Negligence Summary Judgment Appeal Under Varying Standards of Care
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party appealed a judgment, arguing that the lower court erred by applying an outdated legal standard when denying their motion for summary judgment concerning a claim of negligence, despite the appellate court applying the modern standard that required showing a duty, breach, causation, and damages, and finding no genuine issue of material fact as to those elements. The appellate court affirmed the denial of the summary judgment motion because, even under the more favorable standard presented by the appealing party, the evidence still failed to establish a triable issue regarding the breach of duty element, as the facts demonstrated that the challenged conduct was not legally deficient under either the old or the current standard of care.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Negligence Summary Judgment Appeal Under Varying Standards of Care: The appellate court affirmed the denial of the summary judgment motion because, even under the more favorable standard presented by the appealing party, the evidence still failed to establish a triable issue regarding the breach of duty element, as the facts demonstrated that the challenged conduct was not legally deficient under either the old or the current standard of care.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in order 90 for the allocation of costs.
Cited in order 60 for the assignment of legal aid.
Testo completo
!"#$%!&''( !)$'!&''$
* +*, ,-, *, -+
. / ( "' 01 &''$
23333333333
4 +5 + !""#$%& )* ' (
/%+#%/
, 6+
#0 '")1111111111*#$2%*3*' 1111111111456 ,"*)7#$880 9 *) ")#$8$ 00
%0 :;)"#26)7#$$8*9#%:6 #$$$ 7 "3) 5 3*" 6"*3< 11111111110
,0 ' 1111111111'")11111111119 *35" /)" = ' > ? /35@ A 3 B/)" 7 ; " 0
.0 ) " :6 %&&& 6 %&&. 6C* 4 ' D11111111119"3 )3 /)E)'")1111111111
9 0 9B*33C* C*) F)9 36 " 33 )) 0 6C ") 4 G" " '")1111111111 4G"")5"' 11111111110 3*"* 3 6 " 3 *0 3 "* 3 " " "*9 " 7 ' 1111111111" )79 ;" 0
