Contractual Annuity Valuation Method Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe petitioner sought review of a ruling concerning the enforceability of a contractual provision regarding the calculation of an annuity's value upon termination, arguing the lower courts incorrectly interpreted the contract's unambiguous language regarding the method of valuation. The court reasoned that the contract unambiguously dictated the use of a specific internal rate of return method for calculating the surrender value, rendering the lower courts' reliance on external market data or an alternative calculation method impermissible as it contradicted the clear contractual terms, thus upholding the established valuation method.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Annuity Valuation Method Dispute: The court reasoned that the contract unambiguously dictated the use of a specific internal rate of return method for calculating the surrender value, rendering the lower courts' reliance on external market data or an alternative calculation method impermissible as it contradicted the clear contractual terms, thus upholding the established valuation method.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe provision is cited in the dispositive to regulate the costs of the proceedings.
Testo completo
"#$%$"&$$' "(&$"&$$'
!!
) !) )!
* + '
&, &$$'
!"#$ %
%
&& ' & !" (")*! %#$ +%,-./!)-)) ,
! !
2-0.2
-
)3 3 ! $ )4/5! %6% ## +7 %%
8 9:#+;<!= 7!"+)>-1153
-3 &%(7#%"%%%":#+;9$%":$%$;#< ) >% -11?! % 8 & ! 6 %% " %6 $%$ ++$=:$"%:%3)+$6;%@:$%%77$@%$"+7A% % % %6B $6% #+$ + % 97! #"! 6!%<A3
,3 "-4+%#C-11?!:$D$"7%%+$%$ #%D@:#+%#"D%"D%%@$+"+% "#+;3
53 ,1 +%#C -11?! :#+; $$ %% " %6 " :$ 6 DD%,)%C-11?3
?3 ")-%C-11?!:$@@%##@$ #%D"7$%6$@#%%6%"%#%%= +%%%%6D%%"#""6!6 :7#%% " +C%$ % " D% @ 6 %% +$6;%3%#%@7$$%%CD3
*3 )4%C-11?!:#+;$+"@:"%%"%6 :6% $%$ #"D$3 $%% $ " +$%" @ 6 %% +$6;% 7#%%"+C%$%"D%3"%!$%% +$D$C"#%%%#=C%3
/3 ,)%C-11?!:$"(D"#"$#%D$%"7$3
.3 .6#C-11?!:#+;:%$D$$=+$$"%3
43 -,6#C-11?!:$:%%=:DD%":#+9 <!% %$:"#%$"(E#7"F)6#C-11?3"@$@:6% D$ 6 %% " %6 2 7#%% %6 + #G#@+$$"##%3
)13 :%%%%":#+;+:2(E#7#%A#%D" $%A@:$D$"7%%"%6%(7#% "%%%"%%3
))3 "$")1>6-11*!"(E#7"& 92+FH< "%=:"#%$":$%+$+""% " ,) >3 6$ @ #"D% ++%$ + 6 %%
