Property Transaction Disputes and Contractual Breaches Appeal
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involved multiple disputes concerning various past transactions and alleged breaches of contract related to property interests across several years, encompassing issues of property ownership, contractual performance, and damages calculations stemming from these dealings. The court reasoned by meticulously analyzing the documentary evidence and testimony presented for each distinct claim, ultimately determining that the plaintiff failed to meet the requisite burden of proof for most claims, thus affirming the lower court's findings on the validity of the underlying agreements and the corresponding awards or denials of relief for the specific actions brought.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Transaction Disputes and Contractual Breaches Appeal: The court reasoned by meticulously analyzing the documentary evidence and testimony presented for each distinct claim, ultimately determining that the plaintiff failed to meet the requisite burden of proof for most claims, thus affirming the lower court's findings on the validity of the underlying agreements and the corresponding awards or denials of relief for the specific actions brought.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispositive explicitly orders the appellant to pay the costs of the federal court proceedings.
Testo completo
#$%&'#())* +#')%#()),
""+
+" - + " - -
-. & (& ()),
!"""#$% !&'(% '!'( #("!!"")#(*('+ ,-- .(#&/
!('
.. ... ) .. . . "("# ) . -/((('0 &!(1/2345 6778
!"
,8900,
90:2498773 ,3900,
/+
0; # 0<67 #("( &!=# &" 0<<2 >"(# )!%'"$'!(?&'$)('&'"@.; ;A'!"B;
("(' #("( '# !(' "( &'!1"! ( ! &'!1"! &'$ " ("! " )"( C",&'$D . E;
8; (0'#F'8777 #(#%"(")"("'("! !"( !""!1'!(%!('!'>)'!"(A!"47G"!$(' A)/'!#'("!A&!";
.!11'(!''%" #(#!"(FA"%""! '?#"!,/"''?"C ECH#(F"(/!&"("HE;
3; (!''%""">)1'(',((2!(#(#"?!("># ( )"&"(# ('%" #(# 1"B# A 077I $ ( )"( C'&&!'( #" 88 J%"' 8770E; ('"(( (=& !'%(' #(# ('&'";
2; )"&"(#('%"""#A:4I$0<'8770 A67I$0:%'" 8770 &" A 47I $ 37 %'" 8770; 8 J"( 8770 )'# '&'" ! ('%" A &" (& J>) 07 !(!F' 8770 ( ) !% "&"(# ('%"A47I>"#(#&'!!?#&'"( /!'"'(&#'"!&"(# (!(0285J%"'8778C'&&!'("('#""'#(F"BH#(F"( /!&"("HE;
