Damages Valuation Methodology Appeal Affirmation
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involves an appeal concerning the calculation of damages, where the appellant argued that the trial court erred in awarding damages based on a specific valuation methodology, referencing prior case law and asserting the correct valuation should have yielded a lower figure. The court reasoned that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in selecting the valuation method, finding sufficient evidence in the record to support the damages awarded under the chosen approach, thereby affirming the lower court's judgment.
Regesto Legislator
Ufficiale; CHÔMAGE ; DROIT AU SALAIRE ; INSOLVABILITÉ ; POURSUITE PAR VOIE DE FAILLITE ; INDEMNITÉ EN CAS D'INSOLVABILITÉ ; INDEMNITÉ DE CHÔMAGE ; ACTION EN JUSTICE | LACI51; LACI52
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive to rule on costs related to the application of the simplified procedure.
Cited in the dispositive to rule on the costs of the federal appeal.
Testo completo
&'()*&+, -&(.,&+,
!!-
-! #- !# #
#/ + % +. 0% +,
!"""# !$%&' %!%& #&"!!""(#&)&% * + ,%"&"
!&%
-- - * % "&"# !&.%"&/0 $!&1123 4144 1
! " #!! $%
91579 1 -
4: ;"9$%< %!%&= &%'"# < 4% !'.% 1003 (&%$%" >;"9$%< ($!?%= : ""# $% ($!?%$!%@"!""100/ %!%&@@&#!%"% A!%&%'"1B"100/:
1: &&%#"<%($!?% %!%&(&%#?"&-;' 9"9$%<?"&=: %"%"&%$#($!?%$%!%%"%11 A"100/ %"!!&&&"$'"!&"!%&"'%!"&&%'" !%&%!%& ""C(&%$!?#:
3: % ("&%#""% ?"& %!%& #$!# A&" $%< %".%(,!!&%($!?% &46#.% 100/:
/: % AD& 4/ '%" 1006 % $% #@& "& %". !# ($!?% E '%% E %!%& ! 48(726 @%:76 !%%$!& E 4(000@%:E&"&%!"%!"('%"100/ 3(000@%:E&"&%"% !""100/ 3(000@%:E&"&%"%$!%!"#"!D# A" 100/ 1(1/2@%:40E&"&% (""&#$!%'!$%" 4(3B6@%: B6E&"&% (""&# $!% ,% $$#&"% 8(000 @%: E &"&% (""&# $!% ""&"A&"@"# &1B4@%:("&#%F&!%&!"%:
6: B$&.%1006 ($!?%#&##%#@""&:%!%&$%!"& %#$%<(GG -G - 6#.%1006:
8: & 13 A'"% 1008 %!%& #$!# $%< -- - * ;"9$%< "= (""&#("!'.""&# ""C&('!"%%H!"%CAC( !"('%"100/ $%&" &'!"%&%'"#%"<%@!"1B"100/ & $%!"&!$"AD& %".%(,!:
B: % #""!B!&!.%1006 "%H$%%!%&16A'"% 1008 "%A&# !&"@C%!%&('"&$$%" #" &" &!& % $&". 'D%% %!"& '"9E9'" ! $!?% $"C(('"&D"C$&!"$%<'!"%C"&&#(&%$%":
7: -"& E (!$$!"&"! %!%& 4B @#'%"% 1008 " !@"%# #""! 4B % 1008: -($$?& % A%"$% G - -- -;"9$%< G = $%#'!?&C(%#!"&$ %&%"&"@&C((D"&$%$"&!&%!$!?%"$%"'"#D" "&#%F& #&%"& I (% " %$$ C( #" ("&"!&%!"!"#&#AD#""".$% G :($< %!%&($D"&%%"%A!%(&"'"&# 1B"100/ &#$J&
5467051008 93579 $%< %".%(,! 46#.%100/ !"&$ "I!":