!0 " " #$ %& 6 %&&. 4 " *F "*3* 3 B99 "3 ? /35@A 9 *"H))")"3C4 '") 1111111111 &.&2&2- 4 &.&,2&-8 &.#,2&-#0 ))") " 3C 9 4 " " "*9 " 7 "* 6* </*3< **"3 )"B"B* 33* ""#:6 %&&&%89*6 %&&#"#) %&&#,& : %&&%0B*9 33 4))")"3C0
20 "* ",.) %&&. 6*33 "B* )3 "* ",&:39 33 0
-0 8) %&&.B*B33*<"* ") 6*" 0 " F* F 3 "B * ' 1111111111 F 6 3*";"B)35" 6")I 6 33 ) 3*606"B* 3) 3 "BF "3 )"B/)" 0 3 ) F "6 *3< * 6*F"3 ) "B6 %&&.3>6 "B6 " 6) " 3 ) ? /35@ > A0 3 ""6 ))*4BF "3 ) "B/)" 0>B; " **' 1111111111 * 370 9 B* " F :) 6 J"9
+#,!-+%&&. /,+#%/ " " B 9)" "FB* ** ""*)K"*; *0
80 "* "#$) %&&. :*33 "B*0> KF*"6 3C3 )4B6* /)E)"*7 0 " "*9 " 7 "* 6* B</*3< " B* 6 ** ) >6 " B/)" ? /35@ > 'A 3 3 K; " **0 > ' 6 ")"* 4 " 6 3*"B*3 )" **03 ) 36 E *)* " 99*)) 4 B 4 B " : 0 79*"*6 3* *F*3<* " )37" 3 )"3 )"B/)" 7 ; "3K"B<0
$0 " #- : %&&. B* :* "* 3/ "6 7" 0 " F*6 " 6*" *3< #$$$0 6 J "H ))") " 3C %& 6 %&&. <F 6 9 33 0 > 9 5 3) 3"BF "3 )6769 FB6 9 4 K;0 6 9 ")" 4 ,# ) %&&. 3 6 9)05F> 6 6*3 ) 6 %&&.6 3C*3 )0>B; " **</*3<* "*7 0%.: %&&.B*3" 3 5 64 0 7"*; *L +#,!-+%&&.0
#&0 *3"!M%&&. :"0 6* F *3< * " ) 37 " 3 ) " 3 ) " B 7 ; " 9 B 6 6 *3*)0 KC3K5" ;**" 3 FB*"6 3C 3 ) 4 B6 FB * /)E) "*7 0 > *3< K7 4 )E) " 3 "* 4 ' 11111111116 7 4"""*9"7 0 :*F N)E) " BKC3K5 I B* ) * 3; )E) ") F ) / "6 BF " ** 3 F 3 ;;* 4 B " *3< 7 4 " " "*9"7 O0 : 9 6*"33 9)*34 B"3 F 6 ** 9 *0
##0 ""2M%&&. 4"*F "3 " B 9 * K 6< ))") " 3C 4 B* L &.#$8,2$ 4 &.#$8,-20 ))") " 3C ** " 3 ) "B/)" "B*33* ""#),&6 %&&# "#: %&&%,#)%&&.0"*7 9 33 43 0
+#,!-+%&&. /.+#%/ #%0 "* "83)7%&&. 6*33 "B*0 33 B* 3 : 9 * B* B* ;;* 4 3C F3 3 *;"99 0
#,0 ##3)7%&&.B*B33*4"* 0 6*F 3"B:FB) ")%&&.* ' 1111111111 </*3<F 6 3"3 ) F 6 3*"3C 3 )*F0 B* "4 "B) **06 "B* 3) 3"BF "3 )0 PFB6 3J 3 ) 3 7 " > 6 %&&. 6 ))* 4 3C 3 )0 9 B6 :) J " 9 " " 3 B 9) " " 3 6 " FBB* ""*)K F"*; *0
#.0 "* "#!7%&&. :*33 "B*0 " F*F" 5B* ;;*43C4B63 )9K F/309 F</*3< ;"*4):FB,# ) %&&. : 9 3 B33 9)* 4 3 0 *3< * " ) 37 " 3 ) " B 7 ; " 3 K "B<0
#!0 "%&7%&&.B* :*"* 3/ "6 7"*0>7 )E)9 F " #- : %&&. ) 9 K 6< ))") " 3CF 6 ** 9 *2M%&&.0 ** ; *3 7"*L +%#-$+%&&.0
#20 *3"#."*)7%&&. :"0 33* F B* "6 3C 3 ) 4 B6 FB * / )E)"*7 0B9 < )"3 )43C3* 6 3 7 * " 6 33 9)* 4 ))") " 3C F 33* * BC 3 F * 3 ) 4 )) 0 *3< *3" " ) " " " " B/)" 7 ; 0 B* * 37 " 3 ) " 3 ) 4 3 " " " " 6 9 " B F 3 " 3)" 0 * " "*)) *" *K) *;)" *E) "!Q0