4; &'(">#08J"8770"#%"1!(&(B (!'( "> 3,2 "" > "!&(/" &'!('"% '%" "1#'"'!()!'"?"&!(,('(">#("(('$&'!FF;
6; !' ) B &'("># 5 ' 8778 #" )''!"( . !((#>1'('!()(!'!!'%"%"( #(#('"(#!'%("%( !((A)")"'%&!'(#'(('!" !" " > A & >"K !" )"( )#(( )#("( & !' (!(((F""#;
)'# #'"( ! ("%"(# /F"( ! ("%"(# ("( C1F'"("! "'"( #('">E ( B&!# !11'"' ) ?!'"( " ?/ !'>) 1""( &"' /' "( L ('%"; B&"># >) &!%"( ?#'' !' !'>) ('%""( A 47I " ! A 077I '"! '' !' '%"!,!'C!'#("%""!(>%&'1!" B(L(%%'("?E;
90:2498773 ,2900, )'##?(#(#(A)?$%(84J"8778; #'#>))%"(J")"(%("0'#F'8777 (>)A)/'(!#((#("((("!"';
:; '!'('&&!'(#(F"2J"(8778&'' '!!? > &("(!11'"( &'(/#" B>('F' %""("! FJ("%("!(/'">&"(JF&"! "(; ! '&&!'( ' (!(1!" !"?# > ( B '!!?"> #("( &'1"(( !' ( >)" )= %"( ##( !FJ("1 &'((( !''!F!'' ('!F !( &"?"( &("(; ??#'# &'!#' A "?'" '%" 1" #' #%( !("!#"';
5; '&&!'( 82 J"( 8778 ' /"''?" CH#(F"( /!&"("HE !((# > F" '"!!?"> 11(# !('"(&#"!('(">"#>#"!('(">(>)% )"?'" '#"# "" > )B ""> &("( &'#("( ('$ %'"FF((("((=&1"F'!=?">;
<; 88 !M( 8778 ' #" )''!"( . $% '%# > &("( %"( !(# ' ( ("(&!'#%!&&(1!'"("% JF ( > &' "' "(("! #("( (!J!' L )'# &"?(#?()>)# "">!'"%!'; ' !"?# > )#%!("! )! !(("( >)" )= %"( & ('!F '!!?"> !FJ("1 " #"! ('("> ! #>#"!('("> N!O)#%!("!"?!(")(("((=& 1"F'!=?">; )#(( &("( #("( %!" (F""("! ##( !FJ("1 &!%( B&">' ('!F #?# ( &!'"( ) "&"(# ('%" A 47I; ??#'# )!F("' '&&!'( #("# ' !(("!11(#/K'( ;
07; !''&!08&(F'8778 ''1!'# "?!(" H'%"?" &!(,('("> '#" )/'" "(', &!?"2(&""!1"F'!=?"H;
' 84 !(!F' 8778 &!# " )(!' '%" ( !'%1!(3(2;
! '&&!'( "('#""' 8< !%F' 8778 ' #"('"(()'# #?(1"(#(()1"F'!=?";
8 !(!F' 8778 ' &'#"# > &("( !11'"( ) =&(!(!!?" >" F"( ??'%# &' )("%"(# '#&#("("% ( >)B'#!'(>)'#!'"(("!&'!1"!#("(!/"(F;
90:2498773 ,4900, 00; ( 05 #F' 8778 . '# '>L( )%" #" '%"#"'. A' =J!"?(!"' #"!&()'#;
08; ! &&'#"("! #" 05 #F' 8778 ' &#""( -P /"''?" B&!# >)&'$ %!"' B"# % ((("! !(('"!?'&/"'" "&'!!Q"(!"(D
H1'('2!')"(0'#F'8777)(&'!FF; )(A !(#!/!'! &'#B"(( C'#" ./' !BE > !''&!( & ! ./!' 392 ("!#; '#(( '"!!?">C&'#('#"(&"E)B&">( ('!F"11; !('&("()J"&'#(#('!F'!!?"> C!1"'("! &' &#""(E; "% '/" '%" &'$ (!' "& #"!&!(,('(">&(L('"#%";&!"( % ""> " )= & '('"("! !F""(# '/" CB 80;75;8778&'#")''!"(E;'!#>( "&"(# ('%"J("1"'&!'&!';
1"F'!=?" &&!# ( ('!F &=/!,!("> F('(; )?"( &( ) >("! J'""> "(# #>(; )(' ('"(( !'&!' !( " #"' " ("; (("( A )"(#?'"(# 'F ( ('$ "&!'(()(&!FJ("%FH;
