Standing to Sue After Assignment of Contractual Rights
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court addressed whether a party had standing to sue for breach of contract despite not being an original signatory to the agreement, where the original signatory later assigned its rights. The court reasoned that the assignment of contractual rights effectively transferred the right to sue for breach to the assignee, allowing the current party to maintain the action, as the essential facts concerned the transfer of a legally recognized interest in the contract allowing the current party to enforce the agreement's terms against the breaching counterparty.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Standing to Sue After Assignment of Contractual Rights: The court reasoned that the assignment of contractual rights effectively transferred the right to sue for breach to the assignee, allowing the current party to maintain the action, as the essential facts concerned the transfer of a legally recognized interest in the contract allowing the current party to enforce the agreement's terms against the breaching counterparty.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis article is cited in the dispositive concerning the costs of the proceedings.
This article is cited in the dispositive concerning the costs of the proceedings.
Testo completo
())*+(,++- #(..,(,++/
#
#$ # $
"01 2 ' ,, 0 ,++/ !"#$% &'( ''( )!( *!(+(' , (' (' -- * .. / ' ( ! 012
! " #$#% ! &' '
/#3"4/
3$#
"7 ! "152 !&! $ 8!)' ' #665 &'9 *-- * .. / : /&'9 ;) (<*(' *'(* ) (!79=88' '*'(>' =( ? ) =8( ( !(!' '( ? &' 9' &>=& &@ A*'(>'=' (:'(;(0& ) !&>( 0) & ? 8 ( ? !& & @ A *! ( ( * !& 0 ( ' (7
#7 '&&'( '! < * B 8!)' ' #665 ' ! (' ((&! (-,! &>0 @('!!( 8 '! =( *'(>' = (C (!''(!8'(& "116 *((&'9'!( > ''= * 8 ( *!&=>& "11" * (( &'9 ' > ''= !& 0 ( ' ( "114 C= ' &(> 5/%%/."& "115(== ' (' >'&(> '( & #6647 @! @ &( ( ?'D ( ( ) (! C' < ' #6E @* !( ( &C (') ' (( ( ) (! < "66E & ## )' #664 ( < %6E & % F #664 !(( &'! ! @ &0' ) ( 8 ( 8 ( )C' #6647 ' F (<'&&'('' '*( ((* =' ! '#5'#664?('@*=' (88(!#" ' #664 ) ( CF( )! ( ( >' &( ' ) & ( * (' = 8!'/&( ' ?(' ( 0& 8!'/&( ' @* '' ' '7 &! ( -, '>(= (! #2 #664 @ *= ( * !&( ! < >'&(> '( 7
' F(! @* ( ) (! '( ) < #6E '( ( & C !( ( 88 <(')'@&( () (C &! ' ' = =(@*&) ('(' 5>7&'F'C(#>7 &' F' @* !( ( ')> (! & ( < =? * C((& ( '& 7
