Statutory Interpretation and Procedural Compliance in Commercial Appeals
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis decision addresses various appeals concerning statutory construction and the application of procedural rules, primarily stemming from underlying commercial or property disputes. The court's reasoning consistently centers on interpreting the relevant legislative enactments based on their plain language and intended purpose, often concluding that while procedural compliance is mandatory, strict adherence must be balanced against achieving substantial justice where the error is technical or harmless. Specific rulings addressed the timeliness of filings, the scope of discovery obligations, and the proper application of statutory damages or remedies in light of established precedent, ultimately affirming, reversing, or remanding lower court decisions based on this statutory interpretation.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 93 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Interpretation and Procedural Compliance in Commercial Appeals: The court's reasoning consistently centers on interpreting the relevant legislative enactments based on their plain language and intended purpose, often concluding that while procedural compliance is mandatory, strict adherence must be balanced against achieving substantial justice where the error is technical or harmless. Specific rulings addressed the timeliness of filings, the scope of discovery obligations, and the proper application of statutory damages or remedies in light of established precedent, ultimately affirming, reversing, or remanding lower court decisions based on this statutory interpretation.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the final orders to regulate the allocation of costs.
Cited in the final orders to declare the appeal inadmissible.
Testo completo
"#$%&"'&&( "()#"'&&*
+ ,-+ + ,
./ )
! )# . '&&*
!"# $ % & #&!"!'(!
&
)) * &"# !+,- .&/01
! !
%023-%
0,
37 # 3,65 8"& .8 &9# "":!!'!;87
07 . 3,46 *# 88& ! "'; <=7 "' 88&#"!:3,,>"#9!==#!#;##&9 9!!= 9!&&.&#&&&*'!<7 "#! ! ?#&'"& <.&? & 9# *' ! +!" 8""& & .& !;= . #9& !* .!+&<.&<7 &.##=*#.!!.! @!31@05A;7
>7 358#93,,/ !#.#."B!"!!.&&%8" ! "& ! 9 .8 % .B ! *88 & ! *%9!&# C D 9=& &&& @ &# .. 0-.&"'3,,>7
/7 01 " 3,,/ ..& !*(.& #&# #&' . 7 .#&)$<; @*&&!E $ 7 .# !;& 9& F "'; <= 9#&## !.&< #&;# <" & &#<!7 &"# = *# !9& #9&&9(!8&&&!'&.;#7
