Challenge to Arbitration Award Based on Exceeded Authority and Legal Deficiency
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appellant challenged a judgment upholding the validity of an arbitration award, arguing that the arbitrators exceeded their powers and that the award was legally deficient and clearly contrary to public policy. The court reasoned that the arbitration agreement clearly granted the arbitrators the authority to interpret the governing commercial contract and determine appropriate remedies for the breach, and the alleged errors in interpreting the contract and applying remedies amounted to mere mistakes of law or fact, which are generally not grounds for vacating an award unless they rise to the level of legal deficiency or a violation of public policy. Since the appellant failed to demonstrate that the arbitrators disregarded their contractual mandate or that the award mandated an illegal act, the court affirmed the lower court's decision upholding the award.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Challenge to Arbitration Award Based on Exceeded Authority and Legal Deficiency: The court reasoned that the arbitration agreement clearly granted the arbitrators the authority to interpret the governing commercial contract and determine appropriate remedies for the breach, and the alleged errors in interpreting the contract and applying remedies amounted to mere mistakes of law or fact, which are generally not grounds for vacating an award unless they rise to the level of legal deficiency or a violation of public policy. Since the appellant failed to demonstrate that the arbitrators disregarded their contractual mandate or that the award mandated an illegal act, the court affirmed the lower court's decision upholding the award.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive regarding the cost award for the proceedings.
Testo completo
$%&'($'&&) $)*($'&&)
+ "+ , +, ,
-. ,/ 0 ! 1 2! '&&)
!"#$% &' (
(
)) )!(&$$!"#$" (#$ *(+!,-'
! " !#
30.++3
3
+' ' ! $ +421! (- "5 0 # 0//+ ## "3 66(7$%",-89#5:;'($%(( <$"$ =3"( " 0/ # +4>+ 8 ; 5, " 89;'
0' 04 5(#6 0//?! 9#5: #5 "$( "9"( #((@+?5(#60//?9$6((-(5 5" " -! -( ( <( " & "(' 5# -($($"$5 (#$""$#8 ;'
1' ++ (6 0//?! <<($ " & "( ( (($@(A
B$57#((3('$7 B&" C "5($" #$@ (' D:( 55($' ( (' 3$$#( 7:5("5(($"95(-##(" & " E<< ("( <&#( (&F' )< ": $&,C'
?' @(#5$#("9"+4(60//?!9$ "$$%9"(-+G-0//?' @9<( H&&&!&$I7#"(6#-#(<$"&"(' <( " H&&& "F < 5 #' -( ( " " ##$"(! #"$ 5&-#(' 5 &J $(( 55 +? 5(#60//?'9-(H#<<("((<<(5-('
