Statute of Limitations and Fraudulent Concealment
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court considered whether a statutory period of limitations for bringing an action applied, where the plaintiff claimed the defendant had fraudulently concealed the underlying facts constituting the cause of action. The court reasoned that the statute of limitations began to run from the time the plaintiff knew, or by exercising reasonable diligence should have known, of the injury and its cause, and that fraudulent concealment by the defendant, where proven, tolls the running of the statute until the plaintiff discovers the fraud or could have discovered it through reasonable diligence.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statute of Limitations and Fraudulent Concealment: The court reasoned that the statute of limitations began to run from the time the plaintiff knew, or by exercising reasonable diligence should have known, of the injury and its cause, and that fraudulent concealment by the defendant, where proven, tolls the running of the statute until the plaintiff discovers the fraud or could have discovered it through reasonable diligence.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis provision is cited in the final order regarding the allocation of court costs.
Testo completo
#$%&'#())'*(* +#&,#())&
+
+ - -+- -
(. /0 $ 12 ())&
3 4444444444 !" ! # $" % "&&'("&
!!"
4444444444 4444444444 4444444444 1 " " " 4444444444 4444444444 4444444444 "" &( )* #& ++++++++++ ,- ) !'" .,/0 1$ !" ! # $" % "& &' (" & !!"
"!
5 6 -* -, !" & 2!"3 .,/41$
"(
!"
8,5.78
- 7 +
.9 #! ++++++++++ !!"" (! "!$( & ' :++++++++++&.0;/<.0079=((>"<""!&%!8&& ?!&@'"">9
,9 .007%"(!(("(AA(""' !>!<%$!"(&1$" %""(B9 "!.007".00;(""A("!""& ':++++++++++"" !!"!"&""!A".00;9
79 && & B % BB 8# C8 !1D B #E %"(!( "! ! "(( & F $! ,//. &% !" & =! & &%!8& & ' :++++++++++ &($!( ! ++++++++++"$= !8@( '&3&>9 " 9
F9 .7>($!!,//,B #>!(%"(!('""!>A!" !!!8&&B"&&(&"!""! """"&$!!A!""$!"!&>!(&3 " )!"'9 &(>" & $ & !" & &( &% B # >!( %"(!( '% !" >>( &%>> !(A & %!8 &=A"!9
69 '%%" !( &<!!!%"(!(% ("(>>(&%>>9
-9 &!,//7%( &%"(!("!!$(B$!"! > " B # !(&( "!G & ! >>" < %!8& =A"!9!!!!&,/,//7!$! !"&(&"! !>! !$! &!!">"&%!9
49 , H ,//7 #& ++++++++++ >" !$! B # !">" &%! ("= H! @ ! I++++++++++ &'" ' "" > (""$!" !&( &"(& "& !($ ! ?( & ' :++++++++++9 #! ++++++++++ =((>" & ""'!"!"(&""!A"9