03; ' #""!021#%'"'8773 . "1"%'(&'(("! )' 30 ' 8773 !("1 > ('!F &'#(# &' )'# )#("(&'("!"(#%)"(0'#F'8777;
02; '(('05'8773 )'#1"(!&&!"("!A((#""! ("(> "(# (' ( #>( (' ('!F ( )"( 0' ' 8777 #("( #(F" % '("1"( #"B 1"?'( !"' . !''!F!'# &' B J!"( A ! !&&!"("!; &'!"( ('!" !''"' ' 4 6 ( 07 ' 8773 > "," 1"( #(( ) #>"./'(("!>)"B"("('("! "(#'("(')"((#F(('!F B&(' "" F"("11"")(('";
04; ' !''"' 87 1#%'"' 8773 .. . C'," )'#E "1!'# . >)" &''"( /'? 1'"#"B'("1A)11("!!(")?""(A&'("'0'%'"8773! !"1##'')',";
06; ' #""! ' !&&!"("! 06 " 8773 . 'J(# )!&&!"("! )'#(!1"'##""!('&'";
90:2498773 ,6900, 0:; 04&(F'8773 )'#"('J(#'!'!('#""!'!&&!"("! !("1"# 0< " 8773 1"( A !% %!"' >)" B"("( ! ( "(# (' " !' "(# #>( (' ('!F !( !11'"(()"(0'#F'8777;
05; '#&!03!(!F'8773 . !%#)"''%F""(#'!' "('J(#04&(F'8773&!'('"%(#;
0<; 'J?(:%'"8772 2$/F' '"F(!' !" #'# '!' '%F; ! ''L( 87 !(!F' 8774 '"F1##''C - E!1"'#"(J?(;
80; 87#F'8774 . &'"(#!"! !"#'(> " "(# (' (' )(!' '%" !( %"( #(# %"(" '!'(()"&"(#('%"(#'"'&!%"(L('#(F")&$ ' !O >> ('!F &&'(( (F ""> (=&"> %"(#(#'%#;'"' !%#)F"(##>(;
88; #'"(' < ' 8776 '!'( &'"(# )"(#?'"(# ('(!"!!!&&!"("!A)!('#""!. 021#%'"'8778;
83; .' #(#?'#AJ?';
82; (' 1"( &'("( !"' '!( '&'" (( > F!" &'("'!"(&'#(''L(;
"+
0; !&#( '"F#('%F""(#'!'!(#(#" &'''L(:%'"8772 !1"'#&' - (87!(!F'8774;
8; ( ('# %"?' 0' J%"' 8773 ('*( !F' !"1"("! !" N' "(; B (' N'(; 005 ;0' &'(("! N' !# &!' "( >" !( '% %( N('# %"?' !" !( '#?" &' N" '!"(; N"(=("0'#F'8777 &'#("("?'!#> B"#A"$'"&!"("! %"?'J>N30#F' 8778; '%/ '$?&'!#'!("#"((&&"FC'(;58 R -08:28:!";0E;
3; "("? &!'( ' &!"( %!"' > ('!F !( '("! "(# ('( #/#( #>(%N"(0'#F'8777""> '!F"?("!>"#!(&!')"("#,A30'8773;
90:2498773 ,:900, 2; E .! N'(; 6 ; 0 &'(("! N' !( !# N"( &'!1"! N"( ! &'!1"! ( " &'!1"!; N'# !(( '!"( ('"(( #" &&'!&'"# #"! '#(( N"( ( N" ( (!(( ! &'("( "&F ('%"' A "( N"( A ""(# J!'"$' C'(; 07 ( '(; 06 E;'"' !N'(;05;0 N'#'!"(A'(N"%""(# N"%"("%"A07I!"&'"(N"(( !N'(;82;0 "'!"(A""(##>"(F&!'(("(AN"(#?'"(#" &'"( N"( " !11' N(("( "&!'(( ( 'F A ! "(#?'"(# &/="> ! (;'!"(B&'(("!&&!NF!''&&!'("(#(' (#>(('N"((N(("(A(#;
