Financial Metric Calculation Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispute centered on the proper method for calculating a particular financial metric across several fiscal periods, with the core issue being which of several alternative formulas should be applied. The court reasoned that the governing statute or relevant accounting principles mandated a specific, unambiguous formula for the calculation, and that the methodology advanced by one party failed to adhere to these established standards. Consequently, the court affirmed the determination that required the application of the prescribed formula, leading to a recalculation of the figures across the contested periods.
Regesto Legislator
Ufficiale; AVS ; ASSURANCE-VIEILLESSE, SURVIVANTS ET INVALIDITÉ ; COTISATION AVS/AI/APG ; COTISATION(EN GÉNÉRAL) ; ABSENCE D'ACTIVITÉ LUCRATIVE ; DOMICILE ; PRESTATION D'ASSURANCE(AVS/AI/PC) ; RENTE ORDINAIRE ; FIXATION DES COTISATIONS ; PÉRIODE DE COTISATIONS | LAVS10; RAVS28.4
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of court costs for the appeal.
Cited in the dispositive concerning the compensation of the respondent's procedural costs.
Testo completo
&'()*&(++, &--(&(++,
! "! # ! #
. '
% '* /% (++, !"""# $% &!&' !'& $$ $ $ "'"# "&!' ()*+ ,-./
!"# $% %-0/% 0 ,3 # ,4+1 #5!# 5&6 $$ $ $ 7"%5&6 "8 9::""'"! 5!& 5&! '";"'# &'";3 ""<# <'"!"&(!9;!"&="'&;"#'&;!"&'!'"'#&' !#5!> !"&3 "%"<"''#$"1.=",44?3
-3 &!&&"&,25'@&,44? ""!:"&#<9#'"'::""#6 ,&=;"&,44?''<!'";3
13 *!;@&-..1 9&#!#A"!;&AB&"@!&C A!5'&,&#@&-..1'-.="'-..* A &%!'A!5'& -.="'-..*3
+3 &!&&"&,1!'!@&-..* D E":!&#"<9A"' 9"'!';"'#'#;"'"9#5!>9.5'@&,4/+ ;"';&#&'A"%"5",4/2 !5''9'''>3 -.., ' -..- '' &' 9#'"' #;# A +.9+.. :&3 5!& ( > #3
''<9& '''#<9-..- ;"';&#A 9#5!> 9&# '"'& &' 9";""'# "' A 9"' 1.5'@&,4/+ !*-9??2:&3
*3 & !&&"& ,* #@& -..* " 5&" !' !; !"" 9&#" ##""!!'"'"!5!&-... -..,'-..- "" < ";"''"! A ;&& !5' 5!& -..1 -..+ ' -..* " !'":"# #""! !'"'"! &'":"'"; 5!& # -... -.., ' -..- ' #""! !'"'"! 5!& # -..1 -..+ ' -..*3 :" 5&!## A "<"'"! ! !"& '' < 5&! '";"'# &'";1,="'-..*3
23 ,- =;"& -..2 " " &# #!5' !'"'"! 5&!,44? 1,="'-..* &5&#''!F/9,-*:&3-* ""#'"#G !'"'"!,44? B&3 ,9..13-. B&"9""'&'"! B&3 -?34. &'&# B&3 ,9./+3*. $! %B&3 *13+. !'"'"!,44/ B&3 14.3.. B&"9""'&'"! B&3 ,.3/. &'&# B&3 19/++3.. $! %B&3 19++13-. !'"'"!,444 B&3 1/434.