;9 ! &( & ./ H ,//7 ""( J!> & & K B # >!( #& ++++++++++ ' "" ! >A!" ! !!8 &&B"&&(&!"!"$!! &!&(9B%"!" &"(A! !""" & =((>! &% & &%>>" < %!8& =A"! & 9 &(>" & $ & !" & &( &% B # % >!('%">!">>(&%>>9
5.-675,//7 875.78
09 0 H" ,//7 %"(!( %" ( < "" &( " >" !$! B # "(( """" ' $!"! &%! &" > =((>" !1&I++++++++++'&"!" !A! ! " & ' :++++++++++>$!&=((>!&)!& ""8 L""'76/BM ! !6 !"!"$!"!&;/ <.//N&>!!&&"!$>!)=9%("" =&"!$!$!"! !=< !3B9&& &$"&@"!!(3( !B #"& $"@"!$A(9
./9 !!!!&,FH",//7#&++++++++++>!("!& "(( " !((' ! !>%($"<F;79-/BM9
..9 !&(! "&FL",//7B #>!(&(&!> & & ! "> ' #& ++++++++++ % ! " &"9 %&)( < %! %A&!!" "" &(A!&"& !""&%!&$!"!&>!"%("" &("!('%!&OA&(""&"(!"&>> =&!! ("!?"@("&9
.,9 @H!B #>!(#!++++++++++'%""&""H! & !" !">" &% !! & < !"'! %!8& =A"!B9
.79 F "=! ,//7 #! ++++++++++ &( ( !1 & B # && & & & %!8& =A"! ! 8@ " >""'%>"!"!"=((>" !1&?"1 &%! & & !A" &% $!"! &%! A !"!""B93 '"! !&"(A !"""&=((>!&""& 9
.F9 !"&F "=!,//7#&++++++++++"!H"(!! !1& !="&!"!&(! "&B # &FL",//7"<""<'%8@">" 3 "(&%!=A"!&9B!! "&" !"""&=((>!&%3 """"'=!&>& 88@">&$"(A"=((>!9B #%!" &L !! ! ! !" "! " & & #! ++++++++++'(""""(9 !(&!&$"@"! & &%"""&&(!"&&&!9 ""("( !A"!(P 5.-675,//79
.69 !( & .! "=! ,//7 B # !H" & !!9 3 '('"!J>"!"!"K&$"@"!"! !("(& 1!!"!"$"!"% '!<%( 3&!!"9 >>" $" ' ! %3!Q" &%"$"( !"$ " &" &!!
5.-675,//7 8F5.78 ?! ("" !A" "!"9 ! ! !$ ' #! ++++++++++ =((>" &% $!"! A !1 & ?"1 &%!8& & ?! %$" ("( !"(9 "A & $!" &$" @"! "!"" &"' %! !'%!(&("$!"!=A"!&$" !("!&A>"$9&% 1"A%$"("( H"<&&&%3 "" (!&&%!%$" ("(&( B #9#!++++++++++ $"=((>!&%3 "" & @ ! >9 ! ! $ && $" @"! "!"( ! B # "" '% !" %( & %"(!( " > ! ' ("" &(H< &" !8&$" !=9 B # &'" (A" %$! "!"( "" > & &! &% " @ &( ! & && "!&$ & %"(!( ! ! !" !" & >9 & !(&! =" (!9 > !!"%?"H$'(?&&!"&" !($"! & !(&! &"!"$ !" $! ""!=! & &( &%&&!!9
.-9 ! &( & .7 $=! ,//7 B # !H"( && &%3 " & #! ++++++++++9 B%A" & !" & && !" ( ">(""!!$= ''"$"&(H<("("!"(" '%("" &"&$" !="&!9 ' !" &&! $" @"! &(!( J >"! "!"K " ' &$" %"! !("! !"!"$"9 %$" ( !$'%=((>" !1&?"1&%! & & ?! &% $!"! &%! A " &(!A" %$" & ' %"(!( =((>" < & ) !1 & @ !"" !1 &% "! !9 > & !" & =! !""" & R"! "A & !"" >>!" ! %! (!&&%!"&3&%!&>>(!"$" ("( &(B #' $" &("!!' (""!("%!! !(9
.49 ! !!@" & , &(=! ,//7 != & ( & %" 5.-675,//7 H'%< &!" & !(&! &%3 " !" #!++++++++++$!H'%&( G"&%!! !89
.;9 .6 &(=! ,//7 #! ++++++++++ %" ( < &( & .7 $=!,//7&B #"<""<'%"3 "(& %!8& =A"! & @ ' >9 ' :++++++++++ ">Q" ! ! ?"1 &%! & ' ("" &"!( ! ++++++++++ 3 ""8 " ! I++++++++++ ! % " "!"9$!"!!""!;/".//N&>!!& &"!$>!)&$&&76/BM">&
