Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
DE FR IT EN
Analizza in Legislator
ATAS/563/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/563/2007 Generato dall'IA

Affirmation of Liability in Business Transaction Dispute

Numero d'incarto ATAS/563/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)
Apri la fonte ufficiale Archivio Entscheidsuche Versione Markdown leggibile dalle macchine (.md)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The court addressed disputes arising from a business transaction where the lower court found liability based on previous findings, which the appellate court reviewed for error, focusing on whether the established facts supported the application of certain legal principles regarding the alleged breach and resulting damages, ultimately affirming the lower court's judgment due to insufficient showing of legal error in the application of governing statutes and precedent to the facts presented.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Affirmation of Liability in Business Transaction Dispute: The court addressed disputes arising from a business transaction where the lower court found liability based on previous findings, which the appellate court reviewed for error, focusing on whether the established facts supported the application of certain legal principles regarding the alleged breach and resulting damages, ultimately affirming the lower court's judgment due to insufficient showing of legal error in the application of governing statutes and precedent to the facts presented.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
azione intesa alla dichiarazione di responsabilità errore di fatto garanzia di un'attività irreprensibile conferma della competenza controversia commerciale concorso di responsabilità

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Generato dall'IA
A/354/2004
Commercial Transaction Liability Dispute Affirmation
A/2364/2004
Commercial Transaction Liability Affirmation
A/2726/2006
Business Dispute Affirmation of Judgment
A/1654/2002
Contract Interpretation and Application of Law Affirmation
A/743/2005
Business Transaction Dispute and Collection Methods Affirmation

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

            !"#""$   $%#""&

''

() '*+), , , ( )', *

-.  %  !/ - #""& 



 !"##$%"&"% ! & 

&

'( # '#) ####' * &!"  # ' &+, '

                

   (2-4(  

, 0*

05 "0624 "%" & 782117%!9 !  :& % !%&&5  ;& !% < :   5  =&;:> : %%;&  !" !&5

25  ?8& 2117    !   "&" !% % :" %  55 ;";%&&<&> : @ (%<A&& "<A& %2112 (%<:&, %2112 (%!=B!&%"C"=!% ;D %2112 (%+&&&B<%=&D %2112 (% "%E:C&" ,FB!; :";>D %21125

"&"%"";:&"%; :> %%&" % % + ! :<2117% ! G"&>!&,%&G5

  8&" ;  %&& <& "=!& > :A& &" % %   !" !&&+%8 %2112& :A&!%="%!5

75    04 8& 2117 :   &%"    G"&>!& ,%&G5   C%;" E && 9 ;: <& H C +! & & %;    = :" : > :   %  <A&& "<A&%<:&,%+&&&  %  "%   :<& > :& %  % ;&   !" !& ;:E   && !& % 8 &  &&    "&" ++& E  >  < %5 :   9  ! "E G"&>!&,%&G ><%" & ;:":<&%E++&& <&> : "=9&!%&& :&%!%&   <5

.5  G"&>!&,%&G !%&9!;&  & 2. I&2117 & &;:"> : %< : &  , % != B +& %%&  !&  &D %  C &&& %  <  % %  "% E :C&" & %  % !" !&5"=!&> :<%  =<&C5

/5 : &&&; G"&>!&,%&G<&!   ; %; : <;""&&":&="%&5



-./01-2113  (7-4(  

35    G"&>!& ,%&G   !%  ;&9! +! %<E:  & .+"<211/5&;:"> :  %  <A& &  "<A& %  26 < 2117 ( & E ; :"  "&"  !#(%< %2?!2117%C&&& % 26<2117% "% !&E:C&" %26< 21175

;& <:<&> : %!    >  >   &&!&   "&" "%  % :++!&<  8 &  &5   "&" C%;" E & "=  ;  %&& <& > : %%,JC :=&  :<& :CJ="&,"%&&&& ;: %&, <& A& %%" ,; !& & <"  5   %"&& < ;& , % 8 &  "&& %" %  +!9 :=&,"%&%,J&,"%&&%" 5

;& <:"<&> :<% "=!& "&" "%  % :++!&<  8 !!  & +  < :"&& %&";>&&;E ;&,%85

?5 + :"&>!&+&:  <J" +!9%0/ I& 2113 B+5 % 00  D5  &   %%& ; :" <&   "&>!& !" (   "&& ="" & +> !%& &   ++ ;5> :&=&&;%:   >5#:=& &  <:> : ;% >=& ,&% "%E:C&"5 &%<  !& @% & &!%&!%% !" !& %,J&,"%   %  %  %"   ; ";<& E <  , % 85   & + %  +!95   %  "&" &&";:":%> :<%5

