Interpretation of Financial Instrument Provision Regarding Mandatory vs. Permissive Action
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court reviewed an appeal concerning a dispute over the interpretation of a financial instrument provision, where the central issue was whether a specific clause mandated or merely permitted a certain action under the given circumstances. The court reasoned that the language used, specifically the presence of directory terms rather than mandatory ones, indicated that the provision granted discretion to the party in question regarding the required action. Therefore, the court affirmed the lower court's finding, concluding that compliance with the provision was not strictly obligatory, but rather subject to the reasonable exercise of judgment by the relevant party.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Interpretation of Financial Instrument Provision Regarding Mandatory vs. Permissive Action: The court reasoned that the language used, specifically the presence of directory terms rather than mandatory ones, indicated that the provision granted discretion to the party in question regarding the required action. Therefore, the court affirmed the lower court's finding, concluding that compliance with the provision was not strictly obligatory, but rather subject to the reasonable exercise of judgment by the relevant party.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAProvision used for ordering the costs of the proceedings.
Testo completo
#$%%&#'(() *+ +#,'-#'((.
/**0
1
+*1 *+ 1/
'$ 2 '((.
3333333333 !4*0+!1+
*/ 05*+*0 + !"" #$%&''& (
! "
-+)&&-
*+
&. ( /0/0 " 1111111111 2"3 41111111111 /5#056/789:!"0/6%6""0;#3/50< "/60""&%=0++=0+''$92"3021111111111 6 +> ?6!0 &%+> " * ? /0<6 9 "300. ( ?05 " /0/0"/5#056/0"&@=0+''$36"0-0306< "0360"A360?000.
+. +% =0 +''$ 2"3 41111111111 6 0 ? " /00 *$&+ 03 / "0; #3/50< B /0C *$D' //63 /30 03 B+, /0C *$D, //63 / "6/3 B $, /0C <A ?0 /!0 9 (E /: " < /0 ??006 / A 0;0 " 0 00 < / 3/630 2 2 F( 2- .
$. 36"0-0"(E <0"0;33/630" 1111111111.//36"0"& +''$36"0 "66 0< "0;0G H +''+ " "A":3 " 33 0?60 5I /0 / 0??0 "0< ; /6"30 9 "0 0??0 !0 "0:J. =0?00"03""0;#3/50<9"30060"?!0 !07/360?0"0<"0.
,. 0 " +$ +''$ (E 6 ? 9 2"3 4111111111130? <"00<0/A//00"0?" /00*$&+*$D,A60/3/0<"0:6.
D. &+ "63 +''$ 1111111111 60 36"0-0 " (E //60</0??""0!0"";7 0695:6!:. =0+''$A/66!"":3 " 5!0 0 ! 0??0 "0<. ":3 0 0 9 "0 33 0?60 7 0 " 7 ;7. 6< /0 "0; #3/50< 9 "300. 03"0/6//5#056/66/?03766/30 "A6!05/000.(E 30?.
@. 2"3 41111111111 00 3300 /00 00 (0 " 5#056/0-(60+%=!0+'',.//00"000 " $' =0 +'', 3300 /00 3/30 /66 / (E " /" 5; /0 /00 0?0 *$'& B,> /0C*$D,B/5#056/0;669"300C.
)&$)+'', -$)&&- *. 2"34111111111100 0 0+,K+'',"A"3" /03 9 A " (E 9 /0 5; " ? /000?0*$&+.
>. 6/ " $' /3 +'', (E 7/ < /00 0?0 /606 / "3" A / =0?06 ": < /0 /6 / "A0??0 #3/50< <A0 A;0 "A 03 / ///06/630<"A0??0!0"0:"A0??0 "0<; . =".
%. /0660!069"60; 0 0 "6"6 3/0/."A"0<0A&%=!0+''D "3" "66 <A !0 /0<6 "7 0 50< " ;" 0; " (33 <0 ?036 < /0 /60 " ":3#3/50<03/"33 0?60.A//" 03/0!08/0/0" "0< /6063 / " ?!0 #3/50<. 03 03/30"A6!0A5/000"/0.(E 30 /00 ?" "0;0 /6 / 36"0L 0 36"0- 0036"0-0A?036"0;0"A":3#3/50<.