($ !5$(#$"(("&57 " & "( <.5< $$ 5 ! "&! 0+ # 0//?%96"$-$'
2' 00 (6 0//?! ! 5$( 7& (75$"@ " #555(#$"( #((@9"("(( "+G-0//?(@9:-(F6(6(+?5(#60//?' "&($(( "$#$("('(75$(( 5$-(5(($((56"(-%+//K",+?5(#60//?( %2/K",045(#60//?'
G' 9$ $($ 75($ " 0> 04 (6 0//? % @ $$ ':6(75"&"(5 '
L' 55(#$""+>-#60//?" !((("9$ #$ ( " & "(' 55( " ($ - 9"( $(( ( ( 9: -( 5 " $ "$&$$(-' 5(( $(( 5($
.+/01.0//2 31.++3 (( " (- " +? 0> 5(#6 0//?! % 2/ K " 04 5(#6 0L (6 ( % - (( " 0> (6 +? -#6 0//?' , +2 -#60//?!5(($((((#(56"(-'5($(( <-6'
>' "$"0?-#60//?!9<$-#("5(( 5 9$-$#( " +? 5(#6 0//? $(( "$ @9 9&( "9 "(! "9 $ #$' 9$-$#( " +G - 0//? 9$(( 5 " #, -#66 % 9& " (6 (($' (6 "$$ ##<((%9("6("-5-(5M( #5($%F($"(F("((((((5 "9"'
4' +L "$#6 0//?! 7! 3#" " 9$ <( 55( % "$"0?-#60//?!5LH-0//2($((55(! -(@#$"3(%"$"9'
+/' +1 "$#6 0//?! 9$ <#$ 55( % "$ " 9 5$($'
++' "$ " +L <$- 0//2! 9 H($ 955(' <( " 6("-$((((#"#((( 5$(( 6H(-#( 5 " "&($ 5(,' 9: -( <( "##&6F($!"57$#,F($6!"(5 "#(( 9F( 5(-#( "9 "( ( "9 $ #$ % "('!9$-$#("+G-0//?9-(5$($$H@9% "$("9"('((6(($-$#($((#( 56#566'
+0' >-0//2!9$%9(""$55(5, " 6 ( " ' -( 6 6 "( 9&( "9 "$7 " #$@ " &" 1! ( $ #$ % "((F##$"FF("57$#,"$&$$(<'
+1' G#0//2!95($"(#""$"+L<$- 0//2'
+?' 01 # 0//2! 6 " $ ( " " #5( 5("9@M('
( "$$ @ +G - 0//?! <( H&&& 76(' ##( "$ 5$ 5" I 7#" 7$! 5" &$((@&("('M($"##$"(#(' (--"("N55(F5(7I'(,# 5"( "F3( #! 5 9( #$ 5(( % 5((' ($
.+/01.0//2 3?.++3 ! &$$(! @9 -:( # < 5 # 5 "9(56,#'"((5$!<((,(((( 9-( 5 5 H&&& "5 (( "(' )9 <( 5 (, ((( -(""&'+?5(#60//?!(-!9(6$ 55""-' -(-(3@(-"#( -"F3(O!(#M#"&@"$(" 9$-,#("+G-0//?'9-(H##&-(+G- 0//?'5(("(:((-"#$&&5$-(" "'
(" ## ($#! "$$ @ ( B $($ -(# "9 $ #$ ( " &" 1 " & "(! ( $ #5((' 9 <<($ (75 " @ H9 5 (( @99:-(5"$"$&$$(-"&"5((!%9F5(" (@5$(($&,$"$&$$(-##-(-(' 5$@(($"$&$$(-95"-$#$' #$#$("%"('(56@$#$ (-9$-$#("+G-0//?'-(65"5((- (#(##H!((-$57#("&6$@ ("(65#5((@@#-@@#5 ("' "$ " @ # ( +G - ( +? 5(#6 0//? ( "$ (""' " @93"% "9 $ ($ ( 5 "(6 @ 9( 5 " (' ( 56 @ #-#( " - " 5( 5 &" $ #$' ( "<< " "($"#$@'"(H5F5""@" "(($"<(@9((&((-$'5$@" 55("+>-#60//?@H9((("955("($( -9"(H#$<,"<<$##(%"+?5(#6%" +G-0//?C'
+2' 0L#0//2! !#$"3"9(#$!" 55$( #$" 6 " " " 9$' -$ @9 #6( F H( " "$(# 9$-$#( " +? 5(#6 0//? $(( #6%"('($($((56((#(# "+G-(5(7&' $((#(56"$$(("5" ( # :#5(#(& - $5$( " (-($ #' $#! $(( @9 "$7 5( "9 #$@ 9(P( 5 " 56,# #$@ # " (( 9#"( 5&-#( 5( M( ( :( <&$ (( (( (! " !:($"F(#5'
+G' +/H0//2!%"#"" 6"$! "$ ""(9$-$#("+G-0//?',-@AB' #9($0+#0//?"""&"(@95$((
.+/01.0//2 32.++3 "5@@#'9F#@9#($"5(!7# " $ - 5( ( % #6(' "&57$(("#'6&#((5":"# <##('9("(((#("$<$"1F2//#&.H()5( &! @ " 5' )5(( 5(7& #$ " & "(! H9 ##"$ % ' " ( (75$"(' #9( 5 56""(-"$#$("&""& "(' 5( 6 M( 55 -( @95, (( " 0+ # 0//?C'
