Validity of Prior Judgments in Collection Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns disputes arising from several transactions occurring between 1990 and 1995, with litigation initiated in 2005 concerning the validity of prior judgments and subsequent collection efforts, particularly regarding amounts awarded to one party. The court reasoned that the prior judgments were not void on their face, meaning the issue was not jurisdictional but involved potential error or fraud in the underlying action, which generally requires a direct challenge rather than collateral attack in a new proceeding; consequently, the court upheld the prior judgments as valid and enforceable against the challenging party.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Validity of Prior Judgments in Collection Dispute: The court reasoned that the prior judgments were not void on their face, meaning the issue was not jurisdictional but involved potential error or fraud in the underlying action, which generally requires a direct challenge rather than collateral attack in a new proceeding; consequently, the court upheld the prior judgments as valid and enforceable against the challenging party.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive section for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Testo completo
#$%&'#$(() *#+'+#$((+
*
*, ,*, ,
+- . $/ ! $((+
!"""# $% & '!'(
!('
)) % % % % !"""# "("# '!( *+,- .!(/01, 2322 /
!"
$341$
, 0*
27 (8##9":"$'(:";""(#2'<;"' 2==,02"2==1(>2'<;"'2==57
37 06!;8'2==5 :99"(!.'!?@#A B!'#C :'# .'(("! !.#("' 9##' ( (! "" D 8":'$">2'#8'2==57
07 1#8'2==5 :'#!#!!'C: .!'!.("! .'(("! '#('!("; :'$";""(# C !'' 26E-22 9'7
06 ;;'.'(("!.F#.'(!99"7
-7 2, 9#;'"' 2=== : 'G " (! @;!" !.("! A B (( ! ( : (""# .!' !.' ; ;'#.(.#'"!2';'"2==/06!;8'2==5:!(( 5E/159'7267!'G'("(""!2E1009'7367
,7 '#""!0.(8'3662 : !('!F#C:'#'((">' :";""(#>2'<"2===7
/7 ' ((' - #8' 3662 : !"D# C :'# D:" " ;"( ;'#!2,E0239'7('!..(.#'"!2'<;"'2===06 !;8' 3662 (!( ""D( D (( ! ;"( +(' .'("( ! (!(( !.# .' '#('!("9 :'$";""(#7 !H !(('#('!("9".';"'"("'(( ;!'"(8".".!' ;( :;!"' .'" !(( ; : 7 ("( I# C !''"' .( !;#""!.!'(('.#'"!2'<;"'2===06!;8'36627
17 ' !''"' 22 !;8' 3662 :'# 9!'# '#("! !(' (( #""! !( ".""(( C ! ("!7 !.'"( . .!'D!" ! 2,E023 9'7 " #("( '## ' !H .'(("! !.#("' !("("( . .'(("! :"( " :; "'!"(7
57 20#8'3662 '8!'#C: !,E2-39'726( 36#8'3662!((-E2--9'7
=7 .'>#.'((.!'"':'#(!>;(..'"! .'(("!!.#("'!'#.': :'#9!'#!; .'(("! !.#("' (! 25 ' 36607 .'">'#""!#(#'C<(3,;'"36607
267 >2'<"3660 #.'!:'#!(@(# '"!.!' D: '.'".'(("!7
432-543660 $041$ 227 ' #""! ' !..!"("! / !(!8' 3660 : " .'("( :!..!"("!9!'# C#""!-#8'3662( '##C:'# ! 3E5239'716 " ( . 2,E023 9'7 # ""("(7 9"( "#"('#'("(("!!;'#('!..' 2,9#;'"'2===2E1009'736 ""D;'('#('!("9((" ,E2-39'726(-E2--9'7.'"''!;#""! C"( !"9"("! "(("! .'! :'# > 2' <" 3660 #""! D" #("( I# C #""! ' !..!"("!7 %! (( !; #""! '#('!("9.'(("!2E-569'7';"(C:'#7: !.##@(C!'''#('!("9;'#7
237 1!;8'3660 :'#9!'#'!'!('#""!'!..!"("! : / !(!8' 36607 !.#(# "$" .' !''"' .!(# 25 !;8' 3660 .'> D '"8 # " "( ".'(" #" .!' !.#(' ! '!' ! ." :"'';8""(#7 ".""(( ! C :("!#""!(9"(;!"' (!((8!9!" D: ;"( . '8!'' .'(("! '## 9"( D: ;"( (!<!' #(# 8'>: 7 !(9!" '!H#("(""! ; <'"( : !""(# #" 9" !"D' '"8# ""("(!'!'!!7
207 '!''"'2,#8'3660 :"("#'D"."! ((( .!;!"' !' I."("! C '!'( ' #""! ' !..!"("!7
2-7 '!'(!#@( (06<;"'366-7
2,7 ' !'! 20 9#;'"' 366- '"8 # . :!'('.'("7
2/7 $"#(#'.'"(2/9#;'"'366,7
217 25'366, :"("#"(#""!'!..!"("!(!'<( '!' (!(';(D8!9!"'!'(:#("(.7 .' "' I.""(# ! .'(("! !.#("' "J( (!*#>2'<"2===7
257 '!''"'30(3,;'"366, '!'(.'"(#!"!7 !"@#D:;"((!<!'#(#8!9!"(:;"(<"F# ('!.' :"("# .!' !8("' D!D ;(@7 !(' ';# D : :#("(#<C'8!'#!"("#:'@(D:"(""("+('J( D ;"'!( ".!''"('!'C"'!3E5239'7 167
432-543660 $-41$ 2=7 ."D31"366, :"("#"(!"!.'##(7 .'"'';#D'!'(;"(#".""(('" !3E5239'716 "D:".!;"(.'!#'C:I$"(( D#""!'("(("!9""(:!8<(.'#('!'('9"( .('#9!'7
, *
27 !"@;!"':!'@"("!<"""'AB#(#!"9"#("("(# > 2'!J(3660 '"8(!'!" !.!#,<@ !(.'#"((;"$.'#"( ,..#((2/<@'A'(72(7 '(,/ B7
%"(C:("!:#("!2/<@' .' '"89##' 31<;"'366-A )20626/B ' !"@;!"!.(# 209#;'"' ".!"("!('"(!"''@(.'((( '"8(!' !" "#@' ' C ('!" <@ ("("' :((( :#("!!;I<@'7
37 !9!'#(CE'(7,/72(7*70(73(7 '"8(! '!"!K("("D!((("!.'#;C:'(7 ,/ D"!('(";C!"9##''.'(("!!.#("'C :'$;"" ';";((";""(#2='2=/,A B ""D !((("! '("; C !" ' .'(("! (! !.#("' C :'$;"" ( ';";( ( C :'$";""(# 3, !(!8' 2=/5 A B7
%!.#(.!'<@':.>(""#(8"7
07 !"9##''.'("@##''!"('!"/!(!8' 3666A B (('# ;"@' 2' <;"' 3660 ('K( !"9"("! !8'".!"("!#@!"'!"7%' .(#'" .!"(;!"'D'!"(E.."D!"(+('('*#C">' .'"".!D'>@.."8!(;"@'!(!H 9"( <'""D( #('"( !( .'!"( A ) 231 -/1 !"7 2 23/ 20/ !"7 -8 ( '#9#'B7 ';* D" !' .'!#' (C#9('>@('"(!"'!('"' !;'!"(E.."D '#';><!'!('#;"@'A )221=0!"7/8 223 0/6 !"7 -L 2==5 M 01 .7 02/ !"7 08B7 E( .!'D!" .'!#'.(2'<;"'3660!"('!"(.'>(((;( ('"8 (! !.#(( (">' E' !" !( '#@" .' !; '>@ .'!#' !( ( .' ".!"("! .'!#'!("99#'(!".#"!"9"#.' 7
432-543660 $,41$ !(9!" ".!"("! (#'" !( :.> . .."8 '!H9"('!((C:#36627
-7 ('<(##"(9!'.'#;.'!" '!'(';8A'(7,/ (-0 B7