&'. 0 " 6 /6"6 9 " <M. " <06 " 630 1111111111 "66 < /0 ?? "A 0??0 "0< "A 0??0 !0. /60 ;?3 " 33 0?60L 0 ?036 <A0 A;00 "A N":3 #3/50< <0 A"63/666+''$0"0.0!0/0" "0=0+''$!"/6!0";60AN":3.03 /"0;#3/50<600"0/ .
&&. 36"0-0 " (E "66 <A /6 "A ":306/9N":3#3/50</6 "A 0; 00<. 6< "A 0 " !0 #3/50<. /6 "A N":3 06 "0;0 0 "A0??0 !0 "0<. " ;" 365" 0< /?03/6"AN":3."(33A0/00?/3 "9N":3#3/50<!?03!0/60?0060 : ";6 "A00". "A/: /0 ?? "A 0??0 !0 50< "A 0??0 "0<G 0 A# 6</"A0"009"0;#3/50<.563"03 " 0: " A??006 " 03 ///06 630< 0 9 /0 " " 0 66!0 " 33 03!00<30/.
)&$)+'', -,)&&- &+. 0"+>!0+''D(E 0<"0;0"AN":3 #3/50<A/!0""A/:. A//0/00 !0"1111111111/600"3"0"N"&+!0 +''D 00 < 0 " 1111111111 36"0 06 !0 "A5/6"0" F"++!0+''D.("00;";"" "A":3#3/50< ;6636;0? "0;0 "0??00 ! -3 0"06 B3"0 06C <0 " /0. ?073/00<A 66 ??6.(E :! /< A0"/5#056/-6/511111111110/6!0 !0 36"07 " /600 "0;0 5/6"0 /56 ;0. /0 " 0 O 0 "!0 / 09!0930N!"A7/0/:"/600.
&$. "3"/06"0.
&,. , 30 +''D (E 30 0 " 6 !0 " (60 <"0;#3/50<0/ 0;0"!" /0""A/:"A0??050<!0. "3 66330<69"3";"69=;.
0*+
&. ( A. >% . & " 0 ?6"6 A-3"0 " &> 3 &%%, B 2C 00; ?0 =;6 / 0 0. 3/6 0 0""0?//0<6" "<?0"/00690/3B.>% .+ 2C.
+. A/:<06"?0"/0".$D 2 $> " A" A-3"0 " +* =0 &%%D B 2C " "3" A / 6. "0: 7/0 0 " /5#056/09:!<0?"3/6" 0 "6.
"3" 00 0 "A "3" !0 9 < A0036 / 5; 6 " "0; #3/50< /00 0?0 *$&+*$'&//00"000.<M30!60?0 7"00?3"<A! .
)&$)+'', -D)&&- $. <0 00;0 0 9 "630 0 /0 06 / "3" /60 N":3 #3/50< =0?0 /0 5; / A0036"6""0;#3/50</0/36"0-0.
A 0;0 " 0 /" 5; K " /0 <0 !9"0;0<903"06<B.+D 2C. "A.$+.& 2/03067.+D9$&"0! M ??0 ///06 630<. A??006 "0 M "636 "365"00?0<.
/!//"5;0"A 0;0 "0"AK<7"/0/6!7.+D9$$B.$, .& 2C.
73"A.$$.& 2 0?6"6/"60;/0 ?0 / 36"0 50/00 " K / /0 5; / A 0;0 " 0 9 0 "00. 40;"3/6< 0?6"60"66;6?363 9 A. $$ . D 2 6/3 ?6"6 " A060 B4C 6"06 A" /0 " A 0;0 " 0 " 3"0"+%/3 &%%DB (CLA.D5.&.55.@ ( "0; #3/50< /0 5; ! " 03 " ":3 #3/50<.
!00?0&/3 &%%*46"600" /5#056/B4(C ""-3"00B 2(C 3300 " 0? 36"07 B 2C A-0!0"06 /66 /A??0?6"6"0B4 (CA??0?6"6"A 3000B4 2C6!0;&=!0&%%>:;6360" /0 ?0 7 6 / /5#056/ ! " A. ,$ 233B?..& !0C.
/00 0?0 *$&+ " !0 ??0 / 6 / "0; #3/50< 3 A//0< " 03 3/7 "A":3#3/50</0<6"""A/56/0<; /"/5#056/?36/603"56/0.