+' &-9&(H"8;$($#"<$((($!", +N(0//1! 6("!#5$"2H&! "(5$"((-35$"(!255$((+GH&8('+(' (2G ;'
)(%9("9$("+GH&!5 6<$"$ 0LH-0//?8 *+1/+/G;!" &-"5($!+1<$-! "5(((&(5#((( 6(" " $& % ( H& ((! ! " 9((( " 9$("-FH&'
0' <#$#( % =(' 2G ' + (' 7' 2 ! 6 ( " P((@"(((5$-%9( 2G @ ( (- % <$"$ 93"( " 0/# +4>+8 ;'
)#5$(5H&""95,($(6'
1' #Q9$-$#((-5,9($-&+ H-0//1"<$"$5(&$$""(" "G(60///8 ;!3(556"95,8 *+04?;'
?' ((&@("-$#$"(<<(( ("%"(5(M(@<$"$#$%"('
2' ;"(%"5(("$("="($55"=6"!( =$-$#("##&6"(,"((=(((%($!" ($(' ((F&(#5@=:"="#((@! ($-$#("(!"##&(55"("((!@= ( 5 - " #M# #,' =( 5 $! -7! @ ="((@##$"("=(((%($R<((<<( @ =$-$#( "##&6! $ $-(#( % "=( <(! ( 5-@$=(((%($57:@5:7@"=$!=(3%3"@=
.+/01.0//2 3G.++3 5$(##"(@"3')-=$-$#($ (=(((%($($555("($((@( " <(! @ ="#(( ! $7$(! H& F# <"( (#( " &#( "=" #$" 8 * +04 +>+ "' 1'+!?/G"'?'1'+!++411L"'+!++>0>4"'+6($<$;'
6; ) H5" ( "(! =(($ "#((- H& "-( "$ <( ## 5-$ @ @= ( - " $($ 8D##! " " S-5I7(! ? $"'! +4>?! 5' +1GR :&! "-T(&7(5<&! 0 $"'! 5' 0L> 7' 2;' "# " !H&<""$!<"5(("! <(@!<("=M($(6"#,$<(6!55(## 5 -#66! =(3%3" @ 5$(( "&$ " -#6 5$5"$(' <<( " 5 @= <( 5 M( "$$ #( ## 7:5(7, 56' # ( $$#( " <( $&$ -&6! H& "(! $7$(! ( F @ 5( 5 5668 *+0G1G/"'26!+02+42"'0($<$;' =F(3(3 5! "( " ! 55 @ ="#((H&"-(((!""(!<-"=$8 * +0G100"'2;'
G' ; ($5($"(((((("##&6!"(-(!5($ 5 7# 5 F($ F(" @ #5#( ($ 57:@!#(5:7@@(P#(8('? ;'$(" "$<( #M# " ="( @ (, F(" " =((( 5 <<( " <( F($! # #( <( 3#M#' , ! #5( 5 @ <( F($ ( (P$! ! " $@ &- (("' <( F($ ( "$$ ## F(" @= F,"! " 5(! " " $-$#( ( " (( @ = 5(! 6H(-#(! @< " @(" "=76(
8 *+04?/?"'0'+!+00011"'+!+0+1>"'+@ $<$;' $ " % =<<( 8,-#(! "$5#( " 7& (##(;! <( F# " =<<( "( M( "$$ ## F("! (( #5( " ((( 57:@ ( " 76(" 5<("=($$8 * "+2(60//?!4./?;'
6; (!F(#"=('G'0 ! <$"$5(" = " $ 5 @ ( #66 F $@ "= "(' -( " (( "$$&( " #5$(! <$"$ $"($ =(' 4 ' 0 " ’" =3"( " 0/ "$#6 +4>0 8 ;!@5$-(@$-((#$%"(!#M# (5$5<(F($"(,F("A
.+/01.0//2 3L.++3 '<(!"#Q(5#<(#($5 #"R 6'"$6P(#("=((R '"$7"#$@R "'"$7"# '<#("#R <'"$7"("R &'$"&#(R 7'$"(:#5'
(( ( " $ #$ % "( ( F7(- 8 * ++G +?/ "' ?! +?L "' 06! ( $<$R ! )7TI7 <-7&7(!0$"'!+4>4!5'0/0;'("$#$% "( 5 6( "=$-(! 5<( " =$! "(( -( "<< ( #" ( "(' 3"( "-(3 # @@!""((5$($!"-(55M(-( 5 =3#"8 *+01 ??-' "'06!++G+?L-'"'G! ++?1/+"'1R 0//+?125'110!+4>>2L5'1L1"' ?6RU7!<V77DW57V"&&!)S)+44G5'>?;'