0,-/10-..2 %10/% B&"9""'&'"! B&3 ,.3/. &'&# B&3 ..3.. $! B&3 +..3?. !'"'"!-... B&3 ,9?,?3.. B&"9""'&'"! B&3 +/3.. @!&'" B&3 -924*3,. '#&)'!&'!"& B&3 11/3,* &'&# B&3 ..3.. $! B&3 +9?4/3-* !'"'"!-.., B&3 ,9/,/3.. B&"9""'&'"! B&3 *,3.. '#&)'!&'!"& B&3 -,*3.* &'&# B&3 +,*3+. $! B&3 ,922/32* !'"'"!-..- B&3 ,9?,?3.. B&"9""'&'"! B&3 +/3.. $!'"! B&3 -.3.. &'&# B&3 ,91/23-. '#&)'&##&'!"& B&3 /23-. $! B&3 1,-32. !'"'"!-..1 B&3 ,9?,?3.. B&"9""'&'"! B&3 +/3.. $!'"! B&3 -.3.. '#&)'!&'!"& B&3 2-3?. &'&# B&3 +*23/. $! B&3 ,914.34. !'"'"!-..+ B&3 ,9?,?3.. B&"9""'&'"! B&3 +/3.. @!&'" B&3 ,9.+-3/. &'&# B&3 +123/. $! B&3 -91?,3.. !'"'"!-..*7!5'8 B&3 4.43.. B&"9""'&'"! B&3 -*3 &'&# B&3 -*+3/. $! B&3 2?43?* 1 02 )3'(-2(-
0,-/10-..2 %+0/% ?3 9&#:!&#!55!"'"!-.=;"&-..2A"'#""!3 !"6& ::' < ! !' 5"' " ' &## !&&5! 5 > #&'"! :"3 6C A ' #C& < H;! 5!#I '!' #&'"! 9"5J' 95&6 < =9" #'# '># ;! 9;I &@!&# -..+ '&!5 5K# ' @"'' = !" 5K& /9,-* :&3 2*H3 9' 5& "& 5"' 5&6 "&'"! C##& " !5!&'' !@!&'&" $ !"#&' <9H !"' )'& A 5!& !&><'"!'"&A&#!& ;5!"''(& ;!">3 "''"! 5&! ' !5L! < = !" 5 H &6CH $" #''''A9#'&C& &C&@!'5H3
/3 & #""! -, & -..2 " &='# 9!55!"'"!3 5&#" <9 ;"''!'9@!&:">#!'"'"!5&!5&9&#&@ !"'"! :" <9" #'"' 5' 55& < 9#5!> %" #'"' !"""# A 9#'&C& ' < !"'"! :" !5&"' 5 &' ;&# 5& & ' D E3 ;"' 6 !& #C' !" A !'"'"! !"'"# &; ! :!& &' 5&L5&9#5!>3
43 9&#"'&='#&!&2;&"-..2!'&"'#""!3 8'< ! #5!> ' %) !' F' 5K# !'"'"! $ & @ #&'"!:"3 &6;<9(@"'"'B&"@!&C&'9#-..1' !5& 5 5!& < &"! ' H!# A 5K& ! '&!!"< 5&6 : H !& <9 ;"' #5&# ! #5!> ' <9 @##:""<&;!'3
,.3 !-1"-..2 "!''#< !@!# 9::"'!5!5'"!7>'&"' 8 "9;6&<9&##'# !"""#,&=",44/-?!'!@&-..1A6; <9<"''#'! 5!&B&"@!&C <9K'&;,&!F'-..+=<9,/="'-..* 'A <'5&'""3"5&#"<9!"&5!&5&! !'";9#'#!;&'AB&"@!&C!9&#,44?A="'-..*3 " !' < 9' A @! &!"' <9 ::""# 9&# &' '!' '' 5#&"!3
,,3 !&&"&#'#'&"A9&#'C&#A=C&3
#
,3 !"C;!"&M!&C"'"!="""&78#'#!":"#'"'"'# 6 ,&!F'-..1 &"@'!&!" !5!#*=C !'5&#"'';"%5&#"' *55#'',2=C&7&'3,'3 &'*2 83
0,-/10-..2 %*0/% $"'AM'"!M#'"!,2=C& 5& &"@:##& -?=;"&-..+7 B,1.,.28 & !"C;!"!5'# ,1:#;&"& "5!"'"!'&"'!"&&C'5&''' &"@'!& !" "#C& & A '&!" =C '"'"& M''' M#'"!!;>=C&3
-3 !:!&#' A 9&'3 *2 3 , '3 (3, &"@ '! &!"!N'"'"<!'''"!5&#;AM&'3*2 !":##&&5&'"C##&&!"'&!"2!'!@& -... '&# ;"C& ,& =;"& -..1 7 8 <" !' &'"; A !" :##&&M&%;""'&;";'-.#@&,4+27 $83$ !5#'5!&=C&M56'""#'@"3
13 ''&# ;"C& ,& =;"& -..1 '&N' !":"'"! !@& "5!"'"! #C !" & !"3 $& 5'#&" 5!"';!"&<&!"'955"<!"')'&'&(#A"6& 5&""5!<&6C55"@!';"C&!'!O :"'=&""<'#'&"'!'5&!"'7 B,1.1-/!"3-3-' -31P,-?+2?!"3, ,-2,12!"3+@'&#:#&83 &;( <" !& 5&!#& ' A #:' &6C '&"'!"& !'&"& !;&!"'955"<&#&;6=!&!'&#;"C&7 B,,? 41 !"3 2@ ,,-12. !"3 +P ,44/ Q 1? 53 1,2 !"3 1@83 9' 5!&<!" 5&!#& 5' ,& =;"& -..1 ! "'&!"' 5&6 '' ' ;' '&"@ '! !5#'' '"6& 9& !" !'&#C"5&!;&6C5&!#&!' '5& "5!"'"! 5&!#& !' "::#&' !" 5#" !":"# 5& 3