#-0 *3 F"%&"*)7%&&.3 *")" 0 33* F 9 5 6 3 3) " BF " 3 ) "B/)" 3 F </*3< 6 3 ) 0 / * " B F "*7 " ** 6 0
+#,!-+%&&. /!+#%/ #80 "3 F " #$ :6 %&&! " F* F "< 3*" 3 " 9 " F * 3" "6 7 " FB 6 ": "03"**) "* 33 0""*9"7 6*43*" " F F' 1111111111* " 6*FB ; KH)5FB * )3 6 3 " KP); " 0 6 3 *FF* "*7 "33 **"3 )0
#$0 ,#:6 %&&! 7"*""3F : "<L +#,!-+%&&.0
%&0 3*"%$:6 %&&! *9 FB 6 ** " B 3 * " BF " 3 ) " " 9 "9 F</*3< 6 33 ) 9 <*3 :;) " " 60 B* ;;* 4 4 3C 3 ) "B/)" 3 9) 0 B* ;* %&&. F > 6 ))* 4 6 ) " 3 ) 0 3 "))6 **)"3C3 ) FB6 ))*" )9 0
%#0 $ ) %&&! 7 " * " 3 )3 30
" F* F 3 ) * ;3* 9 6C* 4 ' 1111111111 " 6 " 6* #$$$0 / 3C33 ) 6 **6FB 4BF " 3 ) "B/)" 3 </*3 9 0 /)E) 36 3 9 6 6 "B "*3" " %G&&& 4 ,G&&&90 3 ) 0 B6 3 9)* B/)" " " 6 :FB %&&. "4F6 ")"*4F9"3 ) F" 9 " )"*0 ; "*F </: 3C 33 )0 6 33)"</ *3<4") ) 0
" F*FB6 33 " 6"*3 "B" "*9"7 %!7%&&%03 6 ** 9 * F 3 "B0 6 " ) 6C* " ))") " 3C 4 B* 9"* " "*9 " 7 </*3<0 6 9 <* * " " "* FB6 9 33 6 "*" 3 )"' 0FB 9* )3C* 6C 333 )) 0 B* > ' F 6 ")"* "B; F 6 ) 3 ""*9"7 </) 0
+#,!-+%&&. /2+#%/ %%0 #2)%&&!3" " 6") ; < FB 3 ":;)"" 6"6 "7 ""B0
%,0 "%26 %&&!) 7"*3 "B 6 ))") " 3C 3 ) 3 3* " " #:6 %&&&,&: %&&%F 6 ** 9 *:/)E)F 6 9 33 0 6 *;)J)"3"#!890!&" " " ,# ) %&&!0 )3 3 4 F 3" )"0 3 F 6 J 6 3 F 3*"* 3""6 70
%.0 )E) : 3" " > ' F " 6* " )3*3*</*3<0
%!0 #8 ) %&&! " 4 6 3 )3 30
" F*6 3C*3 )33* "") 4"*)7 %&&.0 "9 6 ** *;)637 "0 5#:6 %&&!6 K;*" /)" 0
9 6 7 " * F 3 ) " 9 " 6 **3C*37 "3*%&&&%&&,%&&.0 3 ) )3C*3*%&&#%&&%6 **3 K;3 > ' 4""*9"7 "* 6*350 6 6 ")"* " "*9 " 7 4 B " 3 36 3" K; 3 ) )3C*0 *F " 3 6 )**"*3*6F 9) %&&." " 6" "3C3 )4B6 0
B "" 7"*;"*4:;0
, -+
#0 ;6 B; :" ?A**)" 9 * *"5 #M%&&, 7" )3*"!:; " 3* " 6 /3* " ! 33* #2 :; ?0 # 0!2 A0
> 4B "B* "#2:;3 79*"* %-:6 %&&.? R#,&#&2A" ;6 "3*#,9*6 " 3 ;3) 7"
+#,!-+%&&. /-+#%/ " *; 4 :; " B " B* "6<:;0
%0 9*"*3 ;**"" " "27 %&&& ? /35@ A * 6 ; # :6 %&&, S )" 9 " )7 " 3 *; " ") " B/ )" 0 < ) " G0 8% 0 # 3) 5 3K " 3 )* "3* 333 7<3 < *9 <*6*6 ;? R#,&,#8A0>3)* 3 " 6 F " B33 F " E K* 4 ) 5 " 3 3 F 5; 33 7 6 ; )) I 9 : " F)"*) 3" 0 6K5;"3*" B33 F *6 "5 : " * 6 ; ? R ##- $, "27A0)I3) 53 ** 9 *4B* ) "B6 %&&. F "*3* "6 7 " * ""* ") ") 7%&&. * 6 ;3* )4"33 7G35? R#%-.2- "0 # #%# ,22 "0 #7A0 E 3" "5 "* 6" 0
