Contractual Non-Compliance in Prefabricated Component Delivery
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispute arose from the construction and subsequent alleged non-compliance with contractual specifications concerning prefabricated structural components, where the claimant asserted that the delivered sections varied from agreed-upon dimensions and quality standards, resulting in defects and increased costs. The court reasoned that the contract terms clearly established the required specifications and inspection protocols, finding that the claimant provided sufficient evidence demonstrating that the materials delivered failed to meet these non-negotiable standards, thus justifying their refusal to fully accept the shipment and sustaining their claim for damages related to the cost of rectification and subsequent delays.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Non-Compliance in Prefabricated Component Delivery: The court reasoned that the contract terms clearly established the required specifications and inspection protocols, finding that the claimant provided sufficient evidence demonstrating that the materials delivered failed to meet these non-negotiable standards, thus justifying their refusal to fully accept the shipment and sustaining their claim for damages related to the cost of rectification and subsequent delays.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited for the decision on costs.
Testo completo
$%%&&$%''( $)*($%'')
+
" "+ "+
%, - %'')
. + !" !#$%& '()
'(
. ////////// *+('+(&,(- . '/0' *
!"
#
4$1!!4
+ 0
!5 &* 6666666666 ' 6666666666 ' ' ' ) (' + ( .( 78' ( +( *4' 9: ;4 +(<=.(>5
$5 $?@'$%%$(+((+' (A6666666666&*6666666666 B' ./' +(< 9 & &6666666666 ;4+(<= +C(*> D ;#3 + !$% *8> ' . ;2% *+(*0B*2%*8>5 (0B'(;E"FG32>.* ''' ' ,(5!F"B(5"%4 ',(5!"%5#2+ (D HI (5
"5 ( ((( $? J' $%%$ (0 I +C(* .( (B0 (*7 (*' D * 'B / ('<( +( C(8 *0*'+(.( 78' ( .0''+(*+5
35 ( (((!G ' 7($%%$I.(+C(* ''0(B 08' /. .++('' + +C(* 0(B( 74B 0 . *'' 'C0(+'/5
25 '(4'*+ # ' 7( $%%$ &* 6666666666 B' I ' ( ./' +(<*K*+C(*'(+((+' (6666666666 : & 'D ;#3+$%*8+<>5* '' ' ' B'( ;E3!!F2> .0' I ,(5 $GF5"% 4 ' ,(5 !"%5#2 + ( D 5
?5 ( ((($0*7($%%$.( 08*'(B0 (*7 (*' D * 'B / ('<( +( C(8 *0*'+(.( 78' ( .0''+(*+5 '0 +C(*IB'((*0*'('*')(05
G5 $G 0*7( $%%$ +C(* '(+0 +('( (7'( ''0+(.('5$? ' 7'( 0'0+C(* ;::C> ' (' (( * ; &:L 4+(<= ' '(B(>5 B' ( /. ++('' + 0(B( .0' 74B 0 . *'' / (M +C(* *'' I B (*(''/ 78' ' .((( 'K'((+'05
#5 +(+ ' I +('(GB0(($%%".( (0' (/0 /. *7' + .*( (+ 7'0 B<( +((+' .*0*' ('.*'' 5 0*. + / ' '(B( .++/' /.) *0*' I C(8 .( 78' ( ' I)/ ' ('.*'' '+''
