Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
DE FR IT EN
Analizza in Legislator
ATAS/624/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/624/2006 Generato dall'IA

Contractual Liability Based on Chronological Priority and Agreement Validity

Numero d'incarto ATAS/624/2006
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)
Apri la fonte ufficiale Archivio Entscheidsuche Versione Markdown leggibile dalle macchine (.md)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The court considered whether an entity could be held liable for damages arising from an agreement where the validity of that agreement was challenged based on the timing of its execution relative to prior instruments, involving questions of priority and alleged modification. The court reasoned that the established sequence and nature of the parties' prior dealings, particularly regarding instruments executed in a specific chronological order, demonstrated that the agreement in question was neither prematurely executed nor fundamentally altered such that the entity could be absolved of its resulting obligations, thus upholding the finding of liability based on the contractual commitments as executed.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Liability Based on Chronological Priority and Agreement Validity: The court reasoned that the established sequence and nature of the parties' prior dealings, particularly regarding instruments executed in a specific chronological order, demonstrated that the agreement in question was neither prematurely executed nor fundamentally altered such that the entity could be absolved of its resulting obligations, thus upholding the finding of liability based on the contractual commitments as executed.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
responsabilità contrattuale validità del contratto titolo all'ordine nozione di ente aggiudicatore longa manu traditio accordi tra imprese

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied for the allocation of the appeal costs to the appellant.
Generato dall'IA
A/1687/2002
Contractual Liability and Breach of Agreement
A/1926/2007
Contractual Validity and Enforcement of Agreements Based on Conditions Precedent
A/4623/2005
Contractual Liability and Damages Allocation Dispute
A/1775/2004
Contract Interpretation Regarding Transactional Dates
A/1852/2003
Contract Validity Based on Prior Performance and Consideration

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the allocation of the appeal costs to the appellant.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo



               "#$%"&''(  "(&#"&''(



) *) ! +  )! +!*

!, - .

 # / &''(         !"""#$ %&'('  *!*+ !)*+,#+"!!""-#+.+*     /"    !+*    %% -  %0   % % % "+"# % %     1 0 2 "*!+ 34 5& ('67    

            !   /'8:/  

 0*

(;  +"!"+#)3""))" #)!#(:<#,*"*'665  )*=   %%  -  % 0   %   % % % %       + )*!  "! )*",# 1"/ )*=  "2  ,"+ > -!+*!" -!+"! <"" )!*  +*!" <+  ? +( *)+",+#(@7& (@75 +  (@@6;  +*!" <+ ,",+ A 3""))" , * )=*;   +*,"# !)!B#"!(*C"+'666D(C,"*'665;

'; * #""!  @ !E+ '665   " "  *!  *!"+ A !+"! )!* (<#,*"*'66D>#F*'66&;

D; -"+#*#<!*#!))!"+"!(:<#,*"*'665 !"#*+G!*!"+,"+ 4+*)*"!"#*+"!>!)+*!"C"+'666#C>;

&; * #""!  (( C,"* '66:   "  *C+# -!))!"+"!   <!+ *  )**")+"!  A  )*#, > -*+; ('   !" *  !+"! <"" 1 02;

5; -"+#*# *)*#+#)*.+*/"   "+*C+#*!*@ <#,*"* '66: !+* "+ #""!;  !+  ,*+ *#+*!+"<  !+"!<""(*C"+'666D(C,"*'665)!*(+ (*C"+'666D("'66()!*!)3; !"=*G-<"+,!"* ! *!"+ A !+"! <"" F" ,+ -#3#  #"  A  )*#, )* -*+; (' ; (  0  + G- )+ "" *#* -"#*#   !+"! )!*  )#*"!  "G  > !)+*   +  #)H+   ;  !"I G  CI+ * )*  !""! +!  *!* !*!)#++ '9C"'66D 7D'8'66D+*G <!" -+)))"F-)= =!*G-#++<"+B #+"++G !""!*!*-,"+*#"+#)>+*3*G+"! )**")+"!;

:;   *#)!  9 * '66:   "  !++# -"+*)*#++"!  -*+; ('  0!+)**!*+; !"=* <<+G-")+4+*,*#) A)*++"!"#*##""G; )*"+=!* +*+!"!#""!*!))!"+"!;

9; *!*+*#)"G#D6*'66:; *=,G+A++-*+;(' ; '  0 + "+"G   +*+* > -*+; :6 ; (  !  !F"I+"!

