Lien Modification Validity Under Statute Requiring Written Extension
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispute concerned the validity of a lien against property, where the underlying agreement required written modification, but the parties executed an oral modification specifying a different contractual period for the lien's duration. The court reasoned that because the lien statute explicitly required any modification extending the lien period to be in writing, the oral agreement extending the term was ineffective, and thus the recorded lien expired according to its original written terms, leading to its invalidation.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Lien Modification Validity Under Statute Requiring Written Extension: The court reasoned that because the lien statute explicitly required any modification extending the lien period to be in writing, the oral agreement extending the term was ineffective, and thus the recorded lien expired according to its original written terms, leading to its invalidation.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACosts were imposed on the appellant (Art. 66 al. 1 LTF).
Testo completo
&'()(&*++, "&,',&*++,
"
" -" - -
-. * $ ) #$ *++,
///////// !" #
$ $ ///////// !" #
%$
- 0 - 1 - ! ! " ! - " !$&'()%*+(*+,-*( !4$
2" " "" " ! 34 -5 %$% )% .$)/)%0((1 *2++3 "
! " #$ %
+50
2 "
*8 $9/%'9 +22:*,$;.$ $ .)$ ,$ % )$! -$##<<<<<<<<<%# $#<<<<<<<<<$ ! %+(!.$*'1*8
+8 =; 44$(9/%)$! %! $ .)$ ,$ %$! )$%/ )$ % ! - $ )$!-& )$4 > )$ ; !)?$%$ /8
(8 9/% -$%-!4 % 4+0@%+22:> $ -$%)$%/%!%!%$ A44 $ .!*7 +227 )$?!% )$%/8
08 $ .! %!)$% $ % %% )$!-& ) %$)! % %% !4$)$ % >$ %% - $ )$% > $% $ / % %$ +( !.$*'1*%+0@%+22:8
:8 =$$ $ B == A == = = = = = = (* +227)$%% > )%$ /)$# $#<<<<<<<<<% 0+*A+'1 4$8 '2 4$8 % :+1A::7 % % ! % )$%% $ / - %!$C%D% -$ %*26A:+64$8*2
##<<<<<<<<<A)% !% %$)$!-&)$4 -% $ /%A)A% - %!$% -)$ %8
78 %!%!%$ ?)$% %*'9 +22789$ % $ >!>AD!4%A.$-% A (29 +227$$C%$ %$$ %%.8
68 A.A.9% ! 4 ?!!%!/$!D9/$8
"
*8 A$%8+: 4!!$$ .$)/)$!-&)$4
- $- -%% - %!*6!.$*''(EFG%$!- /$ *$9- $+222$,/)$!$ -$8$>9 %% )H$$)$%% $% D)$%/$E$%8*++%*+( - B G 9/ -$)!%%A$%86(8* 4!!$$ )$!-& )$4 +: 9 *'1+ EG % D ,- $ . %$ ) *$@%+22( %)$,>A44 $
5*6065+227 (50
!%!%$ E$%8*0+ G?!%$A44 )$%/$. ! $!)$% % !%$ !)$9/ -$8
+8 =A$%8++FE-%$- /$) *$9- $+222G -$ )$%% $% > $% $ / % )$%/! 4$!% ?$%8*++*+(*0*%*0+ I$%8(D: FA)) >% )$/ %%D%$4!$$E8*G8$;>9 %)$%% $% D)$%/$$$)D 44!$%$)$%% $% /%! - $ .$ )/ ? %% !-%% % -$ % )$%% $% /%!- $ .$)/? %%!-%% % $ /E48$%8+0FG8$9% D )$%% $% % D A- $ .$ )/ ? %% % $ / %!$C% % -$ E F *+1 +(2I F*+'000G8
H), 9/ )$ ,$ % $! )$%/ )$ % ! )$%% $% > $% $ / )$ $8 % )$% %%H)$%$ /+(!.$*'1*H%$)$% +0@%+22:%D>9/% -$%-?!% $8
(8 = A %$% $ )$%% > )% $ / )$ # $#<<<<<<<<<%0+*A+'14$8'2 %!$C%&%!9D!%!!)$ A % %% )$!-& !4$ !%% $))! > # #<<<<<<<<< A)% !)%$!$ / A%$> %D ?B!)%%+*2A70'4$80:E0+*A+'14$8'2J+G8
08 4$!% D 9$ )$ ) 9$ !%$ % )$ )$%/ 9>A%%$4$%)$%% $% $9 % -$!.!!4 $%%)$%% $ %D %!$C%)% $$ %%B 8 %!$C%%!%? !/A$%8*+ A$$)$!-&)$4 - $- -%% - %! *1 -$ *'10 E +G %? $!/% $ B % )!$ $ E F). !(752+*19 %+22(G
:8 !% $ )$K )$!$ !%% /$% % E$%8 6( 8 + % 1'"8* $)$!$ %$% -*+)%.$*'1:G8
LLL
5*6065+227 050
- " 2 " -" - -
$
678 9 : ;% ',* <=
*8 - %F = = 3M "D-$ $ )%4-$##<<<<<<<<<8
+8 - % B == A == = = = = = = D %$4!$$ )%# $#<<<<<<<<<+*2A70'4$80:DF = = 3M "4-$##<<<<<<<<< > %!$C% )% $ !$% , +0 @% +22:9>A%%$4$%8
(8 H&%%>. 8
08 %>)$!$%/$% %8
:8 4$ )$% >A )-% 4$$ $$ %$ )$!% $$C% ! (2 9$ , % 4 % )$ ) $! $! $ . 4!!$ $ =;N O$;4> 7 7220 %$ ?) $8 ! )% C%$ )$/!8 ! $ % J G >$ ?%% > ! $$% ! $ .% $ % ) ! %%>!I.G?)$)$>% 4 % )- $$%% %$! IG)$%$ /%$$)$!%%8= ! $ % % ) %$ !!% !!$! %%$ G .G % G B $ .4!!$$)$$)%$$% ,$$$$>A -$!$$ $$-.8! $$$% $$& )$- > $% 9 % > ! %%>! % A-)) >!%!?)! !$$%E$%8*(+*27%*21G8 /$44 $ $! %J $$ = .=
) 4$)$!%$$C%%% 4 !?)$% >HDH44 4!!$ $ )$/$44
5*6065+227