1!2$31$%%3 4"1!!4 (*+' + ' 5 +( ( (++0 / ') +C(* (0*<( ''0 / ' 0(B' (0' ' *'' +(< *0 +((+'(5 08*' /0 (' 0'0 +( .BB B00( ( ;, :>$#@($%%"/'(')(((*7 (( +('' .'(' + * .(4* + ' 5
F5 "%($%%" +('('*0/.++(''I.( (*7 (( B'( '85 0(0 / B (*0*' I ' '(B(+C(* ' 00''*'' '(M( *'' /'''' *'' 'C0(+'/5 +(00+( ( / +/ *0 '('' .' + 0+ 0 +(07 * +( C(8 J' +(< .( '' (<( 0'' '.(+('' '.)8('(*7 (*'* '' +''5 +('( +( ( 80 I +C(* / .8' &* 6666666666 *'' /''' + ( (* : & *'0I2%%8.'+0'0(+'05
!%5 ((( (0 I .( ' $ * $%%" +C(* 080.8'((+ '/(0B) +('( 0''(( 0*( N*'' /''0 : & .++/' + I +( C(8 '+' 0'B I +( .'0+((' N &*6666666666 '+(00*'B'. 7@'. ''('*'5
!!5 ( (((!$*$%%".(B (*0+C(*/.(B' +( + ' ' '''+ ('('8' (7(7'(5
!$5 $" ' 7($%%" +C(* '''/ (7(7'( .'+0'0*.(*(((* ''J' "% ' 7($%%"5
!"5 $% *7($%%".( (7(7'(' ' (@' * +*' +C(*5 B' ( / +('' +( C(8 +( .( 78' ( ' K'( (*''80'(+('' B'('/ '(' ) (( * .0('( ' 8 +('' 78' ( / *+( ' +0'0 ;:> ' *'' 5 '' +( ( / ' +( + 0+( +('(' '((I ' '(B( 'C*+.++' *'0(*')+('' '(' (.(4* 78' (5
!35 +C(*(0+ 3@$%%3 (*7 (*''08( B'( '8 +( I C(8 + ( '' (<( (' ((
1!2$31$%%3 431!!4 ' '((05 *''/ 78' +C(* + ('' ( '(M *'' /''' 8' .0' '(4' ' .B (*' +''5 '* < ( ( (*+ '08(*' (*( N*'' '+(0'.( ' /*' . (( 'C0(+'/5 / I ' 08( ' '(B('+ ' 08' ''/.(8*' /.(( + ((' + +(( C(8 .'( J' / ) +('' '(' *.( 78' (.'++(''*( N + ' 08 /0 ( / (' .( (05 (++ +( ( / B'( '8 *' ' B (*0*' I ' '(B( 08' ' : : ;('<( '0 + ( 'B( ('( .( 78' (>5 B .8' : & +((' I &* 6666666666 +C(* (++ / *'' /''0 .++/ '' + I +( C(8 '+' (0''+(.'0+((5(.(0 ' (+(00*'''('*'; D >5
!25 (0+/$#@$%%3.( (</+(' ' '(B( +(0 ' )+(0*' / '(M *'' / ' ((+C(*7 (I.+'/'''B'/.+(0 ' '(( +( '' *0 +((+'(5 ' ) ( ' 78' *7' ) 4* .( (0B<( I (' ., : (++' ) (( /. ' ' B (*( ) *'' 0''+(*7 ((+('' / '+ * .( * 5 '( '= ' '(B( ( + *' +('' I C(8 .( 78' ( *'' 'C0(+'/ *+( ( '(' ) +((+' 085 .( +( + 0/ (( * '''=,(5?$522.8'&*6666666666; '* '' ' 'B'(0' B'+()D >',(5"35#2.8' &* 6666666666 ; ' * '' ' ' B'( 0' B' D ')7 O' : & !%%%87 O'2%%8 0''+(C(8>5
!?5 +/2 J'$%%3+C(*B' (/.'(+(0'' ' '(B(I/(.(' '((I7 B 'I 88*' '('5 '' /. ++('' I .( (' (( '( (0 + ( )8( (*7 (*' * '' /. .'*+ ('/''(' .B( 78' / *7'(+C(*5
!G5 ''' ' P'0@I' +('( +(' '0'0'0I08(((7'(5
1!2$31$%%3 421!!4 !#5 B'.'''$2B0(($%%2' (7 05+(' '' ')*+0((+ ' .( '' I BB(*( /. ++('' + (*7 (( +('' / .0'' + +( C(8 +( .( 78' ( +C(* .0' ' / .( .++/ + ' '(B( / 0*<( )+(0*' *'0(B' / '+('/(. BB5.(880(0 /. ' ( 0 +'' ' *( 8(' I .((+(.'(*0( *05
!F5 '(( 80 +( (7 (7'( .( (0+ +( ((( "!*$%%2/.*''08*' (8*'' /' : & !%%%8+(('I&*66666666665 )+/0/'*78 B8(' + ( ' +0'0 ' / *'' 0 /0 +( +C(* (' / *78 $%% 8 ' 2%% 85 .++ (+( ')'(''+0'05