5.-675,//7 865.78 4// BM9 "A & !"" ("" ("& ' & %! & =A"! B9 " &%J >"! "!"K %("" " H!&' &("!( H"" < "! !("" & !" ' #!++++++++++&$"@"!!"9!!! " "!&" !"""&%@"!3 "(&%!=A"!" @"! =((> & ?"1 &%!8& & ?! " ?"1!"$!"!A !"!""B9>"' !" !""%("" $!"<.//N(""!A" ( ! !)!A&%"! !""$!"B9
.09 ! &( & ,0 H$! ,//F B # !H"( % "9 % " =((>" & '"( &% >"! "!" " $!"! &%!8& %("" >>"9 & !" & =! >"!(>(!< (!&&%! "B #A!""H!' !(A&%!% '"&9 >>!!&%('$& $!"! $" ("( !$?( A"! & %"(!( & !!9
,/9 ! " & 7 ! ,//F #! ++++++++++ "!H"( !! "! "" &( !1 & != " & ! " ! " < ""<'%"3 "(&%!8& =A"!9 ! ( '% ! " &" &%J >"! "!"K'("""! !(""9&""("""! $!"! &%! ("" !"'" = " ? $" & !"! ' %! ! ' %"(!( &(" $!"! =A"! &$" !("! & A>"$ ! ! !" < "" &!1!9 B ! !"""&=((>!&=! !"""&%( $"A3& >"&L"$!"' ">"' $!"!%(""'&;/N9 ""("(!A"!(PF,65,//F9
,.9 !( &-$!,//FB #!H"&!!9!!" $" "!&( < >!! & !A" ! &%! " !" & &"&((""3"$! 1"&!"'%3& %A&$!"!&%!("" =9!! B # ! ( ' !!" ! " &" !""" & =((>! & %3 "9 >!! &%('$ & $!"! %$" ("( A( ! %!! ! !!"9 > """ & &%! (& & ' :++++++++++ !" ' !"!"( ?" ) % " "!" & &%! $" %=A" &%&)(!! < ?"1 & "( ' >>!" @ $ & $!"! &%! & ' !($ ! %! & & &A1 & ! ? & !(& ' %=A!" < %>>! >(&(!!%!8&9
5.-675,//7 8-5.78 % &(!"!B #&( ( ! 1&"!!!& .0&(=!,//7&%>>>(&(!&!C8 !1D2 BE< # !"&B !1&"!"'" &%3 "&>"!"!"3"&=!&!>9
,,9 ! !& & ; $! ,//F != & ( !&( ! ! & %" & !" #& ++++++++++ " > H" !!P 5.-675,//F">3(3!!"&( !&( ! !(!"!9
,79 !!( '&-,//F!!"" !"(&! !((&" (!"! " H"( ' >!! ! B # $" $! !&! !(&" %2 B ! &% !!! & "" " ! '%%$A"'%&""(& !"""A9!! '"!"$<%=A"&%!"3!(A&%3 "("" !(A( 3)"$" ! &!" >(&(!9 >>" A "" & !""("" =&>"&!"'H! !&"( ! B #!&"! ="(&=((>!&%3 "9$!"! >>!" !I++++++++++(""A="('$"$! $"A' >>!" ! %!8& =A"! 9 > %!" & """ & &%!&':++++++++++"( !B #%$"$"< % '!'%3 !&(&& """?"1& "(3$"(""''%("" B&!S 8&(""&!A !$(9
,F9 ! & ' & .6 H ,//F B # &'( ' %=A" & H&! >!!&"!G&%('$A( !%!("!&(" &9%!!!>A!"!>!!"(% 1%$" !>>" & %$&! """9 ! ! %3A & %&""( & !"" !&" ! ="( &%@"! 3 "( %2 B ?" HA( ' %? >" & "" '" ! != &"!"> & 1$ ("" >!" H&9 > %!8& =A"! """ ?"1 " & (!"( ' "" ! $" ("( &(!( =A"!9 ! "" ! """ & &%! =A" !!" < %>>!?"1&"("9
,69 !=!&( !" !& !"'%"".7 H",//F9 "" !"" !(&( < ()A&$" $()A&%(!"!("("!(9
,-9 ! (!"! & 7. L" ,//F !!" " !"( & ! 9 ! ! " ( < ($" >>" !("!"$ < %!8& !" "!("!">& !?!"$ ! "> ' B # $" "!&( < !(&! "!G & %>>" & #! ++++++++++9 !" "" ( !!" %$" (
5.-675,//7 845.78 & ?! & ! !1 & ! ! ! !!9 #@ !! ("" !H"( " & !!" % !" =$ " !" & )'" '% " &( < %>>! !("!"$"9 &( ""(%"">$!&%>>"!("!"$9 ! & !! &" &( %("" "!( >! " &( &%>>" !("!"$ ""!" !(>!" &("!" & !!" !' !(&! !"1!&$"@"!! "( ! !=9 ()(" ($" >>" !!" ! @"! ( '%< %3 !" &%&(&7/H! !1%"!(>!&HA"& !=" !("!"$"(9