47 *'!'& @( '')(<!(' '(((#"F #6657 0 !' @ ) ( !(! C (! ?'' ( ( ) (! '( ) @ (! *&0! ' < ' #6 / 46E ' C 8 '7' (?'!((( ) (!& 8 ( &0' ( & "' !C' #6647 ! C!'!( '! ? &'(( *'/>G=7 '&& @* (') ! < & (& *H( "1$% < )' "12" ( < @ *( ' ! @* ?'! ( ) (! < %6E "' ' "12# 4" (C' "124 !=( < %6E <
344563#66$ /43"4/ "')C'"1B#46&(C'"115&'I(<#6E J "' )' "112 46 )C' #664 :8 (;7 ?& @ @* (') !') *I<%6E&'> ?&' :9' 80';(<#6E&'J' !(((!:'(>';7 (') ((< <"6E&0!C'&'' =7 F( @* * & ) =! *=(' (& *( ) (! &)(&'('& '>' <(&'') '*' ('7
57 (''=! &' * ' @! 1 #66% @ *'(>' = (!( (&'( 9'('!8'((&K> ((( ( ) (!'!'<( ('&'8 @( ) (!&'! '!&!( ( )(0&('(' (C'' (7
%7 ?'>(= @!(!'! !&'' ' .') ! '!= : /&'9 .; ## H( #66%7 !(! '( < ( (' =( ) '!&' ' & (! (') ? &0'(>' =( C (!' == C (!' ' * >'&(> '( ( !C( ='(>' (' * (( &(/ 0) ( &'( ( (!' ' ( *!>'' ('>0 < => ( * &!' '(>'&(> &/>!' & '@! < ' ( '*((&(? 8 ( <=>( ( <' ((< ( (' =( '!&' ' & (! (') ? *?9 &!'((&(/>!0(( *((&(/(' && =) C' 8!' '?G(!!='0'C '(') ' * ('C (( @ ( &'CC( !=!!'( 8 @ 0C '7
! (( @ *'! &'!( (' &'C9 (!'( ' &'(((( (<& (!(') L&!' '(>' (&/>!'C (!' & '@! < => &0'(>' )! =( '> A'(>' @(== C (!''*='(>'!C((7 (')( ) !&(C ! '! (( 7 '( =? (( (( ( 8 ( < ' ( ( @*< => * & A ' & *&!'( *!)( ( (( 8)'C7 . ! (( ( !( (( 8( CF( )@ ?& @( 88 (!@*'!&'8 '!( '7 9' ! @ &( (') 8 ! (@&(&'<> ((( ) (!'(? = C( 9'( @ (( (' ( ) (! &(! '!') @ *!)( ) ==>( *K('8)'C7!' ( (( 8( )(L *'! &( & (') ' & ( (( @ &'=! C('& = ! @*)C'/<*>' A(7 &(&8 '=!8? <'!&!( ( ('(' ' !>8= &(7 !&( ('' (! ( <
344563#66$ /53"4/ = ( ( < !) ('7 &'( >'= ( (! < "6 M= (7( ) (!8 ('!&!( ( ) (( =( (('9 (!7 !)!='!& (!(') *( ) (!>C ('!( '<%6E(( ) (!&(!<16E7 88( !'! @ (') '!( ' !( ( ('9 (! < &0'(>')! =(&'((@* )(') '( ( (&( ((' '(( ' > ! @7 ' (( ( ) (! &(! '!( ' (' ')> & (! (') ( ( 9' ) &( ( ( '( < ! (! 8 ' &( ( & &'!=' 'FC( 7((@!=9'&(' (N>)@@0? '&'(')?8 7
$7 '! #8!)' '#66$* 8'!( '*'!@ ((( !=9' ?( ) ( !(! '( ( * &' ?'D( ( ) (! &'8 < 46E ( '( < (')? >C ( &' '((@*&'!( (& (!(') ' C(? = C ( ) (!>C (*&0!C'%6E@' *&& ( < @*?'( ) (!<46E&'&!@* *0) (!@ &&'(! @' !(((!@*= ((N> !=9' !( ('!<*@K(! @'!=9'@* &'!( (&*&K>( = 8 ( 8*& ((')? >C (@*8 (&'( 8&'(( !( ('F(!7
27 *'! '&'!(! &' +(' /' - 8'! && ( 7 (< O)'*'(*'!&(( &'8 <*(' * /'(* ) (!7
B7 * &'!!<@K(! @'!=(2F #66$7 ' *'! !'! @* ' ( (') ! < %6E (( ( < (!'&&(@*) ((') !<%6E&(A(@* )'D (7 '!(*@K(@*&'!((?* & (!<& '(')? !='"2%E7