0)1.10-11* 2,0.2 $%%##96%%%(7#%"<%#"D% :+% 6C " +%3 :$ $%% " C +C " (E#73
)-3 "$ ++% " -/ D$6 -11*! % = :++% " :$ " -1>6 -11*! D#$ "$ " +" :"#%$ " (E#7 +"% ,) > "F ) 6#C -11?3 %% ++$ +"% %% +% = #+ 6C % D% % " +7 :6% + $%$ #+$ + % D% @: :% + $%$ #":B3
),3 -1 # -11*! :$ % %% "F "$ +F " C % " 6% @ %%
8 ! +$$ " (C"! "+%! +! ": C2"7 6%%IJ2"%6%%%=@%%%36%$%$ 77$ + #+$% $@+ " % +7 = D " -1153 %D! "+-11?!:$%%%6$+7+F#%"F73 6% + D ":G% %#+ C%#% " %6 " +7 C 9# 6 $! %%; %! 6%! %%%<! @ %6 :#% = +73 & #C +% >% " "% " %6 6% "% +%!=:":$%C#%"6B%%"%6!=>%= :%3 ) " %6B ++$#% = D3 6% #D%$ "$" 6 6 "% %% @ %% % + #+7$ ": 7#%% " @ 6%$ " % = %6 B #G# "% @ : %% " %63 & #+; :6% $3 :$%%++C"#%6%@#%D$A@@ (@+%+A36%D%"#C"$#(+F" +%"C%"7"+%!""C"%"%63
)53 )? # -11*! C " $ %" +% " " #+%+3%"$$H
A +% " 8 "% @: " (7#% " %%"6%G%D%3"B%%$%%""$"$%#$3 :D$"76%%#D%$%%DD%$3"6 DD% + ":% %K( #%$ = :% ) % % %6B $6% #+$ + %3 $>= +# %% #G# @ %K(:$%% +#%$>"6D" #+#%3 % 6$D@>"6%6#"@$%%>+" 7$ 9 >:6 " % 6"" #%<3 " D L # (D#:"#"$>:D$3:+$%$+$$"D3#!7 6 %% 6% " @ >:$% ":" 6 +%@ " #+#%! :%2=2" @ > "6 " ##% %6 #
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
"$$H
A 6 %% +" B "% " %6 " :(E% %%! +% = 6% %6 +$6 " "#3 :%)+"+=%%;+36%$%$B#$+ & 2%":(E%%%%$%$>7$D#A3
)?3 &@!$%$7"$=>73
!
)3 76N7%>"9<$%$#"D$%%%$!"F )M%-11,! C%"!#+$"?>7! "%+$"%%62+$"%!?++$%%)*>79%3)%3 %?* <3
&%=N%"N$%")*>7!+ CD$"$ -/>6-1159 O),1)1*<!" 76"+%$!),D$6! "+%%%7%+#%%% C%" " $7 = % >7 %%! ! " N%%% " N$%"6B>73
-3 D#$#% = :%3 ?* 3 ) %3 (3 . ! C % " P%%@"%%%+$6=N%
0)1.10-11* 2?0.2 ?* @%%6=D$"$N2(E#7C7%% N"#%$"N6C%$"-?>)4.-9 <3
&#+$%+>7""N+F%$%C3
,3 D$"$ " * %C -111 +% 7$$ " "% " 9 <%%$67)>6-11,!%P%#"D% " #C "+% $7 " "# " :2(E#73 %++C:+F!"F@D%>"@#%"$%#%% "$$+%$#%=%$679D3 O),155*63"3)! )-45"3)3-<3
#G##%D"+%"6"--#-11-#"D% !@#"D%": "-.#-11,!%$67 )>%-11,9-11,)/?,%).?)<%++C":+F3
53 %>%$%#+%%6C9%3*1 <3
?3 %7+%+""%=:"#%$",)>+$+ %#$3
*3 3&:%3,13)%3!3,%,C !"%":$=:"#%$% +"@:%%##%$%C@2H%%6+++ D% 93 ) %3 <3 + 6% @ + > + @ (E# #+% "% "% "$+" "% = :"#%$3 #C ":"#%$>FD++$"+%"$"%"#C#B## ":"#%$ >F " :%3 -/3 "$ " + % ++%=76%$"D%%+%B$"!+#%D"+! *1>!%"":3)!%37!-?>3:B$%"+% "@B#+F"$C%""$"+93,<3 D$"$ +%+"$##++93,C<3