1 2  G - C" )!#  )*!F= -"+*)*#++"!;  )*+""*  C*")*-C"#"+G##G""++!+"!!I/ "+#*4+)A)*=<"+!IF)!"+*#**#)*+"! G!I#)+-#)*##+*G4+;



8&958'66:  /D8:/   *))G+A+#!*"* !""+#-4+ % * *( *'665'&58'665+!# )"G-"<"+*#"+# "*J

K#+* > A   #" )+ G "G  -!+"! <"" "#*# ),+ !* 4+* #K 1 "  J K"G   #" )+GA-!+"!<""),+4+*#K2;

*!.+G)*!C+!"@55@*)*>-*+;(';' 0++* -"+*)*#++"!   G" + F*  = !* G  *,"+ > *  )**")+"!G"G-"#)*"*; "*!*+=I/+/G K#*"+#C*""G#+#">)*C*")*+!)*+A+ !"G"+G""+"G>*+" !!F"I+"!+*#,"I* #F+"=*"* *!+**)*!F=-))"+"!*"! "<<"+#)*!,*+K!"K!IK;

7; )"G'&"'66: "*#<=*A)*#+>#*"+* 9*'66:;

@; !"*#+#!"G#>*!*++I*#>CI*;

 +*

(; !"I,!"*L!*I"+"!C"""*12#+#!"<"#+"+"+# = (*!E+'66D  *"F+!*!" !)!#5CI  !+  )*#"+ +  ,"/)*#"+  5 ))#+ + (: CI * 1*+; ( +;*+5: 2;

%"+>L+"!L#+"!(:CI* )* *"F<##* '9C,"*'66&1 0(D6(6:2 * !"I,!"!)+# (D<#,*"*   ")!"+"!+*"+!"**I+)*+++ *"F+!* !"  "#I*  * > +*!" CI +"+"*     L+++  L#+"!!,ACI*;

'; !<!*#+ > -*+; 5:  ; ' +;     *"F +!  * !" !.+  "+ "G  !+++"! )*#, > L*+; D7   !" +! *  !+"! <""  (* * (@@: 1 02; % !)#+ )!*CI*L)=+""#+F";

D; *!*@<#,*"*'66: "+*C+#+) +"+*,F1*+;D7 02;



8&958'66:  /&8:/   &; "+"I)!*+*-))"+"!-*+;(';' 0 +))*+""=*+* *!"+*!*+A!+"!<"""#*#(*C"+'666D( C,"*'665;

5; L*+; ' ; (  0 #<""+  *  )*! C++" >  !";  <!+ !++)*+")*!+","+#*+",!"""#+!+ C++" >   %;  +     *!*+   G" -+ ) !++#  ! -"*  <"+ G- )+ F##<""*  )*++"!   * !M L+*+"-<+"=*)*#)!#*++*F1*+;D;(  02;

L!+"!)!*<++)*++"!!*#=!"G""+ "   "  L<+ CGL>  <"  "  !* G " ++"+ LNI  (7   L" + !"""#  %"  !  (5  L"  L+ ) 1*+; 9 ;( 02;

A+*-*+;(' 0J K *!"+ A !+"! <"" "#*#  )**"+ )* '  > !)+*  !+ !M  F##<"""*   !"  ! *!"+ > )*,!"*  !+"!<"" ")+*5)*=<"!")!*G #+"+;

 !+"! )*O  *!"+ !",+ 4+* *+"+#;  *+"++"! -+ ) #  !*G " G  !+ #+# )B# #+"+  F! <!" + G  *!*<""=*!+!+;

*!"+**+"++"!)**"+)*'>!)+*!+!M "-!+"!<""!"<"+ ")+*5 )*=)"+";%"*!"+.+-+)"F)!*G!")# )*#,!"+#")**")+"!)!I #"+!*#+*"+K;

 #!  ++ ")!"+"! G A  L!+"! <"" "#*# ),+4+**##)*L*##")**")+"!"G= #)H+   ;  +A+ #I L""G ) "  A  !",+ 4+* !#+"<;*#+L"+*)*#++"!!+**"!++!*GL+ );=!* L*#*!"+>'&!"L!+"!<""#" "G GL"!"+#"*G++*#!"+""+!)1<; % (998'66:2;

:;  -)=   *!*+  #)!#    (: <#,*"* '665  !+ G" !P" ,  !"  ! *!"+ > )*,!"*  !+"! <""; )+!)*#+*>A-!+"!>!)+*+++ !"+= (:<#,*"*'66D1<; %(':86::,*"'66:2;



8&958'66:  /58:/    (: <#,*"* '66D   (  #   (@@6 )+ !* *!"+ >  !+"! <""   A +* <+ B+ #C> ++"+ -NI  (5 ; "  #""!   " !+*!B+  !+"! )!* (  <#,*"*'66D>#F*'66&!"+/4+*!<"*#;



8&958'66:  /:8:/    ! + *0  *) ! +  )! +!*



123   4  5   67 .(& +8

  3 

(; #**!**,F;

 3

'; *C++;



 I*<<"=*  )*#"+       *"/!"  Q !*"R    !)"!<!*)*#+4++!+"<"#A)*+")*I*<<





8&958'66: