Enforcement of Financial Obligation: Statute of Limitations and Interest Calculation
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA petitioner challenged a ruling related to the enforcement of a financial obligation, asserting that the lower court erred in its application of relevant statutes concerning the statute of limitations and the calculation of interest on the debt. The court reasoned that the trial court correctly determined that the obligation was subject to the specified statute of limitations, which had not expired when the enforcement action was initiated, and further concluded that the interest calculation method employed by the lower court was consistent with the controlling contractual terms and statutory provisions, thus affirming the judgment enforcing the financial obligation.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Enforcement of Financial Obligation: Statute of Limitations and Interest Calculation: The court reasoned that the trial court correctly determined that the obligation was subject to the specified statute of limitations, which had not expired when the enforcement action was initiated, and further concluded that the interest calculation method employed by the lower court was consistent with the controlling contractual terms and statutory provisions, thus affirming the judgment enforcing the financial obligation.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited for the allocation of court costs to the losing party in order 1.
Cited for the allocation of costs to the losing party in order 1.
Testo completo
$%&'()%*++' $ $%,-.%*++/
$
0$1 $0 0$1 $$0 $1
23 - " &+ 2 *++/
!"#$%&'('& ( )*+ ,
(
-. .. .. !/)0 "" ()'
! "
!#
5!165
0 $
7 85&$9 :' (; ' 3 0')< 642()&='&'('>. 7 (('(('( 0( &? ( &? &$ 0 @ .@ .'(' 0: ( 0(7 ) 0:A( !""B (%(' @)0 ( 0(@0((0$('('(?''C-. .. .. 85 &$9-. ::()';7
!7 !)!""B:)&=0:')&0'(0:0( 7 ( 0*'*:'(&()(('('/'&?D?( )/$0(0!2?'%!""B7&(0&((('(( &0DD/(:'&0(7
27 4)!""B:'<0:'&0(70'/)&$( 0:(0(0(00)5'&E'('(('7
47 &&()'0(0F)!""B %' 0)< 0 D D/ ( )(( 0 )<(' 0 :'& 0( '%<70D(*'0()(&(' )&$(0??0((7