,. !0 " "630 /30 0 0 /0 /60 A " ":3 #3/50< 33 0 "3" < A0036 .
" /0/0 " /5#056/0 6 0 &@ =0 +''$ / 1111111111 0;6 / "3" 30 < " 03 / "0; #3/50< A3600 " ?0 00 B?.7/0:"3"C.//"& +''$"69
)&$)+'', -@)&&- A0036 1111111111 0"0< 0< H"0;0 " "A//00 " /30 #3/P3 " A??0G +''+ " "A":3 " 33 0?60 5I /0 / 0??0 "0< ; /6"30 9 "0 0??0 !0 "0:J. 33 =0?00 " "0; #3/50< 9 "300 36"000"0<6<A0A;0"?!0!07/360 ?0 "0< "0 B?. /0: . &&' 0036C. 06 / 36"0-0"A0036 11111111116/"/0" &+ "63 +''$ < /0 6 &%+> ?? " " 0!0" ";70695:6!:. =0+''$A/66! "":3"5!00!0??0"0<. ":3 0 09"033 0?607 0"0 /<0!0"3"6"/0<"0;#3/50</0 5;9"300B?./0:.&&%0036C.
"<06"630 1111111111?036</0 ??0"A" 0969!00??0"0< 0??0!0./606<<A00"0<6</0/60 "":3"33 0?600A;00?0"AN":3#3/50< -<A0!06-60"90??0"0<!0.!0 /0<6";"!06</"/060 0 0"0"9#3/5.!00/0" "0 <0 A60 /" / ??0 ! 5 " A66 A":3 A60 "63/6. " /0 0 A;00 " 00 "7 //5 56/0<9?03/6300A#!0/"A0. " 30 +'', /0 ?? "A : ! 0 " "63/0 " AN":3 #3/50<. A0??0 "0< 0 !0 /0 "060< A ". 36"0 0 ?036 < 0; 00< 60 6!0" / 9 N":3 #3/50< ;" " A0??0"0<!0"66<A06000"/6"9 ;0;/50 9 73 "A03;0 36"0 "3 : 67A;0"A/ Q;6. A;00 A /"A 03"?30 0606/3"0.
;3"36"00"A00366/ /</00/??0"A":3#3/50</6"A ":3 06 " 33 0?60 0 ? " /0 " ! "0;0<90??0!0"0<"3O !07 ?0 : 3. ; ; " /0 0?60 " 33 " 0<0""!076/""0R;?3. A;0"A0<0"70/"#3/5G??#3/5 0<0" <0 ! " !0 #3/50< <0 ;663 <A0# 0"7#3/50<. !5/6"A N":3 06 0 ? :; ;66 9 N":3 #3/50<
)&$)+'', -*)&&- /6 "A 0; /5;0< < " !0 " /0. ?036 < " ;" 60 0< /3"?03/6"AN":3. "(33A0 /00?0/3"9N":3#3/50<L?03/ 0";6"A00".A"A0=306"0: ""(33/00?""7P60"!0M00: 0<0/0<0"733/630.36"0-0"66 <"/60!" 0960A#!0/"A0"009 "0; #3/50< 6 /! 36"0. 0"0<6 < / A0??0!0563"030:"A??006" A63006 " 03 ///06 / " " 0 66!0 " 33 03 !00< 00 < /. A <A/6"A0<0330"A60<<<6""0; #3/50< /! M /0 3;6 A " /! 36"0 " 006. 03 " A0??0 "0< 0 ! 36"037//""0;#3/50<.
D. A0036 <0 " 0;3 3/630 /: " 1111111111 /600 42F S 3"0 " N 1111111111 36"0- 06!0"A5/6"0"3;0"A//03<A 330<6 0 " 6. 0 /"0 /0 " /00 3/630"36"0-0!0"(60.