45  "  03 <!> 211/  ##   #   #    #       #   +" :& : &%!%&&5

65  / "!> 211/ :"  +!" %%& & && "5  "=" A& =<!& , %"  &  & ;&   %< !% %&  <:  :&&!!&< & &% &&&& <&9<&+%%E>(+E >(+5

015  "  %%&  2 <!> 2113  ##   #   #    #       # +!" " +C%;&;:%9<%" " E ;A&E G"&>!&,%&GK:"" &+  "&! ; "&&  !%A,!&  :!%!&  &



-./01-2113  (.-4(     <<&"&"&&"; &!%A,!&%&&;  C &     < & ; :"&&  &"  "&& %  <%%!&5

005    71 <!> 2113  !  "%  :"  &8&"  & && "5  = ; :;A&  :   +!" ;  "%C  %& % !% C &     <5 #%&%%!%%&<&@%   , +  %!  &&  %   &%& %>   <& ,F!" 58&;:+&&!!&%   %"&%"<& &<%>9! :";>!C &A& "% "<& <&+>%!&L5 +&!;;"%C"&&%> :!%&   <&E !& ,!;I&&9,5

025 <&"E%: !  ##  #   #    #       #  %   718< 211?    8&  5  :& "+"" E :;A& !"  04I&2113%+!9 &"%>; "  :"5

, ('*

05 +!"!& E :&5 /3  5 0 &5  ,5     =<  M=& 8  22<!>06.0BD >&  N&&; &&&%"<E:&5/3 +" "   %& =""  &     3 &> 2111 B D &< E    M(< &"  06 8 06/6 B D5 # !%"& %8=  M%9&"&>5

25 &8&"   +! & " %"< %    %"&  & <> B&5/3E31 D5

75    & &"  <=  0 8< 2117 &N&  ! +&  !> %&"=  ! 5%&  < &!% &  %% %%>  9=  &  <=  !!& K  +& 8 ;!& "&!&  & % & &  8=  + %%%%%":"&& +& ""E & "&!&  "%%&&=B O0260  50P O02?.3? 50&"+"D5 M&;;M C!  & "<& E  & M< &" %  %"  %"" & M&"<=  J M%%;M &%%" 



-./01-2113  (/-4(   8;M 70 "!> 2112 &  < "=!&& "= %9 && & B O071.77 50&"+"D5

 :%9  "  %%& &=  2 <!> 2113 & %&"E:&" <=    ;:E:&"<=0 8< 211.  ! +&    +" "  :(< &"  20 ! 2117 B.9! "<D5  ";&  %&  < !&"  & "<&E&%!%&& &A&C!"=  < !  & ! +&  "&<E.9!"<  && ! %&B O071../ &"+"P <"=!& O071726D5!A!%" &"=%< 9=&  &% %& %" &   ++"&%"! +"% 5

++" " 03 "!>211/! +&+" ":( < &" & &"  <=  0 8& 2113 B2113 2117D %%&&  ! +&;&&!!&%"  & <& > & B&5/2/4&30&5 D5 9=&%%> !K  & !&&+"&"+!"%908& 2113 B,5 &5  %& && &< E  ! +&  03 "!>211/D5

.5  &= %&   %&  <  :" %&  < N&  =" :!%&!J5

/5 &  "" !! !%&& && % ;   : &&& E  &"  >  +H %!&  :  :&  : < % % !%  & ""!&   < ;&  B&5 6  D5 & & E :& % !%&&  >""+ : &  < ; %"&&  !%& !J  =< B&5 .7>    +" ":(<&<<&Q #RD5!%& +> ="++& %E< &E&5

35 #:&57?52 9=!& 0?8<0630:(< &"B D ( &<= %08<211.(J!%&  =" !J:"!A!< !JC>@ 5 :   "=9 & !%&& :& % !%  %%&  &  <P >5 :   "=9 & !%&& :& % !%  ! C &  <&"&&<% %!&P 5 :   "=9 & !%&& :& % !%  ! C &  <&"&&!%=!& > %++C"&" < :&5745