B7 0 D 0( 0 B ) !""B 0'/ 0 D0 ((D(<0<(??'0&('0)'* (%E(%0&(()'0'('(('7
37 0(0!"%!""B:'<(/&0:'&0(( (/&0D0(7:&'('('??('&7
#7 (04)!""B )'00:-. ()' * :' &'(( 0 (< 0'D''(? )G7 &'( :'(( & ' % :HD 0 &((7 ( &'' ) & 0:E&(?00'()0('((<0('( :'%')(0!2?'%!""B7
F7 F %)< !""B 0 E&( ?0' 0 )'0 8% < 0D*; ? & -. 0 0D*0:'*:E)*(<0D*'' &7
:E&()(%'((&&)(*:E&'0((* ')' 0 0 0D* 0 0D( &&'( )(%' 0 % 0 )<E % C (('( (?* * '& E*(&'7
123 41!""3 52165 &' 0D( %(9 (( 6 ) &$ &<< (<'D0:'&0((%0)<0DD/ (&<(<'D0D0(I(0&(//*('%$0 ?? 0 (( 0 :'& 0( % / D'5/)' 0'<(( 0I (/ )5% 0(I (( 3 ) 1 &$ )&( (1'5( 0 ?? 0 (( ( ((( ( D'5/)'0:'&0(I((3)J&$)'()(0 D0(000:D(/(0'<((7
%0(<0'D''(?((':E&(0''*:( ( :'%')( 0 !2 ?'% !""B ( &(/D 0'D''(% <G(%'%0:'&0(*0(C:(%(/D &%(&K((7()()<(&:':'((??(&'&(' D0'0'()(0??0((7 50<( 0'D''*0(C:(%(/D0!"%!""B7 ((*(10'('(((00')E)02C3)7
(0('(:'%')(0!2?'%!""B('0D 0((((&00)0&<%)K)E7 ??(( &< * ( '%')( ( D0' ( 0 D 0( ')( <'D:<0:=)&()(DD?(%))'0(7/D ((0))<?'0(0AC<(D0'&'0 D D/ 0 (( )&)( '%'' ( & ' (< 0'D''(?7
67 ( 0 6 0')< !""B )'0 0:-. 0/'' E 0 :E&(7 0*' * (( * 0:'&0(0%(K(0''))(((&(0C?) !""B(4C3)&$:0(7
"7 0'0 B?'%!""3-. ?'0&(&(< D0(&<0:50(<D(()()C (%(&(<C:'&0(0$ %!""B7
7 (0''('?&&'0:&&(0(0 4)!""37
!7 # G !""3 -. G(' :&&( ( ?)' 0' 0 B ?'% !""37 :E&( 0 )&( (( 0( &' & G&0 & % L( & ? &<( :( C G(((*:()'(()E&((&(<C:'&0( 0$ %!""B(*0('(:'%')(0!2?'%!""B ('0D'(('7
27 (0('0B(<!""3))C<0&(4(< !""3 :' < ( 0 7 (
123 41!""3 54165 &&)(C:(00'0#G!""3(<0)( 0')(0:(5E&(7
((('((0:E&(07 ((? &0(())((?()'000F&()<!""37 . 0 ' 0( ??( ( ( @'%0))(@ 0(7(&0'*((/(C)(&((??( ()(&0'&0(()0D0(7
47 2%)<!""3-. G(07&0 0'%&&(:D)((&'('00'&&(7
B7 '( &(' 0 0')< !""3 ( &(' 0 7(()''0&%*%E&(7
37 -. '&*' 0( 0 F ?'% !""#7 ())( %' *: % E&( '(( &? ( &%( K( ?' %( 0 0( 0:K((07
#7 .'('D0'CGD7
0
7 D%MD(G08;'(')0?'((('0$ A(!""2 <(0)&'0BGD 0(&'0((%5&'0(B&&'(( 3GD8(7 (7 (B3 ;7
.(CM(0M'(0 3GD& <?'0' !#G%!""48 N 2" "3;0 D%0&(' 2?'% !""4 0&( (( D( &)((( < ( 0 0 'D C ( GD (( 0 M(((0M'(0%EGD7
!7 ?)')(C:(7B37 (7/7B <0'L( ((*0(((&'%C:(7B30?'0' &( D''00(003(<!""" 8 ;* ((%C?'0':50(0!") 6F 8 ;7
.)&'(&GD00M&$('(<7
27 (G('0?)(0''DE(%<C?)8(7 "3 0(%D( G%!""2(2 0')<!""3 0'D(CM(73" ;7
123 41!""3 5B165
47 (D &( 0( 0 ( C 0 &(( 0 :50( &'0D0(*&'C:'&0(50C0
