Pension Benefits Calculation Based on Credited Service Interpretation
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns whether an employer could deny pension benefits to former employees based on their date of retirement, with the dispute centering on the proper interpretation of a collective bargaining agreement provision regarding credited service for calculating pension amounts. The court reasoned that the controlling provision explicitly stated that credited service was to be calculated using the employee's full years of service, regardless of the specific retirement date, and thus, a subsequent amendment that referenced a different calculation method for a different purpose could not override the clear, unambiguous language of the primary benefit calculation clause, leading to the conclusion that the denial of benefits based on the retirement date was improper.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Pension Benefits Calculation Based on Credited Service Interpretation: The court reasoned that the controlling provision explicitly stated that credited service was to be calculated using the employee's full years of service, regardless of the specific retirement date, and thus, a subsequent amendment that referenced a different calculation method for a different purpose could not override the clear, unambiguous language of the primary benefit calculation clause, leading to the conclusion that the denial of benefits based on the retirement date was improper.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis provision was cited to rule on the costs of the proceedings.
Testo completo
!"!#""$ $%&#""%
' (') )*) ') *(
+ , !
## - #""%
! "###$ ! "%&' ( &"&' $'#""##)$'*'&&'&
"'&
++ , , , ,! &"' #'#$ -./0!%"'123/!4544 1
856478
) .(
49 ' :$$;###& ) &' )&8#(##'$9 ,)< & ="'' %# 4 ">' 4??@! %&''#" "%$'#& '" ' ;$$&(&$%&)++ , , , ,A#8%&B ) C9
59 #D $##" ##'# A%"&'' & %&''#" E "%'& 4&">'4??@!&%'#('4&=(#&4???!4&=(#&5777!4&=(#& 5774'4&=(#&5775C51=#5775!) '"%'!":& &( )#'$&$! ) %#" #'#& ) "'' 4)@77 ;&9 %& $9 ;;'! -#;;& 1 #%"#'#; =F' &#: %&#B& #' 3& 4?@/! ":#F'#" $'$ ;#' E )G8$%"G )&$ %<& %#"#'#& ;(&''&#B&!)"''4/7;&9%& "#9 %'!%&&&.'24=(#&4?@1! "&='#"$F# E)G8"="#')&$'$-#;;&1#%"#'#;=F' 9