17 ' ! "" F ( #66$ * 8 '! ((( ?( *'! < ' 46E &' *( ) (! '( ) ( '(( &' (')? >C (7 '&&@*'!'!?&'(( *'/>G=@ & &8)'*)(!*=('(?*( ) (!K@ 8 ( * (' ' ( ! ' @* ( &7 )( @ ' *'! ') ( & (! (') ' C( ? = C %6E ( ) (! >C ( *&0! C'*&'(@*&'!( ('&&'(*@K(! @(? *&K>( *& ( (N> !=9' "2%E *(' &'( * 8 ( C( ='! * ) (! "#E F( 8 ( & *(' &'(( 7
344563#66$ /%3"4/ "67 *'! ('F(!''"5&(C'#66$(' (! 7'9) @* ()' @*(') (@*<46E' ' *'& @ (( 8 9'(*C =' (<(') '<%6E 7 ) ( 88( !&'! ' @ /K C!!8 * '( * ) (!&()''<!&@*& "*4668'7&' @ ( 8(( 88 (7 .*= ( & (! '! (') = @ ' 8 ( !(( (( 8( '(C'( (8 (@*&) (&'(' & @(' >' &' F' C( & ? >' &' F'7 (( !=( '&&'( *@K( ! @ ' != (('C' @$72@ '( (@"%E*( ) (!'@*C(! '' (&'( !'C(&<( ) (! ' &'( '<F' (<> 7*'!'&'>!=(<*@K( *) '8 ?!(&*( ) (!(?46E&'* (( (#6E&' )(*('( )K(('@*) (7 (9' *(' *@'('(7
""7 '!&#$&(C'#66$* 'F(''7
"#7 #$ 8!)' ' #662 +(' - 8'! ' C ! @* ( *&'7
"47 ' '' ' $ ' #662 +(' (' , !'! ) ' !(! (!&'*'!(&' ! ' C!C ) ' ( 8 ' F=((&)7
"57 '' '* #$&(C'#66$!(!(' <*'!( ='!<F='7
$#
"7 =) 'P'= ( F ':;!(! 8 !( ( (!9 "' H( #664 ' C ( ' ((( 8'!( < *'(7 %$ 7 " (7 >7 # ( @ ' ((( &'!)<P'(7%$ 8!!''&'( =!!'' ( ' $ (C' #666 : ; @ ( '( ) < ' P'/ ) (! "1 F "1%1 : ;7 . &!( &' F=' P&9( !(C 7
#7 ( ('! ) =' "' F) ' #664 ('+( 8 ( != ( ) (( ' ( *'/ ) (!7 & ( ) (&'(&' &&& C'9=' () ='(Q 8 ( F' @( !(' ( ( &' ( ( F= ' 8&' &&'&&'! ''*!((8 ('! !<
344563#66$ /$3"4/ (!(' (! '&& ( ( = : -"#15 7"7#R "$1 7"R4%$ 7"(''K( (!;7
.'8 ' C!'9)@! ( = 0(!(!' (""F (#66$(((('!((8 (F' @(!(' ( '(( < *! #664 &'!( ( = ' ? ! < 9' & ( 7 ) ( @ @* ( ')' @ & ( *( & 8 ! ( * ) (! * ( F' &' - 0'( )((F'*( (!7
@ ' &'!' ( < !8( '9= (' ( ' (' ' ('*&& ( *&& @('!')9F'' ('!) =': -""214 7$CR""#4$6 75R "11B S42&74"$ 74C;7
47 !&! 8' ( ! &'!) &' &'!( '' ( ')C :'(7$6 ;7
57 ( =&'('@( ) ' P'!&'!(='!P ) (! &( CP)' '' (<'(P ) (!7
%7 P ) (! ( ( & (! = &'!! &'( = '! @ '!( P (( ( < (! &>0 @ ( &')( P 8 ' (!=! (P P (:'(7B7" '(7 5 ;7P(( (<(!P(&<!(' (('&' !'( @'Q('+ & (!(') 0( 88('& (!= P'!:0'/'=(ATC' ) )' >'=U' >"112&7B;7
$7 )'( P'(7 #B 7 " (' ) =' F@* 4" !C' #664 *'! ' ( < @'( '( * ( ) < 56E < /'( (?* ) (!(%6E&(<'(( 9' / (&!' '<$$#34E7& "'F) '#665P!>('( P'(7 #B 7 " * & !(! 8 ! (( @* ' @'( ( /'( @* &'(!' *('0'(' /@'('(< ( ='! * ) (! (( ( $6E ' @ (? )'( ' ( < '(( 9'(&!$$#34E<26E7
27 '!)'(?P ) (!')@P'!' (&C( 'P P!( ( & ) (&'!) @P &'' (C( '?'D(P( ) (!@ &( ' C( K(' ? =! &'9 (' (( ( ' '!&(( ' '>! (') !@ C'! :'(7 "$ ;7 P ) (! '!@ P?'(&P( ) (!'( )((&( ' C( ? ='@P ('&'((!)!!'=( <P'(7"$ 8( P & (! P& ' ' (')? >C ( :'(7 #B 7 #C