2 )!""B7
B7 . :( 3 ' &(( 0: ( ' 0M0( &? 0M0( &? ( 0 )0 &?7 0(C0&((0'(0M0('&& 0M<0 ( M'%')( 0))D< 0 ($ 0( ( M((( C (' 0 (' (7 (( ED 0 (' ( ( )& *: = 0:0)(( * ( '%')( 0( 0))D(&&0(0((*:(&%0)K) )$7%/:(&'*:0((* ))'0(0:(((C('I?((??(*:'%')(0))D< ' '%()( C 0:( ?( ( &%*' :((( C (' &/=*&=/*0:':(5C50*:&'())0( *057
.% :'%')( ' ( :((( C (' ( ' & &&( 0 ('((*(0?(*:0)(('/'( GD E)( ?0( ()( 0 D)( 0:0 )'0 ( * 0( K( (/' ?)( C $D 0 0D' 0 %)<&'&0'(&&*'D'')(C:&&'(0&% 0 : 7 * :E( 0: &&( 0 C ??( ( :0( ( 0))D &L( &< ) *: &( & K( *?'0&<<0&(0(C0&((?0' :0('0(K('8 N !6 F 0727 4"3074727 I N 622#07 F!F607 <('?';7
0 (' 0'*( ( *( 0 0( *: &&(( C :0)(((0GD0(/7('(0'*( 0:&$ 00/ (:E&'0%?(0'' '((&&C(L??(0D0*:(&0(%0 '(( &( 0 ?O D'' ?%' & ( ( 8 N !6 F 0727!4"B07!7! !B43 07B('?' B 4"B074;7
.:&(0)((*:0(:?(*0'/&*( 0 ((?O%('%')(0('( ( =)&(P) &'(' & :' ( :0( 0( K( ' * :'(( )0? ('(%(0Q(%(%(:0(8((*(;: (&%(00:'%(*:((((:0(8(( *I 66! 4! &7 #B 07 4<I N'0 :50( <D( ./RS/ 0%R(D/( T.U .S .//( 4 ;7
123 41!""3 53165 ? G&0 ?'0' :((( C (' ( )( 0'/' ) & &%*' & :0( :50( &0 /D=0)0E'C:'%')(0(8 !"""V2#F &7 6"072T N &<'0#?'%!""" 46166UI N &<' 0 F A( !""" 41""I ?7 'D)( 1 . D(/(D%WX/Y0 6F"&7B4&(&7B3;7
37 (()%(0:E:&&(0(3'! (6 ' ! * ((( 0 ' & )' C 0(7 ( 0 :( 6 ' ! (( 0 & (( *M ( & )?()( )&(< C )0 C 0 &/')$ 0'D''(? 0'/0)'*()'C0()K):(&'& ?(E('0($E(07
(( 0&( :( ((? & &(( 0 0:&$7 ??( ?)(G&08 N !242I N 3 23; <?'0' 00'(K(8 N !6433;&&'*:C:E&(0 ($ ZE(0[ 0 E(' (( ( 0( (((%0(0:0(0%(K(''7 0' & )' C 0( %( 0 :( 6 ' ! &<(' 0 :50( <D( && * ( ' ( '')( ('(* 0: 0( C :E&( 0 ?( E(' 0 ($E(07
D?())(*:(6'! :)&&%)( 0:&((:<0('((:0((:(((C ('8 .1 331!""30 F0')<!""3073;7
: ($ E(0 0 :'%')( 0 !2 ?'% !""B :G)'('(('&-. 7.0('((( '%')(((<0D0(((('7
#7 ( (D \ C % :E( 0: 0 (' ( (:'%')(0!2?'%!""B('C('\'00% 0 &&( )'0 0 * & 0' 0( ( 7
*%&<(0:&&()'0*(0'()( :( * &( (DE ( ?( :<G( 0: '(0 (' * &&(?00E))&(*:&'D)(0'( &( E&)' & & E)' *: ( '(' '(< & 0:)$*0&(0(E()'0(:&&'( 0 (( )'0 ( ( ? * 0 :E&( ( 0A)( )(%'7 0)( :'')( 0'()( & % &<(:(:D0)=0&%0'D())&&(
123 41!""3 5#165 ))E&()<(<(7?)'0:<(00 & 0( 8 N !B 2B! 07 2I !! 3" 07 ( '?';7
&& GD :'( & )(? )&'(? 0 0: E&( )'0 (H/ 0 :E&( '(( &'')( 0 )(( &'C0&(0G(0M0)((?0 :'&()'0E0:'((0?(0'7