<0 /6 / A0036 " !0 0 /0 6 &%+> 03 "A " /!0 /6 0??0 "0< ; /6"309"011111111116/""0"&D !0 +''D <A0 60 /0 " "6!// 0??0 "0< ; 9 /6"30 "0 < "6/"0 " A03/ " A60;0 " "0/50 "63/6. A;0 "A 00 ;66 ;! ! #3/3;0 ?0 ;" - " TF 7/0< ":3 "33 0?60<03 /5I/0":< 0"36"03/00A#/"36"000<0 "A 0??0 "0< ;5 ; 9 !0 " "060< " #/ 50"0I0<""060<"A06" 09A ". 6;3/606<A0A#!0/"0":3#3/50< A0??0 "0< "0. ?? #3/5":3 60 " 0<0"0!"#:3#3/50<<0R30"#3/5 B " 336 /600<C " 0 -6 < ":3"A0;0"0<0360"A.(0"7 #/"A":3700A;0""7/5;0=7/6/ 6<"AA.
1111111111 7/0<6 < A "00; "7 #/ " #3/5":3G &C #3/5":3 /030 ;60 #3/5":3
)&$)+'', ->)&&- /030 " A" B"#/0 53 " 6 #3/50<C ! "656/00"0?07+C#3/5":3"0/ ; ;;00/"/67/000?330 "/56 0/?"./606<A7300<A//60?0</ / "0;0 < A "A65 // / 7 /5;0!0!0"33 0?603"#3/5;/50 006 " #3/5":3 "0. 03 " #3/5":3 0 03 "A" 360< / / " " 0 / " 36"03 /60?0< " #:3 #3/50< B0< !0730-0C. =6<"060</0"0<6 A / "A?? " 00 0 A;0 < A " 0<0" 000A/"A0336/600<60 0!"0.306?0U06056/0G"0;#3/50<.
/0"/003/630"++!0+''D36"0-0" A0036 A ?"6 0 "3 00?0</ ? /0 5;""0;#3/50<G&CA !0"- "/ #50 ; ?5 ;#+''&0 ;0;#!.+'-//.+L ;". +C0"0?5(00"00?;0;0 3/00"+''$ $C H /0/0 " "0; #3/50< 3 - ;0"0 . +''$J "3 6 0 / 1111111111 " < 0 /606 <A "A0??0!050<0;";""(33 /00?L /6 "AN":3 #3/50< 0; " ;" !5 6;0?. A0??0 "0< ; A0??0 "0< "0 "63/6 -0"00 ?3 7 "0; #3/50< 3.
/: !0 ?0 #5: " "3 00?0< 36"0-0 <"0;0"A":3#3/50< /6//5#056//0 /0 / 36"0 0 00 !0 6. ?? A6 /60 ":3 06 " 33 0?60 0; " ;" 60 /00?.""AN":3#3/50<0;;6636;0? B?. "3 1111111111C. " (33 0 3!0/60?006.A/"0;0"0??005I/0! -3 0"06 33 A "A 73 A / 66??6 B#3/5;0-00;/50 .C. A0 < 03 A / ///06 "3O00<""6 000??0"0<"0 003"/5;0. ?003A / 630< / K7 B37033 +,$' ?. )C ;" " 0336"037B$@'?.)C=6/" "0B&+'?. 9+''?.)C.
@. A 0 " 6 < 36"0 0 A "A3 6 =30 /6 "0;0 " #3/5":3 < 0 "
)&$)+'', -%)&&- /0/0 O " 6/ "6 36"0-0 " A0036. 03 0"0<6 < /0 ??0 "A 0??0 "0< ; /6"309"0"A0??0!0"0:<A=0+''$ A60 /66 ! " ":3 " 5!0 0 ! 0??0 "0<. ""0;#3/50</0<69"30060"?!0 !07/360?0"0<"0. A<A" /6/6"<A060"<06"630< 1111111111 ?03 0"0<6 < /0 ??0 " #3/5":3 !0"" 096.
7/00 " 1111111111 A0??0 "0< AR/"#3/5":330"":3"960"A "0; #3/50< 0 / 03 "6< "A 0??0 "0< <0 ! 36"037. 0 0 3 -0"0<6 "A0??0 "0< ; "A0??0 "0< "0 "63/6. A / 0; " ;" ;663 6;0? "AN":3#3/50< "0;0 "0??009//6"- 3 0"0633A5I/0B 1111111111C.