29 &"#"($##""'$'$&$E)&$H5?">'5775!"&' %&''#"E"%'&4&=(#&5775!2=(#&5772"&' %&''#"E"%'&4&=(#&5772';#0=(#&5770"&' %&''#" E "%'& 4& =(#& 57709 '&"# $##" "' $F';#''#"8E'"&'8-%#'&&"&&"&') %#"#'#&-#;;&$'';"#E5)0?1;&9%&) 9
09 &"&&#&@"'":&5770! !%&)#'&$##& +,!$E) &$G#&$##"%&'% "%'%#"#'#&D))(#'=#&I9
/9 & $##" 53 "'":& 5770! ) &%&# "'' %&''#" &(# E )&$ %# 4& "'":& 5770 %%&#' %&# "%' #' %#" #'#&! D# :"'# E )F''#" %&''#"!"'"'''%$4)23?;&9E4)/@3;&9"'' 57@;&9"'&$'$(&$E)&$E'#'&&$'&"'#;%"&%&''#" %"&"#)"'":&5770!"''4)23?;&9!$=E(&$9
19 "&)'&'#'$$%-"#D4@"(:&5770!)&$;"&$"%%"#'#" "& E '' $##"9 &J8(" # $'$ ;#G$ 41 $:& 5770 ;# )$':#&%&"B8(&:)"%%"#'#"9"&&J8("!)&$$ %%&#"%&#"%'%#"#'#&'#"$( ;;'&$'&"'#;9 )%%#!;#'("#&D"$%"G!"$ (&')%#"#'#&"&%&"$&#("&%&#B& #'! (#' #'&='$ &"& ' ":' F# ! # :# D) )(#' =#&I#'%#"9
642726577/ 826478
39 & $##" & "%%"#'#" ? & 577/! ) ";#&$ $##" 53"'":&57709)'&$;$&$E#%"#'#"$F"D$##"!"& )F''#")G$'$%!%&;;'B$:'"# "&D-F'$'$"$#%'K'E%&'#&#&' D #8# ' &(9 &($ D) )%B! )$'#' D %& ''& @"'":&5770D"#& !#''"#-J+,! F#'"'%"&"%')#'$&$!(#'#;"&$) ;#'D %#"#'#&D'#")(#'=#$'$(&$E)&$9
@9 $##" & "%%"#'#" ? & 577/ $'$ &'"&$ E ) ( '#"LE#'&#:&4/%':&577/%&%"'&'','L9
?9 &"&&#&55&577/!) &("<$)"&#F#$##"E)&$ "%##%'%&#$''&#B&:#(""#&###D&!$# 4/="&!%"&D"#""&&#&$'#'#'&#:$%"'&''9
479 &"&&#&4&(Ɂ/!)&$&$%"D)(#';#')":='F&( &%&"'D)E%#&&%&#!"&&#&#(#'$'$$&":$ :"*'G''&!&#"%"&D!&"#&D'&"&& F$$&'%&B("#&":'&'%&"''#"&#&!(#'$#$ ''&""&&#&%"'&''9
449 & "&&#& 5/ (&# 577/! )&$ #'&='$ &"&9 "'#' D) GE%&''#"47"'":&5774!(#'="#'=F' &#: %&#B& #' 3 & 4?@/ ## D )&&.' "& ='#24=(#&4?@1'D) ""#&&&9 "' E D %&''#" # "#' (&$ E '#'& &$'&"'#; E "%'& 4&">'4??@!(#';&#'$%9
459 (#'$E$'&#&!) !&$%"47=#577/!"&=' &"&9 BF D )' D 0 ;$(&#& 5775 D )&$ # ;#' %&(#&"%#=F'#("& &#:%&#B&#'A%44 C &$%" E ='#;#'#; 55 =(#& 5775 A%#B 47 C9 'E)&&.' "&='#24=(#&4?@1!#"'#'D)# ;#F&#' % %&# %#B &I "& )#'&'#" %&''#"'D)'D44"'":&5770D)#"#9;#' %& #& &&D& D =# )&$ ) "''$ $##" & %& );;# %# 51 =# 5775! D#! '"'! '#' "%' ) %#" #'#&! D )&$ %"(#' #$' "''& E '& #' $##"9
429 &$%#D 44 =#' 577/! &"&' ;#' ("#& D)# &"&' ;"&#& #'#'$ L#' %#B ='#;#'#( E ;"&#& E ) L D) '&#E) ''=F' &#:%&#B&#'D)&&.' "&='#MD))#&G%&$'##D$&;"&#&D)