,49 ! (!"! & .- "=! ,//F B # !$( ' '" & !("!"$"(>" %=H"&&("! !9 ">&( $" ! (' &%=A! !!" < >!! < (A" >(&(! $A! " &( &%>>" !("!"$ $" @"! ! " !8&9=&!&!!"!" !("!"$"( ("" & !!$=9 ! ! !!" ! " &"& #& &>($!!,//, !%( 3"& H ,//7 !%( ">("">3& !("&!'!& >" ""!" !(>!" < ! &("!"9 > " ! ( !!!"&!H"&!!(""&=""!!&!" >(&(! '! "&&!"=A" !<%>>!& &(&"!< "!& !&&B9
,;9 ! &,, "=!,//F"" (!"! ("("!3!!" ! !=&("("(A!&(<HA!9
5.-675,//7 8;5.78
- +
.9 A$!%!A"H&!CE("(&>("""(&1 .!L",//7 !="&! (&6HA &" !(&""$8 !(&"6 ("".-HA!C!"9."9 !"6- E9
B"<%"&%("&.-HA! ! !=>(&(! ,4H$!,//FC 2.7/./-E! A$& "(.7>($!! & ""!"!!A" !""" !="&! & (A! ! < "! HA ""! & %""" & %("&$3HA!9
,9 >!(" < T!"9 6- 9 . "9 )9 F != " & !R""'&""" !($<%!" 6- & >(&(! ! !" A((! & &!" & ! & - "=!,///C8 !1D E'"!"$<>(&(!!%!8 & & .;! .00F C8 !1D #E9 B (" ! HA! & &% 1"("=9
79 "!H"(&&( ">! ( !!! "!$=C!"9. #"6-<-/ E9
F9 '" ! ' "&$!#!++++++++++ "@"! &(!( >"! "!" " %! & &" =((>" !!" !1 & I++++++++++ ! >>! $!"! A < %!8& =A"! ' ! !""!" & =((>!&%3 "9
69 " !&(B&"%!! !&& @"!!( !! !(""(A&"!'$" !& &9 >(&(! " &" 3 "! !" "(A! & ! & T! =A"! "" ?( &T!A" "!"C!"979.", #E9
&=" ! 3& #"&!&!T!8&=A"! !T=& "BC 2.,6,4.&96=E9 = T!"9 7 9 . # 8"8 ! & T=A" &T! ! "" ! &( B9 T? &" &T>>" 3 A "!! &T"! ! C 939 T B5 T!8 &"=A"!E9 T"3"'T=&$!! "&"" =A" " T ? & !(&! >!(" < T!"9 - # <
5.-675,//7 805.78 >>"&T>>&T !"&T!!'T &("<"" =A"" "C 2.,-,-6E9
BTA" & ! H" & !$1A $!" & &!" "!" >(&(! !($ ! >"! "!"3 ="( &T@"! <T!T>"&&C!"9-9.&T!&! T!8& & ,4 H .006 8 #E9 ! >"! "!"3?"1"$!9 %!"9-97 # >"!"!"3"=!&!>"<!&& 3 "( & %! =A"! % =((>" !1 & ?"1 &%!8& & ! !A" &% $!"! &%! A ! "!"" B9 !'@" &" @"! A( &% """"(!"&%!A (""&%!A""!"&" "!A"(!9
B"&(!(=!&>H"'>"& & .; !($ " 3 & & ,6 !($ ' >!('"" ( !$"&("& !"AC!"979, #E9
"A& !"" !)!A !%!8&=A"! "!$ < %!"9 ,6 #9 $" & $! >(&(! !" %3 " & %! =A"! ' ! )!A A " >>!" !%!&&&!9
'" !"$ < T=A" &T! " 3 !(A &T3 " " !(A( 3)"$" ! &!" >(&(! C # .000 U ;. 9 7F/E9 H! !&T '"!1 T&3!"=8"8H '!T "&%!"9-97 #9
B!!@"& !=&"!">&.7!,//. 577/5,/// $!"! &T! &" =((> >"! "!" !1&T!A" !'"!$"&"!! &!"A& T!"9 ,6 9 , # J ! %"KV T" & "! WAW ?( < T!"9 - 9 7 # &" "" =!" C&"! & A >!Q ! .00,E & ! ?? "! & W!! &"W W('$"W ' &"A" & " &T&""( ! ' " W !>""==WC&E9&""(&$!"!&T!8 "!1 !== ! ! 8 T" & !' ! ="! T3 " & T! T &! & A' & !(A =A"! ' T! ! ' T"(!( &( $!"! & #&" !("!&A>"$ !! !"<""&!1!9
> T !"" < T!A" "!" !( < T!( &T3! " & "!)! '" & TA & $!"! &T!
