+!! ' )*! !+ * @ '! '+! *! ' '+** *!*>* E " 01/ 7;/ *',0 010 3<; *', 0%Q ), +>! '**!* ! *!* !,<1,0 F, +!*!*> +(&*+@ *4 ' '**!* ' * )+'+ = 9*5*'*!+ ' 0. C* 0.8.E*9 4 F !' 4>! = 9*5*'*!+'0/C5* 0.;0 E*9 4 F5*> C(=30'+% 1221,
7, ++') !'+**+ * +! ! 5%@ ) 5 !' !,;. !<7'*)+'+ = 95** ! 5*5! ' 12 '+% 0.7; ' ! 5*> C(= 30 '+% 1221E*9 4 $F,
8, =%C! ' ! ' '+! * !& '=*5*'*!+ ' = + ! +(!' *!@ !'=*5*'*!+,
;, $ = !, 7 , 0 =*5*'*!+ ! '**!* ' *!+ ' >* ++ ! ' > ' + (* +! '= !!*! @ !+ B-*(! 5!'=*)* *!+>+*!'='*'=
6073861221 9<6039 *'!,=*+1 +*(=*5*'*!+! +!+ 5'4(=! ! ! > 5*!+ @ 5 * ' *! & !!* ! ! *'+ !*, ' *!@ !!'+! *+ = !,1<,0 (*'* (= +' *!@ !=*!*5*'@72 !*, !! !*4 *5*'*!+ ' ;; 163 D * ! '= '* *5*'*!+'82D*!'=( ! *5*'*!+'72D* 5 !''&*4*+,
$ =*+ 1 ' H !* =+5!* ' =*5*'*!+ 5 ' ! 5* ( =*5*' *! %!* & I! =!*5*!+ (= ! *%! !!' ' * 4 &+!* +5! ' ' +'!!* ! ! ! '= *!!* +(**% + ' B+ ' ! 5* ! + 5(=* *!%!* =*=+!*!*5*',
/, *( 5 ! = 9*5*'*!+ ! '! ' *! @ ' !!* ! %+ ')*!+'*&, C> '(!*C *'*((*! >*'= !C>' *'*5!% ' '!(*!+!%*!*! '+'*E "01108<F,
' '=+5!*'=*5*'*!+!RB'+'**!@ ! C>! =+!! ' !+ ! @ *'*( ' ( ! ( !*5*!+ = + ! *% ' ! 5* , ! '+ +'* !*!! ++! !* '+! * ( ! 5& ! *%!&*> '= +E "0181;0*',7Q008037*', 1Q007307*',3Q02808F,
(* 5 %!'= !+'*(*!'+! *! =!(*!*!*>*&* !!*!)*!=%C!'=+!')*+( ! )' ' & ! (=* +>! *'+ !**!& *+(=**!+!++!%***' '* E4F(' *!*'!&!+'**!* !)*( * ' =& ! *! %* !*5+ E " 011 0;2Q $ 1222 ,087F, ! ( ' & !* '+ !' ' +' '**! !*5!+!%* '+**! %'=% 5!* )'* ! '=*5!*>!* 4! ** (= * * ' '* !(& !%!*!@' +!!5*!C> *! + ! * >! (= *'* ! ! ' '! ' %*9)'+E "018383F,
' *!)+'+ )*& *!* *4 '= +* - ' 5 **'*% +*!*' 5=*(!!*4 ' +' '**! !*5,
<, $=>*! ' (!* ' ! % !) *% )+'+ ' '+)** )'! **! +!' ' #$#
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
)! -B*& *! )*> ! % ' !!*!@!+!*%'P! O **!+'>*'P !,7 ,0 ,)! -B*&!*! *! * ! * 4>! P4 * ! !* ( '*>!* +'* +*P*-!!*!@!+-B*((*+(*5!@'*E "01/ 1.71..*',8*)*Q " %*+'0<!% 12216070621F,