642726577/ 806478 $'#'#("&$%#42&4?@1!'ED)&&.' "&='#' ( $;##'#; ' G$'"#&M D )' D "& ) "''#" %&B +, D) ( " '''#" ''#&$ & ;#' D $##" '#' '"' "%' ) %#" #'#& D) )(#' =# &I ' D)%"(#')''&ED$##""#'&&"$!B"&D) (#';"&#E);;#'"$$''"'$#&9
409 %#D0">'577/!) #'%"#'#"9
4/9 #"%&'#"%&")''(' &#:$ 4@#57719
''"#"!&"&'#).'&&"%'!B$:'!D %#"#'#&(#'$'$%&#"#$&'#") 9 $F$).'&&E%#&&%&#%&"E)";;#'<("#&&"'&$ '&"#=F'#"#&#;;$&'D#:#'%"*'&""#&' D# # "' &$%" D L)$'#' " IL9 G%#D$ D)E )$%"D! &"'&#' F&( %&":B '$ ' D) ) % "&F "''&$##") %&$&#'9 )'D"&D)"'$ +, D)" # ";#&$ D) $'#' " &"#'9 ;;#&$ ("#& %&"#'G=F'B$:'!GE%&''#"9
"&%&'!&%&$'')#'#$"#F$D)"#&!=F' "&='#)%%&##'D)"'":&5770'D)#&"&'#')#& ='#;#'#;'$55=(#&5775D=F'#("&$'#' "&&$$M&"&'(#'&$F#'0;$(&#&5775!%&"#' $&#%#B!":&D=F' #"# "& ='#9,"#!#=F' ## "&)"'$'$%&"#'E )%%#9) #'"#"!;#'&&D&D! #=F'(#'$'$%&"#'B$:'!#)<&#'&#" %&"$& E &&"$9 &'! $'#' ;G B $%&'! # # "#B& D! "&D %&" ) % &%'$ " ":#F'#" &#F&! "#'%%"&'&"$D9
) *(
49 "#F("#&N"&F#'#"=###&AC$'$"#;#$'#'#'$!B 4&">'5772! &#:'"&"#!"%"$/=F! "' %&$#' ' (#8%&$#'! / %%$' ' 41 =F & A&'9 4 '9&'/1 C9
642726577/ 8/6478 ,#'EN'#"N$'#"41=F&!%& &#:;$$& 53=(#&5770A +427471C!& "#F("#"%'$!42;$(&#&! #%"#'#"'&#'"#&&F'%&''' &#:'"& "# #$F& & E '&"# =F '#'#&! ! N''' N$'#""(G=F&9
59 ";"&$'E)&'9/1! ,"*'#'#D"'' "'''#" %&$( E N&'9 /1 "# & %&'# F$$& &"#' & "# 1 "'":& 5777 A C &'#( E "# ;$$& & %&''#""%$'#&EN&8(##!&(#(''#(##'$4? &4?1/A&'9/194'9-92C'EN&'902"#'"5/ "'":& 4?1@ & %&''#" '" "%$'#& E N&8 (## ' &(#(' ' E N&8#(##'$ A&'9 /1 9 5 '9 C9 , "%$'%"&=F&N%B'"$':#9
29 "#;$$&&%&'#F$$&&"#'&"#1"'":& 5777A C ''&$ (#F& 4& =(#& 5772! '&*' "#;#'#" ":&#%"#'#"$F"#&"#9,& %'$&#!%"#'("#&D&"#')%%#D"#'.'&'&-$E#B& %&##%"D&BF%%#:"'(#F&"'"O ;#' =&##D' $'&#' "' %&"#' A + 453 013 "#9 4! 451 421 "#9 0: ' &$;$&C9 &(-! D# "& %&"$&!'E$;'&BF'&#'"#&"'&#&!"(&"#')%%#D &$&(B="&"'&$(#F&A +443?2"#91:!445 217 "#9 0M 4??@ P 23 %9 241 "#9 2:C9 )' %"&D"# %&"$&%'4&=(#&5772"#'&"#'%&B'''(' '&#: '" "%$'' '#B& )& "# "' &$F# %& "( &BF %&"$& "' ' %& #%"#'#" %&"$&"'#;;$&'"#%$#"#;#$%& 9