.G&0&(((0:'(0:E&(?( * 5 ( 0 (0( *: E&( 0' & (< ?) 0 )$ %(7 ( * 0:(&'(')(((0&(&(C)((')( 0(&(00'0(0:E&(&(E (&'(( 0%D( 0 0 0 & GD < (( )&')( ?) 0: % E&( )'0
8 N !B2B!072<1('?';7
.&&0<&&'(0&%*M&&*< &'0 0)((% *M &'0 0 0 0( 0)((? M0)(( GD &&' <)( &% K( ' & 0 $D ?) &'0( C &&'( )&$( ( D 0 &%7 $ GD 0( E) 0 )$ <G(% ( )= 0 &%**M(&%&0'00)(C0&( &)(((0&(GD)(%<0((DE7
F7 :&$ <0'&(*((*&&()'00 0 F %)< !""B )&( (( 0( &' & G&0 & % 0 & % &<(7 (( &((0(*&)(((0:'(7
()(0:&((*&(&)((0 0(0'((07((0((% *(??(&*GD%C0(00:(&&(7
?(%* )'00:'%(4 )!""B0'GC&('&'0(<0(=&0'D''(?7
(?()'000F&()<!""3:( &&C)(((((07
)$)( (?( )&( & 0( &'(' &' & G&0 & % L( ? &<(7 ?( &( %*:((%((((*D''&(*05 0( * $%( & 0 0( % 0 &(* * 0 )'07
123 41!""3 5F165 :((&)(%':(& ?0''(0&&?000( 0'(&(E()'0%??))(0&'7
E$))()'0(((0(E&*/(C)( :'??(()(&0'&0(()0 D0(7&(&0(0/'C&(0%&*)'0 ((( 0:'D :E( 0: 0 (' %( 0 && Z&(/D&&(/[*:&0%&<()) < ?'0'0M&''8 N 624 707!<1<<I 666 V24 &74"F7072<;7
$))(()'0(((0(7(( &&( 0 G&0 0'GC (' %( 0 ( )&( 0 ?( %(0:E&'*0&&(0?0(&%'D')'0 (((00((0C(/?%0&((
67 ( 0)0 ((? < 0 ' 0:0 (5 E&(70(0:K((08(7!67! (;)&0())(0( 0:<(*:(0'(E??0&%&((8 N !646# 07 !7! ( '?' (';7 GD &( &0( ? ) &<(*:0$*:(&(C&&(&%* &%0)('(&)0?)%((*&'0(0: )$<(C&&'((&'0&%*( &&' ((0 *: &( :) C )0? & 8 N !""B 2#B 07 !7!I N 2" 4!B 07 !7 ;7 % 0 )K) *?(C'(<'(0'GC0(((((008 N !""B26#07470;7
: 0' 0'GC 0 0'( &''0( * &&( 0 :(&G(C(*7$:<00('( :'%')(0!2?'%!""B('0D*0:'& 0( 0& % !""B '( 0'GC 0 ((( * (( 0 07 ( :( 0 < 0 &'0 C 0 ( 0:(( )&')(&(7)&?(*(&(D&:% 0() <0'C0(5 E&(7
"7 % 0 * &'$0 G(' ( 0' &&( (&?)'7(&'('&%(:<((&D0 :&0(C00'&8(73 (7D I(7F6-72 ;7 *:<((($)(D0-. :&0(C00'&8(7 (73 (7D I(7F6-7 ;7&'0'((D(( (&&O0?8(73 (7 I(7F6-7 ;7
123 41!""3 56165 4$ 5 # 1 0$1 $0 0$1 $$0 $1
6722 8 " " 9: ('* 1;
$ 72
7 '%<?)'4(<!""37
$ 7"
!7 G((7
27 (*&'0(D((7
47 ?) &( 0 *M &%( ?) ( &'( K( 0 0' 0 2" G 0$ (?( &$ 0 < ?'0' 8./RS/?*33""4 ;&%0)($00( &<?)')(E(7F!0?'0' <?'0'0 # G !""B 8 N;I )') 0 0( 0* )(? ( )=0&%(&(D(0(0)0(I0( K( 0' < ?'0' & % &( & % '(* E 0( 0 :(7 4! N7 &'( K( ( &$ & 0 (%*')))=0&%0%(K(G(C:%7 D??$ .('&/ , .=% - > D&&'(
&?)0&'(K(((?'E&(*MCM???'0' 0('&<*&D??
123 41!""3