17 &; ! 8"& .8 && = "" #&# ;# :9 3,,1 . *88 ! #!.&& .8 .B ! *& G =!9&!&"7*#""#@"%&".7 .B " .#&# &8& !*.&# & &; #&# &".7 ..&!05:93,,1 !&!.;""!#!.&& .8!*&G9#=*#9&..&= 9&&9"= &B.!"& 9&"&# !;!!!!&:"'7#;"&#&#"&#= &&.;&*#!&&&!#.7&B&!#! &; "#!&!*&GH&=*# *#&& . " !*" &9&# .8 9 #;B ! *<I&"=*#9&.#!.&#*#&&.#7#&# ;#=*#9&8&.9!'9&#"=*#&&!88! !!#&&#C.681 D7
67 9& *#< ! && " !*'9& .8 * !"!# (.& &"&!.!!7..&!*(.& !&# ! 03 9"' 3,,1 #&# #&' . .+<& & <"&;7
2341520556 %>23-% +#&#"&#= !.&!9&&& *#.#&&. !&'&&=": =<!*#&&."&#!"'&# ="'&#!<"'#&&9<"&#!&.& *(" ! !88 . *#7 *+ 9& . ! && .9&#' ":&*("!%=#&&.&&&&;= ! ""' #&& #;"& "7 !;.< "' 9& "&# "; "J 9& #&# &&# &;& .<+;= ! !=1%37"'9	###;B.&!" ".!7 &<!&.&#*9& #&# & &;.< 9&"&##;B<+..&& .#8=7.&!9"&= !;&!"';""#&# .# #@'#&# *#!#.&!01A;.!!#.&7
&@*(".+<;= *#9##;!!#".& = & ! ;& #9&= .+<&= " "& == !#9&& #9=& . ! !#. "=#7 "#! & @#9&&=<K.&#".#7
*;& ! .&# ! &9 "#! & &"# =* !"& &B!&9=#&..&!<;!7
-7 !# ! 05 : 3,,- * :&# !"! ! "&7 && !# #&# 8"# . "" & ! "&B!*9!&#%".#&&"&B%3>:93,,, . . '8#!#!C ) D35!#"'3,,,7 L& ""!. ) &!##=*#'& .&!;!"M#&&@"L"!.!&9&#! "L";==*(N&.##!""&"":!8 '7 .9.'&#&#..&!*(.&!039"' 3,,17
47 ! 0> 8#9 & 0- : 0555 *# !"!# *9& !* .#!9&@*'&&!*&!*9!&#!15O"7
12 !33P&0555 * 8"#*#=&@*L&! ) !35!#"'3,,, 8"&!#!05:3,,- !"!!9& L& "# @ !"! ! #9 & =* !9& !B ! .' =*9!&#!*#*#&&"!8#!"B@8!&7
357 3 .&"' 0555 *# #.! = *L& ! ) & ! " .8 & =* 9& 8"& .#!# %"L" @ "&.=*9&.9&%"@&%7
337 .#& <; &<.#!= !=# ! !&# ! - 9"' 0555 = *# = .;& ! ! @
2341520556 %/23-% <9 !& 88& !*&< .."& 9 ! *&& ! <.&@!&7
#'2 3,&'0553 *#'&<!B@=!*&<.#!&! <;!*.."&!C?#&'"&<.&?D7
3>7 !#@* !&!3/8#90550 .#& )$ "#! & & "! <"&" !=# = *#&& ! .&& *#&& ;;9# !. .&". 0555 .=*& .'B" "' % !#:@ % 88& ! &' .+<= & ! !(.!7
3/7 ..&#&'0/90550. &=.&& 88 ! "'; <= !. 3,46 !* #&& !#.8 "+ #&!.3,,- &!!(.!.!&=*@;< !. &'05557*+:&& 8.&#!&9 <; .!#".&& <+.&&# &'#&<+..!#"7 "#!&&&#!*&&.&#!&9!38#93,,/>3" 3,,- .@15O!3:3,,->5"0553 .@9@355O7 "#& *& &9 & @ *&<!B ! .! !&7 & .&& B; = ! & ;" ! "< 9 ! "' &  .&& !& . .9"<.!055@>55"B&7
317 & ) .#& )$ .+<& & .+<&<#. !=# ! ..& !&# ! 00 :& 0550 = *# 88& !* #&& !#.8 "+7 8"# .#! & &( !*.&# 8 . "#!%&&&&*&!##89'@("".#"&7
367 7 !9"#!#; CD =&#&#" ..& 9# ! 9 !&# ! 0> P& 0550 =*.B *.#& &' 0553 ! *&&& @ <9 & 9 ! == " *&<!B."&&&.&&&"L"!&!#."& = "';*#&&;;9#.&".0555"L"&".=.'B" .+<=&=.+<&&@&&.&#!&9@".& !390553".#&("".#"&7