FE "(#(('!'>N" = "N(('> ( #%#( "( !? '"( & &'!"( (!( ! >N" '"( & '% L "$'; N( & #"' '%/ > N"( !"( "> ! "#"( N(("( A (#R " 1( ( " 11"( > N#%#(!?F !"##%((AN('1(' "(&'!%!># N(("(A(#&/=">!&=/">N'# N(,A,"'>N"&'#( ! !"("! " > ! ,"; .%!"' " N#%#( '# ( N(("(A(#!("#&''&&!'("(#('(>("! 1"( > N""('("! ! #/#( J? B" 1!( ("(''"?(N!''#" (>"!"(L('('/# !1!'( A '$? ?'# %'"F &'#&!#'( &&"># ?##'(AN&&'#"("!&'%N'!"; "" !'> NB"( N '&&!'( A 11( (' N"( ( !? &'*( &!"F ">N&(&L('>"1"#&'!FF&'(""' '!"(A&'(("!#!(N"( '#!"( L('"#C -00< 33:!";0 00585<!";0F('#1#'E;
E"(#(#>(" )&'$!'!'""'/!()B&#'" %" 1"(!"#'##("(&'!&'A('*'11(?'">")( &'!"( '%'#((&'"(1Q!?##'1%!'"#&' ("'!(C -084260!";4('#1#'E;
&'# ('!F &=/"> '#("! J'"&' #??# '"($'!FJ("1>"&'(((J?''($'#>(""(#; (!( )F!' # "( ('!" (#?!'" 1!("! ' #'!( D "( ""?"1"( ! & ?'%"(# C&' B; /( FER"(?'%"(#!=("(?'%;!'&'!#'A (("1"("!"( "!%"(!&)((/'A"$'!( )'#'("(#/!('("> "F"&(S(1!' ) &!"( % !FJ("1 ' )#%#( "( ",L; &'# ) "(?'%"(#!= "1(&''!"#'("!'("!F' '"($' !(&"&!'((!("%(D"'!(!!"((
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
4; )(!'"(#""('("%!J?!"%(!"#''1"(!&'!%#> !'>)" !( !%" '#"(# CT ''" +"%"&'!K'/( 2$ #"("! ' 0<52 &; 036R U %'V(?'/(&1? 8$#"("! &;8:5 /;4E;!" '!" J?1!#""! 1"&!"("!!('"'!" '1"(>" 1()L('#(F""$'"''#1(F &&'"(! & %'"FF )(,A,"' >" &'#(( ?'# %'"F &'#&!#'(; 11"( ! & >) 1"( &" L(' !"#'# ( ! /=&!(/$ &!"F; '" (! ##( 1"( #?# ! %"?F J? !"( #/#( '("' B >" " &'"( & &'!FFC -0802:!";8 875!";6F('#1#'E;
6. !'&!%!"'&&'#"'"(("! N""('("!C!J?N" ='!'E F!"!(>#" #%((N('&#""( !"%( "1!'"';(W/#"!"(A&!'('J?('N#(((#( A "">' > ' ( &!' > ("%"(# N'# ( "&F ('%"'; !(' !# #" !("(( ##( (" &!' #('"'>('%B!&(!''"!F(B"?'N'#C - 084860!";2 004032!";8 002302!";3 074045!"; 0E;
>"!'&'"'%'&'!F(N'&&!'(#" >"( #('"( N(>&!"("("?"B"&!'(("(1"(N!FJ(N#( 1!"# >'&&!'(1!'B!&( >N"&'#?( !"#'("!&"(B&'"# >N""(#(##(F"&"!" !"'C$E >'"&("!!(B(#"!"("'(>N1"
90:2498773 ,<900, !"!NB&'(!"(F"!("%#C -088067!";0( '#1#'E; N##( #('"( &!' %' &'!F( N( &'""& " N!'"?" != &'% " #"?("! ! 1!' N '&&!'( ! NB&'(" "F(F"!!(;NB&'("!"(!L('1!#' !(("!!&$(("?!("&'#" L('!(?'WA ""!!%"("(# (&&!'(''#&!B/("%( #>"%!> B >("! &!#; "( !"( L(' !&'#/"F !((&('/'&!"('!"(;
J'"&' !(( !'> "" !'( &'( !(' F",1!# &&'#"("! #" &' #" '&&!'( '"' !( %' &'% ( ' !O " )#("( & &'("A&'!#'!(!O"!(#(##(F"C -07287<R .; 8<'0<<2R;<!%F'0<<2E;
!1!'#(&'""&">""(!"'>"'#?"(&'!#'!" ' !" )""('("! ( ( )!'!' "('("! !&#("' !'> #?("! &'(" ( ##( '!'(( !"' '>"$'( ( '; &'(""' !"( ((' !%' B&'("!'>)"&&'*(#"''"1"'&(#"BC - 00:853!";2R 0<54T626&;827!";2E;
