Statutory Remedy Precludes Common Law Claim for Property Interference
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe matter concerned a dispute over the scope of statutory protection afforded to certain proprietary interests related to real property, specifically regarding the right to recover damages for interference. The court reasoned that the relevant statute provided a clear, comprehensive remedy for the precise type of interference alleged, and since the claimant had pursued and been compensated under that specific statutory scheme, the common law claim for nuisance and trespass based on the same facts was precluded under the principle that a specific statutory remedy displaces the general common law right.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Remedy Precludes Common Law Claim for Property Interference: The court reasoned that the relevant statute provided a clear, comprehensive remedy for the precise type of interference alleged, and since the claimant had pursued and been compensated under that specific statutory scheme, the common law claim for nuisance and trespass based on the same facts was precluded under the principle that a specific statutory remedy displaces the general common law right.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis provision was cited in the dispositive to rule on the court costs.
Testo completo
#$%%&#'((& )#*'+#'((+
)
) )
,-. % /& - '((+
!" !
! !"#
$
%&%%' ( )"*$+ % "/
& , ( !-. %
! "
-04
0)
+5 67!$ 1.!-..389!)!: : ;!9$ ;" $ !7$$"+(!:+8<.=>! $? @)A ; ! " +83- $ "+8345
-5 % )// 2 ;$/ 67!$ ;"$" : ;!9 $ ";$7;!$" ( ;"(?;/ B;) ";C $!75
15 67!$ ($ ( "/$/-2!-..3B ( $ ;$7 $ "$" $! D// : " -- ;$!:-..3;C"$ ;$75
25 : " $" ;$ ! $$$ ;"(? ; $;" $$$ "/ ;$ !!B!$$ ( ;$B $!7$ $+(!:+8<.$-2!-..35
45 ($7$!"; :$;! E"$:/$($F
A$( ;"(? ! F
• +1 (!: -..3 ' %% % B"B;$$ $ ! B; $!7$ +D3-</54.5
• +G(!:-..3& , BB ;$$ :;7E"9(=12D128/5<.!!$ ( ;$$ :;7 !7"$$/!"!$=E$5-- '5
:A$( ;"(? ! F
• 1.6(-..G %% % H B"B;$$ $ ! !" +!+88. -< /"( -..+ E"($ = G1D4G2 /5 BE "$" $/"" ;9 !;$ : ;7 $ -< /"( -..+5 ;$$ :;7B!!$ !7$5
• G/"(-..G%&%%' B"B;$$ $ ! $$ %<+<+ ' % %% %7;;% E"($=+++D<G3/5-2 !-..3;$$ $!!$ !7"$$C$$5
012230-..3 104
! :%&%%';""; -(-..GB ! "$" " ; + ! -..+ $ BE ;$$ : ;7 G1DG2-/5G.I $!$ ! -8!-..+"$" $ $ 5
• $=E$($" ! ;9 J% & , ;"" B ! E($ ; "$" //" $ BE $$E"$"("5
35 !$$"$"$!C;$ $ 1.(-..G56 $ B" B /!$ !!B" ;$$ : ;7 = ;$7 E"($ = +++D<G3 /5 ; ! $ = 14D8G< /5 1. ; ! $ BD= "/$ D:($ D 8 ! -..G K$ $ $$:5
G5 D: D:6$ "/C""$"7 "=675
)
+5 D$5-4 /" ":;7 ;"(?;/ ((($$( $" +G "!:+881@'A$"(7 +6(-...97;" (5B6$$ ; E ;$$ $=;$7@$5+--$+-1 (H A 67 (!;"$$ D$5G15+ /" " ;"(? ;/ -4 6 +8<- @A $ = 9( : $ ;+L$-..1 $;9BD// "$"$!@$5+2- AC"$ D//;$7: " ";$$ "$!";67 (5
-5 %D$5--'@($(7 ;+6(-...A ( ;$$ $ B $ !7 $ ;$7" /!"!$ C$5+--+-1+2+$+2- M$51=4 'D;;B$ ;7!$$=$/"@5+A5)B6$;$$ $=;$7; = //"$;$$ $7!$" ( : ;7 C$$ "($!$ !!$ ( $ ;$$ $7!$" ( :;7C$$"($!$ !!$ !7@/5$5-2'A56$ = ;$$ $ $ = D( : ;7 C$$ !!$ !7 $"K$ !!$ ( @ ' +-< -1.M '+-8222A5
012230-..3 204
E;9 67 ;!9 $ " ;$7 ; !$" ;$$ $ B $ !7 ; ! 5 $ ;$$$ E;$ !7+(!:+8<. E$;$ -2!-..3 $=B67!$ ($ (C"$5
15 % !$ ; $ ;$$ B ; $ !7 ; ! $ +++D<G3 /5 $ B B ; ! $ 14D8G</51.@12D128/5<.N+D3-</54.A$"K$?$ "6="$""; $$$ ;"(? "/ 5 ! $ = CH"; !$$ 44E81</5@+++D<G3/5F-A$H $!$$ +GD8<8/5+4 @14D8G</51.F-AM"B ! $=CH";!$$ 1GE82</5<45
25 /!"!$ = 6; ; 6 "$!$ ; ;$7 6BD!!$ $/$ ;$$ $ !6$ (":""/ $$;$$ $= $"K$!;$ !$$ H5 $"K$$"$C!!!"7D$5+- D ;"(?;/((($$( $" +< ( +8<2 @ -A $C "7!$ H $ ;" @ ';:"130.- +<6$-..1A5
45 "!!$ ;I ;" "$$ 7$$ @$5 G1 5 - $ <8,5+ ;" !$$( +-;$!:+8<4A5
OOO
012230-..3 404
1)0 ) )
+5 ($%&%%'=$/" !;$ !! 1GE82</5<4=& , ' /( ! B $"K$ !;$ "$ 9-2!-..36BD!!$ $/$5
-5 E? !$$B :5
15 $B;" $7$$5
25 /! ;$ BE ;($ /! $ ;"$ K$ " 1. 6 9 $/$ ;9 : /" " @%)PQ)/B33..2 A;( !$9 $ ;:/!"!$C$5<- /" " :/" " +G 6 -..4 @ 'AM !"! $ B !$/ $ !? ;($;$7$ $ ! $M $ K$ " : /" " ; ( ;$ ; ( "$B C $ D$5 2- '5 ;"$ K$ $ ;9 ; $(B"!!!? ;( ($K$6$=D(5 7//9 " $F %?( , J
;/! ;"$K$$$/"C;$BE=E///" " ;7//
012230-..3