3-7 9 ! #!.&& .8 ! * 9& = !( "#!&&&#&&!"!!*("".#"& .##! .#!@(.&"&!.&!*'9&"#!!* C D7
347 ..&!*(.&#&#!!&!0/.&"'055>.= "#!9& .$7
2341520556 %123-% *(.& *& '# ! ! * & (" = ! *#7
.+<& @ +!" !( "&8" .&& @ .&# @ && .Q= & !#.!& & @ #.! !#.8 9 ! #"7 "#! ;# "&9& # !& 9&8&.9*#..!&9&#.8 ..&=* &&#!!!&&.!*9&%"7@; &!*;;9&!!7.!=#= ;R@ . <; .+<&<#.&= !#=& !'# !* "#!& &!#.9 *#&& ! .&& *#&& &"& "## #&& .## = ==+".&I".&&&=*#='.+<=#&&.#7 "#!:;#=*.9&.# @"+&" .&#!&9 !15O .&&=*#.&'<"&&9"!! #&.8!#=&7
& <"&; .# !;& 9& F "';"" &;'&#&'&&=!.!'&#( 9&<&;%9'&#&.''".&!+!" "&8" !( .&&7 #;"& "&# .#& =* *9&.!*8.&#!&9F'#&#&!+.!#" "!##7 :;# = .&# ! &9 #&& ! & &9( #&& ! !#."& 8#=& " =* 9< *# .& ( &9&# & 9 .'&# ! <; ! .& && < "9"& #.#&&8 & @ ! 45O7 .&# @ &9"":!!&%"#&##9#@>5O7
*""! "#!&&"#=*&&".&&&"&! *&&& @ <9 .&# ! &9 (;' &&!& 45O ! &9&# ."&&& .& & <;"& ! .& 8#=&7 & 9< &"# = "'; *9& . ! &B 9!& ":8!&9&#!7&8"#=*#&&!#.8#9& 89'"& && ':&9"& =*':&9"& &&"&7 & #9=# ! && ! .&# .Q= .#& = &B !* &'!.&#*#&&&&8.#7"#!&9 !":*..#&!*.&#!&9&!#!@15O.& ".&!8&=*#"	&#.##&=*& 8;.+<;="&7
3,7 /!#"'055> 8&"==*#9&& !.@!#. ".&..= !.&!9.<+= .&#!&9&!"#!05O!.&!.&#*(N& &"&.&79#.='!>5O! .&#!&9#@.#!*&'"&8"!(*9&
2341520556 %623-% . !*L& ! " M !& ."&&& ! H& &B9!&@&'*#&&.".7 && ".&=!*&&&!.!& .&"& !"';'&&" &"=&' &"#=.&#!&9!9&&&!" 45O!.&!.
057 30 :9 055/ 9 ! #!.&& .8 9# = *# #.!& . ( !& !*& !* & ".& 9< &<#="& !& . . <; ! " .87 ..# !*; &; !*#9& & !*&& .8 . ! .! <; * + 9& "& .88"!&;.&=**9#&=%."&&& 89&.!*".C.- 81 D7
037 *#!9&;.B!) !38#901 9055/7..&!*#9&#&'30"055/ &=*# = 88&# !88#& &9&# !*"'; & ! .#.& ! !#.&"& ?#&&#&%&&!&? #9##!*(&.&&!" 9!!(&#&# !*! !8&!"&7. #&# ;# =* ".& & "& &B ' ; !#7 '"& *#&&.<+=!*#*&8&"&.#:#!&;7 ""#@&9@355O7.!"& !!&:"'& !9 ! . . 8& ! & =* !P ;"& ! ! "#!"&7 ! 9& .B !( < ! &97 8 ! "!8#9 &9&.=*@15O719 ;"&#&". !&9@-1O"!P&!..&I&7
"H&!&;&9#!"&&.<+=".&&F';& !*& .& .& .'&# ! .9 *..+ . ; ! ".'&# ! .& ! <; && !* "=!8!:"' !"L"!!&9&##;B7
*&&&! &B 9& ! *# #&# ;#7 .' & = *# .& !& " &9&# !*9 !*#&' ! ! & !*"'; ! .&& .B "#= @ 15O " =* #&&!88 !*88"=*.&9&(!*.&7
007 !#!36:&055/ * 8#&&.&&7
* *##&;9.B!)!& =!#"&#= *# !.& !*(& .&&! " & ! ' .&# ! ".#< !*..&;&!*&"7*&'#.. ! & & .&# ! &9 ! !" ! *!&"8&B#;B !45O7
2341520556 %-23-% ".#9=*&.#*#!&9&#.##!& 3,,/ &1/*1468731C!9'&.B!8 ' #&#D@ =* & . &<#="& '& ";# 9!&# & /5*4>> 87 C 0555 3 &9&# ". & #.#&&9 ! *!& "8&B S31% >-TF/*45587./5<72"7U1*55/87./3 -<72"7U65*5/487. 0555U/4*5>487@45OU/5*4>>".&&!*#!&..#"&! 31O.&".&!"&&D '&&@!;#!*9!&#!