2: !%!%/"1008 %!%&!&E(&"!#""! "&"D" EC("!"&"&C(%!"&I""&#("!'.""&# &E C!"&%'!?#E"$!%&&%%%!&& '"& #$:
I$"C C (& $% C( & "&%' !%& $%< ! $!?%$!%!.&"%$"&"%C""#&"&KC(#&#""# C"%!%&A&": "&@"&$$?"& C"& "&%' '% ($!?% 11 A" 100/: ?"& & "& "&%' $%< D"&% !% !&!.% 100/ $!% #'"&% %"&"! ($!?%9#D!"&'&(&%$%"9%"!($%!#%A"""% #AE $& '& A%""&"! !$#&&: $& F&% %$%!,# E %!%& $% !#C& ('!"% #&# "&"': !&"# (D"% $%< AD& $%< (@@" $!%"& "" C($%< ($!?% ! !%%"%C($%!"&!$":
40: %#$!1A"1008 "!&%A&%!%: !"<% C D%# !%%"% ?"& 11 A" 100/ " $& F&% %$%!,# E %!%&('!"%#&#"&"'$"CA&"(#&##$!#C 46#.%100/ !"&"I!"$&%:#"&%!"!"&I":
44: % !%%"% !$#&"% 7 A" 1008 " $% "% "@!%# %".#C(!&&"&$&%#$&"!$%%!%& #""!"&"D":
41: #%"&%!&#&#%#E%!%& &$%&"!&#&#"@!%#$% $"4/A"1008C#&"&D%#EAD%:
5467051008 9/579
! -
4: !"D'!"%L!%D"&"!A"""%;=#&#!"@"#&"&"&# < 4%!K&1003 %".&!%!" !$!#6AD !&$%#"&&'"9$%#"& 6$$#&&48AD%;%&:4&: %&68 =:
-"&EL&"!L#&"!48AD% $% %".@##% 1BA'"%100/; G430408= % !"D'!"!$&# 43@#'%"% "$!"&"!&%"&!"%%D&$%&&& %".&!% !" "#D% % E &%!" AD &"&"% L&&& L#&"!!'IAD%:
1: !@!%#& E (%&: 68 : 4 &: ,: 7 %". &! %!"!)&"&"C!&&&"!$%#'EL%&" 68 C"!&%&"'E!"@##%%L%9,JD!."D&!"%& L""&#L"!'.""A"4271; =:
-!$#&$!%AD%L$<&""#&.":
3: !"@##%%$%&"D##%%!"&%!"8!&!.% 1000; = &%#'"D%4%A'"%1003 L$$"CL$<:
/: %!% "&%A&#@!%&#"$%#'$%!" &%'.;%&:68E 80 =:
6: %&:64:4&61:4 $%#'!"&C""&M
%&:64M N4 &%'"% A&&" $"& !&"&"! C" !& %'" L $!?% "!'. A& E $%!#% LI#&"! @!%# -" ! $!?& &%'"% -" !& %!"& E ""&# $!% "!'.""&# ;"9$%<""&#=!%CM : $%!#% @""& & DD# !&% % $!?% & CL" !& E !&9E %#"%'%"!C .: $%!#% @""& L& $ DD# $!% %"! CL %#"% L& $%F& E L&&& !&!"% L$!?% E @"% L' @%"! : " !& $%#&# "" $!% %# "% '% % $!?%:N
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
%"% !(%&:66:4 $%!#%@""&!"" &%'"% & & $%% &!& % $%!$% E 'D%% ! %!"& '%($!?% AC(EC"("@!%.%!D&"!"& $%!#%: !%C @""& & $%!!# $!&#%"%& E "!&"! %$$!%&&%'" &%'"%C"($%H!"% %"!"@@"&# #!!"C%!&%#$%($!?% (!."D&"!(&%$%%E(!&% %"% #%, &" ' %#$#%% %# ! $" $%%!%!"&E(""&#("!'.""&#: &&!"&"!EC& .!%!# %!"& E (""&# %!%& (%%F& G 44/ 68 & I$%""& (!."D&"!D##%%#""%!D; G41328!": / & %#@#% "&# 443 17 !": / 4222 P 1/ $$: 4/194/3 !":4=:
!(""C$& G (%%F& 24504/$&.%1004 '&$"%C("@"I"D%%"#C(""&%!"#"$!%"& !&% ! " $!?% ;"$"C& !&"@"&"! ( !& $?% I @%" (%#=: (% ( ""&# ("!'.""&# $%#"#&$!%.&(#$%D%I%#(!."D&"!%!%"%I$%!#% $%@!" !D & !K& (I#&"! @!%# %#D" $% ;'!"% * - %%" %."&!'%",%D%,&Q4228R S110 $: 4/2=: (D"& & (#'"&% C (%# %& "&"@ & (&%$% %" $!%%#$#%%!"%"$?# &&&$%!!#@""&!I9 $!?%:(&!%"&#@##%%'"'"&("%A"%'#C&!& $!".""&# C" $%&&& E (%# 'D%% ! %!"& '"& F&% $%" !"#%&"! !&I& & C (! %"& ! I% (.# !&"! !$%!" &% ($!?% & &%'"% ;