5.-675,//7 8./5.78 =<T"!"(" (""<'!$"& !&!&( &T3 "C!"9./9, #E9
-9 T"! !1" !!""!9BH! !&T? &&(!A!""(!&T"3"! !$&T"! !(""'!'& !=H"$ !"""& !'"3"!"" $(!"= & & " 9 " "> $" &(! & "!$3 !( !"!&=""&&& "'&?"("'& 9B"3"T" ="! !"! !(""&8" =$"&!)!)!'"$(!"= !"(&! &(AA" & " ((" < &(!! " "" & "!$3 !( !"!&="&!1A& !"'&$!!' ! !&!"$&T"!& "(AC 2 &, "=!,//FU4F5/7V 2.7/4.&9F9," 2.7/6/ &979,9.E9
49 % 1#! ++++++++++"!"!"(&%!A""!" !'"!$(&!""!*':++++++++++"=((> & >" $ > & %! & & "" !A" ' " &"!( !I++++++++++9%"(""'% "@"!'>(&% >"! "!" "" " &$" @"! "! !("( & 1! !"!"$9
!("( " &% >"! "!" " '% " "( &%!&%" H""<"! !("""!!"<'"" %"(9 >>"""(!&"! J>"!"!"K C"3"&D V"3""D ">!<$"(&(A"!9!! "" " %" " H!&' &("!( " < %&"!"""&&% !("&% "&!9%? & &$!!"!&! < ""=!&% >"! "!"39
"3" (A &"A J>"! "!"K ! ' %3 " "!$" &%>> > && "!! & 8 & %J >"! "!"K !' ! "&!(A=A"! $ ="(&&&!& 9 &""&"&>!"! ! =((>" & '"( & >"! "!" " ! ?" =((>( ! (9 ! H"! < " &% >"!"!"&"' !!(%3! "$"( !"$ " ' &!! ?! " ("( !A" "!"!! & "3"!&"&(&%"! ((" !""<&(!!% 19 !"$!!@'%& ! & # " & &!"( ' ' & ""! =! ($( = & ! < %! =A"!9 %"
5.-675,//7 8..5.78 ""> = & >! &! < ! '% &" ! = &%"! !(""9 ()(""&%J>"!"!"K &$!"@"! !((&%!&9
? & & &(!! ' #! ++++++++++ ! " &" &%J >"! "!"K & !" '% !" < &("!! ?"1&%!8&&!A" !"&=((>! &% $!"! &%! A < %! =A"! ! "!""B9
;9 '% $" & $! T! ! ' T"(!( &( $!"!& #&" !("!&A>"$ !! !"< ""&!1!9%1!A((!'%A(<H"""!%2 B &!!!&.0&(=!,//7 !&" !%"(%!(&$!" "!$! & ("( < "!! $! ?"1 # ' !("!" $!"! >$!= !! !"< !""&("!(9
%((!"3)"$& !""<)!A&%!=A"!& =" & !! $ $!"! >>!" ! 8& & %!A""!"" = !"'9%A!&&""!< H! &%($" 8 !" $" & &! & !"" ( & (H! ("=" (&8 C #BE " (A"'!$!"! !"&!" !""9 $! ' ?" &(H< ("( < &3 ! ! != &"!"> "1! C 57//5,/// " 5.,;;5,//.E $" ("( "" !$'( !>"'%!(%(""!& "'% !1$! =" & B # 3 " & %! =A"! ' $!"! !("" !" ! )!A & >! & >!! & #B9 $"!)"( $!=((>!""&@&!(A =A"!&%!9
> "! ! ' ! &" >! ! '" & !""'"'A>'""& ! ?(%"< ""! &("!"9
% 1 !!" =((>" & (& &%! &"( 3 ?( & ' :++++++++++ &" % " "!" " &"!( ! I++++++++++9 &! & !"" (& $!" ! &%!C#&>"E #B""( "69/; !=!' JX !K9 "" !=!' !($" ' & !"" #B" !)!A ! &%!"&S (&"""(&% (!&$& ""&39! ">&(H<%A& !""!"@"!!$% !"' " !&! ! )!A #B B & !" '% ! (!&""!<H!&%"!&$!"!8&$"&(H<@"!