-./01-2113  (3-4(   #M< &"&M!%& M(< &"B  D   !& ;M J  !%&  =" !J  :&5 7? 5 2 &5  ;  % " !A! &"  !J C ;& :  "=9 & !%&& :& % !%   ! ;& &     < B,5 4114  D5

?5 #8% & %!%&&"%&&C !@ 5 <A&& "<A&P >5 <:,P 5 !=P

5 +&&&B %DP 5 C&&&P +5  "%B :%%&!&E:C&""&> &&P O02. 2.?5P02061 57&"+"D5 !9=""&"%&%&E&  <:" ;%&:!%; :+H+!C!LB O013 0/6 52>D5 %%&%&%%>;::=& :%%" %&" :!%:&&&EC&&&B O0206/ 5 3P O 020  6.  5 3> &  "+"D5 % &  & & &   % ++  !A! & % :+!&"   ++& % %  E :C& : !%& B  0646 %5 224 & 0643%5 /1?P ,5 4107  D5

;:J&"&" :& :!%!& :&   <!%&&%+&%&:&%>=&;% ";&:  :&%&&%%& +&%&P ++&>& ;:;9:  :&;%  +&%&B,54100  P O00?0.3 52D5

45 +&% &;%&&+&: &"=9&!%&&5& "=9;%">%&<>,; 8 % C!%     % & %+ !& &  C  &8!%<&<>;!&,;8!A!% +%8B,5412/  D5

:  &  "" !! !%&& ;  % "  %& % !%!+&%&;:%&+;:%C : ++& C+  : !9 ,>&  ;:    "&& %J,;   %& :!%  && %&9   ; !A! < :  : &   %& !%  &   "&!" %;&&& "" %B,54123  D5

65  J<%%!&;:& &A&%"&&& 8"+% & >9<&%&%9 %"%



-./01-2113  (?-4(   ;:%&A&"5"&" < &A& !: :<9 ; :" "  < !&&&  =  +H &9 %>>&(!A!& &B,5417/  D5

015 & E :!%=!& % + + C "&"   <  & < % >& :"<& ;  %  & !%9&!& " E :>  &- <& A&%" ,!;5 ;: % ""& >!&&!%=!&&"%&" &&& : !%& +> B,5 41.1  D5  :& % " ; :!%=!& %++C"&" <&"%% : !& ;+"%"!&+!"B,++41./  D5

:!%=!& & "= ;: & "&"  !J  ! C ,%!%"  &!B,541/7  D5

 &%"<; :!& > %& &&C&%E  "&"& >:"&& &" %"5;%!& ,J%&,"&; :!&  !  C&"  ++& % P :!&   % " &  "&"& >";&   "&&  &" <&  & :A& "8E !+&"5 :!%=!& " & E :&& <  %   & & E  !&< % "&>  &&%C!%:!!&&E !+&&B,541/2  D5

#%""&!&!%=!&%++ C "&"   < !     %  +& %&  &   <B%C!% %&& &&CD !A! %&& :   %& A& %  !%& ;:  + & E && :  %  +& %&  &     < & E && :!%=!&%++C"&" <B,541.4  D5

005 :%9:&!"8&" !  :&5+:&>" %%& :;A&"&>0/I&2113 &&;:"&> : %!% C& !&;++&%E< < &E&5 %%&"&""&>&E:;A&% : +!9  &"  %>; &  &&&  & : % &&"%&5  =!&;:%&%  , B ;  "8E "&" %  !%&D  %!   %   &%&%>&8&;:+&&8%  %"&5  ++&% &%E "; &<& &E& :!%&&&":%95

025 "= C "&;%"9 &&8&"5



-./01-2113  (4-4(  

'  1 *0  '*+), , , ( )', *



  23 -

05 "<>5

 23

25 8&&5

75 :"!!&+C"E211+5&!E,= &5

.5 +!  %&   ;M %<& +!  &  %"& A&   "  71 8 9  &+& %9  > +" " B#,SF,+;3311.  D%< !&9  & %>+!"!&C&542 +" " >+" " 0? 8 211/ B ODP  !"!   &  ;   !&+ & !J %<&%&=& & ! &P & A&  "  > +" " % < %&  % < "&; C  &  :&5 .2  O5  %"& A& &  %9  %  &<;"!!!J %< <&A&8&E:<5  =++9  " &@         OO )#  )



%+! %"&A&&&+"C%&;MEM+++" " %=++





-./01-2113