344563#66$ /23"4/ (') ='& "'F) '#665;7'@P'!?' ( ) (!'( )<(&&'( (') K(''!!'!P('&' F (P ) (!&'((( ) (!(!)!P'(7"$ 7.P & ( (')? >C ( P ) (! ( 8 ?! P7 #C &' (( ( ) (!/< :'(7 #B 7 # (' (' ) =' & "' F) ' #665;7
B7 ( ('&'!C 8( ? '*='(75(% @ !(> *!)( P ) (! ) (*&& @':'(7#B ''!( ) '(7 #2 ;7 > ? !(> *!)( * ) (! :!(> =!!' &' ') !(> ?( !(> &! 8 @; !&'(((C!!8 '&(( '(L'!?'D(( ) (! '( ) < (& &( '! ?'D( ( ) (! '( ) < (& &'( '!( 87
17 ' ) ' '! ( K(' !'! &' ?'D( ( ) (!<& (&<(&&'( '&( )(&'!(' '&'( *( ) (!'( )&''&&'(<'!?(')?!=' ) ( *? '@8' (*'!K '(* *!( (&(( ( (!7''!(') (!= 8(( '&( (( 8 (&'8 @(N>*!( ( <*!='8(*N=&( (&'8 8'( & ( (&'! & ( 7.&'( @@( ((( ( K(' ('>! ' C (( ( @* *( !)&&! F@* ( Q * ('( &' ! ' @ &' ((' *!)( (!@*'!' (?'!( ) (!'( )* ) (!(! C(! 8 @8'&'C( ''>C ((' ( ' (( =='!)' C&'!&!'(: -"#% "%6 7#""2"15 74C('!8!' (!R."112&746" 7#C"11$&7#61 7"('!8!' (!;7
"67 ' (9')' C&'!&!'(@ (=!!'(&& @! ' ( *' )( !=( &' *&&'! ( &')' : -"""42# "C("6%##1 4;7 ( )' C&'!&!'( = 8 @*? (*8 ((& )' CC @ C :87 - """ 425;7 ' F=8! 8 & ( (' ' '8 (@ 8(*K('!(C 9' ''!8(C&&' ( & )' CC *(/</ ' @ &'!(( ='! )' C &'!&!'(7 88 ( & @* 8 ( & K(' !'! ( >0&(>9 & C7 ' ( !!( 8 ( !=! ) =C F= ( !>!( '( ' ? @ &' ( & &'CC: -"#$4$6 7%C"#%"1% 7#('!8!';7 *? (/(/ & ' ( ' &' & @
344563#66$ /B3"4/ * ('( F=)' ((('(8)'*'!: - "#$4## 7%;7
""7 P&9P'!(') !F@*)C'#664<' 46E (#6E ') J ( "6E < &' ' =7 @!@( '')(<!(' '(((#"F #665@* C (! ' ( ?'! ( ) (! '( ) < #6/46E &' ( 8
8 '7 ((8 F(! @* ) ( &')( (') ! < %6E &' I(@ ) ('! ((&(') <#6E*!( (' !(((!7
' *@K( !=9' *'! (( 8 / '( !'! @*' ((') !<%6E *) (&88'(((*'(>'(( ='((&&'*('( ( ? ?7
) ( =!!' *'' &'!8!' ? &' 9' !'( *'! 8 ( ' @* =' ( &(/K(' !@ F' @ ?& ( )&)(K('/ (/8' ('!8? (!' ': -"#"52 7#""%"54 7B;7
0((8 *C')'@'&' 9'!'( *'!) ( !F<?& @!@*) ('! ((&(') <#6E' !(( (!7 ( 9 ' (( < 8 ( )' CC @* * ( & &' @( ''( 8(((7 ((((( 88 (&(&< <&'(') ( @*C(!' ((') !<%6E7
*'!9=@*)' ((') '<%6E&'( 88 '8 ( @* *( !&'! ' 7 -' ( ((8 ((' @* )C' #664 '@* &' (') ' @* ) ) ( !F< < ' :87@K( !=9'; * & (! * (! *'/>G=7 &&'( '& '&&'( ! ? @ &' 9' (( ( < (! (88'*'!(')9"116@**(((8 8! & (! (') @*< &(' *)' #6647 0 /(/ ((' @ *'!)' CC('! ((&(') "115&(%6E< #6E&' (! &'@*) (!(! !&' ( 8! @7
) ( &' !@( P((' @ (( !(( (! P'!' (( !<(') 'K&'&'( @*( ''K( (') C @ ='! * ) (! ( K(' !(' ! !(> ?( < ' 46E &' *( ) (! '( ) ( '(( &' (')?>C (7
"#7 )'(P'(7#2C 7" :(') ='F@P4"!C' #664; P ) (! '! @ P?'( @ &'( ( ( ) (!
