Contractual Termination Clause Consideration Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involved a dispute over whether a particular contract provision, which allowed for unilateral termination by one party upon written notice, was enforceable despite a claim that it lacked consideration because the right to terminate was already available under common law. The court reasoned that the express contractual provision providing for termination upon written notice was supported by consideration because it modified the common law right by setting a specific, agreed-upon mechanism and procedure for termination, thereby creating a mutual benefit or detriment beyond the pre-existing legal obligations.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 106 LTF, Art. 68 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Termination Clause Consideration Dispute: The court reasoned that the express contractual provision providing for termination upon written notice was supported by consideration because it modified the common law right by setting a specific, agreed-upon mechanism and procedure for termination, thereby creating a mutual benefit or detriment beyond the pre-existing legal obligations.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis article is cited in the dispositive to dismiss the appeal regarding the costs.
This article is cited in the dispositive to regulate the court fees for the appeal.
Testo completo
#$%&#$''( !#&)#$''&
!
* !"* +! *+ +"
,- ./ 0 ,1 23 $''&
4444444444 ! " #$$$ %& " ' "( ) *+ ,"$ ," - . ,, / $ 0 ! $
$
4444444444 4444444444 ,"$ ," - 1$.21 3 4 / $ 0 ! $
$"
+" 5+ 6 +!" " !;" "+ ! " "$ .5 67 $ $2 5 ) *+
+" 5+ * "!
7"!*+!" *"8* ! 6 +!" " 7 ""!!" * +! 9+": 1 4$2"( 89 ' *+
6 !" "!"!*!" *!" $"$ ,$ 1" ,( ' :" .
!"
2 %<=2
6"!
6@ " A($ %7 +1" %778 6*" .1" " 1 ," *" $ ,"! +" - BBBBBBBBBB ! BBBBBBBBBB 6? $1" 6>=9 $ - " BBBBBBBBBB ! %? A $ 6>=& " ! $ ? ;!+" " 6>98@
%@ " 1 ," *" $ "! ,"$( ," $ ! + " ,"!+5 ,"; 0 ," . !,C "$ " (@
8@ A($ +" $ + !; $ ; 6D A+ " %77?@
?@ " 1 ! $! ,"$ " $ $$ ,"!+5 , $",! $ $$ !;" ," $ 0" $$ + " ,"$ 0 "$ " ( $ $" ? ;!+" " 6>98 $ 6D A+ " %77?@
=@ 4 "" " ,"!+5 ;$ " , $ ," $! 6D A %77? ,"$$ 0 ,$ " ( ," " $ ?D%E78> ;" 67 F "" " ,"!+5 ," ($ / $"$ ,1 0 $ ;$ " / $"$ $ *+ ) $! 69 A %77? " $ ?/97? ;"@ F "" " #$ $ $$ ,,!$ + > G$ %77? $ DE8?% ;"@ D7 $ "" " " $! %= " %77? 67E786 ;"@ D= H$";!"! %= " %77? ' #$ $ $$ ,,!$ + I@
D@ $ $ !$! $" C ,"$ $ %= +1" %77?@ A" $ " 0! 0E' !;$ E1"+$ E 68 !1" %77? ""J$ " $ " " $$ 1@
" 0! 6= !1" %77? 0/ $$ $ , $$ "!$$ $$$$ +"! "@
" /$ , ;$!@
&@ E1 E1A$ ! ; C! !$! ("! ' A("@
<%>=<%77?
2 8<=2
"!
6@ E"$@ %= ;!!" " 1" ,( ,"!+5 ,"; + "+ +$ $ + $! 6& !1" 6>>8 H#I $"! + (" 6" A+ " %777 "*( ,"!" +"@ "0 A $ $ , /" " ,"$$ "$ ' ,"$(" H"$@ 6%% $ 6%8 + 2 I A( +" ,!$$ E"$@ &8 @
6 ;!!" " ,"!+5 ,"; %= A 6>9% HI $ '
*+ " 1 $ " , 6" G$ %778 $ ,"* 0 E;; " !$! $" H"$@ 6?% I C!$" E;; ,"$( "
1 ! "!,"$ $ !$" ! ," A( +".