09 C '#B&%&''#""%$'#&;$$&!$##"&"%%"#'#" "'=''E&"&$#27="&A&'9/194'1794& M ;9$F' &'9 ? "# '" 40 "'":& 4?1/ & %&''#" ;$$& "%$'#& E N&8(## ' &(#(' ' E N&8 #(##'$ Q +RC %&B '&#: & '" "## N&$A&'9/@94 C9$#;#G$%&"#"&'%4/=#' 4/">'##('A&'92@90 C9
:C ,NF#' %&''#" "%$'#& '"! N&' 02 "# 5/"'":& 4?1@ & %&''#" '" "%$'#& E N&8 (## ' &(#(' ' E N&8#(##'$ A#8%&BH C "(& .("#&"#'9
642726577/ 816478 C N%B!&"&$'$$%"$;"&'$##%"$%&"#! "&'DN#'&(:9
/9 #'#F%"&'&&"#'&"&'E("#&"&(;;'&$'&"'#; #;;$& %&''#" D# # &#' E "%'& 4& ">' 4??@ '' "%';#'D%#"#'#&"'#$'$'"%'%&) )&#'%>).'&9
19 )'"&#'$#'#$;#'("#&D)-F')'%&#"%'D)E"%'& $:'"#"&D#$'$"$';#'&&D&D))%B! )'D)"'":&5770D)&$#;#'%&(#&=F' "& ='#''''D))(#'=#&I%#"#'#&D'#"9
&"&'"'#'%"&%&'D)&#'""'$#&8 "' =F' ' "& ='# 8 E ) ! G E %&''#"!47"'":&5774$=E'D)";;#""# &&&D)###":&$%&&9
39 #( ;$$&! N&'9 5 '9 %&$("#' DN"' &"#' G %&''#" #(#D#%&I"#('&''#B&N&8#(##'$9"'' %&''#" "%$'#& "&&%" "& E %&' $% &"D#GB&($'&#'A&'9294 C9 &"#'E %&''#""%$'#&%&#%&#&="&"#"O '$%"$'"O"'&%#'"'"#'#"$FGD# ':"&"$A&'95494N"&"&%&''#""%$'#&E N&8(##!&(#(''#(##'$4/=(#&4?34Q 8 ,6 RC9
," N&'9 2 9 4 ! &( $'&#' "%&' "'' %#"#'#&%&$(%&&"#';#A'9-C9
-F' ;"&' " &( $'&#'! %&''#" "%$'#& "#' .'& F'$! &$#' " %%&#$ "&D $%&"!&($'&#'';"&':#'##'#" " F''#" %"& &$ D# & (&#::' "F9 ,"' $'&#'$%"('&("(G'&:!"(&'# & $! ## D ;"&' G#'' E ' E D -F' #'&(#'A&'95/94'9 8 ,6 C9"($##""#'%"&'&;;' B$:'"#"&D-F'$'$"$!#%'K' E%&'#&"#D#8#'&(A&'95/95'9: 8 ,6 C9
,")&'95094 !&"#'E%&''#""E"'#'#"&&#$&$ )$'#'#D%&B;#"#%"&D%&''#"$'#''#D %&B;#)$#(#%"&D"'#'#"(#'.'&%<$9
642726577/ 836478 )&'9 50 #%" ":#F'#" &#F& E )<' &"#'! D# "#' "#D& &'& E )"&F '" "%$'' '"' -F' #''#"%&"''"'"#;#'#"#:#''#"'$	
@9 D# "& %&''#" '"! N&'9 0 %&$("#' DN"' &"#' G %&''#" %&" "' &( $'&#' N''#' % &(##'"N#"#%%#:9
&( $'&#' N&'9 / 9 4 "%& "'' " &I '#'& N ":#F'#" N'&'# (&' &"#' ;# A'9#C9
"'' %&''#" "%$'#& '" "&&%" E #;;$&'&&(##'"N#"#%%#:' &($'&#'N#'$&$A&'94/94 C9&(## '" N# "# F&'# N$B( E +&9 54?0@98! N# NF#' N %&" $#:'#&!((!#("&$!$%&$"&%";#'A&'9294' C9
,"'$'&#'!%"&;#G'#"%&''#"!&'!%#"''& %&''#"%$&#"#DN$#(#"&A&'9?'9 C';"&' 4& =(#& N$ %"& D %&''#" ' $ A&'9 ? '9: C9 %&''#" ' "#;#$ " &BF %&$( '#B& %&''#" "%$'#& ;$$& E N&8(##! &(#(' ' #(##'$A&'94? C9