+! " !+' +**+!* (!&'*!* '( !4 *5*'!!H! &! %!) ' &E " '01 1227;<3623'!*+@%*!**',1,1 )* + " %*+ ' < C* 1227 1<1623 ! 1<3623F, 4 5* ++!+ ( + '= !!*! -B*( -! 5 ' '* !!!+ +'*! ! ( ! % !) ' & !*!*! % ))*! '!! **!!* ' *!+ ' ! 5* ! K! *>+ ( ' ! ! % =! O*! (=&!*! **!!* ' > ' + ' *!+ ' ! 5* 5!'* @*5*'*!+'*)=**)!*!5 ! +5+ *!+ (=%C!*5! * 5 ' *!+ ' ! 5* 5*! *%!H! &*>+'= + *!* !% *+!+, $ " !4 &*>*% '= )) ! ' 5!+ ! ' ! +*!+> !*' '! 5**! + *)! '= %*'*!+ -B*! *( '= *!+ ! '= ' +
6073861221 9026039 * !!*!' *!4 *5! +!! !**!*!+! !M
9 ' ))!* B *( *!! E ' V>*! W W>XF ! '*) =+!'! * + +**' %
9 !'=*!+> !**'!!*)!!*'5*
9 +!! -B*( *!*+ +5!* *% !B+ !*( (! *!+! =+B ! *%+ !* ' ' +!* ' )*!-B*(E )*! ** !* +''*)*!''*F
9 =+B'! *!!%!* !6!!** ) & 4>' = !!' ' +B%**!!*'+*!'!*5!*!')) !' + ! ))!'! %!) ' & E " +*!+'01 1227*',1,1,3F,
*% @=& !-B*! '=*'*( @='**! !*! *%*! ' ( + '* ' -B*( * !!! ' ! ' )!* +>! ' *!4 !*+ ! '=+!%* ' *4 %C!*5 * !! ! ' !*!!* -B*( = + ! & !*5*!+ B+ ' ! 5* > + ' E " +*!+*',1,1,7F,
!@ %*'*!+-B*! *(9*=!'* '+!!'+ *) ( * &9* 5! H! (*)*+ !!*! -B*( *'+'! ' ! % !) ' & * =* +54! H! % ' = +*!* ' '* +'* ' *)!* E +!*5F '=>!'! %E " +*!+*',3,3,0F,
(* ))!* !*( *!! (* * =! '=*) *!+)!*'! 5*5!H! * *'+ !*'= +*!*' !4 *5*'!'! %!) ' & ( * !*!! ' *'* )5 '= B > -B*( +!* + 5 *) +>!*5 =)) ! ' 5!+ &*>*% ! ' E " +*!+*',3,3,1F,
$=>*! ' *!4 ' =+!! -B*( *!*+ >' ! V)*! ' '*X ! !!! ** ' !* )*! ** ' 9* *%+ ! ' +!* ' )*! -B*( " +*+ (= )*! '* !* +''* *'=!!!*!'=!* ' B**('='+B >'=%*>!*(!*'*=+!*!C *'*(! !*!E " +*!+*',3,3,1F,
6073861221 9006039 ., ! B @ = ' 5* *5* =5* ' & !* ' # !' ::::::::::(*!!!'&@*!+ +*' '82D' )*& +5!=!!*!@!+,
)*! ' '! ( & !* *! *!4 C * '!* O! *5 %!,
$ * '! ' & ! '!+ ! % !) ' & *!!!=+!!'+ *)(!(*)*+''> + - # ! ' '-!B-* :::::::::: ! *) *!+'! 5*, # *'+ +' +*!*' **(!+!!'+ *)+!*! +!*@= H!'! 5*' ! 50..8*!&' !*@*!'*'!! '+4') 4 0..1, ))!9**'*(+=5* C* +!+ 5!0..8'! %'=B !5* %**!+> +=+ 5' ' !') 4 , !!*+'*%+>!H! !>+ :::::::::: E), , 08 ' !F, )*! ( ! % '+ *) ! '5 *! B *( =- B> *, +!! *!* ' C * ' +*!+ ! +!! '+ *) !*! = !!*! -B*( *'+'! ' ! % !) ' & ' ! (= %*'*!+ -B*! *( ! H! '*, =C! ( ! %'=B *)!!5+5+ *!+C!*)*!@& **!+'! 5*,