5467051008 98579 4222 P 1/ $: 4/3 !": 4=: (& "" C G AD# (%%F& &"!# C (%# ('"& $ %!"& E (""&# !&"@ C(" #&"& %&# &!&& "&"@ $& $%< &%!" !" $%< @" %$$!%& &%'" '& ""% %". %(,!: (& #D& "" C( AD# %".#(%#(?& D"$!%$%"<%@!" C$%< C&%!"$%<!""&&"!!.#%##@""&"'(&%$%" ;@: -34451008=:
8: ($< & "@@#%&: ( $%& %!%& @"& '!"% %!"& !%& $%<!$!?%!%&!"('%"100/ C" #,# ! ""&: %!%& (& !% %# ?"& !$#&& C"(&""!"%&"&%$#($!?%$%!%%"%11 A" 100/: < !% C( '"& "" ?"& & C "9" D" %$"& '%($!?%%!%&('"&$$ D"%$%!& & '"& !&%"% "% D"% ?"& C" '"& &"$ D%"@ E (!&% ($!?%: (&$%!#C&E&!%&C"C"@"#!$!%&& %!%&("&"@&"%@#%!"&E(""&#$!%!&"@:
B: & E I"% " &% !"&"! !& %$": @@& I &% %<D #D &"!# L""&# !'% %# "% $!%&& % C&% %"% !" %$$!%& &%'" C" $%### $%!!# @""&:&#&." &$%"%!!&&# C%#$!%&%C&% %"% !" ; I"= %$$!%& &%'" (!%% % !" ('%" E A" 100/: %', $! C&"! '!"% " &% %# %!%& $%& (!'%&% %!"& E (""&# ("!'.""&#:
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
%& %$$ G (%%F&4143BB!":1 "(%#,JD !%%!"&E@"%'!"%#!&!&%&&%'";"%!""&# $!%%#""&"!&""$#%$$!%&&%'"= "."&$$%&&%'"E $%%!"#%&"!;%&:44:3 =&"$&$%#&%(""&# ,JD;%&:7:4&:. O G442/8=: !&@!" !&C& I%!"&#!&!&%&&%'" "'%(""&#&.%!D ,J%&!%!"& ?!$%"$%"'"<D#D AC(E!%% (""&#,JD'%#$% !@!%#&E(%&:12:4&1 : $$"&"! && "$!"&"! ""&# ,JD $'& F&% '%# $ $%&""<%& !%C %# &%'"% & %& "!&&# "C!%!'%&&#&!"%%"!("!'.""&# ($!?%:& "I"& !(I$%"!" !&C&E &"@&"! $%#&&"! &%'"% ;%&: 12 : 4 " @" O + !:"&: $:42/=:
7: ($< %#%!%&&!$!# ($%& "% &%"&! 9 '%" & " 100/ & $"& ,% $$#&"%9 (&% $%& "% K $& !D# #D & (""&# $!% ""& "A&"@"#:
%!#C& 'A%"$%&"!# %!"&E(""&# ,JD& $%"!%" !'%&:C"$%#< %!%%" #""! " # & !"% %'!?# E " $!% I %!"& E (""&# ,JD #D&"' $!% #&%"&"! !&& (""&#$!%"!'.""&#:
5467051008 97579 2: %!%& C" !.&"& D" %!"& E #$ C" %!& @"I# ($<E4(600@%:
UUU ! # - 1 -! #- !# # %
234 5 6 78 ',+ $9
4 4: #%%!%%'.:
% 4
1: (&:
3: #""!1B!&!.%1006&4B%1008:
/: '!"!"%E"$!%#""!!"#%&:
6: ! " '%& ( ""&# @'% %!%& 4(600@%:
8: @!% $%&" CL $'& @!%% %!% !&% $%#& %%F& #" 30 A!% < !&"@"&"! $% $" %!# %# %". @##% % -,V"W%,!@C" 8 800/ &%!" I$"%: #" $& F&% $%!!D#: #!"% !"&M = ""C% I&&C#""!%!%&#"%!.&"%"&$#""! &&C#O .= I$!% $!% C !&"@ " &" $!'!"% % && &% #""!O = $!%&% "D&% ! ! %$%#&&: -" #!"% !&"& $ &%!" ##& ##%# ! &&% = .= & = "9 %".@##%%$!%%$&%%&"<%%%!%CL" '%#%%"%%'.:#!"%%!%&"!%!%!? $%' C" %!& A!"& "" C #""! &&C# & L'!$$ C#&#I$#"#%!%&;%&:431 408&407=: D%@@"% %#"&M "%% - .-
!$"!@!% $%#& %%F&&!&"@"#I$%&"&-%#&%"&L &&E L#!!"$%D%@@
5467051008