344563#66$ /13"4/ '( )(&'((&'(!)!P'(7"$ 7.P '( ('<'(')?>C (P'(7B74 P ) (!(8 ?! P'(7 #2 &' (( ( ) (!7 8' !(' ' &'( '&( ) P( ) (! '( ) ( P& ( (' (')? >C ( ( ' ='! P ) (! P&'9 > & ( P'! ( 88(! ? ( ) (! @( :!(> ?( P!)( P ) (!;7 8(!)'P&'(P ) (!(')?>C ( &' &' ( ) (! :'(7 #2 ; ( P(' &'( P ) (! ( ) (! '( ) &' &' ') :'(7 "$ ;R &'' ' !(' ' P ) (! =C P&'9 (& '! < ? >& P( ) (!7 &'( P( ) (! &'8 PC (')? P'!(!(' !&'(P>' '(') &'8 @( ( P>' ' & &' P'! ) R '&&'( &'/(('?)'7&'((')?>C (( ('( &'(=: -"4641% 7474('!8!'"65"4$ 7#;7
"47 '&) ''='!P ) (!P ('( :F=P 0 ''; C ( @ ! !)(( P(' &! ( )( 8' '7(N>! (<&'('F=( 'P!(((!(< @'@'(&'@( ) (!P'! ( &C(') '7('!! ( ((!!( ( &' !(' ' @ (')? &( ' ' C( ? =' P'! : - "#% #$" 7 5 ""% "45 7 # ""5 4"5 7 4 "6%"%B 7";7
@ ')'&'C(P'&&'(! @ (!(' ( P( @ & ( ( = ? ( 8 ( PCF( P !( '( ! @ '&&'( 8 ' ? &( @P &' !=( !'( & (?&' !&'&'? !@P (!(!!(C & P9 @ ' &( (?( ! ( P&&'! ( (( ! ( '(8 @ P?&'( ( H( ( )!7 '( P!!( !(' ( &' )' &'C( P( P' = 0 &') ! =( '&&'(?&'( C(C (: -"#%4%# 7 4"##"$6 7"('!8!';7
"57 *&9 ' !(C &' . '&&'( ## H( #66%7 '&&'( '& ( ( '!@ ( F' &' &'((( ((' C' & )' &'C(7 88( ' ?& @! @ ( ((( (<(!''((@ (( ('+ (7. ( '(C ( )!'(@ ' C !*( 8*!'('70 '( '!@@ *(( ( < (! &'!(! &' ''( ('+ ( & (! (') ( = %6E *( ) (! >C ( '!( ' (
344563#66$ /"63"4/ 16E ( ) (! &(! !(( &'! ! @ &' (( ( ) (! &(! '!( '('& (!(') (( 9')&( ( ( '(<! (!8 '&( (&&'!=' 'FC ( 7
'&&'(B8!)' '#665' !=(( !< %6E & F #664 & (! (') &( (7 '( F(! @*( ) (!'( )<#6E'( (& C8 (<*!) ((8 '(&(') 88( )((') !&'&( (F@/<7
"%7 ' !)' P ) (! '! (') ( != P ('( &'9 < @K( ' ( ) (! !=9' ( 8 ? P&K>( > ( ) (! >C ( 8'!( &&!( " ? '( ) '( P ) (! ( P &( P88 8!!' ' :R&! (>7#"##;) ='"'F) '"1144"!C'#666 :9 "' F) ' #66" >7 461% ' ' '( P ) (! ( P &((P'/ ) (!V W7 ' C8!!'' !F<P P(('8' (!?'(7%7" (#27"(# ((&'( @ ('( ):''K(1)' #66"7$%5366( ''K(&C !##H(#666 7"6#366("%)C' "111 ,7 44"311;7 ( @K( )' &'C( ( P( @P< ( (' ?&( = 9'( '@ !'( P'! '( & ) ((( 8 ( ' & ! @P 8 8 ' &'!' &' ! < ( ( &K>( @ P (!'! '('( ) (!>C (:.#66"&7"%B 74;7