$(M(8 *+04?GG;! 6<$"$"5$ "("=("5(("$5#$% "(' <#(H5"56$F *+01?1(" 0//+ ?12 5' 110! 55 @=% =F5( " (, F(" " F($! (( ( "( (((- " ( "="( "-( M( $$' & @= (( #(,! =F( "= F($ 3 ( $-$#( # % "(! F( 5 7#! 5(6 "=M( (($ " #, 6H(- ( @ 5$( ( #5( 3 -M( 5($ 5(, @=% "$<(! <N(3 ## #5 <( "$7( " $ 5 " $#$$ % =(' 4 ' 0 ! (6 (($ ( #<(#( #5(6 % #" % " 57$#, "$&$$(< "( 5 7& #6 % =3#"8 *+04?G>"'?!+01??-'"'06!++G+?L "'0!++?1/+"'1R 0//+?125'110!+4>>2L5' 1L1"'?6RU7!'('!5'>L;'
-(3"=F("=$5#$%"( "(Q<("##&6F($<"-=55( 85 5#, <; " " "(<$ ## $(( " :#5(X# " $ 5 " $#$$ % =(' 4 ' 0 (' % 7 ' =55(""((@(((5F($ "H5"' "=((#!=("$"( 5$%=F("=<("##&6F($##$$"<( @=% ##( 5$! =$ $5-$ " " 5 5#, <' =F& "= <( "##&6 F($ =( 5 5 "$ @
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
;9M(5$($8+>/./1;! * "$$@<(555( "F9$5-(6#M#(#5@9(("( "9#""",5"(%(#(#" 9$5 ( @ #-#( 9-( 5 $($ "! -( "9 (&-($' (!9$(("$$##(!@##6 5$ &7 ( ($ " #, 5(, ( @9 57$#, F($ 9(<,' ( " @ 9$ 9$(( F$ 9$5 &7 $-$( 5 @9 $-$#( # % "(! F(57#!5(6"9M((($"#,6H(-("9 (#5(!(5"('*(""##&6F($!9: -( 5 "9"#(( @ 9$ ( $($ -(# "9 $ 5 #$ % "( " H5" ( " "5( $& 5$($'
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
L' ; 95,!$#$<(5("("$#$% "("9('4'0(' ' $@!5M(%7& " 93"(! (( $ "( - $($ "$7$ 5 F($!"H5"5$($' ($&"!@("- <("-"5(55((7&"9-"F% (O5((((<("##&6F($5((-( ",@ 6"$5-@($(( $#$"(<<(((9$-$#("+G-0//?Z @ (( #<(#( <( "##&6 F($! "9 (($59(#$!(("&%("&#("5" I7#"Z(#(56#566'
<<(!(F5$!"-((!@9-((+G - 0//? " " ##$"( % ( "9 #-#( <$ " & F$($ "( H&&&! @ 9$(( #"$ 5&-#( 8@("9"+4(60//?;!@"$((( "( 0 % 1 # 5 9$(( #$ 5(( % 5(( ( @9 9$(( 5$ # @9 "-( < (, ((( 5 5 @9 -(! #$&( & 85,3-6 " 01 # 0//2;' ! <#$@$5-(M($%9$-$#("+G-0//?$(( (@"(#(##H"&(P(@@#5 (""(#(#5#5(((@"$"@#(+G- (+?5(#60//?$(("$B(""C'#M#! !
.+/01.0//2 3+/.++3 ((-(@95-("($!((($@9-(5( ( ((#( " $<$" ( )5( @ " 5! 5((5(7&#$"&"("("0+#0//?!(% ( " 9$-$#( " +G - 0//? ( 6 ($#( % " +? 5(#6 0//?' <! -$ @ ($ $(( #(56($(9$-$#("+G-0//?",@9: -( $5$( " (-($ # ( "$ " 5 " 1 # :#5(#(&' 5"(! - ( % ( $&" -M( < 56(",@9(<"$<($!(@((5 $5$(((-($#"5+G-0//?(@99:-(5 " :#5(#(& "( 1 #' ! -7! "$$! ( "#M#@ !@9$#$"F(#5 $(( 566 $(( @9 "$7 5( " #$@ 5-( <&(('
6; : "9"#(( @ ($ ( ( 9$-$#( " +G -0//?($#$"( <<( ( ($$!- "&$ " -#6 5$5"$( ( @ 9 (- 5$ "9 $#$%"('
>' $@! "( M( "# ( 9(#$ "#$ % 5" 7&("9"('
.+/01.0//2 3++.++3
, 3 "+ , +, ,
!
456 7 8 9# %-' :
6
+' $-6'
! 6
0' 9"#(""$('
1' (@5$"(&(('
?' <# 5( " @9 5-( <# ( 5$( M( " "$ " 1/ H ", (<( 5 5 ##"$ "$ 6 <$"$ " ! )7TI7<@ G! G//? ! ( F#5' "$ 5( M( 5&$' #$# "(A ; "@ F(#(@"$("$6((5""$ ((@$R 6; F5 5 @ #(< (# 5- "#" (( ( "$R ; 5( &( " 5$((' ) #$# (( 5 ( $$#( $#$$ (( ; 6; ( ; 3"! 6<$"$"55(#(,@9 "-"$-6'#$#"#(#: " 5-! @ ( H(! @ "$ ((@$ ( 9-55 " @$($F5$"$(8('+10!+/G(+/>;' &<<,A 5$"(A :) $
5<#"5$(M(((<$F5(@9%9<<<$"$ "($56@5&<<
.+/01.0//2