Judgment Interest Calculation Adherence to Mandate
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA dispute arose concerning the calculation of interest on a judgment, where the trial court applied a statutory rate intended for contracts to an original judgment based on tort, and the appellate court had previously directed the trial court to recalculate interest based on the statutory rate applicable to judgments. The court reasoned that the trial court was required to adhere strictly to the mandate of the appellate decision, which specified the correct statutory interest rate for judgments, regardless of its own interpretation or any perceived prior agreement between the parties, thus concluding that the trial court erred by reintroducing an incorrect interest calculation.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Judgment Interest Calculation Adherence to Mandate: The court reasoned that the trial court was required to adhere strictly to the mandate of the appellate decision, which specified the correct statutory interest rate for judgments, regardless of its own interpretation or any perceived prior agreement between the parties, thus concluding that the trial court erred by reintroducing an incorrect interest calculation.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied to impose the costs of the appeal on the appellant.
Testo completo
%&'(%&))* +%,&)%&))*
""-+
+" . + " . .
/) # &))*
*0 .1
22222222222
. ." 3 " . + .. + !"#$% &&'(
!" # $
)*+,)
4+
"- .& ///////////$ ( "0*1$ ( 2 & '& & 3&) 2 4$ 56&7&&&&8 ' ('&-
*- 5( 99( :' % 5(6&' ; && *< ' 1= >& *==1- : 9 5 ' ?- #"@-) (( (% -
1- ( % 5 AA . BA ' &7' '(&:$ 9& 85 & & : &- *< C *==1$ ////////// (&(8:'99(5>&((%& (>&9 8 & >& : &&' ;&( 8 ( 5D 8&&'&% 585%&)'E'-
@- & "F '6 *==1$ > & % 5($ &9'( 5 AA . BA 8 D >& (( 99(6 (>&985>& 6&7&% ;7 '&- 5 ( 9 5 AA . BA $ & &' &-
#- &"1>'6*==1$5(&&((&&9' -
<- (&&"=('6*==1$ 9( &;7 C:'99( 5($'&985&9 & & 6&7&' % ;7 '& 7 5 &5&- 5 &&9'( 5(*@('6*==1((G( $ (&&"0G>&*==@-
F- 5(&G("<9(>&*==@-: (89& (&(((5H>&8 (& &&7((&8$&5 '& : :' ;$ ''( ?($ 6 (> &)9&' >-5 $'(&)& 5( (($ 2 85& (& (7' '(&)
&$ 5( &&( 8 5>& 5 '(&)&$8>&&>(&9I%85& & ('&- A 9$ & &2 8 9'(' % .$ &> 7 (>& '&$ 8 5)6&7& & & ;7 C &
)1+,)
:' &( % ( % ' '&$ && 8 : ' (>&>9>5( &&2''(-%8 & '( % D 9 5 AA . BA ?-#"@-)$&( -
,- ( 1 ' *==@$ 2> 8 :' 99( 5( AA . BA 5 ' (>&>%;75)'&- '&& 85 &9'& '(& 5 (( &>( '(&)& $ 5( D &' ('& >( 9& 5&9'& '(&- $ (& 85 (G%('(&)&'&>'6 *==1 9& 85& >&- A ;& $ & % >'&&9&85& (&$8&((9& *F9(>&*==@- (8G-
0- ( &81='*==@$2785 & 5 & (>& ' 5:;&>&( ' '(& % ;7 5)'&- $ & &' 85>&'(&)&5&&'(( > &-
"=- '&& &$ : ' 8 & ;7 6& &8( ' *==1 5 >&76$(('8 585% &"G>& *==@ 8 :' (( '& & '& (&9&8 '-
)@+,)
"+
"$ 4 & 7>& 57&& G&&& 34 (( '&9&( &&($ 2 " C *==1$ &6 & 3- " - 4-
E1='*==@$ $ &6'&&&93&) 2 4 (599&&(5-"-$&(8 A>& ((((>&&5-"1" &&7>&) )-
64 ?8&&&&6($: '&9&>J