'( 8 '<*C =( '! '=:87 -"#4#44 74 ('!8!';&'@ *&!= (8 '@*&( ' C((('*8 *! ''& (!(') ('! ' 88(*(( (<(!R (&'( '&''' ( 0 *!@ &( &&' !=' &&'&' !7 . *(( ( < (!&''!((@'( (')?&)(K('& @*)& ( ! (( C& & (& ( ! ((' &' '!@*'!&'( ?(') : (!=(& ( '&((')?&'=(;(@*'''>C ( <* C'8 7'>'=(') *(!(' (&' * ) (!@'@&''!&('* >' ''& '((')?!=(&'!@(C ' &'(( * * &' ?(!' ' @* ( '!!''<( (': "1B5&7"54 7%;7'*!)( * ) (! (')? >C ( * C' 8 : &'( '8(;)/<@*&((('/ &''!*(&(( ((!:''K(&C ! 7B)C' "114 56231#R ''K( .7 "" H( #664 $B"36#;7 0 88(
344563#66$ /""3"4/ '@(( (&(' (8 ' CK (( (K '( ) (*(('<') '&'(( *'7 !>!( &( '!(' = !8'! *!(( (! '! &' '! :) ' !=( 0'/' >(&'>= =' >(AU' >"112&7###;7
"$7 P&9 P &'!! < @K( ! @ ' !=R '!((( )(L
')? !'( &K>( ) (! (!= %E 6E 6E (( 46E "6E 4E ('( =( #6E "6E #E >(3' )' "6E 46E 4E )3('( #6E "6E #E )K(( . ?8( 6E 6E 6E ?('C' 8 )' "%E %6E 27%E ( "66E "27%E
(( @K( !(! !(C 8' (! ) ' ' ' * ) (! ( * &(* : ;788( 88!'(( ) (!''(( !(! &!'! ( 9' @ *C '&'!( "66E !&( ( !=@ * &&'' *!= (!(' (((' '! :'( @ . "112 &7 465 7 5;7 * ( @ '@ *&9 *'! !& ( ) (! * *(' (!=' :&' ?& *C *8( ( *(' C' 8 ! (( ;&!'( ('&( (K('=(!*((7
P'! ((! &!'( '( (')? !=' !(C &' P@K(7 9'88(@(?"%E*( ) (!'(<'C' @ $72'( )?( ) (! '*(&88 ('@?46E&' * (( ( #6E &' ) ( *('( )K(( )' ( & K(' !)!& @*) (7
. *) (&'!'<''( (' & (> (!&' *'! (L $7#L #6E 46E $7%L "6E #6E( $72L 4%E "%E
344563#66$ /"#3"4/ ) ' ( '( ' &K>( < >(' "$E @ ' *& ( ( ) (! !=9' @ 8 ' ( & '!((
8 7
0<(!=' (('@*'''*(= !& ($72 *@K(@('! (!4E:"%EL%6;@ ' (H'&' ( ) (!!=9'='!* ) (!"4E7(?*&K>(*( & & !(! ''(( !(C ' Q (( (! (? !&"66E7
"27 P!)( (? P ) (! 0 !(> ?( P!)( !(' <P 8' )(L
?X:VUYW?,;
Z(') 8' &''!((@&' ) ?'D( ( ) (!'( )>'&' 7
Z > & '('! (( @ &' ?'D( ( ) (! '( ) &'(7
UZ'!(') '&'?'D(( ) (!'( )<& (&C'>'!>'&'
,Z> &'('!!=&'(7
"B7 (? P ) (! C( ( @ @* ( 88 ( &' F( 8 ' *(' *@'('(*'(7#B7" 7
'' (/ K(''F(!7
344563#66$ /"43"4/
4#$3 #$ # $
'
5 0
"7 !'''')C7
' 5
#7 'F((7
47 *!(8 ?!<#668'7( <>'=''(7
57 8' &'( @P &)( 8'' '' (' &'!( ''K( ! 46 F' 9 ( 8 ( &'9 ' C 8!!' :.>[ A'>8@ $$665 ;&') ''( 9'' ( &C 8'!(?'(7B# 8!!'' ' C8!!'"2 F #66% : -;R ! ' '' ( @' ( 8 ( 0&')(&'(' =('''(( 'R ( K(' '! ' C 8!!' &' ) &( &' ) !(' @ ? ( *'(7 5# -7 &'!( ''K( ( & 9 & ''( )@!0&') )(K('F (<*) 7 ='88 9' '! ( ' / U ' \
& 8'&'!(''K((( 8 !?&'( @P<P88 8!!' ' &'='88
344563#66$