,0 9)*) 4 G0 !2 0 # 0 K0 . 7 " S F" 3*64B !2 F 6 4 9*"* B/)" " #8 ) #$$.? /35@ 'A0 7")3* " " ") " B* "B 3 )) " "*3P " 0 B**") *456)3*" 7"*3:; ""B35 *7 0 3"* 9) )3*3 "FB " E"**670
.0 > 3 F " 6 B 4 : F 3* ) 6*"33 <3 9)*30
!0 "73 3<" '""G/)" 7 ; 3 G)7 " 33 > ? R #%2 %28 "0 ,7 *9*A0 G0,0# '3// 3 3"G7 ; "G 33") *> 0
B7 ; " 3C " "* " B0 2# ' F 3 3 < M 3*6 3 B0 2. '0 *F: " F )3* 6"B99 6 "4 /)" B*" 4 "* " / 0 B 9 < /)E) ) " 3 )43C3*?02#0# 'A0
+#,!-+%&&. /8+#%/ > " ;** " B 7 ; " ? /35@ AB*" 3C3 )4B60 /)E)"*7 0 3 )9K F/33C74,&:"5*3 " 90 * "* 3 36 *E " " F " 9 "33?0#-K0%0A0
>B0$&0#"B"B/)" "%-: #$$!? / 35@ 'A 3 ) " 6 E 3C* 4 B6 3 3 ) 0 < " *E ) 3 3 ) *K B0 %2 0 # B*564!Q3*?0$&0% 'A0 "*3 "B )) B* 3 3 3 ) 3 3 < M *K B" ;;3*""3 0> 3*"7 4 ""*9"7 B 9)B *)3*"B " 0 > *6* " 3 F 3*6 3*7 4 B *K;*"*" "3 )?0$&0, 'A0
" : 3")" " " 63"* 9)B33 4))")"3C3 *"*" '? R#&-2&#&$.2A0
" 6 9 6 3* "* " 7 ;
9 5 " G* ?3 ) " 3 ) 0 2# ' " 3 3 G0 2. 'A 3 6 " G<* 9* 9*"* 3 3 " 9 " ## 6 #88$ ? /35@ T 0$&0, 'A0 G*6 ;" #:6 %&&, ? G7; "G088 'AG33*)" 9 *; )
6 ; :FG 0 *F G 7**9 "G :;) <* "G08&F ) *"* "* 33 <* 3 ") 4 3C )) "G; 4 9 " M* ?0 !. 0 % A 3 F* " :; ) 6* "*9 6"G33 0>G " 33"G ") 6* " 9 6 7 /9"* " 3* 3 6 " 3*" ") 6 9)*)4G0-$? ' %&&.LD,&230.2! "0!0,0#!0,0% R 37 *"#29*6 %&&!D#22+&.T R 37 *" #8 ) %&&! D 8$+&.A0 > * 4 3 "F 9 33 ; 3 6 " 3*" " ") 639 S" 03F* " 3 FB 9" "* 3* 9 F * <3*)B33 0
20 F3"B* </) FBB 3"*7 " **" 0 ")"*;) 3*" ** 3* " ) I B J 9 33 6 ))")"3C0
+#,!-+%&&. /$+#%/ F "*7 " 33 ** " 3 )F*3< " )37"3 )"3 )" B7 ; " 0))")"3C7* ""*9"7 "* 6*4B"B</) "B*0
-0 B35 B:) 6C*"9"33")) 4 0 " ) 9 9 " ))") " 3C : 9 * 3 " " "*9 " 7 "* 6* </*3< F B6 3 *;* 9 " 3 ) F 6 ** 6C* 3 9) 0 9 * 3 ) "B " 0
F B/)" 7 ; F " B99 " 3 ) " 3 *; < 6) 3 '0 );?RR#$$%#%.A R*"*))"**F * 3C 3 3 ) B "6 B99 " *3* 3 )C: " F4" 3 ?3 )3 63 A0 >B; " F " )3 )F F : 3" 3) " )3 " 3 ) *K 6 " 3 " 4 " *0 'E) F B3" )""B35 * " )F F B 3 3*" 4 )3 F 3 F3*"3*64B0$&0,. ' ** 5)3* ? ' %&&, D %,. 33 ##/#, "0 20#/20,T = ' " *""" <3 "B/)" >)39 %&&.30%%$A0