+3 #5!# :!& ' #" #C> &!& ' &;@ 7&'3 *2 ' 2. 83
*3 "'"C5!&'&9::""'"!9&"&'9#-..1 9 5&' '&&!"'"9#&'&!"'"!:"5!&'"& !5' :">'"!!'"'"!5&!5&9&# !"'"# &;!:!&&'5&L5&!#5!> !''#5
23 $!' &# ' 5&'' ' !'"& A 9 $ 5&! 5(K"< !"""#$"7&'3,'3 $83
K " !''& < ! 9::" '! C;!" 5!5'"! 9&#<"''#6;5!&B&"@!&C,&#@&-..1 ''&; !'&'!5&!;B&"@!&C,&!F'-..+3'"";&"@@ <&'("'!" #'#!"""#'!B&"@!&C3 9 '!':!" #'# ::""# 5&6 9 " !5'"! :&"@!&C!" &' ''5#&"!3
0,-/10-..2 %20/% B!& ' "" !& < 9&# ' &'# !"""# $" 5" ,44? "'&&5'"! ' <9 ' 5&'' ' 9<"''& !'"'"! 5&! $% ''<!'";3
$!9&'32+3- $ !'!''::""#>"!5'"! '!5&!M>&L''";"'#&'";3
9&'31* &6C<'"!!5#''&G HM&&>"M!::"M"'!5#''3 M&&<"'"'5!&!5#''!''#""!"5&'" !''!5#'3 M&&<"'"'5!&"!5#''&#""!M"&&;@""'#" 5&'"5&#'<M"'!5#''H3
9&'32+32 $5&#"<9#&!C'"!AM&'31* !:"'&'": A M::""'"! > " !' '&(# 5& M!::" !5#''3 #""! "%"5')'&&<"5&"!5'"!'5&M"'#&# '&'=!&6'"!M;"&'":AM::""'"!3
956 !:"' !5#' 9 F )'& '&(# 9C"' 9::""'"! 9&# &' 9# -..1 5"< " '! :&"@!&C!"!5'"!9'5"'&;3
9' 6 !& A @! &!"' < " &## A 9&# 5"' !'"'"!,44?1,="'-..*3
?3 	>&L''";"'#&'";5"'!&!"'"!!" 7&'3,.3, $83
!'"'"! 5&! '";"'# &'"; !' "" #'&"# & @ & :!&' ' &; <9 '"&' &'3 $" 5&! 9>&L' '";"'# &'"; "5! A :!" 9 :!&' ' 9 &; !:!&&' !''&''"5"#5&-.'=!'#A :!&' 7&'3 -/ , ' - &6C' & M&%;"" ' &;";' % $83
$! !'' !"#&# ! &; ! :!& &' &' ' 5"!'!C&7 ,4//53,/+83
!'&;(5&'9 $'9 ""<5&''"! !5#'"&7"&'";&!'"'"!'&;"&"#5'' 5&!'";"'#&'";9 $ ' %R-.4,83
"!@ > " !5'"! 9#'@"& &; ! :!& &'3 %"'&;"'''<5!"@""!;9'!&"'#:"'!
0,-/10-..2 %?0/% !""9 !':!" &"!"::#&'&!'"!:"' $&;!:!&&' !"'"!'''!&"'#"' 5"!5'"!7R-,--83
9&'3-/3+ $5&#"<G H" 5&! &"# !"' 5K& !'"'"! ! 5&! '";"'# &'"; !'"'"!!'#'&"#&@!"'"#:!&'' &;!:!&&'!53;)5!&'!'M# !"!&"C3!&'!'M#&'<";!&#'#5&!!# !'"'"! !' #'&"# ! M3,3 "%" M55"< #C' A 5#&"!5!'#&"!=!"'H3
/3 9' 6 !& A =' '"'& < 5& #""! ,* #@& -..* ' ' &5L'5&##' ":">#!''!'"'"!5&! 5& 9&# 5!& # -... A -..- '' !5' !"'"# &' ;&# A ! #5!> 5& D E ' ' <9 5& #""! ) =!& #'@" !; #""! !'"'"! 5&! 5!&#-..1A-..*3
0,-/10-..2 %/0/%
#0 "! # ! #
%
456 7 8 92 ',( #$:
6
,3 #&&!&&;@3
% 6
-3 &=''3
13 "'<5&!#&'C&'"'3
+3 :!& 5&'" <M 5;' :!&& &!& !'& 5&#' &&)' #" 1. =!& 6 !'":"'"! 5& 5" &!# &# &"@ :##& & $(S"I&(!:<" 2 2..+ '&!" >5"&3 #" 5' )'& 5&!!C#3 #!"& !"'G 8 ""<& >''<#""!&!&'#"&!@'"&"'5#""! ''<#P @8 >5!& 5!& < !'": " '" 5!;!"& & '' '& #""!P 8 5!&'& "C'& ! ! &5&#''3 $" #!"& !'"' 5 '&!" ##' ##&# ! ''& 8 @8 ' 8 "% &"@:##&&5!&&5'&&'"6&&&!&<M" ;&#&&"&&;@3#!"&&!&'"!&!&!K 5&; <" &!' =!"' "" < #""! ''<# ' M;!55 <#'#>5#"#&!&'7&'3,1- ,.2',./83 C&::"6& 5&#"' &"%!" T !&"D
!5"!:!&5&#'&&)''!'":"#>5&'"""<MAM::":##& &!"5&C&::
0,-/10-..2