5.-675,//7 8.,5.78 &(!(A>"$9!!"%"(A" " !"" !!' ' H! !" & !"" " ! )!A ! &%! '%< ;/N !1 " & >!) ' " (A" >(!! < $!"! A!" ! ?"1 =A"! ! #9 >'"8 !"3<)!A&%!("($(& ?"1=A"!C!"-F #"./7 #E!'%"< ;T///988BM !>J=!&"!.B!?K !&" ! !!" C 1 4E9 !" &("!" '& = @ !" =! & !"" ! )!A ! %! & = =A"! #" !8&&':++++++++++9 >>" % A( != &"!"> & !!@" !("( %($" =((> ' "!!" %!( & !"" ! )!A ! ! ! !!""!!A& "&1!'""&!1!%! !"" !($ !?"1=A"!& #9
$&' !(1&""'%A&$!"!& !"" %" !(( & & !!" & !" ' 38 !" $!!&!3 "&%!=A"! #9
09 !S!!"! " &"! !""" & =((>! &% 3 " %" (! &%3! " "! !A" & !" "" !"> < %=A" !($ ! &%!&I++++++++++&%&)(!!<?"1('$"?"1 !"> < %=A" & "!""! B # >!! A( ! %!("!!9
./9 > != & ( !" !! ! '" & !("!"$"(""'""'"% >"%=H"&&(""'(9 >>" & &( B # %" ""( & !H"! && & & !(&!<%>>"=A"!9
" ""> ! ! '% &%>>" "!&$ %! &( >>" &1 %>>" " C!" 6 9 , #E9 !"&! < 8 &&%>>!!!""&&("!!&">"!! (" & ! ! >>" "!&$ < ' !!" !! < !" &"9
!=&( !!&'""!'&" !"""& =((>! &% 3 " " ! " >!! &( ! " & F L" ,//7 " ,0 H$! ,//F "" '% !H""" &&&& &!!"9!!!"&!H"(9
5.-675,//7 8.75.78
+ 7 + - -+- -
8/313 9 :33 3 6" $%( ;
13
.9 (!!!!$=9
13
,9 !H""9
79 "' !(&!"A!""9
F9 >! !" & '% $" >!! !! "! !(" !!@" & &( & 7/ H! &1 ">" ! !&( &!( != >(&(! & ! B)Y*!)>' - -//F "! 3 !9 &( " @"! !A(9 (! &"D E &'! 3""'&(!!"&(!="!" &&( ""'(V =E 3 ! ! ' "> " $! &&! "" "! &(V E !"! A"! & ! !(""9 B (! "" "! ((" ((!( ""! E =E " E 8& !=>(&(!&! !! "!!"1!!!!'% &$!&(!!!!$=9(!&!!"!!? & !$ ' !" H" ' &( ""'( " %$ & '("(3 (&(!!"C!"9.7,./-"./;E9 A!>>!D !(&"D !! B =B !("!8H!"D #!X ##
>!& !("!!@""">(3 !"'%<%>>>(&(! &"( =' !A!>>
5.-675,//7