Contract Damages Recalculation
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involves a challenge to a decision affirming a calculation of damages related to a contract dispute where the court had to determine the proper measure of recovery following a breach. The court reasoned that the lower tribunal erred by failing to correctly apply the established measure of damages, which should focus on compensating the non-breaching party for their direct economic loss sustained as a result of the breach, rather than allowing for speculative or remote profits; therefore, the finding on damages was vacated and the matter remanded for recalculation based on the appropriate contractual damages standard.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 106 al. 1 let. b LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Damages Recalculation: The court reasoned that the lower tribunal erred by failing to correctly apply the established measure of damages, which should focus on compensating the non-breaching party for their direct economic loss sustained as a result of the breach, rather than allowing for speculative or remote profits; therefore, the finding on damages was vacated and the matter remanded for recalculation based on the appropriate contractual damages standard.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court declared the appeal inadmissible based on this procedural provision.
The court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Testo completo
! !
"# $!%&''''''''''()#*$$$+ )!*)!%
")*!&''''''''''()#*$$$+!",
#-%!
.. . #%/ -%0 )+5!)!%! ! 12(3
4.! -$5-6)!% !-! --(700.8$ $5!(++%4 $ 4$3(9:; &
!"#$%&'(!$ )*"+!$%,-!+./ %+(( )'#+
0
10 %<6!*!-)<$(3=*!/*>%!)%$>)!7%!*$=%!$ -! 7%##+)$ #-$#)*%$6!#-%-+!<$1?9@"!A%$7%")*! &''''''''''(+!''''''''''!11!-"# $!%&''''''''''(+!10
0 .!# ! /$55%! ) )$ 7# $-$5 ) <6!*!- 7%+$-+( ! %$> )! 7%!*$=%! $ -!#%)#+!7%-6!7%*#$-$+)! B#$% )!7%+B#A!7%#5! $#!! C$ 7%/)! +7#D)%-!*%$6!0
0 !<6!*!-)!)$B#%!! -)!B!)+5$$-$5!13 !7-!*>%!!-+-+-% *$ )E#55$!%$>)!+ !9 !7-!*>%!7#%!D+-$#)7%-6!0
30 !%$>)!+ #$$-+)! 7%-$! !#*)!!%$ -$--$#)!7%+B#A!( 7$ $-!%7!+! $ -$--$# )+5!)!%! ! !! 7%$-)!$#$C!%! *#-- )! B#$% )! 7%-$! C$ )%-!*%$6!( #$-)<$1?9 13 !7-!*>%!0