%@ 4 E"$@ %% # H+ $" + (" , 6" A+ " %777I +" ,"$$ "$ 0 "$ " ( $ ,"$(! ;"!$ C "$@ 6%% 6%8 6?6 $ 6?% F "$@ 8 ' = # E,, 0$ ," ( $$ ' $";!"" H@ 6I@ " .0 A $ ,"$$ "$ ' ,"$(" "", ' ;;!" $" ,"$$ "$ ($! + " 1" ,( C $$ !+$$ $ +" $ ,"$$ "$ ($! + " 1" ,( C $$ !+$$ $ " ( H;@ "$@ %? #I@ " A$ ' ,"$$ "$ $ ' E+ " 1" ,( C $$ $ " ( $!"J$ $ +" H # 6%9 %87F # 6%> ???I@
8@ /,* A( ," *" $ "! ,"$( ," $ ! ,"$$ "$ C2!,C@ $ ,"$ $ $ / ,"$ " ( ? ;!+" " 6>98 /$" ,"$ 6D A+ " %77? $ ' 0 A($ +" $ + C!$ "@
4 $ ," $ ,"$$ 0 ,$ " ( ," " $ ?D%/78> ;"@ 67 $ 0 0 ," " $ %6E6&9 ;"@ %= $$ $!"J$ 5$ !A' !$! ! ," $ $$ ,"!+5 !;"@ " $ ' C2!, $$ %86E76> ;"@ == H?D%E78> ;"@67 K %I $ 2 $ $$ 67E=9> ;"@ 6% H %6E6&9 ;"@ %= K %I "$ 0 /$ " 0 $ ' " $$ %%7E?87 ;"@ ?=@
?@ ;"!$ ' A" ," , A" !$" $ ," ,"$( A0E $ $";"$ ,"$$ "$ " A $ +"! 1!!; " $$ ,"$$ " $ ' $!"J$
<%>=<%77?
2 ?<=2
,$ " " $$ 2 @ $!"J$ $ ! $C !( E"$@ 6% E" " ,"!+5 ,"; + "+ +$ $ + $! 69 +" 6>9? H %I $C "!($ " 2 $ ,!" " H # ,1 ! 8D<7% 69 A $ %778I@
=@ !$ " ,"L ,"!" !$$ ("$ $ H"$@ &8 @ % $ 9>3 @ 6 " ,"!" $"$ + 6% ,$1" 6>9=I@
<%>=<%77?
2 =<=2
+ !"6 !"* +! *+ +"
9.; < = 7> ,?$ :
6@ + $ ,"!+5 ;$ " , $ ," '
$";!"" ,$ - " BBBBBBBBBB %%7E?87 ;"@ ?= ' ,"!+5 ," ($ / $"$ ,1 0 $ ;$ " / $"$ $ *+ ;+" - BBBBBBBBBB@
%@ + $ ,"!+5 ;$ " , $ ," '
+"" , $$ $!"J$ ,$ " $C !$" ! !"$ * 6D A+ " %77? A0E $ $";"$@
8@ /5 $$ 0 1 @
?@ $ 0 ,"!" $ ("$ $@
=@ ;" ,"$ 0E ,+$ ;"" "" $" ,"!$ ""J$ ! 87 A" * $ ; $ ," , "! "! " 1 ;!!" " 4.M N".;0 D D77? $" C, "@ ! ,$ J$" ,"(!@ ! " $ K I 0"
C$$ 0 ! ""$ ! " 1$ " $ , ! $$0!F 1I C," ," 0 $ ; $ ,+ " " $$ $" ! F I ,"$" ($" ","!$$@ 4 ! " $ $ , $" !!$ !!"! $$" I 1I $ I 2 " 1 ;!!" " ,"" , $"" $ *" " "" 0E +" !"" ""+1@ ! " "" $ " " 5 ,"+ 0 "$ A $ 0 ! $$0! $ E+,, 0 !$! C,! ! ""$ H"$@ 68% 67D $ 679 I@
(";; *"K "! $ K
-" 2 : " O
, ;" ,"!$ ""J$ $ $ ; ! C ,"$ 0/' /;; ;!!" " ," (";;
<%>=<%77?