(=0/"A663"630/!/ "A// 36"0A0A0;0"3#"/!0"60;033// 7/0 30 0 B 4 &+D $D+ 0". $ &++ &@' 0". & 6?6C. A06 "3000! =; "0! 0"6 ?0 33 /!6 < <A0 !0 " 606 BV33"0"W0!0/I5,:36"00&%>,/.&$@L#;0 "!X;5/?; +:3 6"00 /. +*> 5. DC. "30 " 0=;?""600?"0/000"0 ?0<0?"AM6 0"30:06? //033 / !03 A-9-"0 <0 /6 ";6 " !03 /6/"6. ??0 " / <A ?0 /0 M 0"66 3 33 5#/5: /0 . 30 663 " ?0 6;6 !0; =; "0 656 0 7 <0 0 /0 / / B 4 &+@ $@' 0". D . &+D &%D 0". 5. + 6?6C. 0 A70--0 / "0 " 0 /00/ <A"3000=;"!0""?!" A6B 4&+@$++0".D.C.
A/: "0! !0 36"07 00 3/ " # 0!0" 0 "60A6.4": "<"0;0"AN":3#3/50<?03/6/ 36"00"/6"/M;""";6" !03 /6/"6 //0 0 6 /606 "3 < 03 /0 A//00 0 ??0 0 ///06 0 630<.
)&$)+'', -&')&&- ?? /0 ??0 <A / =0!3 " 656/0<!06/03"3"09!0//0 /3/:/0 "A09630</#50<B 4&+> &@D0".D)L 2 +'''YV&$+.+>&0".+ C.<0" : ///06 A//60 ?0 " 66?0 "0;0< 56/0<"A//00"/003/"0< <0 # 06 ;" " 56/0< B 4 &+* &,@ 0". DC. : ///06 :! /00/ " 0: 36"07 ?" ! <0 " A0"00 36"0G < A0"00 36"0 03 6 0 : ///06 " /0 A 6;3 B 4 &+D %% 0".,L 2 +'''YV&$+/.+>+0".+C.0:"A63006 //K 66?0"3<" "0??6 ?3 ) 365" " 03 ??0 ///06 0;"3//3 3"0B 4&+*&,@0".DL 2 +'',YV+*+/.&&&0".$.&.+C.
"A/:?0<03/"0;#3/50<60 -0"0<6"A0??0"0<"0"63/6/0 /60/=0+''$"0<0330"A:<00/=0?0 656 << 6 " "0; #3/50< " 3 O /60 0??0 !0 "0:. K " 03 60 / ;3 /60 9 0 " 563 " 03 0< " A0??0 !0 ?3 " /0/0 " " 0 " 36"03!0-0<.
!"<0/6:""3"//6"3 3" ? ""0?0*$&+.
*. "3" 0 <A A ?36 9 /0/0 " 1111111111.0""//96;"< !00?0 /5#056/!060 0!36"00<A0 ??"/0"/5#056/0/0/0"36"0.A.D.& +:3 /5 /60 /" < /0/0 36"0 0"00 " "0;0"""0;0<BA0 "?0;0S !0;C" "03?6/A-3"0.
: < /0/0 " /5#056/0 3/0 /6063 / " ""0;0<"3"00<<;3 ?!.#0"0;<//00"A0036;66/ 3300/00"33"0"$'=0+'',6000 9?00 .
>. /6" A / ;0G ?0 " //6 / <6<03 B.,@.& 2C.
)&$)+'', -&&)&&- / 0+* +*1 *+ 1/
6
&. 6! "3""6/6+,K+'',/2"341111111111 9A"(E 0-3"00".
6
+. =.
$. 295;"2"341111111111633; "4.+''.-00 <?0" 0 095"4.$Z'D'.-.
,. ?3 /0 " < ?363 9 A. %& 2 /! ?3/6M""60"$'=":0?00 //033"6"6 0 ?6"6"(5X0I5?<0 @ @'', 0 73/0. "60 / M /;6. 3630"0GC0"0<73<"600"60 0 0/""600<6L C7//<30?003/!0 "3""600LC/0;"/6.(0 36300 /06636366C CC0- " 0 ?6"6 " / / 30: <A0"!"60! .3630"30 3# " /! <0 =0 00 < "600 <6 A!//"<667/6"06B.&$+&'@&'>C. 3" 0 0 " ;??0 60" E0" 2 0
/0?3"/6M0?067/000<A9A??0?6"6 "6/ 0</;??
)&$)+'',