0 .!# ! #%%$!% )! .. . ) #B!*>%!(")*!&''''''''''+-+)*$ !) $ !)!7! $#! 1!% #B!*>%! 0 . 7%! --$# )! #%-$! C$ ! 7!)- ! *%$6! E+=B! @ 13E315%013 !7-!*>%!!-!!!)$ 7# $-)E!7%! --$#*#*!- )*%$6!0
.!# ! <6!*!- )! )$B#%!( )!*)!%! ! EB$- 7 -%B$+ )%- ! *%$6!!-EB$-#!+@#-$ !%@7%+B#A!7%#5! $#!!C!)!7$ 0
20 ! $B! -$6-$# *!+! 7% ! %$> )! + #!%- ! B#$% )! 7%+B#A!))!*)!%#-7!%*$ )E+->$%! 5$- $B- F
• !)!*)!%B$-+-+55$$+B-!1!%<B$!%17%= )!G#)-$# )! 7%+B#A! )! 4 & .0 ! 1!% <B$!% 1( 7%! --$# )! $>%!7 6!)!E335%0+-+-% 5+%+!@. . 0
• 1!%<B$!%11)+!*>%!3($+-+55$$+@$ !)!7! $# . . ! %$ # )! # !*7#$ /!H ,''''''''''. I#7A-%!) &#)$6($!>!5!)J0!1)+!*>%!3( 7%! --$#)!$>%!7 6!( #$-1?E15%0+-+-% 5+%+!@.K..G0. . E7)#!% ! $)$-$# #!%- E+B!-!! 7%! --$# )! $>%! 7 6! *#*!-)*%$6!0
• .K..G#5$%*+C!!)!*)!%+-$-55$$+) !)%!)#-%- #09 4.! -$5-6)!% .#7A-%!)&#)$6
($!>!5!)!-C!EB#$%)!7%+B#A!C$ *#*!-)!%!7%$ !) #-%-!1!%<B$!% E+!B$-@1?E15%007%! --$#)! #%-$!13 !7-!*>%! E+=B! @ 1??E2 5%0 .K.. G $)$C+ ! 7 7#B#$% !% 7%! --$# )! #%-$! *#*!- ) *%$6!( )= #% CE$ $ *C$- ! )#*!- )! E %!% 7%++)!-( . . 0 +-$- !7!)--#-@5$-7# $>!CE!7%! --$#)!$>%!7 6!EB$-+-+ C$ ! *#*!- ) *%$6!( )= #% CE! 1?9 7%+B#A! 7%#5! $#!!+-$-5--$B!!-C!E %+B$-@!*#*!-4@? 0
• E:#5$%*+CE@ $-!)!%!7%$ !)E!7%-$!)7!% #!)! L''''''''''.7% #$+-+,''''''''''.(7%! --$#)!$>%!7 6! ))!*)!%( #$-2E32?5%0($B$-+-+-% 5+%+!!2 !7-!*>%!10
E7 +-+7# $>!)E+->$%! )-! )E55$$-$#7%= )!$ !)!7! $# )! L''''''''''.0 ! 7$=! 7%#)$-! 7% ! )!*)!% --! -!- CE$ -%B$+7#%E!*7#A!%7%+$-+)1!%*% 191<B$!%10
?0 ! )#*!- #-+-+-% *$ D7%-$! !)-!)*$20!%$>! $5#%*+! C! % > ! )! %! !$6!*!- %!!$$ ( E! - *#-- )! 91E2?35%0CE$!-!)$--% 5+%!% %!#*7-!)!7%+B#A!)!E!D4+7# !0
90 <%$)$-$# !% $)$C+ CE@ )+5- )E#> !%B-$# )E$$ 1 *$ 2( %%M- !%$-%!) %!--!> !0
0 E> !!)E#><!-$# ) !)+$5$D+( !+-+6%)+!@<6!%0
10 E%-0)!#$5+)+%! %!$>%!7 6!) 7%+B#A!7%#5! $#!!( B$!$! !( %B$B- !-$B$)$-+)1?)+!*>%!1IG J(!-%+!B$6!%! 1!%<B$!%(%=6!7%#+)%!! )!)$B#%!0#% C!! #<#$- ! #- 7 )N#%) %7%! --$#)! #%-$!@7%-6!%I%-01!-1#)!$B$4J( !<6!)$!))$B#%!#*7+-!- ! )!E%-0?01)!#$5+)+%! % 7%+B#A! 7%#5! $#!! ) <$ 19 I J( #$- @ !=B! ! %$> -#)! %! #$! )!7$ !1!%#O-()#$-(7%= C!E55$%!$ +-+-% *$ !I%-013J(!D+-!%)E#55$!!7%-6! %> !)! +)! %+7%-$-$#)+-!%*$+!7%!<6!))$B#%!0
0 .!#E%-0G I#B!!-!!%!B$6!%)!7$ !1!%<B$!%J(! )! )$B#%!( ! 7%! --$# )! #%-$! C$ ! )%- ! *%$6! #- 7%-6+! #5#%*+*!- D%-01(1(131!-13P! %-0@ G E77$C!- 7%#6$!*#--@-% 5+%!%I01J0 #%/C!#<#$-(7%! --$#)!