!&! *!4 !)) '=))!* B *( *!! ! ( ' 5 !*> '= *>* )!* ' B*L !B ' *! '+ + ' ! % !!*( ! '+>++ !*) '+ + '=B- B!+ +* ! '=%+*!+, $ ! 5 !*> ! HB+ ! )* = 9BJ>! !*5*'!, !*!*'*(=*!*)+>!*5 =)) !'5!+&*>*% *'! 5*'4 (=*!*)!!!+)*' !'*!+,
*!4 ' ! *! * ' !! *)!!* ' 5* =! *)!! *,
!H! &( ! +!+!!-B*( *!*+'4 (=*)!'!! (=*'*!%!5+' &E !' '&*4 )! @ =R> ' ! * * 0.<7 ! ' ) 4 0..1F, ! +> '& !*'4 ! +>!(=*5*'*!+' *'*0..2 = ) >**+ ' N 'G '4 ! )!*!')* +*!*(*!'!!!+ $# + (* 5*! '*))**! (* * +! *! !B>* -B*! *( *5*'!, & ! ' # '!!! ** (
6073861221 9016039 **!!*)!*! )*' !! !*5 5+ ' & B *( E, 0< ' !F, +*! !!)* +*! '!*'=! *!!+'*!&!*'+ (*VY *!!9 H! !! '=+* '* ! -!!>* ' )*=+!!'+ *)!%**+X, ! ::::::::::*!+>!'=5* (=! *!!-B*! *(+**+ *!+* +!!-B*(* +5!! *!+ ' ! 5*, +5!* % '4 *% !B+ !*(' !(!!'*!*' *!4 ! *,
(* ! *!!%!* ) & 4>'= !! ' +B%**!!**!+B+(=** **H! B+ @ ! '=5* (+ ' !*5!* ! ' 5* )*! '=)) ! ))*! ! ))!'! %!) ' &,!@ 5 !!)*( !%H! '*+@!! @ ! *!! !*'+ ! -B!B+ * (* *! & ! +* @>! +!!'!+!*!+'! 5*,=* !' *!4 '*!'4 H! '+ +,
+! ' (* +4' ( * *!4 C * '!* ! +*+ '!! ( -B*( ' ! ! *))*! * !! ' ! ' , $ ))!* !*( B *( ! =+B ' ! *!! +'*& *! ( !)) !'5!+=!= &*>*%, '! *!4 *)!!5=*!*!+&*>+C * ' @ **!!* ' *!+ ' ! 5*, ** 4 +*!* ' =% ' *!!* ! ' '* +'* *% ' + !* ( '*!* )*&+ " ! =4 * O! !4 *5*'! & ! % !) ' & '+*! ' 5* +'*& '*5 >!,
+(! C!+,
6073861221 9036039 *3 *, ,* , ,
7.080 9 :00 0 4" $+) ;
80
0, + 5% *! C!+ #'::::::::::! '+** '1; 1221'=))*!'= 9*5*'*!+,
80
1, C!!Q
3, ) !* ' (= 5! ) ! +! H! ' '+* ' 32 C '4 !*)*!* * '+ ' + *% )+'+ ' $BZ*L B)(* ; ;227 ! * &* , '+* ! H! >+, +* '*! M F *'*( &!!('+** !'+* %!* *!''+** !!(+Q %F & ( !*) * !* 5* '' !! ! '+**Q F ! *>! ' +!!, $* +* ::::::::::!! *++!++ +!! F%F!F*9' *% )+'+ ' ! !*4 (=* '5 '+ * 5%, +* ' !* - ' 5 (* ! C*! ** ( '+** !!(+ ! =5 '(+!+&+'*+ !E !,03102;!02<F, > ))*4 M +*'!M [\ ] #- #
*) ' +! H!!!*)*+& !***(=@=))*)+'+ ' * > ))
6073861221