)E)3*""3 E;;** F / B :) 6 " " 9 " )) F B< ; B0 $& '0 : 3" 9 " "F /)" 36B33 "B*0>B B< 3 " "* " /)" 6 4 " " B* F / 9)* 33 ))") " 3C 6 4 6 " ) 6*36 0 3*7)43 " "* "6 "*9 6 <* 3 U "B33 9)* 3 B* ))") " 3C U ")" ) 6* "*9 6"33 0? R#&$.2T" #$8!$%T>#$$.#!.A0
" *; )* 4 3 ) 6* "*9 6 "B"6; 37 ") 6*36 0
9 6 " 36 3*" 4 ) 6* 3 " 5; ) )"3*"B )3< 0 :;"= <3*)3* *"*E"%)%&&!? R 37 * D %.+&#A F "B6C )) <
+#,!-+%&&. /#&+#%/ *F " 6"3 )3 3 <M6"B;; 3*" " 3 0 )) 3*7 "6 7 ; 7)3EK3*"BFF) 6*0
>B; 33* *)"") 4B/ )" 7 ; 3)"*7 "3 )"3 )3 B)7"3* " "** ":6 %&&&4)%&&. FB 6* 0 7 ; "* " ' " B ' " " ;** "B " 0 ) I B* " 6* " *3< "3 #2 6)7 #$$8 E "*7 " 3 ) " 33 3 ) 7 "B 37 * " * " B0 #22 " " 6 "B " 3 6 ) ;0* " 3 " 9"*") I " ) ) : 3" C 6 36 )3) 3B33 F"B35"3 3 *0 )3"4 "6 * ") *6</*3< " " 37 * " 9 <* 3 : 3" )3 0 "B 3* *4: F: 3"B33 F 4 *; )) ) F33"3B* 3" 3" 6 F * 3* *)B0
F "F "9 3:) 6 9 36 3) 4 0 6 3 F / 6 6 36</*3<3 FB6 9 36 4" )) :6 %&&& "*:4 4 " " 3K/ F 0 6 *;) "3 ) "B7 %&&% ) F *3<* " 6* FBB9 )*"B" ")3 3"$)%&&!0 9 *4B6C" 9 )) FB4 ' 11111111110 9 " 3*" / B6)3 ""*9"7 * 0 "* "*"4F B "* 9 )) 0 B 99 " ) 3 6 7""*9"7 "* 6*</*3<0
6 "B; 3 6 " 3 ' " "B33 ) 3 "3*" )33 "F "39"F 3*"B) 6*)E)36 E"* FB6 "6 0 3*"BB35 3"**3*3 0
3 3 4) "M 9 4"*
9 <*"B **"3 )FB* "0 9 "* * 9 7) 3 3 ) 6*"*9 6"B33 0
+#,!-+%&&. /##+#%/ *;) 3 6 3*" K7 4 6C " 9 3 " )) 6 "B; 3 6 " 3 0 > 33 4 3 3 9 < * " "* " ) 6* 36 4 B* 3 7 * "B 7* ""9)" 0 FBB6 /") 5 "B; **3: 3"" R 0
"B359""F B33* 3*"P 4*")C"9 6 ;) "0 99 " "*9 " 7 "* 6* </*3< : 9 ) " 4 6 " 3 3 F 0 3*" FB K " 6 6 ; ) )"*; 69 7**9 3 6 0
80 3"5;"3*"3*FF) 6*< ))")"3C 9 *4B* E3*" "B350 " 6 * 4 ; 3 7 "B " 9)*)4B0-$0
"") "* ; " *0
-+6 +*, ,-, *, -+
78090 : ;00 0 < ")& - =
90
#0 *670
90
%0 ")0
,0 "* " ) 6* " " , ) %&&. . ) %&&. 8 3)7 %&&. F "* 33 " #$ ) %&&. #! 7%&&.0
.0 F3*"; 0
+#,!-+%&&. /#%+#%/ !0 9) 3 " FB 36 9) 3* E " "* " ,& : "5 9 3 3 ))"* "* 7 9*"* " >KV HK9F 2 2&&. <)3 0 "* 3 E 3;*0 )*) " @ A " F <)F"* "* 7 3""* F*T 7A <3 3 F ) 9 ) 36 ")" "* T A 3 ; " 3*0 > )*) **) *)** A 7A A /" 7 9*"* " 3 3 ) 5 FB "6 "* 670 )*) " ) )C " 36F : F"* F*B633"F **<3*" *?0#,%#&2#&8A0 ;99 * "@ W " ' * /: @ ' = ''
3 9)"3*E 9 *<3 FB4B99 9*"* "*37 F3;99
+#,!-+%&&.