Validity of International Arbitration Agreements Absent Formal Contractual Compliance
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispute concerned the validity of arbitration agreements within contracts for the sale of goods, where the arbitration clauses were subject to an international convention. The court reasoned that where the law governing the main contract permits the arbitration agreement to be concluded separately or validated by subsequent conduct, and the evidence shows the parties manifested assent to the arbitration clause through their actions, such agreement is valid under the applicable international framework, even if formal requirements of the domestic law of contracts for such clauses were not strictly met.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 93 BGG, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Validity of International Arbitration Agreements Absent Formal Contractual Compliance: The court reasoned that where the law governing the main contract permits the arbitration agreement to be concluded separately or validated by subsequent conduct, and the evidence shows the parties manifested assent to the arbitration clause through their actions, such agreement is valid under the applicable international framework, even if formal requirements of the domestic law of contracts for such clauses were not strictly met.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAUsed to declare the appeal inadmissible because the decision was interlocutory.
Imposed costs on the appellant for the federal court proceedings.
Testo completo
#$%&'#$''( )#*+$#$''*
) , ,)
- ),- ). - . ,
(/ 01 + ! $''*
2222222222 ! "#! " ! $ !%%&'('!%'')
!
, 3. ),. 4,, '!'( 3,-), ) .)- ),. ). 5 6 4, . %"! *+,+-.+
! "
2-/12
4,)
+) %(''%+3!4 -.., '%$!'5''%$'%! ' ! % ! !' % ! % 67 8'2 6 99: (( ; "' <<<<<<<<<< &'!( %$' '(2=( ! % '(!( >; 5'' '! % ,?1@+ 5 ) A3 (!! %= &$ 4' %5''!! %!*! '4!'%$!'5'''B( %$!4 -..-;C!-..1)
-) $'!' 5 ( $'!( ( (!( D!( %('' % $'!'( % -, 74 -..,!'5&$'7'!'(='== 7==!'' 4''!()
1) $'!( ( '! D!( -1%(4 -..,E'%% (4! D!' % /-0-@/-.., > /-0-A/-.., "! ! /-01./-.., 9 '7&5'!&5''!%'(!($!!D F! (!!! 4''!()
,) '4 % ( ! 55! (=! '' % %* '! D!( $'!( ( ! % %('' '!' % ' % !' % '(!( ' % ! ' (! ; !'! % ( !'%%='!%1-?A0@5 )-3 (!!!'!' >/ / / 'B( 8 ) /-0-@/-..,: ! % +?.@A 5 ) 13 % ! '4!'%$!'%! '!(8)-0-A/-..,:)
.,)
+) '=7' $ ='!'D%''' 8:(!(%'5'(!'!'!(%6 + C!-..1 '4!% '(%3D= %! ('%!!7'2 ('%!3(!!+0D= 8 !)+!) !30 :)
>'!;$!'%$(!'%+0D= '45(%( -GD7' -..,8 9+1.+.0: % '=7'%!(+15(7 ' %''!'! '!' =! !!! '4!% ' % '(= ; ! ' D= !'!' % $!!! % $(!'%7*D= )
-) '4 ! % ' #! '! '& % !!!' !'7 ; ' ! !' 5'' % + +AA08 !)30:)
>(! D= %%$6!''(!4')
/-01./-.., 21/12 1) ! ''! (4! D!' % ( /-0-@/-.., > /-0-A/-..,"!! /-01./-.., 9)
>$ !)G.)+%' (% %''! !'7%+-!4 +A@3 8 :$! '!(!%$55' &H!D'% H (% % 55' &' !! ; '!!' D '%'& '%!'& ; D '%'& ) $ '4 % ( '%6 &$' D!'5' !'!(%D'% ('!(%6 &$'!! % ' '! ! ! % ' ! % !'7 % '! ! &$ !'6 %$ > % % '! %''! !'5 ! 7 ! 6% '45(%( % )
,) *! %$ !)+,%'=7' (% %''! !'78 : (% !H! % & !%(%%!'%$&!' % ! '7' ( %''! !'7 %! %7! ! ! '!( D&$; % '! &!') 5 !' ' ' !2 '4 &%*!%!%7!HD '%'!')
$6 ' 7'! % % (! (% D&$; % '! %)-0-@/.,!'6 %$ >)
.),4 ),- ). - . ,
789 : ; 3" +%$ . <
+) >% ?'! '!' % $ !) +, D&$; % '! % (% )-0-@/-..,)
-) ( 7'!% (% )
= 55' ('%!J I'% " '
'5 % (! H!!!'5'(* !' = 55
/-01./-..,