) 9&7 & &&9 5E- $ & &&9 5 G7' 8(& 5&( ; G7($ '&9- 5&(;G7(5(%:)&8'K & &&9 D >& : (' K & % 8& &&7& 3 ? 0< *0#H L $ (& & '&&&9$ @2' (&&$ "00"$ - *@, H B6;&$ & G&&& &>( &$ "0," -1"1-4-
) 5&(;G7(>8&85&&8 'D 8&6 >&:'&39-L $ -&- -*#"4-$& M 5 2:8 >&$'E' >&$%5&5 &G( >&& & &&8 E( &5 9&:5(&G7 A$ N&&&(&&&G&&&-
) &&&&&E((-A$5 & && )& 6 39- )?I& 6$ ;A;O&!$>-$"00"$ -"F,$@1=4->& >85&6&277((57&> $ &&2' 8 (8 5& 6>& (7&' G&&8 3 ? ""* 1"14- '&9'&&$28&( &85E >&%&5:&5G&&&8&9& &" C*==1(G%$G7&&$&&8G7 ($ (((7&2'(-
)#+,)
4 A :'& 599& ' (H > 5E 1= ' *==@ &G85%:&$&(7'%>(&9&9'&(%5-"1" &5&&-
AG&&&'&&&> (&$85& '& &&&-D& 85- #F & 9(( & 7(( & & ) )$ ( >&7 " G>& *==1$ ;8 && &6 $ 8& & &8 '& &- & && (7 9(( 6&7 % 7 &: & 'E' &$ &:G8%( &%2>&>''&& - 5&& ( %5:&7 ( &9(( 8(7&7>&(( A-
A5-"1"-" $P&(6&&6: ' G7 &>& (H 27 '6$ 57&&$ G&&&' (Q-(& "0F"$& && &&((' (( &(*$&6(''&JP&6 '&&&9&&( &'&&&9 K& (>&Q-
&&5& 2'E' && 8&&&- 27 5& (& ' G7 (77 5 & && J & & % & (& &($ ;&&8$ ((7&8D('&8'-G7> & &&&' : & &- $ E 1= ' *==@$ &(( 8 : 5- "1" - * && 5 &6: & '&&&9H & & (( P &6Q ''&7&9& P&6Q-$5-"1"-* (&8 &6 '&&&9 &&( P K & (>&Q- 5 & 8 (&' &: '&&&9 2> 5 G&&&- &&5& (&&( '%8 'PQ&E8&9&($7''&'$5&&('&(-
D 9&'( & (& ;&&8 ((7&8- ( >: ( & 3.('& & R . )"0F=$ -##@-48(7&"0F=&($:N( G&&& &>& ( :& (> % 5- "1" - " $ &6'&&&9&( >&:(&9- &6(&&(% ' &(R &5 $''&&$S8& >& % M (&& ( '- 5(& 8&8' '&7(($& 8 &65(&>(' (5&6&-(&(>&8&
)<+,)
''&& (& >& 6&$ '' & ' && &&23' && &&$: S4-A.('& &$ -##F$PD2'>&7($ $ &5 ''&& (&&('&&(((&($& G&&& '&&&> && &( $ 8 ( &' (Q-
2 " G>& *===$ (( '& 6((9& 5 7(( ' (- && > G&&& '&&&> (& & '' 3- #< 4- >$ '&& ''&& (&((: ('(99&'(3. "00F$ -0@1=4-&&&( G&&&5 G'&(('&$& ?& ? - >& &&8&&' E;((7&$88 ( $ 9& ' ( '&2 5 &$ G8%(>%''&&$%G&&&'&&&> (&$ A5-
A&5>&&>5& (& E1='*==@$ ' A$ '& (7' ''&& (&$D' &;( &)'E'&&&&- 5'&9' ((6>&( (7&-
> 8& (2$ (& A && 9'% &&7>&-
5(& G7 D & (( ( &6 9(($E*FG>&*==@$ &7>& ($ "1 9(>& *==@$ & && && ' A &(7 % & G7 &&$ $ 5 5(& >: -
*- &6 & $ & &8$ & (>%5&#<&9(( &7((& &<6*===3 4$(>&7"G>& *==1$ &> % & 9(( 5)'& ", ' "00@ ''39-&#<&("4;&99@4-A' ( G75 2&&(6&-
G(9'(&(7:$>63&#<<= 4-
)F+,)
1- A 5& *< & 9(( 5)'& ", ' "00@ 3 .4$ 5 6&7& & ;7 C & :'&(%(%' '&&&8' (>&> 9>5( &&2''(- :'' (>&> 99( & '(&-
&'&(:-*#%1"&>E99&$ &( ('&8- 599&&( & E ('( '(; &&9&8 3-1*&(" .4- &56&7&&$ > ;75C8: & (> :-*#%113-1@&(" . 4-
''(& (>&%;756&7&& '& (&( % 5& "* 5 ( ' 9((5&(& &56&7&& '&*0 '6"00#3 A4-
5 2$ :' 99( AA . BA (( &8(*==1H5(85&"* A >61"('6*==18& &6$(7 && 8 27 &6 >&7 '' K 9& G&&8'('& &3 ?"*F@<F&-"4-
?8D &' 5 & (>& &$N 9'&&85'&& '&7(& >5T71=3-"* A4'''7 ;&$ '2$9&U3-"* A4-
>;$ :' 6& &8( 5 AA . BA 3 &>&$ &74& :' &;7 5&5&"* A-
9&$ &' % 8 ( $ 5& "* A$ & &&5&*< .$&6&&:;&> & %;756&7&&-
$'9($&EG(-
),+,)
" . +4 +" . + " . .
56 7 8 9$ :(&
6
"- (>6H
6
*- GH
1- &8 (7&H
@- 9' & 8V > 9' ( E (& 1= G 2 &9&& & ''( ( &6 9(( $ A;O&!;98& <$ <==@ $ & :' &- (& E 7(- '('& & J 4 &&8 :' 8V (&& (& 6& & (&&8(H64: 8'&9&&' >&' (&&H4 &7 (-A&'('& & & ((' ('(( 4 64 4 &)$ &69(( '&28V& >(&>6-'('&'&'D >$ 8& G&$ && 8 (&& 8( V> 8((: (&(3-"1*$"=<"=,4-
799&J (&J W& . &
(E''&8( &9&&: &&&8V%V99&9(( & 799