$%5 :(+ '+C(**+( (((!3@$%%2/ : & B8(' + ' +0'0 B (* . *78 !%%%85 )+/0 /.I .0+ / 0( *0*' 4 B8('' @ (H P'<*B (*'/H(:'/.0'' 7 B 5
+
!5 : .('5 #F 5 ! B00( ( .(4* !# *( !FF3 ; &> '8 '( (( ' B (( ' @80 +( (7 (7'(5 ' *+0'' (7 (7'( ' ' '(B ' ++/0 / B (( +('' ' '0 I ''( +(*' ;('5 #F 5$ &>5
.+</'0B ((+('' ('5"2 &' "# . ( ( .(4* $G @ !FF2 ; &> +C(* .' + ''05 ' I (/0(' '( '08 ( (( &5 *+0' (7(7'(' <'/*( N+C(*P''05
$5 '8 + (' ( +(+*' ( +( C(8 J' D (/ ' + 0+( '+(*+5
"5 >: Q('5$2 &Q( 78' ( +(C(8 J' +('' /('I8 '/( I'('(*'0/ ;('5$2 5!>5 +('' *+(' '' *0*' +(('
1!2$31$%%3 4?1!!4 +( *0 ;('5 $2 5 $ '5 7> ' +('' +C(* ( (**0*'+(('+(*0;('5$25$'5C>5
7>:.8'*0*''+(0/0+('*'0'+(< ( '0 *+0''' B (*0*')+(+.BB'0 '.0 *'00 0)('5"$5!'3"5? &''(B +( ' ' 7' ' ' )( *+ P0 + ( +((+' *8'(L'(B *+(+('' +C(*;('52$5!'5 C5$ &>5
B (*0*' I Q('5 2$ 5 ! '5 7 & ; ((0' ('5 "3 ' "G &> ., : +(< ( '0 B00( *0*'0'7''+()+(0+(' +C(*'/' *0*' B' 0;'+0'0L:>5
Q* ' +' K'( (' Q *'' L 4 +' '' (++ ('( I /''0 ) ' *0 ;B5 ('5G" &>5
> :.8' D *'' 0'0 + 0 I *+'( !( ' 7( $%%!= *0*' .' +( C(8 +( .( 78' ( /('('*'+'' 7<Q'4I4(+ 0' * (+ (;& >+0(( 08I"2+(< (+(07 *04 .((5
35 .+<.'+ ''0/(0(*+'+ ' 0 0 ' / .( 78' ( . + I +(( C(8 D /(0'0+(('5 0/.'I/.((H 0B'H+P(*0*'5
' ( ' .( B' ( /. *7 + .*( (+ 7'0 B<( +((+' *0*' ' / ' '(B( .++/ /.) *0*' I C(8 .( 78' ( ' I ) / ' (' . *'' (/ +''.(*+'+ ' 5
+C(* ''/'I/.(. 78' ./''( B'(IC(8+ ((' ((' '(.(05 <8/ 78' +C(* + ('' / ( '(M *'' /''' 8' .0' '(4' ' .B (*' +'' ' '* < ( ( (*+ '08(*' *( N *'' ' ' /' .+< ' /*' . (( 'C0(+'/5 /I'08( ' '(B('+ ' 085
1!2$31$%%3 4G1!!4 25 > B (*0*'IQ('5"35! &((+'++(( C(8 ''( Q( 78' ( Q'( J' / ) +('' +(0)('5$2I"" &5
.('5 2F & +(0 .8' B'(' / B (( +('' '/(((B'(''('*';5!'5> +('' B (40'0 +(0 ''(B/('++74 ;5!'57>'8 '4 (/(('B ((+('' . '+(0 ' '(B(4'+(0/+('' +( C(8+(.( 78' ( 'K'((*''80 '(;5">5
7> '$#@($%%"., :(0(';%"1%>)(( & ' I ( (0(( .8' '(M ('<( 0 */ +('' 5 P'(++0)((/.(*+'B ' . (8 08).)0' .( 78' (' /.''/' ' (+'( + ' 085 ' '' '0 I . '( ) ' B)0+ (+('' . :''0'(*'/P ')0'' *+'' '*'' 0'' + (*7 (( +('' / ' + * .(4 * ;C5"5">5
> .+< .(8*' .( / (' & (*7 ('+('' I+C(* +*( N + 7'0(' (( '(.(0+('0'0)+(0*'(0(05 .' *' /' / .( 78' ( +( C(8+('' '8**+*'/.(+'P'<*'( +P''(0+( ' 5
'I.('52F &B (' ''(/..+0'0 0.+< *( N)B'('8*' '08' ' : :/'('<('0+ ('B( ('(.( 78' (5
'I)*( 78' (0'' ' '(B(+ () +('5
?5 > ' '(B(.++/I' '+('' +(0+( & ( .( 78' ( I C(8 (( ' 0 ((**0*''+0'0 '/ 'B ( +( +C(* ' 0 I +( (0 ( .(4* 78' (;('53 ' >5
7>.(8*'(/0(' / ' ('+++7 (/ ' *'' '+(00' *7IB)5 BB'