01 05388&.9!&@&7
*;& !*#9& " .8 * &"# =*&.!&@8&.!*".@!" .&!;!""&&!*##&&&9"&. &;&&M(&&"<#!&9&"'!*& &9&#".&#.#&&9!.&#@"&&=&' 8"&.8..#"&7
0>7 !01P&055/ *#8"#..&@&&!#7
0/7 !>5!#"'0551 8"#* =*#&& !&#!.&&#&&&#;'"&&&."&=7 &&8 ..# = &; !*'9& .8 9& . #=&&.#:&7
017 &) !=# 338#90556 =*#&&.+<=! .&&*#&&.;;9#7
067 3> 9 0556 * ! !# ..& 8"& !#!36:&055/7
* 8&"== ) 9&8"#!L&!35!#"' 3,,, !# ! 05 : 3,,- :&& !"! ! "& ! 9.87
*& . #8## ..& ! ! 0/ .&"' 055> & @ :.! ..' "&B ! &' "&8" !(7 &&# = *# .#&& . ! &' .+<&= #9B ! &' ! .&# # =* *.& ! 8& & ! "#; =* 9+& " 9 . =* #; *#&& ;# & =*@ "B ! ##"& &' "&8" !& 88& ".& . !& :.!& . !"&& =* 9& ! #=9!&7
& @ *..#& ! 8!& * &"# =* *#&& . ..@"&&*#9&!(.&<"&; !*&&=* '&="&.&!*#7#= * *&!
2341520556 %423-% '#.&#!&9(;'&.(.&"#!(9& =&;!*'9&9&!*."!"&	!<K*# !*(& .&&! " & ! ' .&# ! ".#<7 * . ..# = :.! !& . ! .! ( &&&8&..#& =*@!"#!&&&7
#= !## = *# .9& ( &9&# #;B @ 45O7
0-7 !00"0556 *#&:@*&! !# ! 3> 9 0556 @ =* & &&# = .&# ! &9 *&&&=15O @*&!".8&!*!"%& 9 &!8&!#.7
*# #8B ( &&& ! & @ *#9& ! )!& 7 && = & @ .&# ! 45O &"& = =*#9=#&( #8#&"&@'#
8&9=&<#"#!&".B&&!&9#&# ="H&!&;!)!&&.'97
& 8& 9 = !& ."&&& ! H& &B 9!& @ & ". ! " M 88 !* 88& .<=#"!'!.3,,>7H&=*'& . ! .& !*&#;& ! && "8&& ! 9 " 88"=*9&'.""& 8@!" & & ( ! #&# . .&# .<+= & ! .&&7 &@!&&9@*#&&.+<=&# & &"=*&"8&"&".!"M!#."+ ..H& &'# 9 .&# @ && .Q= .&B"& ;#.)=.##*'!*"#&= :&& *.&# ! &9 ! @ ! 88& .<+= & "& ";# &&"& !" 8 !B !& &9 @ *#< !&&"&!#.&!"&9&&!88&."&&'& #;"&##7
& B; = "& *+ . ! "!8& ! #&& " =* . .& & "97 #8B ..& ! ) & .. =* '& &"& .+<"& ".;# !*8&;=#"#.)!&7
!"!&988&#&&80>"0553 !&! 9!"!7
2341520556 %,23-%
047 9&#@. * !#.!05:0556 :&! 7
#8B @ *(.& .!. ## . ! = & = ! &9&# !.&# *(N& .& .&# ! &9 ! *# &&& 45O7 * !"& =* & .# !*88& . <=7 9< && = &' "&8"*".;.!*"'!&#.+<&=;9 =**+ ..&!*&#;&!&&"8&&!9&=*#&& .+<= *& "8&"& . &# #9& .' *#.! !#.8#&&!##""9!#".(.&79! #= !&&9@*#<!&&"&8"(B;! *& *& . ". .7 * & = &' "&8" 9L& . &B 9!& & = &( ! .&# ! &9!&L&8(#@45O &&".&!"&&!@*&&& !&#.<+=7
0,7 #.=!01P&0556 &"&.&7!"! =*&.#!#@ 9(.&.+<&=7 ;= )!& ;! 9&# * .''"& .# @ %!@ ! "&8#"&98!'""&7..= )C338#90556D &(!*.&#&!15O7
8& =* !#9..# && 9&# & "L" %!@ ! *(;' . "& ! .#! ! & " " 9 &( ! /5O !*88&# &&"=*..&#.9!&B9!&! &'"&8"7..=)!*!#&% ""#&&!*#9#&#&= !*.&!9':&8 "9 !.&#!&9.&.&="&.L&'"&(;#7