)&'9 47 9 2 %&$("#' D & "#' ="#& E '"' %#B'#"&'"$''#(#!""##!&$#!;'E -&F! &"& ' ;"&'9 $&'#" '$&#&! # "#' $&& E );;# '"' ;#' "( '& E '&*& "#;#'#" "'' %&''#" D# # "' "$ " & %%&#" A&'9 44 94 C9
?9 )%B!;"&'"''&D&"&')%%%"&'&%&(D) ;;'#(' %&"#'! G E %&''#"! "%# =F' ' "&='#9 '$F&!"'#'#'$L#' %#B ='#;#'#( E ;"&#& E ) L E D &$;B&! )# %"&' ;;'#(' '#" &#' L("# G =F'L! &#' .'& "#$&$ " $$' %&":' & "O # )F#' D L-S8#'L ;"&# E '"' &$ %"& # &%%& D "' ="#& E 9 # )##D D )&$ )< "#' ;;'#(' ";"&$9 "'&#&! #' $(B' : $"'&& "'&#& %#D! %& "&&#& &$ E )&$ ' 55 =(#& 5775! #'#'$ L ='#;#'#;L! ) # G%&$' $ "%$'& %&''#"%&%&"'#")&'#":&"'!"'=F' #("&9
642726577/ 8@6478 &'!%&''#"!)&$#&''#"$-#;;& @&:&#D"&$E&"&H
L $%#' ) $##" =###&! = )# =# '"-$ %#" #'#& %"& ;# ' "#8. A=F' #("& &$ #5774E)++ ) ,, CL9
&!;#F&"#&) !&$%"E55=(#&5775! D)"%#=F' 3&4?@/!&D'#:&##DD)# $'$&I'0;$(&#&57759
( "#& ' G%#'#" %%"&'$! # %%&*' " ( (&#:%&$%"$&'D)&$)%&"#'D=F' '! "#;$(&#&5775!&#"%"&D) %&#"%'%#" #'#&ED=F';##'#""9
&"&'&(-#!"&"#'#"!D)(#'&&D$B $:'D''%#"(#'$'$%&#"%'%&) 9$"#! &"$E#'&='&&"&"'&$##"51=#5775'"'&D# "'#(#!5?">'5775'2=(#&5772!"&'D$##""''&$ ;"&9
479 )'#&%%&DN##'&'#"N'%&##%%'NG#& &$G!E"#D)"'#; &$(##"G#'A;9!#( ;$$&! &"#' $#' %& =&#%& N&'9 11 "# ;$$& & %&"$&##'&'#('!#('"!)&'90@"#'"45 %':&4?@/&%&"$& ##'&'#( Q RC9 )##'&'#"'## ' %&"$& E &$(##" A%&"$&C ) $##" '&$ ;"& ;"& "&D "' $"(&' ;#' "(G " "(G "< %&(!%'#:"#&E%%&$#'#"=&##D#;;$&'A +453 01? "#9 5 ' &$;$&M ! "( %&''#" ''&("#%&'''"#;#'#"$##";"&! #H , , 0365772 %9 2?2! ' &&.' #'$C! %&##% "&$ #( ;$$& %&N&'9/2 9
449 &!)%B!;"&'"''&D)"'&"(%&$(##" %#D;#'#("D$%&&"&'"'%"(G'D"< %&(#("D$"'%"%H)&$(#'"#)&&.' "& ='# ' %' $' "'#& ("#& $'$ %.-$ ;' %&"#& " )#'&='& &"& "'& $##" & =# 5775! =(#& 5772 ' =(#& 57709 &'! G%#D$ ("#& '&(&$ %$&#"#;;##9%%&*'D))%'=#$'$%&#($%#'$ #&'%"#'%"("#&F$&&;;#&##'&'#("E'"' "# ) $$F& F'#" E '#&9 # % '! )&$ ' &$ %#( &' % '% "$D' %#D % G "'
642726577/ 8?6478 $"$ %# %&#B& $##" ) (' D) &$F# %& $&#'9
459 $F& G "#$&'#" D# %&$B'! # )(B& D )#'#$ )(#' % )":#F'#"&$G#&$##"'&$;"&%#57759&"&' %&"$D'&='$9
642726577/ 8476478
*(.
(') )*) ') *(
/0121 3 411 1 56 %# *7
21
49 $&&"&&(:9
21
59 &=''9
29 #'D%&"$&'F&'#'9
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
"%#";"&%&$'&&.''"'#;#$G%&'###DNEN;;#;$$& &"#%&F&;;
642726577/