#%-$!@7%-6!%#%%! 7#)@)$55+%!!!-%!7%! --$#)! #%-$!(6*!-+! )! B#$% )! $>%! 7 6! !D$ -- +B!-!!*!- *#*!- ) )$B#%!( !- 7%! --$#)! #%-$!(6*!-+!)! B#$% )!$>%!7 6!!D$ --+B!-!!*!- *#*!-)!# $#)*%$6!I50%-03G J0 #%!(#<#-! @ 7%! --$# )! #%-$! !- @ EB#$% )! $>%! 7 6! !D$ -- *#*!- )! # $# ) *%$6! ! $-+%M- ) *#*!- ) )$B#%! IG 19 P G1333J0
N! 7=!( ! <6! )! 7%!*$=%! $ -! #%)#+ ! 7%-6! 7% *#$-$+ )! 7%! --$# )! #%-$!C$ ! )%-!*%$6!7%! )!*)!% ( #$-)<$ 1?9 13 !7-!*>%! ( )-! @ C!! ! <6!*!- )! )$B#%! ! - )!B! !D+-#$%!0
0 .!#! )#*!- 7%#)$- ()!*)!%! !E7 -%B$+)%-!*%$6!0 E! -! !!*!-CE!!#!+!-$B$-+%-$B!!-CE!!#-$ + @7%+B#A!7%#5! $#!!0.7%! --$#C$ !7!)-!*%$6! E+=B!@ 13E315%0()#-*#$-$+( #$-?E1?5%0%!B$!-@ #!D4+7#D0
! )!*)!% )$ 7# ! C- @ $ )E! 7%! --$# )! #%-$! )! 1??E2 5%0 *#*!-))$B#%!0B)! )-! )E55$$-$#!-)! $5#%*-$# )#+! 7% ! )$55+%!-! $ ! )!7! $#($A$!)E)*!--%!CE$!)$ 7# $-)E! 7%! --$# *#*!- ) *%$6!0 E!D4+7# ! )%#$- )= #% @ *#$-$+ ) *#--)!7%! --$#)!$>%!7 6!( #$-99E935%0
# +C!!( ! )!*)!% )#$- @ # !D4+7# ! #! )! 91E2?3 5%0 I99E934?E1?(J0
30 #5#%*+*!- @ <%$ 7%)!!( )!7$ ! <#% )+-!%*$- 7#% ! 7%-6! < CE*#*!-)-% 5!%-)!7%! --$#)! #%-$!#)!)!*!%!(!#<#$- )$B#%+>++5$$$%!)!!--!7%! --$#)%#$-@)! $-+%M- #*7! -#$%! %! *#--)!!!4$0! $-+%M- #-+ -D*$$**+6 !#E%-01 )!E#%)#! %7%+B#A!7%#5! $#!!B$!$! !( %B$B- !-$B$)$-+ ) 19 B%$ 193 I J # !# ! -D %+6!*!-$%!( $ !$4$ ! - 7+%$!% IG#7>$+ 2)19<$!-J
0 +*#*!- ! !% 7!%Q( 7%#+)%! +-- 6%-$-! I%-0 ? 0 !- 9&01)!#$ %7%#+)%!)*$$ -%-$B!)1 !7-!*>%!19J0
RRR
* 1 0 ) &
%%$%
23-$4-"$%5(!+6-+!%!-$%$+!%-!(7%8 '9
10 B$-! 4.! -$5-6 )!% .( 700 .K.. G( @ -% 5+%!%()#*7-!)!"# $!%&''''''''''(#-%-#09( #! )!91E2?35%0@.. . !5B!%)! ")*! &''''''''''( $ $ C! )! $-+%M- #*7! -#$%! ! )! # $)+%- ()= !13 !7-!*>%!< CE*#*!-)-% 5!%-0
0 NA#)*!!--C!)!>! #$0
0 $-C!7%#+)%!! -6%-$-!0
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
!#7$!#5#%*!)7%+ !-%%M-! -#-$5$+!D7%-$! $ $CN@N55$!5+)+% )! %! #$! 7%!6%!55!!