>57 !/.&"'0556 * ..&"&.&7
2341520556 %3523-%
,
37 8"#"& @ *&7 16 7 3 &7 <7 ! ;9 V;& :!!009"'3,/3CD '&! H& &= !&&&.#9@*&716!8#!# .& ;## ! !& ! ! 6 &' 0555 C D &9 @ 7 &9 @ 8#!# V%9!&# ! 3,: 3,1, C D7".#&.:;!!V.B&#&'7
07 & &# 9; 3 :9 055> &H& ! "!8& #;&9 &""& ! !& ! *%9! .& ! 9 &". &....'B;!!&9;""&M 8& :!="& !#&"& & .!& & :; ! 8!.. ...# *#&&!8&##@ !& !#&"& ! !# ..& &; C ) 30, / !7370J36,!73J>16!73&L&&#D7"M !"! ! #9 #&# !#.# 0555 .. ! !& &&". ""!&*("!'%8!#!!#..&!3>90556 @"B!!.&! ..#!*#&!&:=* >3 !#"' 0550 & #<#& ;! ! 9 !.& ! ..#!.&#C )3>5>>0!7070&07>D7= .#!&@!#8&!B;&&& 9!& *..=#9!B:!	C )33-,>!7 6'J330>65!7/J 3,,4W>-.7>36!7>'D7
>7 ' ! # && = &:&# ! 8" & !# .&. &9'@8"C87&765 D7
/7 &;.&=&!9*#&&!&#!&*&;;9# !. !# & ! 05 : 3,,- ! 8N @ 9 !& @ ! .&& ! *%9!&# = & 8" ! & &2 ! ".87
17 (&"!&7/ &4 *9!&#&!"&!.&#! ; .#"#."&!;!# =#&!*&&&@&# .<+="& .9&!*8"&#;#& !*"!!* !&C87#;"&V&74 D7
+!.#=:.! &!V9!&# ! !&! &&#"=&"#!J& #= #"= ':&9 ! V.&# 8& =V ".& !V#9 C ) 335 0-1 !7 /J 351 05- !7 0D7 =V !V&9&#!V# !##"=8&!#8& +! 8! !# !V! "#! ! " M ."&&&
2341520556 %3323-% !V#9 .&# ! &9 ! V&## ! ! &9&# '"& (;'C )3313>>!70J351314!73D7
67 *&7 /3 ! & 9; :=V >3 !#"' 0550 *9!&#!*'##8!&"!8!"B@8!&@ & %& .*9 ;"&# #!&.."#7 &<;"& ".&&!& ..@8!;#!*9!&# !!&@ & .& ! @ #9 ! %7 .& ! 9 & <;"& *& .!& !& L& &<# ".& 8& & =* .#&&""&!!#&!&&&#;& @ *#.= ! !# &; C ) 35, 061 !7 /J 356 4- !73J351>5J )330>-0!70'&>,5!73'D7&.& L	#"&!"!8&'!*#&&!&# " = % & &# "L" " = #= .&#!;&'<;"&".&&C )3>5>/,!7>71J 33>0-1!73J330>-0!70'&>,5!73'D7
93-70 =&.=&(!V9!&#!'##8! &'&"!8&&' &&!V88!"! #9# .V9 @9;"&##!&#= .."# * . ..&# ! "!8& ( .. :.!& !#9..# '!V&7/3 #;"!!&9;:=*>3!#"'0550 C ) !>59055/ 60625> !7>71D7
-7 *.B + "8&"& ;;9& ! *#&& ! *# !. 3,,- .=&..!!(.!".&&7 &&;;9&*& !* . &&# . *&"# .= ! & &# "&B 9!"!!.&&7&@("*#&&!*#*&"!8# .&!9!&@!.&&7
47 (&"! *9!&#&!"&!.&#!; .#"# ."& ! ; !# = #& !* &&& @ &# .<+= "& .9&!*8"&#;#& !*"!!*!&C87 &7/ &4 D7
+!.#=:.! &!V9!&# ! !&! &&#"=&"#!J& #= #"= ':&9 ! V.&# 8& =V ".&!V#9C )3350-1!7/J35105-!70D7
,7 &&&@&#.+<=.9& ""&&&.<+= &H 9!&# ! *&7 / C 9 *&7 4 D7 !B . "" ! #= !* #&& .+<= "!8 ! . "" ! 88& @ .! <; . *%9!&# !"&!.&#!;=*#.&".L<8&.9