&'""& J? N#'( & !("1 "&#'("1 !"! N B&'(" #" (W/ NB&'( #(( &'#"#( ((' !" &#" A "&!"("! J(" 1" N#"'' ' &( #"B N #(( 1"( !#; .! J'"&' &( !("(' '"! N#'(' N B&'(" J"""' 1"( > ," !("( !('"("! ! >N ',B&'(" !'!# &' '"F 11"' !"! "$'!%"(; !(' !'>N('&#""(#(((!&""! !('"' &( A ((' #'"( !( &'(" #("! NB&'( N! &( B' ! "('&'#(("! "%'?( !"!'"'&'J?! F!" "('("!!&#("' !1!'N!%B&'("#"C -0058<7!";0FR008 38('#1#'E;
'"'" ""'&&'> !J'"&'!(( "=" )((/' & )"&!'( B !((("! 1"( &' &#""( >)A )&&'#"("!1"(&'#"('"((C 0<55&;472E;
:; #" !(# &' )'# !( !#( " > ('!F&'#(#&')'#)#("(&!FJ("%F;
"" ' #'"( )B '!!?"> ! &'1"(( !'&'#"(>)")=%"(##(!FJ("1&'(((!''!F!'' &"()'#C'&&!'(2J"(8778E(!"?(>)"=%"(
90:2498773 ,07900, '("! "(# (' )"( 0' #F' 8777 ( #F( ('!F B&(' "F"("11""A(('C1B'8773E;
' J"( ( &(F' 8778 B&!# > F" '"!!?"> )%"( #!('# #"! ! #> #"! ('("> ( > ! )B ""> &("( &'#("( ('!F (=& 1"F'!=?">;
"#(#!1"'#88!M(8778&'#")''!"(. ' (&'#"('"(()'# ' >" #?(1"(#((1"F'!=?";
.' & &=/"> ' &'#"# > '!'( &'#("( ('!F (=& 1"F'!=?"> &'#B"(( >" (#'"'( #(# !1"'# &' ' ( ; (!"("! )#((#&'"1'"(&'#(()('!%"(&'!!?#; ' >(A""#)B"()(("((=&1"F'!=?">;
5; -"( %" "'!("# ' '%# >) 1'(' 2 !' )"( 0' #F' 8777 )#("( & &'!FF; )( 11( A !(#!/!'! &'#B"(( C'#" ./' !BE > !''&!( & ! ./!' 392 !F'%#; '#(( '"!!?"> )!( & " #%" '#('#"( &" ( )B&">( ('!F "11; & &("( ) J" &'#(# ('!F '!!?">; (( &&'#"("! 05 #F' 8778 '&"( '#>""( J'"&'(" ("!# ", >( A %' &'!F( ) ( !( $ !' >) ( 1!# ' B '&&!'( #")''!"( >#("(!"?#&"()'# "">')F!"'"">('"!!?">;
%>"&'#$ ""(#('('('!FF"&' '!'( ( )"( 0' #F' 8777 '"( L(' " ?'# %'"F '>" &' J'"&' ,A 30 ' 8773; !#> #""!)"("#(('('A&'(("!&'L( &1A'"(">;
<; !' '& !"' #" #(( !&( !"! '!'( %"(AB&'("&&#("'(1!#;
)"(>'!' 1!# ('J(#;
" - +/ +" - + " - -
90:2498773 ,00900, 012 3 4 56 $,( 7
2
0; #''!''%F;
2
8; 'J((;
3; 1!' &'(" >N &%( 1!'' '!' !(' &'#( ''L( #" 37 J!' $ !("1"("! &' &" '!# '# '"F 1##' ' ./V"K'/!1>" 6 6772 ('!" B&"'; #" &( L(' &'!!?#; #!"' !"(D E "">' B((>#""!'!'(#"'!F("'"(&#""! ((>#R FE B&!' &!' > !("1 " (" &!%!"' ' (( (' #""!R E &!'(' "?(' ! ! '&'#((; ." #!"' !("( & ('!" ##( ##'# ! ((' E FE ( E ", '"F1##''&!''&(''("$'''!'>N" %'#''"''%F;#!"''!'("!'!'!= &'% >" '!( J!"( "" > #""! ((># ( N%!&& >#(#B&#"#'!'(C'(;038 076(075E; ?'11"'D '#"(D X" " '#("',J'"(D B'
!&"!1!'&'#(''L((!("1"#B&'(""">NAN11"1##' (#&F">&'?'11
90:2498773