:%3553)%3%C +$6%@:%%##%$+%$%6+ ++D%:$@H+#+%#%!+%+6%" C7% %% " %6! "$ = #+; #%D " $%"%%"%69%3<Q$$2#G#%%"%6! 6 $%$ +$C#% $ ":C% % #+! D : +6% G% B7$"@:6K%#+9%3C<3
:%35?3-%, %6%H
"$"+":B""%=:"#%$%"H
3 )=)?>"D%$7FQ C3 )*=,1>"D%"76%$#;Q 3 ,)=*1>"D%7693-<3
0)1.10-11* 2*0.2 ; D% 76 @ :$ C" #+ $+%$ 6C :G% $ ":C% 6 #+ @: D #+ $+%$ 6C#%D6C93,<3
C3+""%=:"#%$+$"(E#7"M= D%":$! ++%":%355 3) %3 !+++ $%"++%"%6+">%#%D"%3,,/%,5* 3 - 3 DD% @ #+%#% 7$$ " :$ % "$ 7$"#%"2!#G#@:;%"+(":"+D =D3 +%G%@:#+;$+$%%F!" 7!@"++%"%6%C9 O))--55"3) % G% %$<3 + " "% = :"#%$ +% +"% G% D7$=:$@#+%#%+($=2%#%$%C3 @:"DD$"++:$=#+;!DD#%" "DD%+=$%CD%%%$+:$%D#$ +":%+6"+%=6:"#%%>79 O ))- -5? "3 )! )44,0)445 R -* +3 )., 63 "3 -Q & )44- +3 ??) "3)<3
/3 3 :+F!%$%C@:#+;$$%%"%6"% ,1+%#C-11?!%##$"%#%+F6" " :$ " -4 +%#C -11? " @ 2 %% %# " 6%%"%6@$%$++$3
6"%"%##%"+$%%"6%% " %6 % ++% " %$ 6 $% %73 % = "$%#%%%%6":D%" 3
C3++P%%%":C"@%%"%%=%6+ #+;! B #G# "% @ +$6 " %% " %6 %!@:%+%%$+:%#$3 :%##%"+$%%" 6 %% " %6 @ % 2 @ #+ 2 ## %%!=%":%3)!"6%K(2%#$$7% 6 #+; 6% = C%! % ++ " @: #+% ##6%7#%%"%K(%!%7#%%" 3
! :#+; $+" + %% " #%3 %! ## : 6$ :%#$! 6 %% " %6 :% + %@C % %6%+!+%!=6%%6%"%6+ (E%!%%%D$9$%%)>%-11?<3:"#+# @ % +6% $7%##% :@$% " %# " 6 %% +$6;% :C7% ":DD% A% % %6B $6% #+$ + %A"F@:6%"$>=6$""DD$"6#+;=
0)1.10-11* 2/0.2 >%9%6++$#%!#+#%=D"%@>"7$ +<3
:++P%+%@C@%%(%$D%#" 6%%%6"@+$":7#%%" %K(%%($=D%"+73&"#"%%""" C%$ %%! @ +#% ": = :#+; " %+ " "$7%=6%%6"%6%6!D6" %69D3 O ",)#-111!5 5*?044<%%##%=@G% "23
6(!#F"%%$7$!%##%%#" " -4 +%#C -11?! +#%%% + = :#+; " + @: %"% % = %6 " #G# "%! # % +%E% %" @: D%! %% (;+%(F! 6 %% ++$! @ 6#CC#%#%6$:#+;=$+#%%#+#%%% "%6"%3
.3 6 " @ +$F"! ; ":"#%% @ % ! + #+%#%!"$#%D"$%"%%"%6=#+;3 +"%!%#%=:6":%#$!D%##!6"%B% +$%$!"%G%@D$"$7F3
$@!+"*>+$%+" ",)>3
43 %%!+%#%"#%"$%7$D#$!" +$%$3
0)1.10-11* 2.0.2
! - !) )!
./010 2 300 0 45 #'& 6
10
)3 $6C3
10
-3 :"#%+%#%3
,3 "$++%")1>6-11*%%@:+ +""%=:"#%$",)>3
53 +""%=:"#%$"%"*>3
?3 %@+$"%7%%3
*3 D# +% " @N +6% D# % +$% G% " "$ " ,1 > "F %D% + + ##"$ "$ C D$"$ " ! &(IS(D@ *! *115 ! % B#+3 "$ +% G% +7$3 #$# "%H < "@ B%#%@"$%"$C%%+""$ %%@$Q C< B+ + @ #%D %# +6 "#" %% % "$Q < +% 7% " +$%%3 & #$# %% + % $$#% $#$$ %% < C< % < 2"! CD$"$"++%#%F@N "6"$6C3#$#"#%#; " +6! @ % >%! @ "$ %%@$ % N6++ " @$%$B+$"$%9%3),-!)1*%)1.<3 7DDF $"% ;& $
+D#" +$% G%%%D$B+%%&$%%"N %%= N$#+7DD
0)1.10-11*