2341520556 %3023-% ! ' 9&#J " ! = & (;' !& L& !#&"# ':&9"& = .' C ) 350 361J 0553 .7 00/ !7 0' & #8#J87 )30-0,4!7/8D7
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
"&& # @ *( !* &9&# #&& !* (;#& ! +".&I" !* && "'' B; ! @ *'!*&&&@	&!&@!.&&!*7 "'!&&9;#8;&!!&!!#& & ".&"& '9# *#;& !*& ! !& &#&= !"& 9; *' ! !"! ! ;! !9; & 8"& 8 . .&& & && ! *"B 8&=!.&&B!#"&&9&'*(.& = *#;& ! ! <!. ";# 9"& .+< && C9 W2E2W " '< KZ< W[. +<
2341520556 %3>23-% ! K <Z;A& F <ZK< !K< E<<8& 3,,- .73/>/ 9#8#@#&!..8!!EA&)&J9 *"'!:& )3>3/,!73707D7
8 !& "#! C87 &""& 2 2 $ S#!7T && W8A& .+<< &[; %35 W.&S)T /B"#!& .73,3D =8! '8#!#! #&& !#.8 &&& ! "8&& C#&9D !*".;"& ! &' "&8" !( ! & =* & !;& & L& "" &&&8 !* "'!&# .+<&= &" ! &' "&8" !( C ) 3>5 >14 !7>7>738J+% .7&7 .743 &3>1D7
357 .9!;#!V9!&# V!"&&C:; V+ D ' ! !"& = "#! #9&"& !V& .#& !9&87&R<!"#!&@.&:;"& V#&&!&#&@!=!="&.=&9&#V# &.'!&97& !#"#!&&&##"& & . !#&" = &9( .& '"& (; ! V#C )301063!7/J3313>/!70J33/>3/!7>J 351314!73D7
:;!!&("!"B':&9&"+ ! .9 = =* & .9 . !#! !"& @ !.& ."&&& ! .& :;"& 9' !& &;(7 ..& "#!( & &!& .& =! *88 ..# *"'!.9&!=.= 8! . "#! & . &7 *& =* ".& . 8#.9.'&@..&"#! =.&&;(& 8& *':& !* #&! &# = ..& 8! ! (" ".& =* . #;"& !#& .& (."# . .("# =*&#&##&'.!*"B = !.& ! &(& "#! & *..#& ! && "#! & & 8 = ! "#! & !P"& "&9#7 !"& *##"& !#&"& . 9 .'& *& *; ! "+!.9!#;&""..&""(.& "'& '&C )301>10!7>#J300365!7 3#D7
9& 8 ! .# = :.! && :; ! ..# #;&# ! !# &&=# B; ;## !V.B V#&& ! 8& (&& ""& M !# &; #&# ! C )303>66!73'&L&&#D78&9.&#"&
2341520556 %3/23-% &=&"!8#&&&& !9&""&8V':&!V9 !#!"&&9C )303>66!73'#D7
337 V & #&# " @ (.& <"&;= & .+<&=7
(.& & .#!# @ (" ".& & "&( ! V#&& ! &# ! V#78 &..+#V&!!&&## "B +&#"&=7 & #&' && ! V# && ;##7 .& ! V# & #&# . ".&7 ..& & &# & "&9#7 "' &8& ! @ &#=&:.!&&!&9H&9.'& @ #9.B7 =V8&"= ":&! V.&#!&9@=&.#!#(.&!:&8 .7 && ":& ! " M & "&9# . 88& !#.+# .&\=&!"&.&&#\&.8&=V &8;.+<;="& .&L&;##. '!#7 88& &.@!&B.:.!7
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
! .#& 8& = & & 8; .+<;="&:&8.#!&..#"&!"M #&#!=#=#&	&.&I&89'"&&M V!9&+9 !#".& &!&.#9!!;#!V9!&# &&.';;9&8&!&.L&&.#@&!7 &
2341520556 %3123-% 8& =V "#; . 88& 9& . = !& ! @ "".&#!&979&!B =V8&V ! &=V#.&(@45O&9&#!.&#@#&&!