1!2$31$%%3 4#1!!4 '' '*(I/+('' .+IK'(+( C(8+(.( 78' (+(/.' *7 +B(C5 .( . (*7 ( + * +C(* 4 P'<* '( +P' +(0 +( ' 4 ' (0*( I .(0 +( ' (*7 (*'* ''J5*K*+ (+('+' ) J' !%R5 '++ (/ ('BB0(' (/ ' *'' '+(*+5 8(B(/0(' ' K'(0('05
G5 .( / 08*' C5 !5? ' !5# .('5 ? ' / *' ' *7( ( +C(* +( '' *0+((+'(;('5?5!5?>' +'';('5?5!5#>5
BB'.('5?5! ' 0*<(+('' ('+(')4 +C(*5 .8' '' 0(B' . ( 8 .'' ' *'' 0' ;C5 !5">5 ( (' (*' ')'4*K*/*'' 0 /0 '/*'/'''5
'.( B(*0+(.('5$.)2 ' ('B) * '0 B ('( +('' 5 .0 " '' + ' +(0 ' /. ''' 0+*'*'' :+C(* B (* .(0 ' H 4(+' (7 H 08*' *0 +((+'(B'/.((+((+C(8 J'5( ' *(8 .('5 $ '''0= S ' (<8 .0 *'0T 0* '(' / *'' /''' ' 05
' .( )+(0*' B(*0 +( (<8*' ' '(B(!$($%%$;B5 '('5?5!C5!5">5
B (7 (*(/ / ')' ' $%%3 ' 0 (* +(B'*' ( +/ .(' ! 5 " +(0 ' 0 (* /.S 0+*' *B' *'' /''0 ' +0'0 +C(* B (* .(0 / ((4* +(' + C(8 J' (*04'('''*0 B.(( 0+*'+(''T5
' B' / .('5 ? +(0 ' 08*' . 78' + ( +C(* +(( '' *0 +((+'( ' +(00= S *0*' (/ C'0+(+''T5 (.' +0I0(B' *'' 'C0(+'/ ''(/0('5
*K* ( +'' 0 /0 I .('5 ? C5 !5# + (' ( 8(0'C0(+'* *' +'*)+(*0*' .' 0(' 8 +((' '(' .*+ * '' I . 7( 'C0(+'/ ' ( +((+' .'' '
1!2$31$%%3 4F1!!4 (' .B (*' +'' ( BB' ( + 7 ' 0(B' 7 +''*'<(.B (*' 5I ( ( (++ (' + ) *'' 'C0(+'/ 0'*'+ 05
#5 '((8*'+'B(+ ' +C(*'B'/ .('5 !" 5 ! ' +(0 ' )+(0*' / 07'( +C(* ' 0 + ( +('' 0 +( ' ' ( ;P'<* '( +P' ) '(* .('5 3$ 5 $ &>5 : ' (0(0 +('' B ( +(< / .(( /0 +C(*/.7'+. 78' +('' 4I4.(0 /+('' '+5
F5 *<( / +(0< (7 (7'( <( / .( . 78' ./''(* ''(0*0+(+C(*+ (D +(('5++('(.(0*('(*7 (*'I(0 *( N.( 78' (+(+C(85
!%5 /' + 08*' ( .( ' *( J' : & +(('I.(05
(7(7'( ''/.*78!%%%8B8(BB'*'+ ('+0'0'/+C(* *8((B'(5 ' (( I.((+ '5
(/K'''(<+('*'*5
1!2$31$%%3 4!%1!!4 0 "+ "+
!5 0((/K'(7L
$5 * 9: :: & 4 : I (( I 9 & &6666666666* ''*78D +(('I (0 ' .8' &* 6666666666 ,(5 !F"53% ;?$522 U !"%5#2>' .8' &* 6666666666 ,(5!?25G% ;"35#2 U !"%5#2> I C(8+ (.(0*((*7 (*')'0(0L
"5 '' / 9: :: & 4 : . + I +(( C(8 J' *78 !%%% 8 : & +((' I &*6666666666/B8('+('+0'0L
35 *9: :: & 4 :I+P(0* *' ,(5 "%54 / B( ' C (( (7 (7'( ( I C'(,(5!.#??54L
25 * 9: :: & 4 : I (( I 9 & &6666666666 ,(5!.$%%44I''(+('+' I B('0+L
?5 B (* +(' /. +' B (*( ( ( '( +(0' ((K' 0 "% @ ( < 'B' +( + ( 0 (0 (7 B00( ( :CVW(C B/ ? ?%%3 '( )*+(5 0 +' K'( +( 805 *0* ( '= > /( )'*'/0 ( ('0( 7'('+0 ''/0L 7> )+ ( + ( / * 'B '* + ( *( '' '( 0 L > + ('( 8'( (+(0''5 : *0* ( '' + '( 00*' 0*0(0 ''( > 7> ' > 4 (7B00((+ ((+'((*'<((( (/. (0((((75*0* (( (*' ( (* P +( / ( ' @ ' / 0 ''/0 ' . ++ /0'0)+00( (';('5!"$!%?'!%#>5 * (7 (7'( ( 8(BB<(= (0'= ,, A(: A
1!2$31$%%3 4!!1!!4 + B (*+(0'((K'' 'B0)+('/.I.BBB00( '0+7/+(8(BB
1!2$31$%%3