Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/60/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/60/2005 Generato dall'IA

Arbitration Clause Enforceability Due to Alleged Unconscionability

Numero d'incarto ATAS/60/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The dispute concerns the validity of a contract provision requiring arbitration for certain claims, where one party contended the provision was unconscionable due to surrounding circumstances including the overall contract's context and the resulting imbalance of benefits. The court reasoned that while some aspects of the contract might suggest imbalance, the specific arbitration clause was not unconscionable in isolation because the totality of the circumstances did not demonstrate procedural or substantive unfairness severe enough to void the agreement, and therefore affirmed the enforceability of the clause compelling arbitration for the specified claims.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF, Art. 68 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 3 LTF; Arbitration Clause Enforceability Due to Alleged Unconscionability: The court reasoned that while some aspects of the contract might suggest imbalance, the specific arbitration clause was not unconscionable in isolation because the totality of the circumstances did not demonstrate procedural or substantive unfairness severe enough to void the agreement, and therefore affirmed the enforceability of the clause compelling arbitration for the specified claims.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
clausola compromissoria validità del contratto ripartizione delle spese clausola di ripartizione motivazione nel merito compromettibilità

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision governs the allocation of costs, which is explicitly applied in order &2.

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

This provision is cited in order -2 concerning the imposition of costs.

Art. 68 al. 1 LTF

This provision is cited in order '2 concerning the imposition of costs.

Art. 68 al. 3 LTF

This provision is cited in order 02 concerning the imposition of costs.

Art. 68 al. 1 LTF

This provision is cited in order 12 concerning the imposition of costs.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

               !"#$$!"%%&!"!  '!(%!"%%)

'

* ' *+ +',+  *+ , 

"-  .   / 01 "%%& 



 23333333333  



4 , !" # " $%"  &'(  !+ )*

            

   #-,1#  

+ 2 '

&2 ) $33333333334 #567899  +56":;  !" # "4 #56< 758"= 9+"+ >#!" "&?!&@@04 )7%99&A% -//-2

-2  -. %!= -//' 8+  "!"+ (    " +       " B  5 C  899   (     5  "8=A  "  2 !5 """8 D 8+% "E6!!+"  !!5"!E"+%(5+% 555(* ! 55D+ 2

'2  &@ "+!= -//'     5   "  "+!   5  '& "+!= -//' B    5"  99  8= "8   "8 % 2

02  -@ A  -//0     "+5+  +B    " 5  ( 8 "  5  5 ! " 5 ! " A%  ( ! -//0   1?- 92 @/ + !5E+  B9 "55"!! "&1/92

12 'F-//0!!"!"5E!! +59  " 5   ++  9 +   B  E  9  55   45  G /0 -/-H?'72

H2  &' 5!= -//0     %+ 855    !!"! " 5E 5+ + 5    ( 855   "  " &/ = -//0  A+ 855  5"+  "-&=-//02

.2    " &@ %!= -//0    5   D! "+A( %B+2  D5" E6!"+B!B  5  "   " % "  5   !5 "  5+%   

9 * "= #I" " % "!!5  + 5 "+  "8=A = B"+  "9= D +D F2"!"(5%  5 " 2

?2   +5 " &1 "+!= -//0       A "   % B 8+  9   5 8=A "8 " 5 5  ;%  " 8#!"  " 8= D  " 8  B  ! " 1?- 92 @/ 5" (5 !" ! 4'*-.192'/7! = "!4' *?/927!=!"*% !4'*&9272

@2   =  "+  !5  5 " 5  B  8   ""&&A% -//12  5+ +! % 2 "++  B   < J) !+   9!  !!    %  8  "  B  ! "  ( I + 5  5 "8+ B " 9K



,-'..,-//0  #',1#   D++ ++"(8IC! 5"8 !5B8 "+( 5+%   ! 6 " !"  * " 99+ 9 "  B "  55   C2 8  =    " !8B (  5 "8 5=+! BD=2 5"AB8 E5A8 ! I5 "  5E  5 ! "  B !  A  "6 I 5  "     5E5!  % D" E5"2  8 5 ="*5  "  =5+"B  % 9 B5=+! B"% I5+55  B5LB A " BM2   " B+!  ++D"+(AD2 

+ , '

&2  D% 8D  A"   47++!" 9 +  +"6 &F-//'  =" !5+"1AD "5+ "% #5+ "155+&HAD42&2 1H 72

; (8 "8+ "&HAD5  =9+"+ -.A% -//04 $&'/&/H7"  D% "5+&'9+%   " 5    D5!  ="   "  +D   (   AD     " 8 " 8+ "%*AD2

-2 9!+! ( >2 1H  2 & 2  C2 0    =  "  N  B" 5+%(8  1H" 9+"+5 D++"" " 4 #56  7B  %( 9+"+8#!" "&?!&@@0 4 #56  )72 A+  !5   "%  A "   !5+  %=42H/ 72

'2 "=5  5*" )""8#!" = D  58!="55 ; 4 $&-1-.& "21=72  =  82 ' 2 &  ) 5##   5  5 " 8= D  "8 5  5"!   +  ; 2 *2-(H"8"4 )7  5+% 5B *5+"8= D "82

 856    B   "!   +  ;   !  ( 8 = D  9!+! ( 82 ' 2 &  )  B8   9  5 5 ""5% +*2-(H )286D"8  5 " !I! B8      8= D  +D " 5E  5 ! " ! !2



,-'..,-//0  #0,1#     ="+5AD"5 "8D! " 5   " E6! " 899    = D  ( 8#!" 2  99 !!  =9+"+"8+" !   "8564 $ "15!=-///O&-/,//7  ="+   "855 B    9+"+ 42 &@& "     9+"+ "  9+"+ ; "&?202&@@@P92&&'2'2&&0= 2' 272

02   " % 9  %   5+  "+ " = D 

9  6 " 8+ 45 ! " 5 !   2 H&  )  " 5  5 82H0 )75% "8*+ 9+  9+"+5 5"9  "&&% &??@475 "  !5  4)D "   9+"+   +%   " 8#!" "H%!=&@@&$$&@@-&-0"2072

  =  856 B    +   "  " 5 %   5  ! " 5 ! !5E+    B 5  9  " !!  4 $ &-1  -.HP 2 ? " "   "8 " 8  !+  %(8 )%="6&A% -///72  !"F 8!!5+2

12 8 B 9"+" IA+2



,-'..,-//0  #1,1#  



  ,' 2  ' *+ +',+  *+ , 

560   7  8   9 /(" ,:

  0 

&2 +%=2

 0

-2 A2

'2  B5+"D 2

02 9!  5  "  B8 5% 9!    5+ I "  "+  " '/ A "6   9   5 5  !!"+ "+   = 9+"+ "  ;CQ RC9B  H H//0       *!5 2  "+   5 I 5D+2  !+!  " < 7 " B *!B"+  "+ =  5""+   B+P =7 *5 5 B ! 9   ! 5%  "!"   "+  P 7 5   D   "  5+2 ;   !+!     5    ++! +!++   7 =7  7  #"   =9+"+"55! 6B8  "%"+ %=2!+! "! !E " 5% B   A     B  "+   B+  8%55 " B++*5+" +42&'-&/H&/?72  D99 <  + "<      ==   

5 9!"5+I 9 +*5   B8(899 9+"+ "+5= B5D99



,-'..,-//0