& ( '9& (= V& 9# )!& & 9& && . ':&8 ! !#&" ! = " ! " .8  =#&#..#.<& "&B!&' "&8" !( :.! .# ! &B ' .# "&B!V(;'&#!V&9&#&V&'=!&L&("# &B9!&!V&&&7
V.B 8&!&&=V&'.#!*88& . <= &' "&8" *".; . !* "'!&# .+<&= ;9 .= V# V& &&& = !V #&& !#.8 "+ #&& ..# = :.! =* &' !#.8".;&'"&8"!(&=*..H&"" #& @ % && . 88& &" !&& ! +!" !( .+<;B !* "'!&# .+<&= "8&!*&#&!*!#".&&C )3>5>14!7>7>73& #8#@+% .7&7 .743&&3>1D7
! V# V+ . .& !*&#;& ! && "8&& ! 9 =V V!"& %"L" .=V .&. "#; V.!8&&9#9 '="!7
.& . . !# = #&& .+<= & &# #9&.' *#.!!#.8#&&!##""9!#" .(.&7
8 . "L" !& &9 @ *#< ! &&"& 8"(B;!*&*&."..7
) & ! ! && = !& ."&&& !V!"&& &B 9!& ! V&&& & . # V.B ! & = V& @ :& && = V !## = &( ! .&# ! &9 !9& L& 8(# @ 45O &&".&!"&&!@*&&&!&#.<+=7
307 &@9#8!!;#!V9!&#=V&9#V 7 = ". 9 = & #&# &&& @ &# @ =V .& # (N& &9&# ". & #.#&&9 ! !" ! V!& "8&B .H& . &=' ! " M :& ! (.& & ! "H& ! &; ! )!& =& @ V&9&# 9;' & M ! H& !"& ! 31O #&# ..=# .&".&!"&&!V#7V+!.!V#&! &(!V9!&#& !01 05O 88&.9!&@&7
2341520556 %3623-% 3>7 .=&!".879&!9= V&.##"&!'&!!#&"!&"#&&# &=8"!9&#<#&L&!#=V " .! V'9& .8 @ )!& 7 & ! !"H&!&;=V&9&#.!.&#@V#& !V9!V#&'!&!V"';!.&&.B"#=7 8 8"& .8 ..#"& V". . ! " M (& "<# & "' !V&9&# ". & #.#&&9 & = %@ !&"& ' @ V#7 9< V..@= !.'##8!V!."&V 8&!"!@V &"&"&9#7
3/7 #;!(!#&=.#B!& "8!# &:
2341520556 %3-23-%
4 ,0 ,-+ + ,
!
5 .
37 #9'7
! 5
07 :&&7
>7 &=.#!&;&&7
/7 8" .& ! =V .9& 8" & .#& L& ! !# ! >5 : !B &8& .B ! ' 8#!# C<ZK<8=6 655/ D .9!"&B!!& .' 8"#"&(&740!8#!# '8#!#!3- : 0551 C )DJ "#" ! !& != "&8 & "+!.9&.&;&!&!"!&J!& L& !# ' 8#!# . 9 .& . 9 #&= ( !& ! *&7 /0 )7 .#& L& & .B . ! & 9=#"""+!.9 !9&L&:&@*97 ;88B #!&F )) W W
.8"!.#&L&&&8#(.&=V@V888#!# .;88
2341520556