,7 ;'(:'(7072 !((.'(("!!.#("'9##' !''.! C .'( #. '! D" I> '; #('"(7 '" '"' 9"@'( !(( '( :'$ ";""(#A'(7072(7 B7'#@(("!"("D'#@"(.'(("! !.#("' (! A97 '(7 0 ( , 7 2 (7 B7 .'(("! !.#("'!(!9!("!!((';(#.7
/7 #""!:!('!".'(("!!.#("'.;(+('!"9"#; 99(I$( !'D!('#"#!"("!D".'#"(C'#;!("! .' !(' :#""!""('(";7 (#@' "F""("@'(' '#;""! : #""! ('# 9!' 9!' C D :""('("! ( ( .'!#' !'D !( #!;'( 9"( !;I ! !;I !F.';.("8!"'C..'#"("!<'""D"99#'( A )23332!"70 205!"73 210!"7- 313!"7 232- !"7 / ( '#9#'B '!"#'("! : #""! 9!'( .# 9!' *! <@# ( ' D (!'"(# <"""' :( . .'!!#D(9! CD:""('("!.(.'!#'.!'((D #""! !"( !( ''!# ( D '("9"("! ';+( ".!'(!(8A )23332!"70 210!"7- 312!"73 0/5 !"70 232-!"7/(''+("(#B7
D" !' '#;""! :!8"@("! '("(' .'(("! !.#("' "J( (!*# ( ! #( (. !( . 8!'!#C;"!("!:!8"@("!'"@'A )23320=!"7 3 B7 99( ":@"(".('#(8"':!''#@.'>#!;'(: 9"(!;7
17 %! :'(7 31 7 2 :!'! ' .'(("! !.#("' :'$;"" ';";( ( ";""(# 2, <;"' 2=12 A $ %4 B .'(("!!.#("'9##'"J((!*#!";(+(''("(# .' 8##9"""' ! .' *#'"("'7 .''".("! !" 9##' ' :'$;""(';";(36#8'2=-/A %B!(.."8 .'!@"C'("(("!(.'(("!(C"8#'("!:!8"@("! '("('7
:'(73-72 .'#;!"(#@('("(("! I+!"("!D: ";9##' .'(("!!.#("'(!.'G"J(7
432-543660 $/41$ 57 :.> :"("#!#.'(("!!.#("'C'!'(> '
2 #8'2==5 ((!.(:"$'(:";""(#7'"( '!'(.(8##9""#:'(:";""(#!.>( .'#""! 0 .(8' 3662 ; 99( '#('!("9 2' <" 2===7 :@"( "'( : 9"( !; D" !"9" ' !(8 8 .'(("!!.#("''!'(>(((7'!#D( ; D" ;"( :+(' I.!# :"("# #("( (!( C 9"( '!"( '#;"' #""! ""(" > 2' <" 2=== 9" '#"' .'(("! D !(!((#('"#.'!(('(:";""(# !I.!# "$7
!(( ! !((# .'(("! "J( (!*# .( .#'"! "("@" :#>; C 2,E023 9'7 (( ! " !;"( #"' ! : 9"(:"("# !(('G C;!"' ,E2-39'726 -E2--9'7( !.'G('!. 2===2E1009'7367'"' ;'( '(7 31 ( '(7 31 :"("# ( #@( '!"( !.' '# ; .'(("! #* C ;!"' ; '#('!("9 J C '!'( !'#(#""!2,.(8'3660 D"(I#C#""!' !..!"("!((D#7!!'.''!'(:#>;""C3E5239'7 167
#""!!(('!':;>'""9!#7
=7 .."("! '(7 -1 7 2 % ( 1= 7 2 '>@( ' :' ;"" ( ';";( 02 !(!8' 2=-1 A %B " !"( +(' 9"( '" :!8"@("! '("(' (!( ! .'(" !(( "J( (!*# C :'# !'D:" #("( 8! 9!" ( '"( " "(("! "99""7 "; (! '(73-7 3 (2-'>@(:.."("!!"' .'(("! (! !.#("' C :'$;"" ( ';";( ( C :'$";""(# 3, <" 2==1 '.'( (' ".!"("! 9##'.'#"(#7
:!'' '!'(".""((9!'#('" '! '!'7'!H:"("#:. !' I"# (( D("! " !;"( > !' " ';!F' 9" D:" (( ' $"7
432-543660 $141$ *0 *, ,*, ,
12343 5 633 3 7" %8$ 9
43
27 #''!'';8L
43
37 '<((L
07 !9"' #""! ' !..!"("! / !(!8' 3660 :99" (! .'!?@#L
-7 ;!"C:"("#.!'I'"'!'(L
,7 "(D.'!#'(@'("(7
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
!."!9!'.'#(''+((!("9"#I.'("""D:C:99"9##' '!".'@'99
432-543660